Connect with us

Northeast

Court rules on alleged cheater who kept $70,000 engagement ring in case that challenged state law

Published

on

Court rules on alleged cheater who kept ,000 engagement ring in case that challenged state law

The highest court in the state of Massachusetts just decided what to do with a $70,000 engagement ring at the center of a dispute between a former couple.

It overruled a six-decade-long state rule that pushed judges to identify who was to blame for the end of a relationship, instead stating that the engagement ring must be returned to the person who first purchased it.

The former couple, Bruce Johnson and Caroline Settino, first started dating in the summer of 2016. Johnson allegedly paid for extravagant gifts and vacations for Settino, according to court documents.

BRIDE CALLS OFF ENGAGEMENT, ATTENDS WEDDING DAYS LATER WITH HER FRIENDS AND FAMILY

In August 2017, Johnson asked Settino’s father for her hand in marriage and proposed with a $70,000 diamond engagement ring.

Advertisement

According to court filings, Johnson claimed Settino then became critical and unsupportive, not accompanying him to treatments for his prostate cancer, and berating him.

Johnson looked through Settino’s mobile phone and found messages from her to a man he did not know.

The engagement ring was valued at $70,000.  (iStock)

“My Bruce is going to be in Connecticut for three days. I need some playtime,” Settino’s text read. 

Johnson also discovered a voicemail where the same unidentified man called Settino “cupcake” and said that they didn’t see enough of each other.

Advertisement

After confronting Settino with the messages, Johnson ended their engagement. However, ownership of the $70,000 engagement ring was unclear. A legal battle ensued.

JENNIFER LOPEZ’S ENGAGEMENT RING FROM BEN AFFLECK PROMISED HE WAS ‘NOT GOING ANYWHERE’

While one trial judge concluded Settino was entitled to keep the ring, an appeals court found Johnson should get the ring.

The case ultimately landed before the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court in September of this year, which ruled that Johnson should keep the engagement ring.

When a wedding doesn’t happen, justices said in their ruling that the question of “who is at fault” should continue to govern ownership rights over engagement rings. 

Advertisement

A Massachusetts ruling from nearly 70 years ago found that engagement rings are seen as conditional gifts and can be returned if there is a broken off engagement if that person is “without fault.”

The justices wrote in Friday’s ruling, “we now join the modern trend adopted by the majority of jurisdictions that have considered the issue and retire the concept of fault in this context.”

Attorney John Kappos, standing rear left, argues for the doctor in Boston on March 9, 2022. The Supreme Judicial Court hears oral arguments in Roger M. Kligler & Dr. Alan Steinbach vs. Maura Healey & Michael OKeefe. Dr. Roger Kligler, who has incurable metastatic prostate cancer, wants doctors to be able to prescribe lethal amounts of drugs to terminally ill patients with six months or less to live, without fear of prosecution. The states highest court on Wednesday weighed arguments in a Cape Cod doctors controversial right-to-die case, with justices questioning whether the times, law, and medicine had evolved to make it time to legalize medically assisted death and whether the decision should be left to the Legislature. (Photo by Pat Greenhouse/The Boston Globe via Getty Images) (Pat Greenhouse/The Boston Globe via Getty Images)

“Where, as here, the planned wedding does not ensue and the engagement is ended, the engagement ring must be returned to the donor regardless of fault,” the justices continued.

Stephanie Taverna Siden, the lawyer who represented Bruce Johnson, said she was “pleased” with the decision.

Advertisement

“We are very pleased with the court’s decision today. It is a well-reasoned, fair and just decision and moves Massachusetts law in the right direction,” Siden said to the Associated Press.

One of Settino’s lawyers, Nicholas Rosenberg, said they were disappointed with the outcome to the Associated Press, but respected the decision of the court to follow the majority rule of the rest of the states.

“We firmly believe that the notion of an engagement ring as a conditional gift is predicated on outdated notions and should no longer be a legal loophole in our otherwise well-established rule that a breach of a promise to marry is not an injury recognized by law,” Nicholas Rosenberg said.

The Associated Press contributed to this report.

Advertisement

Read the full article from Here

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Vermont

Efficiency Vermont winter resources – The Vermont Journal & The Shopper

Published

on


REGION – As 2025 draws to a close, many Vermonters are facing uncertainty and rising costs. When budgets are tight, projects that improve comfort and reduce energy bills may feel out of reach. Recognizing that households and businesses are feeling stretched, Efficiency Vermont has gathered a collection of free resources, practical tools, and affordable projects that can help Vermonters begin to improve their homes and get more from their energy budget.

Do you want to understand what’s driving your electricity costs? Try our electricity usage calculator to see how your energy bill adds up with your appliances, lighting, and other needs, and see where you can save.

Do you need to diagnose the cause of high energy bills? Call Efficiency Vermont’s energy advisors to see how your home is using energy, understand what equipment could be wasting money, and learn about services and rebates that can help you reduce costs.

Looking for a deep dive into ways your home can save energy? Schedule a free virtual home energy visit, and take a virtual tour of your home with an Efficiency Vermont energy consultant. Get personalized advice for using less energy at home, plus a customized list of next steps tailored to your needs and priorities.

Advertisement

Get $100 back for a do-it-yourself (DIY) weatherization project. Use our $100 DIY weatherization rebate to get cash back for completing simple projects like air sealing windows or adding weather stripping.

Businesses, nonprofits, and other commercial operations can also take advantage of helpful resources and rebates, such as those listed below.

Free business energy consultations – Understand where your business is losing energy, and what you can do to fix it, through a business energy consultation. Our energy advisors can help you identify cost-effective opportunities, find efficient equipment, and connect you with our Efficiency Excellence Network of contractors.

Up to $25,000 in bonus rebates for custom projects – Businesses can double their incentive, up to $25,000, for custom projects tailored to an operation’s specific needs. These bonuses are available for businesses, nonprofits, farm operations, and institutions that complete projects by November 2026.

Increased incentives for preapproved lighting projects – Businesses that switch to energy-saving LED lamps can get up to 100% of the product costs covered when they replace existing linear fluorescent lamps. Agricultural businesses upgrading to LEDs in livestock or sugaring facilities can get up to 100% of project costs covered.

Advertisement

Efficiency Vermont’s 2025 holiday gift guide also offers inspiration for sustainable, local, and fun holiday shopping. The guide has a collection of thoughtful gifts and experiences, including ways to donate previously used items, implement energy savings, give the gift of rebate-eligible appliances, and support local businesses.

Federal home energy tax credits expire at the end of December, but Efficiency Vermont’s rebates and programs will remain available in 2026 and beyond. Whether you’re just starting to think about energy efficiency, or you’re ready to begin a project, visit www.efficiencyvermont.com/rebates to find ways to meet your energy goals.





Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Boston, MA

‘Christmas angel’ donates $25,000 for Boston’s St. Francis House annual meal for hundreds of guests

Published

on

‘Christmas angel’ donates ,000 for Boston’s St. Francis House annual meal for hundreds of guests


Hundreds of people from Boston’s homeless community were treated to a warm, restaurant-style holiday meal Christmas Day at St. Francis House, and it was all made possible by a $25,000 donation from a family in Medfield.

The day shelter, the largest of its type in all of New England, hosted the annual celebration for what they estimated to be between 400 and 500 guests.

President and CEO of St. Francis House, Karen LaFrazia, says the large donation from the Medfield family not only funded the Christmas meal, but also another event and hundreds of gifts the night before.

“Today, we actually had a donor family that completely underwrote all of the costs of our entire Christmas dinner,” LaFrazia told the Herald. “Yesterday, we had a special event on Christmas Eve where we passed out Christmas presents for everybody, so everybody came through and they got their choice of a backpack and a choice of a sweatshirt and a gift card so they can spend on what they want and what they need. And it was completely underwritten by a generous family.

Advertisement

“They are our Christmas angel,” she added. “The mother in this family used to come here when she was in high school and she would volunteer. She’s in a fortunate place right now, her and her family, so they’re able to give back in a very meaningful way.”

Volunteer Amy Wendel serves up apple cider to diners at the St. Francis House in Boston on Christmas Day. (Mark Stockwell/Boston Herald)

But it appears that a notable amount of regular St. Francis House donors have been diving deeper into their pockets than ever before, according to VP of Philanthropy and External Relations Andrew Russell.

“Increasingly, this year, we have seen an enormous amount of our donors leaping in their giving. So, for example, this family from Medfield had been giving us $1,000 per year until this year, when they gave us a $25,000 donation. Donors who had been giving $5,000 per year have been giving $50,000 per year. So, it’s heartwarming to see,” Russell said.

The warm, festive environment offered guests what staff say is a “moment of dignity,” paired with a chance to escape from the daily burdens many have been experiencing in their day-to-day lives.

Jason Tench, who tells the Herald he’s been homeless for “a long time,” says he seeks services at St. Francis House because staff “really, truly care.”

Advertisement

“These people care a lot more [than most shelter services]. They come in every day and they appreciate us, which makes us appreciate them. It’s not just a job to them. They understand and they really, truly care. And it shows in the incredible work they do for us,” said Tench.

“It means a lot,” said Stephen Gonzalo, another homeless guest of St. Francis House. “I think this is where Jesus would want to be. It’s my first time here and luckily for me its on Christmas Day with this amazing meal and good people.”

Russell, the VP at St. Francis House, said the increase in donations — which allows St. Francis House to offer events like the Christmas meal — come as a blessing.

He says aside from special events, the extra cash is needed now more than ever, especially as the housing crisis paired with soaring utility costs in Massachusetts continues to make life unaffordable for residents.

“There’s more and more people that are coming in, whether it be seniors or young people that are on restricted incomes and if their rent goes up they can’t afford food or electricity, and people are forced to make difficult choices. So, the housing crisis definitely is playing a big part in the number of people we’re seeing on a daily basis,” Russell told the Herald. “We’re now up over 500 guests per day, every day. When you go back to 2023, we were seeing 7,000 people per year. The last two years we’ve been seeing 10,000 people per year.”

Advertisement
Volunteer Michael Casey, left, waits to serve food at the St. Francis House in Boston. (Mark Stockwell/Boston Herald)
Volunteer Michael Casey, left, waits to serve food at the St. Francis House in Boston. (Mark Stockwell/Boston Herald)

Homeless guest Arsenio Borges tells the Herald that he’s seen firsthand the help and support offered on a daily basis by St. Francis House, crediting the organization with helping him find housing for the first time in years.

“I think this is great. I live at the 112 Southampton Street shelter and this place has been incredible with how much they’ve helped me out. They actually just helped me get my Massachusetts ID so I can get housing finally. They’ve gotten clothing for me, shoes, socks, everything. So, they do help a lot,” said Borges.

As she enters her 19th year at St. Francis House, LaFrazia says the goal of the annual Christmas meal remains the same: to offer guests dignity, a warm meal and hope as they work to get through the challenges they face.

“I’ve been talking to our guests this morning and some of them have been reminiscing about Christmases past, when days were better for them and its bringing for them, a sadness,” said LaFrazia. “But, there’s also a little bit of joy for them to be here with friends and with staff that know they care about them and love them and us to give them a message of hope for the new year that things can and will get better.”

Kareh LaFraziak President and CEO of St. Francis House in Boston speaks before volunteers served free meals restaurant style to people that are homeless. The day shelter on Boylston Street severd up several hundred meals on Christmas Day. (Mark Stockwell/Boston Herald)
Karen LaFrazia, president and CEO of St. Francis House in Boston, speaks before volunteers served hundreds of meals on Christmas Day. (Mark Stockwell/Boston Herald)



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Pittsburg, PA

Why Pittsburgh Steelers fans should root for the Detroit Lions to beat the Minnesota Vikings

Published

on

Why Pittsburgh Steelers fans should root for the Detroit Lions to beat the Minnesota Vikings


Pittsburgh Steelers fans should root for the Detroit Lions to knock off the Minnesota Vikings during their Christmas Day clash due to playoff implications.

If the Lions lose to the Vikings, that would cause the Green Bay Packers to clinch their postseason berth, which could have implications for their game against the Baltimore Ravens. Now, that would not be a slam dunk, as the Packers could still win the NFC North and have seeing to play for over the next few games, but it would lessen the urgency to their situation.

As such, it would be pertinent to at least root for the Lions to keep the pressure on the Lions. Meanwhile, Green Bay has some questions as quarterback heading into their Saturday game against the Ravens anyways.

Jordan Love was limited for two straight days while in the concussion protocol, and while things seem to be going in the right direction to play, he still needs to be given the green light to play. His backup, Malik Willis, did not practice yesterday with an illness and continues to battle through a right shoulder issue.

Advertisement

The Ravens may not have Lamar Jackson either, though, as Jackson has a ‘significant back contusion’ that has forced him to miss the first days or practice this week.

The Steelers clinch the AFC North divisional title with a Ravens loss to the Packers.



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending