Connect with us

World

‘Very happy’ Ed Sheeran wins Thinking Out Loud copyright case

Published

on

‘Very happy’ Ed Sheeran wins Thinking Out Loud copyright case

Civil lawsuit introduced by heirs of Marvin Gaye co-writer intently watched over implications for musicians’ artistic freedom.

British pop star Ed Sheeran has expressed pleasure and aid after a United States jury discovered he didn’t plagiarise Marvin Gaye’s Let’s Get It On when he wrote his mega-hit Pondering Out Loud, calling the ruling a win for artistic freedom.

The English musician hugged his crew inside a Manhattan court docket on Thursday after jurors dominated he had “independently” created the 2014 Grammy award-winning tune.

The closely-watched lawsuit was filed by heirs of Gaye co-writer Ed Townsend, who sued Sheeran for copyright infringement in 2017, claiming that Pondering Out Loud copied the “coronary heart” of Gaye’s tune together with its melody, concord and rhythm.

The heirs sought a share of the earnings from Sheeran’s hit.

Advertisement

Exterior court docket, the singer-songwriter informed reporters that it had been “devastating to be accused of stealing another person’s tune”, and he was “very glad” with the end result.

“If the jury had determined this matter the opposite manner, we’d as properly say goodbye to the artistic freedom of songwriters,” Sheeran mentioned.

Business insiders have been intently following the civil lawsuit amid issues it might open the door to future litigation and hamper songwriters’ creativity.

It was Sheeran’s second copyright trial in a 12 months. In April 2022, he received a case in London over his tune Form Of You, a large hit in 2017, saying the lawsuit was emblematic of copyright litigation going too far.

There have been a handful of landmark music copyright instances lately.

Advertisement

Probably the most notable was in 2015, when members of Gaye’s household efficiently sued the performers Robin Thicke and Pharrell Williams over similarities between their tune Blurred Traces and Gaye’s Received to Give it Up.

The end result shocked many within the business, together with authorized specialists, who thought of lots of the musical parts cited as foundational and present largely within the public area.

On this month’s case, 32-year-old Sheeran testified in court docket, guitar in hand, enjoying demos for the court docket to show the 1-3-4-5 chord development at problem was a standard “constructing block” of pop music and couldn’t be owned.

He mentioned that his buddy and collaborator Amy Wadge first began strumming the chords for the tune throughout a go to to his house in England and that they collaborated on the lyrics.

A musicologist for the defence informed the court docket the four-chord sequence had been utilized in various songs earlier than Gaye’s hit got here out in 1973.

Advertisement

These chords “are a songwriter’s ‘alphabet’, our instrument package,” Sheeran mentioned on Thursday.

“Nobody owns them, or the best way they’re performed, in the identical manner no person owns the color blue.”

Joe Bennett, a forensic musicologist on the prestigious Berklee School of Music, informed the AFP information company he was “delighted” that “sanity prevailed” within the case.

“In music copyright litigation, instances involving one or two bars of music, the plaintiff’s allegation of plagiarism is nearly at all times mistaken,” he mentioned. “Coincidental similarity occurs on a regular basis, notably with chords and brief melodic fragments.”

“Hopefully this wise verdict will discourage different spurious complaints.”

Advertisement

Legal professionals for Townsend’s heirs didn’t instantly reply to the decision.

Sheeran faces two related lawsuits in New York, introduced by funding banker David Pullman’s Structured Asset Gross sales, which additionally owns copyright pursuits within the Gaye tune.

Pullman mentioned after the decision that he and his legal professionals had realized from the trial.

“We’ll know what to anticipate,” Pullman mentioned.

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

World

Russian court seizes two European banks’ assets amid Western sanctions

Published

on

Russian court seizes two European banks’ assets amid Western sanctions

Freezing hundreds of billions of dollars in lenders’ assets was part of dispute over gas project halted by sanctions.

A Russian court has ordered the seizure of the assets, accounts, property and shares of Deutsche Bank and Commerzbank in the country as part of a lawsuit involving the German banks, court documents showed.

The banks are among the guarantor lenders under a contract for the construction of a gas processing plant in Russia with the German company Linde. The project was terminated due to Western sanctions.

European banks have largely exited Russia after Moscow launched its offensive on Ukraine in 2022.

A court in St Petersburg ruled in favour of seizing 239 million euros ($260m) from Deutsche Bank, documents dated May 16 showed.

Advertisement

Deutsche Bank in Frankfurt said it had already provisioned about 260 million euros ($283m) for the case.

“We will need to see how this claim is implemented by the Russian courts and assess the immediate operational impact in Russia,” the bank added in a statement.

The court also seized the assets of Commerzbank, another German financial institution, worth 93.7 million euros ($101.85m) as well as securities and the bank’s building in central Moscow.

The bank is yet to comment on the case.

In a parallel lawsuit on Friday, the Russian court also ordered UniCredit’s assets, accounts and property, as well as shares in two subsidiaries, to be seized. The ruling covered 462.7 million euros ($503m) in assets.

Advertisement

UniCredit said it “has been made aware” of the decision and was “reviewing” the situation in detail. The bank was one of the most exposed European banks when Moscow launched its invasion of Ukraine, with a large local subsidiary operating in Russia.

It began preliminary discussions on a sale last year, but the talks have not advanced. Chief executive Andrea Orcel said UniCredit wants to leave Russia, but added that gifting an operation worth three billion euros ($3.3bn) was not a good way to respect the spirit of Western sanctions on Moscow over the conflict.

Russia has faced heavy Western sanctions, including on its banking sector, since the start of the war in Ukraine. Dozens of US and European companies have also stopped doing business in the country.

Continue Reading

World

Ukraine's divisive mobilization law comes into force as a new Russian push strains front-line troops

Published

on

Ukraine's divisive mobilization law comes into force as a new Russian push strains front-line troops

KYIV, Ukraine (AP) — A divisive mobilization law in Ukraine came into force on Saturday, as Kyiv struggles to boost troop numbers after Russia launched a new offensive that some fear could close in on Ukraine’s second-largest city.

The legislation, which was watered down from its original draft, will make it easier to identify every conscript in the country. It also provides incentives to soldiers, such as cash bonuses or money toward buying a house or car, that some analysts say Ukraine cannot afford.

Lawmakers dragged their feet for months and only passed the law in mid-April, a week after Ukraine lowered the age for men who can be drafted from 27 to 25. The measures reflect the growing strain that more than two years of war with Russia has had on Ukraine’s forces, who are trying to hold the front lines in fighting that has sapped the country’s ranks and stores of weapons and ammunition.

Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelenskyy also signed two other laws Friday, allowing prisoners to join the army and increasing fines for draft dodgers fivefold. Russia enlisted its prisoners early on in the war, and personnel shortages compelled Ukraine to adopt the new measures.

Russian troops, meanwhile, are pushing ahead with a ground offensive that opened a new front in northeastern Ukraine’s Kharkiv region and put further pressure on Kyiv’s overstretched military. After weeks of probing, Moscow launched the new push knowing that Ukraine suffered personnel shortages, and that its forces have been spread thin in the northeast.

Advertisement

Russian President Vladimir Putin said on Friday during a visit to China that the Russian push aims to create “a buffer zone” rather than capturing Kharkiv, the local capital and Ukraine’s second-largest city.

Still, Moscow’s forces have pummeled Kharkiv with strikes in recent weeks, hitting civilian and energy infrastructure and prompting angry accusations from Zelenskyy that the Russian leadership sought to reduce the city to rubble. On Friday, Mayor Ihor Terekhov said that Russian guided bombs killed at least three residents and injured 28 others that day.

Moscow denies deliberately targeting civilians, but thousands have died or suffered injuries in the more than 27 months of fighting.

The U.S. last week announced a new $400 million package of military aid for Ukraine, and President Joe Biden has promised that he would rush badly needed weaponry to the country to help it stave off Russian advances. Still, only small batches of U.S. military aid have started to trickle into the front line, according to Ukrainian military commanders, who said it will take at least two months before supplies meet Kyiv’s needs to hold the line.

Thousands of Ukrainians have fled the country to avoid the draft since Russia’s all-out invasion in February 2022, some risking their lives as they tried to swim across a river separating Ukraine from neighboring Romania and Hungary.

Advertisement

Late on Friday, Ukraine’s border service said that at least 30 people have died trying to cross the Tisza River since the full scale-invasion.

Romanian border guards days earlier retrieved the near-naked, disfigured body of a man that appeared to have been floating in the Tisza for days, and is the 30th known casualty, the Ukrainian agency said in an online statement. It said the man has not yet been identified.

___

Follow AP’s coverage at https://apnews.com/hub/russia-ukraine

Advertisement
Continue Reading

World

An unusual autumn freeze grips parts of South America, giving Chile its coldest May in 74 years

Published

on

An unusual autumn freeze grips parts of South America, giving Chile its coldest May in 74 years

Chileans are bundling up for their coldest autumn in more than 70 years mere days after sunning in T-shirts — a dramatic change of wardrobe brought on this week by a sudden cold front gripping portions of South America unaccustomed to bitter wind chills this time of year.

CHILE SHUTS DOWN A POPULAR GLACIER, SPARKING DEBATE OVER CLIMATE CHANGE AND ADVENTURE SPORTS

Temperatures broke records along the coast of Chile and in Santiago, the capital, dipping near freezing and making this month the coldest May that the country has seen since 1950, the Chilean meteorological agency reported.

An unusual succession of polar air masses has moved over southern swaths of the continent, meteorological experts say, pushing the mercury below zero Celsius (32 Fahrenheit) in some places. It’s the latest example of extreme weather in the region — a heat wave now baking Mexico, for instance — which scientists link to climate change.

Footprints create the shape of a heart in a snow-covered rugby field in Santiago, Chile, Wednesday, May 8, 2024.  (AP Photo/Matias Basualdo)

Advertisement

“The past few days have been one of the longest (cold fronts) ever recorded and one of the earliest ever recorded” before the onset of winter in the Southern Hemisphere, said Raul Cordero, a climatologist at Santiago University. “Typically the incursions of cold air from the Antarctic that drive temperatures below zero occur from June onwards, not so much in May.”

The cold front sweeping in from Antartica has collided with warm air pushing in from the northwestern Amazon, helping fuel heavy rainstorms battering Brazil, according to that country’s National Meteorological system.

Chile’s government issued frosty weather alerts for most of the country and ramped up assistance for homeless people struggling to endure the frigid temperatures on the streets. Snow cloaked the peaks of the Andes and fell in parts of Santiago, leading to power outages in many areas this week.

“Winter came early,” said Mercedes Aguayo, a street vendor hawking gloves and hats in Santiago.

She said she was glad for a boost in business after Chile’s record winter heat wave last year, which experts pinned on climate change as well as the cyclical El Niño weather pattern.

Advertisement

“We had stored these goods (hats and gloves) for four years because winters were always more sporadic, one day hot, one day cold,” Aguayo said.

This week’s cold snap also took parts of Argentina and Paraguay by surprise.

Energy demand soared across many parts of Argentina. Distributors cut supplies to dozens of gas stations and industries in several provinces to avoid outages in households, , the country’s main hydrocarbon company, CECHA, said Thursday.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending