Texas
Rap music on trial: Upcoming Texas execution stirs national debate
Rap music has been used against criminal defendants since the genre took hold in the 1980s and its use has only increased in recent years. Some states are trying to limit the practice.
Tennessee set to execute woman for first time in over 200 years
If Christa Pike’s execution is carried out, she would be the first woman executed in Tennessee in 200 years and the 19th woman in modern U.S. history.
An upcoming execution in Texas has gained the attention of prominent rappers like Travis Scott and T.I. for the questions it raises about the place rap lyrics have in the courtroom and how justice is meted out to Black defendants.
James Broadnax, 37, is set to be executed by lethal injection on Thursday, April 30, for the 2008 double murder of Stephen Swan and Matthew Butler, two producers of Christian music killed during a robbery outside their studio in the Dallas suburb of Garland.
Broadnax’s case is gaining national attention for what his attorneys say was an unfair trial that saw prosecutors eliminate almost every potential Black juror and use Broadnax’s own rap lyrics against him. The result, defense attorneys argue in a recent U.S. Supreme Court filing, transformed Broadnax’s “artistic expression into a death warrant.”
In a friend-of-the-court brief filed in the Supreme Court last month, rapper Travis Scott argues that rap music has been increasingly used as evidence against defendants “in a manner that exploits and perpetuates stereotypes.”
“Because rap lyrics are art, they are not literal,” the brief said. “And introduction of rap lyrics as evidence against criminal defendants invites jurors to transfer their opinions about the genre onto the individual before them, risking punishment for expression unrelated to the crime at issue.”
Rapper Killer Mike echoed those thoughts in a similar brief filed in the case. Other powerful people in the entertainment industry who joined in that filing include rappers Young Thug and Fat Joe, record executive Kevin Liles, and actor/comedian Anthony Anderson.
Texas prosecutors are defending both Broadnax’s prosecution and the use of his rap lyrics to show jurors his “cold, flippant attitude toward the murders and the judicial process.”
“The State saved the jailhouse lyric, written while Broadnax was awaiting trial, for the punishment phase − to demonstrate to the jury Broadnax’s outrageous and extreme lack of empathy, regret, remorse, and accountability,” prosecutors say.
Here’s what you need to know about the case, Broadnax’s chances at a reprieve from execution, and how the victims’ family members feel about the issues being raised.
What was James Broadnax convicted of?
On June 19, 2008, a bicyclist came upon the bodies of 26-year-old Stephen Swan and 28-year-old Matthew Butler outside of their recording studio in Garland Texas just before 1 a.m., court records say.
Later that day, court records say that Broadnax and his cousin, Demarius Cummings, went to a family member’s home in Swan’s car, and that Broadnax displayed Swan’s driver’s license and bragged that he “hit a lick,” or committed a robbery. The two cousins left in the car, and a family friend soon after called the police when she saw news reports about the double murder.
Police pulled Broadnax over later that night in Swan’s car 150 miles away in Texarcana and arrested him. After police returned Broadnax to Dallas, he confessed to the murders in multiple interviews with members of the news media, court records say.
During the interviews, Broadnax told reporters that he and Cummings had driven to Garland looking for someone to rob and that he alone killed Swan and Butler.
Prosecutors leaned heavily on the confessions during trial but the sentencing phase focused more on rap lyrics that Broadnax had written in his notebooks. The lyrics, which included “I hit the lick, but the reason I got caught cuz the (expletive) snitching,” showed that Broadnax was a dangerous person and was likely to commit more violence unless he was executed, prosecutors told jurors.
Court records say that jurors asked to see the rap lyrics twice during deliberations over Broadnax’s punishment and delivered their verdict the same day. They gave him the death penalty.
Meanwhile Broadnax’s cousin recently came forward to say that he was actually the triggerman that night. Cummings said the only reason Broadnax confessed was because he didn’t have a significant criminal record and the cousins thought that he’d be treated with more leniency. Cummings is serving life in prison without parole.
On trial: The use of rap lyrics
The heart of Broadnax’s arguments for a reprieve center on the rap lyrics used against him during the penalty phase.
His attorneys and the entertainers who wrote to the Supreme Court argue that such lyrics are protected free speech and have nothing to do with the crime committed. The way they were presented to a nearly all-white jury, they say, was prejudicial because rap music “often invokes negative racial stereotypes about Black men among jurors and judges.”
Dallas County prosecutors called Broadnax’s claims over the rap lyrics “meritless and not worthy of this court’s attention” in a recent filing.
“The rap lyrics in his journals are relevant and admissible to show not only his gang affiliation or interest, but also that themes of lawlessness, violence, and drugs − whether fictional or not − occupied his time and thoughts,” they wrote. “If Johnny Cash had ever been on trial for murder, particularly if the murder was alleged to have occurred in Reno, no doubt his ‘Folsom Prison Blues’ lyrics (‘I shot a man in Reno, just to watch him die’) would have been admissible during the punishment phase of his trial.”
Rap music has been used against criminal defendants since the genre took hold in the 1980s and its use has only increased in recent years, experts say. Some states including California, Maryland and Louisiana have passed laws to limit its use.
Among recent trials where rap lyrics factored in: Rapper Young Thug’s 2023 trial on RICO charges (he pleaded guilty), rapper Drakeo the Ruler’s 2019 murder trial (he was acquitted), rapper Tay-K’s 2025 murder trial (he was sentenced to 80 years), and rapper Lil Durk’s upcoming trial on murder-for-hire charges (he has pleaded not guilty).
“These high-profile cases have brought attention to the risk that rap lyrics will be used as evidence of criminality or to enhance a criminal defendant’s sentence,” argues rapper Travis Scott’s filing with the Supreme Court. “Unsurprisingly, this risk chills rap artists’ speech.”
What do the victim family members say?
Lost in much of the coverage of Broadnax’s execution are the victims in the case: Stephen Swan and Matthew Butler. Their families both have expressed steadfast support of Broadnax’s execution.
“I can not believe that this evil, heartless killer is still alive,” Matthew’s mom, Theresa Butler, wrote in 2016 about her son, who was a 28-year-old married father of two when he was killed. “My son and Steve had no choice about whether to live or die that night … This killer should never have the choice to live after what he did to them.”
Last month, she called Broadnax’s most recent arguments a “hail Mary pass.” She previously called Swan and her son “two wonderful Christian, hard-working young men.”
“Matthew would have given them a ride home since the train and buses stopped running in Garland. He would have paid for an Uber for them to get home,” she said. “He would have done anything to stay alive and enjoy a wonderful life with his wife and two babies. And, his whole family. He loved us all so.”
Swan’s sister, Deborah Burkhardt, sought an execution date to be set for Broadnax last year and wrote in a court filing that “every piece of worthless litigation filed by the defense is another insult and another injury to us,” according to NPR for North Texas.
She added: “There is no end to what they will come up with, or try to put a new spin on.”
What ways could James Broadnax win a reprieve?
Broadnax’s attorneys have cast a wide net of possibilities to stop his April 30 execution.
They have multiple appeals sitting in the Supreme Court, the Texas Board of Pardons and Paroles is considering the case, and Broadnax’s attorneys are also planning to bring his claims to the governor.
USA TODAY will be closely following the case and covering the execution should it move forward.
Amanda Lee Myers is a senior crime reporter who covers the death penalty, cold case investigations and breaking news for USA TODAY. Follow her on X at @amandaleeusat.
ENGLEWOOD, Colo. — The Denver Broncos finally made a pick in the NFL draft, selecting versatile Texas A&M defensive lineman Tyler Onyedim with the second pick of the third round Friday night.
The Broncos, who were the last team to make a splash in the offseason — by trading their first-round draft pick for wide receiver Jaylen Waddle — had snaps available for rookies at two spots: defensive tackle following John Franklin-Myers’ departure in free agency and middle linebacker after they’d jettisoned Dre Greenlaw after one injury-filled season.
With all their second-round targets off the board Friday night, they traded the 62nd-overall pick to the Buffalo Bills for a third-rounder (No. 66) and a sixth-rounder (No. 182) Saturday.
The Broncos, who reached the AFC championship in Bo Nix’s second season, didn’t have a first-round pick this year after trading the 30th overall selection to the Miami Dolphins for Waddle, the only big move Denver made this offseason following their unusually quiet free agency.
The Broncos have been on the sideline for Round 1 three times in the last five seasons, but they hit on second-rounders Nik Bonitto (No. 64 in 2022) and Marvin Mims Jr. (No. 63 in 2023).
“The good news is we have experience with this,” general manager George Paton said last week about not picking until Day 2.
Onyedim spent four seasons at Iowa State, where he was a nose tackle, and played one season as the three-technique penetrator at Texas A&M, which boosted his draft stock.
“At Iowa State, it was a 3-3-5 scheme … he wasn’t penetrating, he wasn’t rushing as much,” Paton said Friday night. “We got to see him do that more at A&M, which he’ll be doing here.”
Onyedim said he was excited to play again with former Hawkeyes defender Eyioma Uwazurike in Denver and in Broncos defensive coordinator Vance Joseph’s standout system.
“Oh man, it’s going to be a blessing,” Onyedim said, “being able to learn from the best. They’ve got a really good D-line. I’m excited. I’m ready to go, man.”
Onyedim is considered a good chemistry prospect for a locker room that notably lacks troublemakers.
“The mindset’s just to learn, don’t be no arrogant person,” he said. “Sit back, learn from the vets.”
The Broncos will be busy Saturday with seven selections, including the eighth and 11th picks in Round 4 and the final two of the last round.
Denver lost in the AFC championship to the New England Patriots after Nix broke his right ankle in the Broncos’ overtime win against the Buffalo Bills in the divisional round. Nix is expected to be ready to participate in the team’s offseason program.
Carnival Tropicale is named after the original MS Tropicale, which was Carnival’s first originally designed cruise ship. That vessel helped shape the Fun Ship era, making entertainment and shared joy as central as the destinations themselves. It also introduced the iconic winged funnel to the fleet, which is now one of the most recognizable symbols in cruising.
In 2028, that legacy returns, reimagined for a new generation with innovative design and next-generation guest experiences.
Carnival currently homeports four ships in Galveston, and its continued investment in the region has been a driving force in the state’s tourism economy, attracting guests from across the Southwest region and beyond who come to Galveston and the greater Houston area and spend on other tourism activities as part of their trip.
“Carnival’s continued investment in the Port of Galveston is a big reason why we’re the cruise port of choice for a growing number of Americans and why we’re setting new growth records year over year,” said Rodger Rees, Galveston Wharves port director and CEO. “Carnival has been a valued partner for this port and this community for 26 years. We look forward to many more years of growth together.”
In 2024, Carnival became the first cruise line to welcome more than 10 million guests to Galveston, underscoring the strength of the Texas market. That same year, Carnival Jubilee was the first new ship to be inaugurated at the Port of Galveston. The Excel-class ship was the first North American ship to provide guests with 5G connectivity, and the first homeported in Galveston powered by liquefied natural gas (LNG) – reflecting Carnival’s focus on innovation and sustainability.
Texas
Texas attorney raises concerns as investigation continues into 2 home explosions on North Side
SAN ANTONIO – Barriers on Preston Hollow Drive have been moved back, but part of the North Side street is still blocked off. This is where the National Transportation Safety Board is leading the investigation into two home explosions.
The explosions happened on Tuesday night. In total, five people were hurt. The latest update on Thursday revealed three of those victims were still in critical condition.
While the focus right now is on what caused the blasts, Texas attorney Michael Lyons is already looking ahead and raising concerns about what comes next.
“This is a recurring issue that exists in not just Texas,” Lyons said. “Gas infrastructure can be really dangerous.”
“I handle a lot of cases involving gas explosions nationwide,” Lyons said. “When there’s a gas explosion, my phone usually rings.”
At this time, Lyons, who is a partner at the Dallas firm Lyons & Simmons, is not directly connected to this case. But he has represented families here in the city with very similar stories.
“We tried the case in February of 2025 that resulted in a big verdict against CPS (Energy),” Lyons said.
He’s talking about Virginia Rymers and her son Robert. KSAT previously reported they survived a 2021 natural gas explosion at their East Side home but became severely injured as a result.
On Thursday, KSAT built a map showing all the house and apartment explosions we’ve covered since 2020.
One of Lyons’ biggest concerns is making sure the homes are not demolished on Preston Hollow Drive before the investigation is complete. A spokesperson with San Antonio’s Development Services Department confirmed to KSAT on Thursday that “nothing will be done until the investigation is completed.”
“The city and the taxpayers ought to know what happened and why and who is responsible,” Lyons said.
CPS Energy sent KSAT an updated statement just before 10 p.m. on Thursday, where a spokesperson for the utility said for the first time, “Electric and gas services in the Preston Hollow subdivision are clear and safe.”
Marc Whyte, the District 10 councilman, said his office and the city are currently working on creating a website to give out updates on the investigation as they become available.
CPS Energy will keep its customer response unit at the Northeast Senior Center through Sunday.
CPS Energy said if any customers at any point smell gas, they should leave the house immediately and call CPS Energy at 210-353-HELP (4357) or 911.
Read also:
Copyright 2026 by KSAT – All rights reserved.
-
Montana4 minutes agoMontana Outdoor Radio Show – April 25th Recap
-
Nebraska10 minutes agoMid-Nebraska Community Foundation honors Eric Seacrest at retirement ceremony
-
Nevada16 minutes ago1 dead after crash on Interstate 15 in Las Vegas; northbound lanes closed
-
New Hampshire22 minutes agoBetween Concord And Portsmouth Is A New Hampshire State Park With Mountains, Beaches, And Incredible Views – AOL
-
New Jersey28 minutes agoExclusive | NJ grandma with heart of gold goes viral for making salami sandwich for her mailman
-
New Mexico34 minutes agoStronger winds develop this weekend
-
North Carolina40 minutes agoNorth Carolina Central University hosts the HBCU Dope Art Tour at Hayti Heritage Center
-
North Dakota46 minutes agoNorth Dakota highlights nearly 10 Years of victims’ constitutional rights during National Crime Victims’ Rights Week