TALLAHASSEE — Lower than every week after Florida lawmakers rushed to make property insurance coverage adjustments, a contractors group Tuesday filed a constitutional problem that targets a brand new restriction on legal professional charges in lawsuits towards insurance coverage firms.
The Restoration Affiliation of Florida and Air High quality Assessors LLC, an Orlando agency that does work equivalent to mould testing and leak detection, filed the lawsuit in Leon County circuit courtroom.
It got here after lawmakers final week handed a measure (SB 2-D) to attempt to bolster a troubled property insurance coverage market that has led to owners shedding protection and seeing spiraling premiums. Lawmakers gave last approval to the invoice on Wednesday, and Gov. Ron DeSantis signed it on Thursday.
Insurers have lengthy blamed litigation and legal professional charges for driving up prices. The brand new regulation took a sequence of steps to attempt to tackle these points, however the constitutional problem focuses on a part of the measure that offers with what is named “task of advantages.”
In task of advantages, owners signal over their insurance coverage claims to contractors, who then search cost from insurance coverage firms — typically spurring lawsuits about claims and funds.
Contractors up to now have been capable of recuperate their legal professional charges from insurers if they’re profitable within the lawsuits, an idea generally known as “prevailing get together charges.” However the brand new regulation stripped contractors of having the ability to recuperate prevailing-party charges when they’re assigned advantages.
Owners can nonetheless recuperate prevailing-party charges in the event that they file lawsuits immediately towards insurers, however the contractors can not. The lawsuit alleges that the change violates equal-protection and due-process rights and denies contractors entry to courts.
“Claims submitted to insurers for work carried out by contractors underneath an AOB (task of profit) are usually not giant in financial quantity,” the lawsuit mentioned. “When the insurer delays, underpays or doesn’t pay a declare in any respect, contractors are pressured to start an motion towards the insurer to recuperate the total quantity due for the work carried out. With out the corresponding proper to recuperate prevailing get together charges, SB 2-D makes it economically unfeasible for the contractor to pursue its lawful rights and treatments in courtroom. Invoices for work carried out by contractors underneath AOBs are usually not vital sufficient for a lawyer to conform to characterize the contractor on a contingency payment foundation and it’s not economically affordable for the contractor to … pay a lawyer on an hourly foundation to recuperate the quantity(s) owed.”
The lawsuit mentioned invoices for work accomplished by Air High quality Assessors and plenty of different members of the affiliation typically complete $2,500 to $3,000.
“The lack to recuperate prevailing get together attorneys’ charges will successfully shut the courthouse door to plaintiffs as a result of it will likely be cost-prohibitive to pay an legal professional for these kind of small claims,” the lawsuit mentioned.
However William Giant, president of the Florida Justice Reform Institute, a business-backed group that lobbies to scale back litigation, mentioned in a press release after the regulation handed that “property insurance coverage lawsuits have exploded over the past a number of years, overwhelming Florida’s insurance coverage market.”
“Senate Invoice 2-D incorporates vital litigation reforms and will get to the center of escalating charges and restricted protection — lawsuit abuse,” Giant mentioned.
Get insights into Florida politics
Subscribe to our free Buzz publication
Political editor Emily L. Mahoney will ship you a rundown on native, state and nationwide politics protection each Thursday.
You’re all signed up!
Need extra of our free, weekly newsletters in your inbox? Let’s get began.
Discover all of your choices
Task of advantages has lengthy been a contentious problem within the insurance coverage business. The Legislature in 2019 put further restrictions on task of advantages, not less than partially due to a rise in residential water-damage claims.
However contractors contend that task of advantages helps owners who’re unfamiliar with ensuring insurance coverage claims are dealt with correctly.
“AOBs aren’t new and have been used for a very long time, particularly throughout emergency climate conditions,” the lawsuit mentioned. “In Florida, AOBs are prevalent within the residential property context when owners endure injury to their house and want to rent contractors to restore the problems.”
The lawsuit, which incorporates looking for a preliminary injunction towards the regulation, names as defendants Melanie Griffin, secretary of the state Division of Enterprise and Skilled Regulation, and Donald Shaw, government director of the Development Trade Licensing Board. The case has been assigned to Leon County Circuit Decide Layne Smith, in response to a web based docket.
By Jim Saunders, Information Service of Florida