Connect with us

Science

Nonprofit Health System Ends Practice of Denying Care to Patients in Debt

Published

on

Nonprofit Health System Ends Practice of Denying Care to Patients in Debt

Allina Health, a large nonprofit health system based in Minnesota, announced Wednesday that it would end its policy of denying medical care to patients with $4,500 or more in outstanding bills.

Although Allina’s hospitals treated anyone in emergency rooms, other services were cut off for indebted patients, including children and those with chronic illnesses like diabetes and depression, The New York Times reported in June. Patients weren’t allowed back until they had paid off their debt entirely.

Allina issued its policy change less than a week after Keith Ellison, the attorney general of Minnesota, announced that his office was investigating Allina’s practice of withholding care from patients with debt. The investigation is part of a broader look at how the state’s hospitals, which are all nonprofit, bill patients for medical care.

“There is a growing consensus that there is very little difference between a for-profit and nonprofit hospital when it comes to behavior,” Mr. Ellison said in an interview.

Nonprofit hospitals like Allina get massive tax breaks in exchange for providing care for the poorest, most vulnerable people in their communities. But an investigation by The Times last year found that over the past several decades, many nonprofits had largely abandoned their charitable missions, with devastating consequences for patients.

Advertisement

Allina Health owns 13 hospitals and more than 90 clinics in Minnesota and Wisconsin. Its nonprofit status enabled Allina to avoid roughly $266 million in state, local and federal taxes in 2020, according to the Lown Institute, a think tank that studies health care.

In exchange for those lucrative tax breaks, the Internal Revenue Service requires Allina and its nonprofit peers to provide services to their communities, in part by offering free or reduced-cost care to patients with low incomes.

But the federal rules are silent on how poor patients need to be to qualify for free care. In 2020, Allina spent less than half of 1 percent of its expenses on charity care, well below the nationwide average of about 2 percent for nonprofit hospitals, according to an analysis of hospital financial filings by Ge Bai, a professor at the Johns Hopkins Bloomberg School of Public Health.

“The industry needs to tell people they might be eligible for charity care,” Mr. Ellison said. “People don’t seem to be told that ever.”

At least 100 million Americans struggle with medical debts. Their bills account for about half of all the outstanding consumer debt in the country.

Advertisement

Hospitals have increasingly used an array of aggressive tactics to collect debt from patients. Some flood local courts with lawsuits to wring payments from patients. Others garnish patients’ wages or seize their tax refunds.

But Allina’s policy took things a step further.

A 12-page document had instructed the health system’s staff on how to cancel appointments for patients whose debt totaled $4,500 or more. The policy walked providers through how to lock the patients’ electronic health records so that staff members could not schedule future appointments.

Some of the patients who were kicked out had incomes low enough to qualify for Medicaid, the federal-state insurance program for poor people.

Allina employees said the policy had forced them to ration care, even for children.

Advertisement

The health system had initially defended this policy when contacted by The Times in May, noting that it only cut off patients after contacting them by phone and after sending repeated letters that included information about applying for financial help.

But Conny Bergerson, a spokeswoman for Allina, said in a statement this week that the health system had re-examined the policy this summer, and decided that there were “opportunities to engage our clinical teams and technology differently to provide financial assistance resources for patients who need this support.”

Allina’s doctors are continuing to press for additional changes. Earlier this month, the system’s primary care physicians began an effort to form a union. If successful, it would be the nation’s largest union of clinicians. Some doctors are pressing for legislative changes that would restrict or outlaw the practice of withholding care from patients with outstanding bills.

“The state of Minnesota should prohibit the refusal of medical care to children based on medical debt,” said Jennifer Mehmel, a pediatrician who recently retired from her position at Allina. “Children are clearly the innocent victims in this, yet they’re bearing the cost of the problem.”

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Science

LAX passenger arrested after running onto tarmac, police say

Published

on

LAX passenger arrested after running onto tarmac, police say

A Los Angeles International Airport passenger was arrested early Saturday morning after he became irate and ran out of Terminal 4 onto the tarmac, according to airport police.

The passenger appeared to be experiencing a mental health crisis, said Capt. Karla Rodriguez. “Police responded and during their attempt in taking the suspect into custody, a use of force occurred,” she said.

The man, who was not identified, was arrested on suspicion of battery against a police officer and trespassing on airport property, she said. He was taken to a nearby hospital for a mental health evaluation.

A video obtained by CBS shows a shirtless man in black shorts running on the tarmac past an American Airlines jetliner with a police officer in pursuit. The officer soon tackles the man and pushes him down on the pavement.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Science

Video: How SpaceX Is Harming Delicate Ecosystems

Published

on

Video: How SpaceX Is Harming Delicate Ecosystems

On at least 19 occasions since 2019, SpaceX’s operations have caused fires, leaks and explosions near its launch site in Boca Chica, Texas. These incidents reflect a broader debate over how to balance technological and economic progress against protections of delicate ecosystems and local communities. The New York Times investigative reporter Eric Lipton explains.

Continue Reading

Science

Live poultry markets may be source of bird flu virus in San Francisco wastewater

Published

on

Live poultry markets may be source of bird flu virus in San Francisco wastewater

Federal officials suspect that live bird markets in San Francisco may be the source of bird flu virus in area wastewater samples.

Days after health monitors reported the discovery of suspected avian flu viral particles in wastewater treatment plants, federal officials announced that they were looking at poultry markets near the treatment facilities.

Last month, San Francisco Public Health Department officials reported that state investigators had detected H5N1 — the avian flu subtype making its way through U.S. cattle, domestic poultry and wild birds — in two chickens at a live market in May. They also noted they had discovered the virus in city wastewater samples collected during that period.

Two new “hits” of the virus were recorded from wastewater samples collected June 18 and June 26 by WastewaterSCAN, an infectious-disease monitoring network run by researchers at Stanford, Emory University and Verily, Alphabet Inc.’s life sciences organization.

Nirav Shah, principal deputy director of the U.S. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, said that although the source of the virus in those samples has not been determined, live poultry markets were a potential culprit.

Advertisement

Hits of the virus were also discovered in wastewater samples from the Bay Area cities of Palo Alto and Richmond. It is unclear if those cities host live bird markets, stores where customers can take a live bird home or have it processed on-site for food.

Steve Lyle, a spokesman for the state’s Department of Food and Agriculture, said live bird markets undergo regular testing for avian influenza.

He said that aside from the May 9 detection in San Francisco, there have been no “other positives in Live Bird Markets throughout the state during this present outbreak of highly-pathogenic avian flu.”

San Francisco’s health department referred all questions to the state.

Even if the state or city had missed a few infected birds, John Korslund, a retired U.S. Department of Agriculture veterinarian epidemiologist, seemed incredulous that a few birds could cause a positive hit in the city’s wastewater.

Advertisement

“Unless you’ve got huge amounts of infected birds — in which case you ought to have some dead birds, too — it’d take a lot of bird poop” to become detectable in a city’s wastewater system, he said.

“But the question still remains: Has anyone done sequencing?” he said. “It makes me want to tear my hair out.”

He said genetic sequencing would help health officials determine the origin of viral particles — whether they came from dairy milk, or from wild birds. Some epidemiologists have voiced concerns about the spread of H5N1 among dairy cows, because the animals could act as a vessel in which bird and human viruses could interact.

However, Alexandria Boehm, professor of civil and environmental engineering at Stanford University and principal investigator and program director for WastewaterSCAN, said her organization is not yet “able to reliably sequence H5 influenza in wastewater. We are working on it, but the methods are not good enough for prime time yet.”

A review of businesses around San Francisco’s southeast wastewater treatment facility indicates a dairy processing plant as well as a warehouse store for a “member-supported community of people that feed raw or cooked fresh food diets to their pets.”

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending