Connect with us

New Hampshire

How a school-choice request in N.H. led to questions about state board’s authority – The Boston Globe

Published

on

How a school-choice request in N.H. led to questions about state board’s authority – The Boston Globe


“We didn’t want to do this,” Lempster Superintendent James M. Lewis said, “but this is the route we have available to us now.”

If the Lempster School District prevails, this dispute could help to clarify the limits of the state board’s authority, according to Barrett M. Christina, executive director of the New Hampshire School Boards Association.

And if the state’s legal team prevails?

“I think it would give the state board of education unfettered authority to overrule decisions made at the local level,” Christina said.

Advertisement

Last fall, Leite asked the Lempster School District to sign a tuition contract with Mount Royal Academy, a Catholic school in nearby Sunapee. That way, high school students from Lempster — which doesn’t have a high school of its own — could opt to attend the private school at taxpayer expense.

The district already has contracts with a few public high schools in the area. Leite sought to add Mount Royal to the menu of options. That has been permissible since 2021, when state law was changed to allow districts that lack a public school for a particular grade level to approve tuition contracts with private religious schools.

As of last spring, a couple of students were already attending Mount Royal through such a tuition arrangement with the town of Croydon, according to headmaster Derek Tremblay.

Lempster’s school board met with Mount Royal representatives in January to discuss Leite’s request, but decided in February not to pursue the contract, according to school board meeting minutes. The board voiced concerns about the narrower scope of services that Mount Royal provides, particularly with regard to special education.

“After all consideration, the board said, ‘You know … it doesn’t match with what we’re looking for,’” Lewis said. “And the board has that right.”

Advertisement

Leite, however, didn’t give up and filed the appeal.

The state scheduled hearings on the matter, but then the Lempster school board filed suit in April, claiming the state board has a pattern of asserting jurisdiction where it legally has none, forcing public schools to spend time and money on appellate processes that lack any basis in state law.

“Sometimes you have to say ‘no,’ and this is a situation where we’re not going to roll over,” Lewis said.

The presiding judge granted a preliminary injunction on July 30, with a ruling that suggests Lempster’s claims seem potentially persuasive.

Advertisement

State claiming very broad authority

Lawyers in the attorney general’s office, who represent the state board, have refuted the Lempster School District’s allegations. They argue state lawmakers clearly intended the state board to supervise, manage, and direct local school districts. They cite a law that gives the state board jurisdiction over a range of appeals.

One of those lawyers, Rory S. Miller, argued in a court filing in May that the state board has “complete authority” to act when disputes arise between individuals and school districts unless state law offers a specific command to the contrary. That, he added, means the state board has the discretion to direct public schools to approve tuition agreements with private schools on an appeal-by-appeal basis.

But that argument drew a skeptical line of questioning from Merrimack County Superior Court Judge Daniel I. St. Hilaire during a July 31 hearing on a motion to dismiss Lempster’s lawsuit.

“How can they upend a decision by a local school board and force them to enter into a contract?” he asked. “I don’t understand that.”

Miller replied that local school boards are subordinate entities that must obey the state board’s edicts. That’s how it’s been in New Hampshire for more than a century, he said.

Advertisement

St. Hilaire has yet to rule on the state’s motion to dismiss, but his order granting a preliminary injunction rebuffed key pieces of Miller’s case. He wrote that the Lempster School District can pursue contracts “in whatever way it wishes,” that the district was “under no obligation to comply with Leite’s request,” and that the attorney general’s office has cited laws that don’t actually give the state board authority to review this particular decision.

Christina, of the school boards association, said the state Board of Education clearly has legal authority to hear certain types of appeals, but the attorney general’s office is advancing an overbroad argument that would give the state board too much discretion.

Christina said the state board — all seven members were appointed by Republican Governor Chris Sununu and confirmed by the state’s five-member Executive Council — has taken an expansive view of its power in the past six or seven years. Members often seem to side with appellants just because they dislike what the local school board decided, he said.

“Anybody with any complaint seems to be getting their way, regardless of the merits or legalities of the case before the state board,” he said.

Andrew C. Cline, chairman of the state board, disputed that claim. He said the state board has ruled against parents several times because what they requested would have been inappropriate for the state board to impose.

Advertisement

“The board cannot and does not exceed the authority given to it by statute, and we consult with legal counsel in every contested case between a parent and school district to make sure we do not exceed our granted authority,” he said in an email.

Cline noted that parties can file an appeal in court if they believe the state board has overstepped.

But the appellate process itself can put resource-constrained school districts in a tough spot, Christina said.

“They can appeal an unfavorable decision from the state Board of Education, but that’s time, effort, money,” he said.

Advertisement

Religious discrimination not the crux

During the July 31 court hearing, Leite told the judge she assumes the Lempster school board’s refusal to ink a contract with a private religious school must be discriminatory and based on the board members’ personal beliefs.

But others said the school board members had asked questions and articulated concerns unrelated to Mount Royal’s religious affiliation.

“I don’t think the religion aspect had anything to do with it,” Superintendent Lewis told The Boston Globe.

Tremblay, the Mount Royal headmaster, said the Lempster school board members were “cordial” and “sincere” when he met with them in January.

“It seemed to me like they were asking all the questions that really mattered to them,” Tremblay told the Globe, “and I don’t remember religion being a dominating influence. … I don’t even remember the question being asked.”

Advertisement

Leite, who has not granted the Globe’s interview requests, also told the judge she doesn’t believe it’s necessary for her family to pursue any alternative funding arrangement, such as by asking for a “manifest educational hardship” exception or tapping into the state’s “education freedom accounts” program.

“I am not looking for any handouts,” she said.

Under the EFA program, a family that earns up to 350 percent of the federal poverty level — that’s about $109,000 for a family of four — can use money the state would have spent on their child’s public school education to cover costs associated with private school or home-schooling. That EFA funding averaged $5,235 per student last year, according to the New Hampshire Department of Education.

Tuition for high school students at Mount Royal will be $10,700 this school year, Tremblay said.

Parents who send their children to Mount Royal do so knowing the school doesn’t have the same level of resources they could find at a government-run school, Tremblay added. The academy doesn’t have a school psychologist or specialists in speech or occupational therapy, he noted.

Advertisement

“We will not be able to support as much as you could receive in a public school,” he said, “but we’re certainly willing to do everything we can.”

The dispute between the Lempster School District and the state board is happening as policymakers have debated whether and how to expand New Hampshire’s school-choice policies, while also grappling with court orders that deemed major components of the state’s overall school funding apparatus unconstitutional.

The leaders who voters select in November could bring big changes.

Sununu’s successor will decide who to appoint to the state board of education as incumbents finish their four-year terms.

Exactly how much power those appointees can wield over locally elected school officials could depend on how the courts decide Lempster’s case.

Advertisement

Steven Porter can be reached at steven.porter@globe.com. Follow him @reporterporter.





Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

New Hampshire

5 People Diagnosed with Legionnaires' Disease in New Hampshire After Possible Exposure to Cooling Tower

Published

on

5 People Diagnosed with Legionnaires' Disease in New Hampshire After Possible Exposure to Cooling Tower


Five people in New Hampshire have developed Legionnaires’ disease after possibly being exposed to contaminated water droplets from a cooling tower.

The bacterial pneumonia, which is caused by inhaling water droplets contaminated with Legionella bacteria, was found in five people between June and July, said the New Hampshire Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) in a press release on Monday, Aug 12.

An investigation showed that all five individuals may have been exposed to water droplets from a cooling tower behind the RiverWalk Resort in the downtown area of Lincoln, N.H., that tested positive for the bacteria.

“RiverWalk is partnering with DHHS to address the contamination, with additional test results for the cooling tower expected next week,” the press release said.

Advertisement

The resort also confirmed in a statement that they are “working very closely with state officials” to remediate the situation.

Legionnaires’ disease.

Getty


“Upon discovery, our team immediately took the necessary corrective action to kill any residual bacteria per the state’s guidelines. Based on our engineer’s preliminary tests performed this morning, Tuesday, August 13, remediation appears to have been successful,” their statement posted on Facebook read.

According to NBC News, four of the five infected people were initially hospitalized and later discharged. All five individuals have recovered from the disease, per the outlet.

Advertisement

The New Hampshire Department of Health and Human Services (DHHS) noted in its press release that because the cooling tower is “still in operation while remediation is ongoing, there may continue to be some risk of exposure to the public, especially for people within a half-mile of its location.”

New Hampshire State Epidemiologist Dr. Benjamin Chan advised that people who have visited the area near the contaminated cooling tower should monitor themselves for symptoms.

Legionnaires’ disease.

Getty


“People who develop fever or other symptoms of pneumonia within 14 days after spending time in this area should talk to their healthcare provider about testing for Legionella infection,” Chan said in a statement included in the press release.

Advertisement

According to the Mayo Clinic, Legionnaires’ disease usually develops two to 10 days after exposure to Legionella bacteria, with an infected individual examining symptoms such as a headache and muscle aches.

Never miss a story — sign up for PEOPLE’s free daily newsletter to stay up-to-date on the best of what PEOPLE has to offer, from juicy celebrity news to compelling human interest stories.

By the second or third day, additional symptoms can include a cough, shortness of breath, and chest pain, per the Mayo Clinic.



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

New Hampshire

NH families of the missing and murdered demand answers from AG’s office

Published

on

NH families of the missing and murdered demand answers from AG’s office


NH families of the missing and murdered demand answers from AG’s office

In New Hampshire, there are about 130 active missing persons and unsolved murder cases under investigation.

At the New Hampshire State House in Concord, families of some of those cases gathered to demand that their loved ones are not forgotten.

Among them was Valerie Haynes Alvarez.

Her niece, Trish Haynes, was last seen in New Hampshire in 2017.

Advertisement

Her dismembered body was found a year later.

Alvarez is frustrated with the way the case has been handled.

“Trish’s case is not an unsolved case. It’s unprosecuted,” she said. “It’s like reliving it. We don’t want to have to keep reliving it, especially in the light of they have not charged the people who did this.”

Julie Murray, the sister of missing UMass student Maura Murray, is a key member of the group organizing the event.

She is urging the New Hampshire Attorney General John Formella’s Office to be more responsive to these families.

Maura Murray has been missing for more than twenty years.

Advertisement
NE Unsolved: Family of missing UMass Amherst student Maura Murray still fighting for justiceNE Unsolved: Family of missing UMass Amherst student Maura Murray still fighting for justice

NE Unsolved: Family of missing UMass Amherst student Maura Murray still fighting for justice

“We want a response to an email. We want a return phone call so that we feel some small sense of hope that somebody cares,” Julie Murray said.

Members of the Attorney General’s staff attended the event and talked to families

In a statement, the AG said resolving cold cases is a top priority.

The daughters of 2015 unsolved murder victim David Oldham, says what’s needed, is very simple.

“Everybody deserves justice. It doesn’t bring them back, but it least gives us answers,” Ashley Pittman, David Oldham’s daughter, said.

Advertisement

Download the FREE Boston 25 News app for breaking news alerts.

Follow Boston 25 News on Facebook and Twitter. | Watch Boston 25 News NOW





Source link

Continue Reading

New Hampshire

In Their Own Words with George Brown – New Hampshire Magazine

Published

on

In Their Own Words with George Brown – New Hampshire Magazine


There’s a sign high on the wall inside George Brown’s woodshop at Pinkham Notch Visitor Center that reads “grand juction.” 

After 10 years and roughly 600 signs, the missing “n”  is simply a reminder for Brown, a member of the Appalachian Mountain Club and official “Sign Maker,” to take his time when carving out the newest directional signs that line New Hampshire’s trails and which keep hikers on the right track. 

Brown, along with AMC staff and volunteers, helps maintain about 440 miles of trails in White Mountain National Forest — about 750 trail signs in all. When current signs wear out their welcome, become difficult to read, splinter or get chewed by bears or porcupines, staff and volunteers will note its ID number on its reverse and add it to a continuously updated database. That’s where Brown comes in.

Using a premeasured, pretreated white pine board sourced locally, Brown uses a “signmaking machine” — “I’m sure there’s a fancier name,” he says (it’s a Marlin 3-D Carving Machine) — to make a tiny mark in the wood for character placement. Then the machine helps him carve each character using standardized letters in plastic molds.

Advertisement

After chiseling the message, he squeezes a bit of ordinary house paint — chrome green to be exact — into the grooves, then uses the handle end of a small paintbrush to spread the paint and fill in the carved letters. The rest of the sign receives house paint in white.

Retired signs are returned to the woodshop; each year a few are auctioned off, some for a handsome price. 

Here’s an inside look at Brown’s craft.


  New Hampshire Magazine: I think it’s always a relief to see one of your signs — then you know you’re in the right place.

George Brown: I look at it like it’s an adventure. And it’s like a discovery as you hike along. And I think when people come to a junction with a sign, it kind of confirms “Oh, yeah, we’re in the right place, at the right time, we hope.”   

Advertisement

George Brown examines a damaged, splitting sign that has spent years enduring harsh elements.

NHM: I didn’t realize each sign is numbered.  

GB: That’s the actual sign number in the database. There are so many things about trail work that people take for granted — signs being one of them. There’s just a lot of cleaning drainage, building rock walls, brushing the trail and blazing it. A lot of people just don’t know. I can’t fault them.

NHM: How long does it take to make one sign from start to finish for you?

GB: Well, of course, it depends on the number of lines but on average, I would say between an hour and a half to two hours, and that includes layout, which is quite time-consuming. But then you got to spend time putting it together. Sanding it, painting it. And painting the letters, as you can see, is the most time-consuming, because it’s so fine.

Advertisement

NHM: How many coats of paint do they get?

GB: The white is three (coats). One prime, two finish. And the green is just one coat. We always buy top-quality paint, because we don’t want to do those letters twice. Once is enough. 

NHM: These signs seem very consistent. Who came up with this style?

George Brown 7

This wooden sign that was stationed on the Zeacliff Trail has a layer of patina from its time outdoors.

GB: These standards come from the owner of the White Mountain National Forest, which is the United States Forest Service. Most of the time making a sign is spent laying it out to make sure the trail name gets centered and that the text is all the way to the left and right like it’s supposed to be.

Advertisement

NHM: Do the distances on the signs ever need to be adjusted?  

GB: Whenever I make a sign, I refer to the White Mountain Guide. You’ve seen that big thick volume? It tells me exactly where this sign is. I’ll look in the guide and make sure the distance is correct. Chances are, in fact, if you see any sign that is this thickness — five-quarter inch — it was one that I made. 

NHM: How often are the signs replaced? 

GB: I’m guessing 10 years, maximum 15. Ones that are in a somewhat sheltered location — this one is right around Lincoln Woods — this one will probably last 12 to 15 years, I bet. 

NHM: What happens to the old, wornout signs?

Advertisement

GB: Every year, the AMC Trails Department will auction these off. It’s kind of fun to watch it. Someone paid like $1,800 last year (for one). I bet this one will get close to, if not more than, $1,800, because it was in the alpine zone. Anything that is above treeline and gets exposed to that kind of weather, which can be horrific, (is more valuable). 

NHM: How long will you continue to do this?    

George Brown 3

Brown uses locally sourced, treated white pine as he measures the proper distances between characters.

GB: As long as I can, as long as they want me to. I really enjoy it. It’s a great job. There’s always a challenge, but you do have to think through laying things out and spacing and checking the text to make sure it’s accurate.

NHM: Do you ever get bored with this job?   

Advertisement

GB: No, it’s a fun gig. I get to work here at Pinkham. … And it’s a great community here of staff that you get to know pretty well. I’ve got two golden retrievers, and they’ve got many friends here that come in and say hi.

NHM: I came across a picture of you hiking, and you had a new sign in your backpack. Do you always replace them? 

GB: No, I used to put some up. But my knees really started bothering me lately. It’s just real hard for me to get there, and I miss it horribly. There’s a seasonal staff person who puts signs up, but he also has a team of volunteers that puts signs up and also help with the inventory and assess trail conditions.

NHM: Do you still go hiking?    

GB: I do. I maintain the trail over in Evans Notch. I call it the undiscovered gem of the White Mountain National Forest. I look after the lower part of Royce Trail — the first mile follows a cold river stream. And of course, the dogs love it.

Advertisement
George Brown 8

A new sign with chrome green paint in the letters awaits its marching orders.

NHM: That trail’s not too difficult?  

GB: I was done by the end of the day. Because there’s a 2,000-foot elevation gain. So yeah, I still get out there, but I can’t do the 4,000-footers. I was on Emerald Bluff, a 2.4 mile hike along Israel Ridge Trail and Emerald Trail, a couple years ago, and I came to this beautiful outlook of Castle Ravine. And I had this real deep sense of remorse that I can’t do this anymore. And yet, right after that I said, “You know what, I feel just great that I was able to, that I can say that I did that.”





Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending