Massachusetts
‘A bloodbath’: New wave of cuts to NIH research grants hit Mass. hard – The Boston Globe
Charlton no longer had money to pay her staff or any of her researchers. On Monday afternoon, she called and fired the center’s executive director — who just months earlier had uprooted her family and relocated from Los Angeles.
“It breaks my heart to see years of work wiped off the map,” said Charlton, associate professor and founding director of the LGBTQ Health Center of Excellence at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health. “I’m not sure we will ever recover.”
In what has become a weekly ritual, the NIH on Friday afternoon abruptly terminated tens of millions of health research grants in New England and around the country. The latest round of cuts strikes deep at the heart of the medical research infrastructure in Greater Boston, imperiling years of research into disease prevention and health disparities among traditionally underserved populations, according to a half-dozen health researchers whose funding was cut Friday.
Among those hardest hit is the research arm of Fenway Health, which for five decades has pioneered infectious disease research in the gay and lesbian community. On Friday, the NIH terminated five of its research grants. These included multi-year studies into prevention and treatment of HIV for adolescents and the effects of social isolation among older LGBTQ people. Including Friday’s cuts, the Fenway Institute has seen a dozen of its 27 NIH grants terminated since Trump took office — amounting to $1.8 million in lost funding.
“It’s being called a bloodbath,” said Dr. Kenneth Mayer, medical research director at Fenway Health. “The government is essentially saying that, only certain people with certain characteristics matter… and the less you know the better.”
An NIH spokesperson did not respond to questions about the scale and legality of the NIH cuts, instead sharing a link to an agency website and a list of terminated grants. The list shows that more than 300 NIH research grants — with anticipated funding of nearly $200 million — were cancelled between Feb. 20 and last Thursday, March 20th. The cancellations from last Friday are not included in the latest tally.
The cuts are part of the Trump administration’s crackdown on research focused on gender and diversity issues, and appear to violate federal court orders blocking the NIH cuts.
Two legal experts who reviewed NIH termination letters shared with the Globe said they violate federal administrative process law, which prohibits “arbitrary and capricious” policy changes. The mass cancellations also violate contract law because the NIH is imposing conditions on research projects that did not exist at the time the grants were awarded, the legal experts said.
“These terminations are illegal,” said David Super, a constitutional law expert at Georgetown Law, who reviewed the termination letters at the Globe’s request. “NIH has no authority to cancel these contracts without individualized assessments, and doing so violates court orders against blanket cutoffs of legally obligated federal funding.”
The financial impact of the grant cuts has rippled through universities, hospitals and other research institutions in Massachusetts, which is the largest recipient of NIH grant funding per capita. Already, academic scientists are warning of a massive brain drain, as graduate students and post doctoral researchers rethink their futures and consider whether to abandon medical research entirely.
More than a dozen universities, including Harvard, MIT, Brown, and the University of Pennsylvania, have frozen hiring, and the University of Massachusetts’ medical school has rescinded dozens of admissions offers to Ph.D. candidates.
“This could destroy a generation of scientists,” said Dr. Bruce Fischl, a professor of radiology at Harvard Medical School. “A lot of young people see the potential dismantling of medical research and they don’t want to stick around for it.”
Julia Marcus, an infectious disease epidemiologist and associate professor of population medicine at Harvard Medical School, said she burst into tears after the NIH abruptly terminated three of her research grants late last week. Among them was a $2.5 million grant that funded a five-year study exploring the implementation of a long-acting, injectable drug that has been shown to be highly effective at preventing HIV.
Now, she is scrambling to find money to issue paychecks to her research team.
“It’s peak inefficiency,” Marcus said of the cuts. “We poured so much time and effort into this study and then to have it terminated, on the verge of a payoff is, well, I’m running out of words.”
Nearly all biomedical researchers in academia rely to some extent on support from the NIH. Laboratories are run like small businesses, with scientists constantly applying for grants to pay for salaries, supplies and computers. Preparing a grant proposal for the NIH is a monthslong process, with many grant applications running more than 100 pages long, say university researchers.
Some researchers said they were hopeful the NIH cuts that began in earnest last month would slow, or even stop, after the courts intervened. A federal judge in Maryland twice over the past six weeks blocked the administration from terminating funding, saying in his most recent decision that the cuts “punish, or threaten to punish, individuals and institutions based on the content of their speech, and in doing so they specifically target viewpoints the government seems to disfavor.”
But the NIH continues to send out large batches of termination notices, which often arrive in researchers’ email inboxes on Friday afternoons. Many share nearly identical phrasing, including, “This award no longer effectuates agency priorities.”
“Research programs based primarily on artificial and non-scientific categories, including amorphous equity objectives, are antithetical to the scientific inquiry… and ultimately do not enhance health, lengthen life, or reduce illness,” one of the form letters says.
Ariel Beccia, an instructor at the LGBTQ center at the Harvard T.H. Chan School of Public Health, has spent the past two years studying how the COVID-19 pandemic caused health disparities to widen among LGBTQ people; and had entered the most important phase of the study exploring the factors causing the diverse outcomes. A grant from the NIH funded her data analysis work as well as her salary.
Like many of her peers, Beccia has been anxious about losing her grant money since February when Trump issued a series of directives aimed at rooting out “gender ideology.”
Then last Friday afternoon, Beccia was anxiously rebooting her email when a termination letter appeared in her inbox at 4:30 p.m. In a moment, she learned that her sole source of income, including the money she needs to buy groceries and pay rent on her Cambridge apartment, had vanished. Like many of her peers, Beccia is now scrambling to raise money from private funding sources — but the grants are smaller than those awarded by the NIH and the competition is fierce.
In her case, the NIH form letter said diversity, equity and inclusion studies “are often used to support unlawful discrimination” and harm the health of Americans. “It’s disgusting and wildly incorrect,” Beccia said of the letter. “Everyone has a gender identity. So research related to gender is critically important to improving health.”
On Tuesday afternoon, Charlton held a Zoom call to deliver the grim news about the NIH cuts to a dozen members of her research team. They were already reeling from an earlier round of notifications that had terminated a five-year, $4 million study to explore how discriminatory laws, such as so-called “Don’t Say Gay” bills, impact mental health among LGBTQ adolescents and how the laws can potentially lead to suicide. Charlton’s team had interviews lined up with more than 100 adolescents across the country when the termination note arrived.
On the call, Charlton became emotional as she explained that she no longer had the money to pay them but was aggressively seeking private donations to fill the gap.
“I am feeling really hopeful that we’ll figure this out,” she said. “But I also believe it’s going to get a lot worse before it gets better.”
Chris Serres can be reached at chris.serres@globe.com. Follow him @ChrisSerres.
Massachusetts
Who will take care of our older and disabled people? – The Boston Globe
Write to us at startingpoint@globe.com. To subscribe, sign up here.
I’ve been writing for years about immigrants filling jobs that Americans don’t want. Haitians in particular have stepped into the void where the work is hard and the pay is low – cleaning, groundskeeping, preparing food, caring for elderly and developmentally disabled people.
When an influx of migrants flooded into the United States a few years ago, a number of savvy Massachusetts employers opened their doors to them. Thrive Support and Advocacy, a developmental disabilities provider in Marlborough, hired 41 newly arrived Haitians, filling all its full-time direct-care jobs for the first time in a decade.
With the Supreme Court last week siding with the Trump administration’s attempts to end Temporary Protected Status for Syrians and Haitians as part of its continued immigration crackdown, Massachusetts stands to lose 10,000 Haitian TPS holders in the workforce. A decision on Trump’s executive order to end birthright citizenship, which grants automatic citizenship to nearly everyone born on US soil, is expected today.
But it isn’t just a numbers game. Employers continually cite Haitian migrants’ loyalty, hard work, and devotion to the people they’re helping — many of them elderly. Not to mention the ripple effects of losing these valued employees as the aging population skyrockets.
“At some point, many people will be rehab patients,” Adam Scott, CEO of Hebrew SeniorLife told me. “At some point, many people will be long-term care patients. And this impacts all of them.”
When the TPS ruling is implemented, 10,000 Massachusetts residents will be out of a job and expected to leave the country. But many of them have nowhere to go. A pharmacy tech I’ve been talking to over the past few months knew this day was coming, and she has a detailed plan in place that will allow her 14-year-old US-born son, who has autism, to stay. But she has no plan for herself. She can’t go back to Haiti, where she was kidnapped by gangs as a teenager. So she’s hoping to keep working until her employer tells her she has to go.
To where, though, she doesn’t know.
—
Read: Who will care for the elderly and developmentally disabled?
Also: More than 100 Venezuelans deported from the United States just hours before the deadly earthquakes are missing. Seven children were among the group, which was taken to a hotel that was destroyed in the quake. (AP)
🧩 6 Across: Bookstore category | ☀️ 88° Hotter Wed.
World Cup: Can the US soccer team beat a European national team for the first time in 11 matches and make it into the Group of 16? We’ll know tomorrow night. In a thrilling upset, Paraguay sent four-time champion Germany home at Foxborough.
Five in a row: Don’t get too excited yet, but the Red Sox followed their four-game sweep of the Yankees with a 6-3 victory over the Nationals last night. They were led by Wilton Contreras, who has been struggling with the news of the deadly earthquakes in his native Venezuela.
Cannabis rollback: If Mass. voters repeal marijuana legalization, would that put you in danger of being arrested? We answer your questions here.
Heat wave: An Extreme Heat Watch has been declared for Wednesday through the Fourth of July. Here’s how hot it will get.
Wellesley killing: The 24-year-old man charged with fatally stabbing his father had suffered serious mental health issues and battled “to contain his demons,” family friends say.
Hiya, neighbor! Cambridge wants to build “social housing.” What is it?
What now? More people are surviving cancer than ever before. Now health providers are helping people navigate the next step.
Duck Boat accident: Questions about equipment quality and decision-making are being raised about the accident Saturday that injured 11 people when the craft flipped in East Cambridge.
Beaches, shellfish areas closed: A sewer line break in Haverhill dumped millions of gallons of wasterwater into the Merrimack River.
He’s No. 1: Yes, but what made AJ Dybantsa the NBA’s top pick? He’s the exact type of player NBA teams are looking for.
By David Beard

📺 Best TV so far: A whip-smart Italian import. A New England horror comedy. A gay Lutheran minister and his sister stumble across a criminal. Check out our faves.
🏰 Home of the Week: Hail, Victorian! Brookline’s regal Webber-Bouve Mansion has hit the market for $4.3 million. Take a peek. Plus, see the 1976 home for sale that has a Revolutionary War touch.
🍕 Riverside eats: Years in the making, the $24 million Esplanade pavilion project with a café nears the finish line.
🎻 Music as a focusing tool: The jury is out on whether music helps you study or work better or takes away focus, However, instrumental music may help more than those jumping lyrical workout tunes. (The Conversation)
🏴 Tartan adventure: A Globe reporter went to Scotland to find family history, Highland culture — and a wee dram of whisky.
Thanks for reading Starting Point.
This newsletter was edited by David Beard and produced by Ryan Orlecki.
❓ Have a question for the team? Email us at startingpoint@globe.com.
✍🏼 If someone sent you this newsletter, you can sign up for your own copy.
📬 Delivered Monday through Friday.
Katie Johnston can be reached at katie.johnston@globe.com. Follow her @ktkjohnston.
Massachusetts
Millions of gallons of wastewater discharged into Merrimack River due to broken pipe
Approximately eight million gallons of wastewater are currently being discharged into the river per day.
HAVERHILL, Mass. (WWLP) – Those traveling for the Fourth of July weekend are being advised of a wastewater pipe break on the Merrimack River.
The Massachusetts Environmental Police stated that over the weekend, a major wastewater pipe in Haverhill broke, releasing millions of gallons of sewage into the river. The broken pipe was carrying wastewater from the main pumping station to the treatment plant.
Police estimate that approximately eight million gallons of wastewater are currently being discharged into the river per day.
At this time, fishing in the river is not prohibited, and the estuaries and beaches remain open. However, the information is being released to the public to help community members be aware of current conditions and use caution.
To access more information on water quality testing results, you can visit the official DPH website. Updates will be provided as more information becomes available.
Local News Headlines
WWLP-22News, an NBC affiliate, began broadcasting in March 1953 to provide local news, network, syndicated, and local programming to western Massachusetts. Download the 22News Plus app on your TV to watch live-streaming newscasts and video on demand.
Massachusetts
4 shot during World Cup watch party in Massachusetts
BROCKTON, Mass. (WJAR) — Four people were shot on Friday night after hundreds had gathered to watch a World Cup match in Massachusetts.
Police said the shooting happened just before midnight on Main Street in Brockton.
Officers said the victims were taken to the hospital.
BE THE FIRST TO COMMENT
Police have not said if there were any arrests.
-
World7 minutes agoNeon Closing in on Luca Guadagnino’s Sam Altman Open AI Movie ‘Artificial’ After Amazon Drops Controversial Film
-
Lifestyle49 minutes ago‘Dead but Dreaming of Electric Sheep’ is full of beautifully written grotesqueries
-
Technology57 minutes agoGoogle’s NotebookLM can sum up your research in a TikTok-style clip
-
World1 hour agoTrump admin backs Bolivia state of emergency as leftist ex-leader’s loyalists fracture nation
-
Politics1 hour agoCongress eyes rare bipartisan housing win with or without Trump’s help
-
Health1 hour agoAmerica’s national parks could add years to your life — here’s how they boost health
-
Sports1 hour agoLeBron James Next Team Odds: Warriors, Cavaliers, Heat In Mix
-
Technology1 hour agoThe trick to smoother streaming at home and on the road