CNN
 — 

After Rep. Tom Rice turned the primary electoral sufferer of Donald Trump’s revenge marketing campaign in opposition to the Republicans who voted to question him, a GOP colleague who had additionally backed the previous President’s impeachment reached out to the South Carolina lawmaker and tried to console him.

“I instructed him afterward, I stated, ‘A lot for the adage that members of Congress are extra involved about their subsequent election than their job right here,’” retiring Rep. Fred Upton of Michigan recalled telling Rice, in a nod to the truth that his impeachment vote is probably going what price him in final week’s Republican major for South Carolina’s seventh Congressional District.

Whereas Upton’s feedback have been meant to raise Rice’s spirits, additionally they function a actuality verify for the Home’s remaining pro-impeachment Republicans combating for survival in aggressive primaries: supporting Trump’s impeachment – and persevering with to forcefully and publicly rebuke the previous President, like Rice did – is politically perilous in at this time’s GOP.

“You impeach the Extremely MAGA king, you get the boot,” stated firebrand Republican Rep. Lauren Boebert of Colorado, a Trump ally and vocal supporter of the makes an attempt to overturn the 2020 election.

The so-called impeachment 10 – who nonetheless communicate by a bunch chat and have provided one another recommendation and luxury amid a barrage of assaults from Trump and his allies – are wrestling with their very own political survivals after watching their numbers dwindle. At the least half of them gained’t return to Congress subsequent yr, with Rice dropping his major to a Trump-backed challenger and 4 of them opting to retire as an alternative of duke it out, though a few of these selections have been influenced by redistricting.

Now, in hopes of stanching the bleeding, these remaining Republicans are attempting to discern what, if any, classes could be discovered from Rice’s demoralizing – if not considerably anticipated – loss.

There could possibly be no less than one vibrant spot for the group: California Rep. David Valadao, who voted to question Trump however has stored his head down since then, seems prone to have edged out a far-right challenger for a spot within the common election as counting from the state’s June 7 top-two major continues. However Valadao didn’t should compete in opposition to anybody endorsed by Trump, and his district is much much less conservative than Rice’s deep-red seat in northeast South Carolina.

“We now have completely various kinds of districts, we have now completely various kinds of election processes,” Valadao stated. “Everybody handles their scenario in a different way.”

Upton expressed optimism Sunday when requested by CNN’s Dana Bash on “State of the Union” if there could be any Home Republicans left prepared to face as much as Trump after the midterms.

“We’ll see when these primaries are over. However I feel there’ll be among the 10 which might be standing,” he stated.

Nonetheless, between Rice and Valadao, there’s a rising consensus that the important thing to survival after crossing Trump is to mute the general public criticism and concentrate on hyperlocal points.

“If I have been (Rice), I’d have mentioned the problems,” stated Rep. Joe Wilson, a fellow South Carolina Republican. “Him and Trump really agreed on the problems. The most effective that might have been carried out is to emphasise the problems.”

The impeachment Republicans who’re nonetheless staring down major challenges later this summer season appear to be heeding that precise recommendation, cautious of centering their campaigns on an anti-Trump playbook.

Rep. Dan Newhouse, who represents Washington state, instructed CNN: “We’ve bought a technique in place specializing in the problems that matter most to my constituents.

Freshman Rep. Peter Meijer of Michigan stated he’s cognizant of the outcomes of different races however wouldn’t say how that’s affecting his personal marketing campaign technique.

“Each district is completely different, each challenger is completely different. So I’m not going to get into marketing campaign technique. However we’re very aware of what we’ve seen in different races,” he instructed CNN.

Rep. Jaime Herrera Beutler, one other Washington state lawmaker who voted to question Trump for inciting the January 6 riot, virtually turned a witness within the Senate trial after revealing what Home Minority Chief Kevin McCarthy instructed her about his personal dialog with Trump as a mob was storming the US Capitol. However since then, she’s largely prevented the nationwide limelight and any Trump discuss, opting to return to her concentrate on native points.

Requested whether or not she’s frightened that Rice’s major defeat is a warning signal for her personal race, Herrera Beutler instructed CNN: “I be ok with it.”

Rice didn’t return a request for remark, and he was not within the Capitol following his major defeat. He did, nevertheless, flip to a well-known face to function his proxy for ground votes: Meijer.

One notable exception to the keep-your-head-down technique among the many impeachment Republicans is Wyoming Rep. Liz. Cheney, who has pulled no punches since voting to question Trump final yr. Her continued public criticism of Trump’s election lies price Cheney her spot in Home GOP management. And she or he has taken on a high-profile position on the Home choose committee investigating the January 6, 2021, assault on the US Capitol, serving as its vice chair alongside Chairman Bennie Thompson, a Democrat from Mississippi.

In contrast, a lot of the different impeachment 10 have stored the choose committee at an arm’s size. Cheney and retiring Illinois Rep. Adam Kinzinger, who additionally serves on the panel, have been the one Republicans who supported the creation of the choose committee. And most of them have stayed comparatively silent concerning the slew of damning revelations about Trump’s makes an attempt to remain in energy which have come out throughout the panel’s string of public hearings.

However notably, even Cheney’s first two marketing campaign adverts have been laser-focused on native points – not her work on the January 6 committee or warnings about Trump being a menace to democracy. Cheney is taken into account to be probably the most susceptible of the remaining impeachment Republicans, with Trump and his allies placing appreciable vitality into defeating her in her ruby-red Wyoming district. However highly effective names within the GOP institution have lined as much as help Cheney, who has constructed an enormous struggle chest and is pitching herself as a champion for Wyoming voters.

Nonetheless, Trump and his allies have seized on Rice’s major defeat as an indication of momentum for the MAGA wing.

“Similar factor’s going to occur in Wyoming to Virginia ‘resident’ Liz Cheney, that occurred in South Carolina to Congressman ‘Impeach Grasp’ Tom Rice, who misplaced as an incumbent by 28 factors!” Trump posted on social media final week.

One other latest instance of strolling the Trump tight rope is freshman Rep. Nancy Mace. In a little bit of cut up display screen from Rice, Mace, additionally a South Carolina Republican, beat again a Trump-endorsed major opponent after drawing Trump’s ire for strongly condemning his position within the January 6 assault on the Capitol, although Mace didn’t vote for impeachment.

All through her marketing campaign, Mace emphasised her conservative voting report, help for Trump’s insurance policies and endorsements from different big-name Republicans comparable to former South Carolina Gov. Nikki Haley. Mace even filmed a video exterior Trump Tower in New York, calling herself one in every of “Trump’s earliest supporters.” Whereas the opposite impeachment Republicans haven’t gone almost as far, Mace has proven the political upsides to softening her Trump criticism in a aggressive Republican major.

Nonetheless, lawmakers warning that each district and race is completely different. And, not like Rice, GOP management has been on the lookout for methods to spice up Meijer and Herrera Beutler, who characterize swing districts that might have an effect on the GOP’s effort to recapture the Home majority. Nonetheless, even with social gathering leaders on their facet, their victories are hardly assured.

“You’ve set to work exhausting,” Upton stated. “And the others, I imply, they’re working actually exhausting.”

This story has been up to date with extra response.