DENVER — Jurors on Friday discovered police used extreme pressure in opposition to protesters, violating their constitutional rights, throughout demonstrations over the killing of George Floyd two years in the past, ordering the town to pay a complete of $14 million in damages to a gaggle of 12 who sued.
The jury of two males and 6 girls, largely white and drawn from round Colorado, returned its verdict after about 4 hours of deliberations. The decision adopted three weeks of testimony and proof that included police and protester video of incidents.
Legal professionals concerned believed it was the primary trial in a lawsuit difficult officer techniques in the course of the 2020 protests that erupted across the nation over the police killing of Floyd and different Black folks.
The protesters who sued have been shot at or hit by issues from pepper spray to a Kevlar-bag full of lead shot fired from a shotgun. Zach Packard, who was hit within the head by the shotgun blast and ended up within the intensive care unit, acquired the most important harm quantity — $3 million.
One of many protesters’ attorneys, Timothy Macdonald, urged jurors to ship a message to police in Denver and elsewhere by discovering the town liable throughout closing arguments.
Advertisement
“Hopefully, what police departments will take from this can be a jury of standard residents takes these rights very critically,” he stated after the decision.
AUSTIN POLICE:19 Austin cops charged for dealing with of 2020 George Floyd protests
DALLAS POLICE:Warrants issued for two Dallas officers accused of assault throughout 2020 BLM protests
Elisabeth Epps, a lawyer and activist who was one of many protesters who sued, stated the attorneys for the town she loves gaslighted the protesters in the course of the trial, questioning their account of what occurred. At one level, a lawyer for Denver known as her a “skilled protester” after she testified that she had attended protests since she was a toddler and had acquired coaching about how to answer being tear-gassed. She grew emotional speaking about what it meant to have the jury facet with the protesters.
“It seems like being seen,” Epps stated.
Advertisement
The protesters stated the actions of police violated their free speech rights and rights to be shielded from unreasonable pressure. Jurors discovered violations of each rights for 11 of the protesters and solely free speech violations for the opposite.
The protesters claimed Denver was responsible for the police’s actions by means of its insurance policies, together with giving officers huge discretion in utilizing what police name “much less deadly” units, failing to coach officers on them, and never requiring them to make use of their body-worn cameras in the course of the protests to discourage indiscriminate makes use of of pressure.
AFTER GEORGE FLOYD:Former Minneapolis officers discovered responsible on all counts of violating Floyd’s civil rights
Throughout the trial, Denver admitted that errors have been made on the protests, which it says have been unprecedented of their dimension, length and quantity of violence and destruction. Over 80 officers have been injured as protesters hurled rocks, water bottles and canned meals at them, and the state Capitol, the hub of the protests, incurred $1.1 million in harm, in response to the town. Legal professionals for the protesters who sued careworn they weren’t accused of being violent themselves.
Certainly one of Denver’s attorneys, Lindsay Jordan, instructed jurors that the town had deliberate a big coaching in crowd management within the spring of 2020 due to the upcoming presidential election, nevertheless it was canceled due to COVID-19. She careworn that errors made by officers in the course of the protests don’t mechanically equate to constitutional violations, noting 1000’s of individuals returned to train their free speech rights regardless of the pressure police used over the 5 days of demonstrations.
Advertisement
“The violence and destruction that occurred across the neighborhood required intervention,” she stated.
GEORGE FLOYD, TRAYVON MARTIN:For a lot of Black People, these deaths and others have triggered lasting trauma
5 Denver cops have been disciplined for his or her actions in the course of the protests, in response to the division. One other officer, who was new and nonetheless on probation, was fired in the course of the protests after posting a photograph of himself and others wearing tactical gear on social media with the remark “Let’s begin a riot.”
Aggressive responses from officers to folks protesting police brutality nationally have led to monetary settlements, the departures of police chiefs and prison costs.
In Austin, Texas, officers have agreed to pay over $13 million to folks injured in protests in Might 2020, and 19 officers have been indicted for his or her actions in opposition to protesters. Final month, two cops in Dallas accused of injuring protesters after firing much less deadly munitions have been charged.
Advertisement
Nevertheless, in 2021, a federal choose dismissed many of the claims filed by activists and civil liberties teams over the forcible elimination of protesters by police earlier than then-President Donald Trump walked to a church close to the White Home for a photograph op.
On the day after Doug Burgum became governor of North Dakota in 2016, he addressed questions about what he would do about all of his wealthy investments.
They included extensive real estate developments benefiting from state programs that he was suddenly in a position to oversee. His answer was that he would “manage” his conflicts of interest, but he would not divest from his holdings in the state.
“The issue here is to make sure that I have no conflict of interest relative to many state programs and decisions,” he said at the time in an interview with a local newspaper.
Since then, however, his range of holdings, which include extensive urban real estate development in the state, tens of millions in technology investments as well as oil and gas leases, intersected with his policy decisions as governor, a New York Times review has found.
That is particularly true for extensive development efforts in downtown Fargo that have been the beneficiaries of targeted state and federal tax benefits. But at the time, he did not disclose the specifics of any potential conflicts or how he managed them.
Advertisement
Now, as Donald J. Trump’s pick for secretary of the interior, Mr. Burgum could face questions about how he plans to avoid conflicts in leading an agency with vast influence over the use of public lands in ways that reverberate for landholders, energy producers and others.
Rob Lockwood, a spokesman for Mr. Burgum, said in an email to The New York Times: “Everyone who knows Doug Burgum knows that he is a man of outstanding character and ethics who complied with all guidelines as governor.”
Mr. Burgum, whose confirmation hearing is scheduled for Thursday, said in an agreement with the Office of Government Ethics that he would divest from a few holdings that include oil and gas and mineral leases that could pose conflicts.
But he also said he would hold on to other investments that he had been advised might be financially affected by particular matters that could come before the interior secretary. These investments include a range of venture capital funds and some of his Fargo real estate developments, though he will resign from managerial duties in his companies. In those cases, he said, the ethics office had determined that he would be able to recuse himself from decisions that had an impact on those entities or get a waiver.
The Interior Department has long been susceptible to ethical concerns. It has influence over how vast tracts of mineral-rich federal land can be used. During Mr. Trump’s first term, the department became a center of allegations and investigations about conflicts of interest involving high-ranking officials, including the two men who served as its secretary.
Advertisement
Federal law has much stricter disclosure and recusal standards than Mr. Burgum operated under as North Dakota’s governor. It also has criminal prohibitions against officials becoming involved in decisions that could personally benefit themselves or family members.
Mr. Burgum previously disclosed his detailed financial assets for the first time in 2023 as a presidential candidate. An updated version he submitted recently was released by the government ethics office on Wednesday ahead of his hearing, showing a range of assets that could puts his net worth well over $100 million.
While Mr. Burgum was governor, his policies included expanding a state tax program targeted narrowly at real estate development firms like his own that were seeking to revitalize aging downtowns.
His firm, called Kilbourne after his mother’s maiden name, was one of a handful of developers in the state relying in a significant way on such tax breaks and by far the largest in Fargo, according to local officials. He also gave final approval to the zones that benefited from a federal tax credit program, which included areas with his company’s projects in them.
Mr. Burgum was not paid a salary by Kilbourne and “had zero operational authority,” Mr. Lockwood said.
Advertisement
Still, Mr. Burgum continued to have investments in the company’s projects and maintained formal positions in their entities, financial disclosure forms show.
While Mr. Burgum was in office, questions about other ethical choices emerged, including his use of a luxury box at the Super Bowl provided by a regional electricity utility.
After the tickets were reported by The Associated Press, Mr. Burgum said he accepted them to have “quality time” with company executives and he repaid the utility $37,000.
The controversy prompted the governor’s office to enact an ethics policy stating that office officials should “take great care to avoid conflicts of interest or even the perception of a conflict of interest,” including in cases of overseeing policies that involve personal business interests. But the guidelines did not state what actions should be taken when an appearance of a conflict arose.
More enforceable state ethics rules requiring disclosures of potential conflicts of interest did not go into effect until 2022, the result of a 2018 ballot initiative.
Advertisement
Ethics experts in North Dakota and outside the state say that under generally understood norms, Mr. Burgum probably should have made more disclosures about potential conflicts and how he would mitigate them.
“Even a small appearance is enough to trigger an obligation to be open to the public,” said Kedric Payne, a government ethics expert with the Campaign Legal Center.
‘Nobody Really Cared’
In his first State of the State address, in 2017, Mr. Burgum laid out an unusual plan for a state that was one of the most sparsely populated in the country: Go urban.
“It takes safe, healthy cities with vibrant, walkable main streets and downtowns to attract and retain a skilled work force,” he said.
In Mr. Burgum’s vision — built upon his mother’s reverence for historic buildings — North Dakota towns would grow upward rather than outward.
Advertisement
His dream also aligned with his business strategy.
For more than a decade, he had been focusing his development interests in downtown Fargo, eventually becoming one of the state’s biggest urban developers. He also became one of the most reliant on a government tax incentive program called Renaissance Zones.
The program gave state tax incentives for companies that invested in neglected neighborhoods. Mr. Burgum quickly made use of them as well as other similar tax break programs, through acquiring and renovating a turn-of-the-century manufacturing building that was scheduled for demolition, and then turning it over to the local university.
The program allows for state income tax exemption for five years, offering investors in big projects to save up tohundreds of thousands of dollars a year per project in property tax savings.
Twenty Kilbourne projects worth about $300 million have received the Renaissance designation, Jim Gilmour, the city’s director of strategic planning and research, said in an interview. Each of the Kilbourne Renaissance projects was approved individually by a number of city and county entities, with the state’s Commerce Department overseeing the program.
Advertisement
As governor, Mr. Burgum eventually made an expansion of the program a plank in his economic agenda. In his State of the State speech in 2023, he proposed a “Renaissance Zone 2.0.” Among the changes, which were enacted by the Legislature and signed by Mr. Burgum, was a provision to allow for the tax benefits to last an extra three years.
(Kilbourne has not added any new Renaissance Zone projects since then, and Fargo’s county government so far has not agreed to adopt the expansion in benefits.)
Dustin Gawrylow, a longtime Republican critic of the program who unsuccessfully lobbied against the bill, said the perception of a conflict from Mr. Burgum’s status as a top Renaissance developer who could potentially benefit from the expansion was sometimes discussed behind closed doors around the State Capitol.
“It was brought up, but nobody really cared,” Mr. Gawrylow said.
Mr. Lockwood said that “local leaders, the media, and Fargoans are very aware of Doug’s decades-long efforts to revitalize the city.”
Advertisement
Managing Conflicts
While Mr. Burgum was running for governor in 2016, a different state tax break program he used became a subject of discussion on the campaign trail.
Mr. Burgum had founded in 2008 a firm called Arthur Ventures with his nephew, James Burgum, that had invested about $65 million in technology startups up to that point. The firm had taken advantage of a state angel investment tax break program, which provided benefits for certain funds that put money into small startups.
Two funds managed by Arthur Ventures earned investors $800,000 in tax benefits. But the program came under fire from Republican lawmakers for sending a large portion of the investments into out of state startups.
In March 2016, while Mr. Burgum was campaigning, James Burgum testified before the Legislature to try to help save the program that was under attack. The campaign of Doug Burgum’s Republican opponent called him the “poster child” for the problems with the program.
Mr. Lockwood said in his statement to The Times that “job creators being attacked by career-politician opponents for using a law designed to encourage economic investment, innovation and entrepreneurship in North Dakota was a ‘water is wet’ moment.”
Advertisement
Later in the campaign, after Mr. Burgum’s Democratic opponent raised concerns about his ability to manage conflicts of interest, Mr. Burgum said he would “take all the appropriate steps to assure North Dakotans that I’m fully focused on serving them with integrity and transparency.”
After taking office, he explained that meant that he gave up his day-to-day management positions while maintaining his investments under the leadership of others.
But the federal disclosure Mr. Burgum filed to run for president in 2023 revealed that he did not entirely step away. He was listed in various positions ranging from manager and president for various Kilbourne-affiliated limited liability companies and maintained investments of around $15 million to $60 million in several dozen Kilbourne-related entities and funds.
Kilbourne’s managers downplayed his role in the firm, even as they highlighted his affiliation as helping to attract other investors. In an interview with a local publication, Lauris Molbert, Kilbourne’s executive chairman of the board, said the governor’s hefty investments were an important signal to other investors to get on board.
“He personally put his balance sheet to work,” Mr. Molbert said.
Advertisement
A Development Opportunity
In the spring of 2018, a state news release announced that Mr. Burgum had designated 25 neighborhoods in North Dakota to be opportunity zones.
Their designation was part of a new federal program similar to Renaissance Zones but devised to limit federal tax liability in order to help direct investment into struggling neighborhoods.
The idea, Mr. Burgum said, was to “help revitalize our low-income areas in North Dakota.”
Left unsaid, however, was that two of the neighborhoods chosen were ones where his firm owned properties it was hoping to develop. In the years that followed, Kilbourne developed five projects in those areas through two investment funds that offered the tax breaks, with Mr. Burgum’s stake valued between $2 million and $10 million, according to his 2023 financial disclosure.
The structure for the opportunity zones was enacted under the Trump administration, and governors were given leeway in selecting the zones as long as they met certain criteria.
Advertisement
Under the system set up in North Dakota, the city and county of Fargo applied to the state’s Commerce Department for opportunity zone status for 11 areas, including the two containing the Kilbourne properties. Of those, Mr. Burgum designated the two with his properties and three others in the region.
Brett Theodos, a senior fellow at the Urban Institute who has studied the federal opportunity zone program, said he had never heard of such a prominent official tasked with designating the areas having a stake in the zones selected.
“A lot of the country qualified, so there were a lot of options for governors to choose from,” he said. “The whole trust-us approach is problematic.”
Tim Mahoney, Fargo’s mayor, said in an interview that initially he had concerns about whether Kilbourne might get favored in its extensive dealings with the city, but he has concluded that the treatment was aboveboard.
The city relies extensively on the approval of state loans and other sources of funding that are under the governor’s purview.
Advertisement
Mr. Mahoney said he had not spoken to Mr. Burgum directly about any of Kilbourne’s business. But, he said, the governor had met with the planning department and pressured him and other city officials repeatedly to make downtown development a major priority, arguing that added properties build a tax base that supports schools, water, the police and city streets.
That fits with Mr. Burgum’s general evangelism for urbanism — and with where he has invested his money.
“The governor was very clear on what his bias was,” Mr. Mahoney said. “His bias is downtown places will make more in taxes for everybody.”
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favourite stories in this weekly newsletter.
BP is cutting 4,700 jobs, or just over 5 per cent of its workforce, as chief executive Murray Auchincloss tries to save costs and revive a share price that has lagged behind rivals over the past year.
The UK oil major is also reducing the number of contractors it uses by 3,000 this year, adding that 2,600 of those had already departed, according to a memo sent to staff on Thursday by Auchincloss.
In the memo, Auchincloss said BP was making “strong progress” in its attempt to be a “simpler, more focused, higher-value company”.
Advertisement
Auchincloss, who marks his first year as permanent chief executive on Friday, has come under mounting pressure from shareholders after several quarters of disappointing results.
Auchincloss, who was first took the top job on a temporary basis in September, 2023 following the departure of Bernard Looney, last year announced a two-year plan to save $2bn of costs.
In the memo, the 54-year-old Canadian said BP had “stopped or paused 30 projects since June” to streamline its focus, and also intended to expand its operations in lower-cost hubs such as India.
Last year the company opened a 400-person technical centre in Pune, near Mumbai, India, to provide engineering, data and subsurface services.
“We are uniquely positioned to grow value through the energy transition. But that doesn’t give us an automatic right to win. We have to keep improving our competitiveness and moving at the pace of our customers and society,” Auchincloss said.
Advertisement
BP shares rose nearly 2 per cent following the news, but have fallen 5 per cent since Auchincloss took the reins of the company on a permanent basis. The share price has lagged behind that of rivals, including Shell, ExxonMobil and Chevron.
BP’s workforce has swelled to roughly 90,000 people, with roughly 20,000 of those joining after it acquired the TravelCenters of America network of nearly 300 filling stations in 2023.
BP also bought out its joint venture partners in solar business Lightsource BP and Bunge Bioenergia last year, moves that added more staff.
This week BP postponed an event for investors in February so Auchincloss could recuperate from a “planned medical procedure”.
The company is due to report its fourth-quarter earnings on February 11.
Advertisement
In recent weeks, analysts have cut their estimates for BP’s fourth-quarter profit after the company signalled trading in the period was weaker than it had expected.
Performers with the Bob Baker Marionette Theater gesture to the crowd of families at Vidiots, a historic theater in northeast Los Angeles, a few miles from where fires are still burning in the Altadena and Pasadena neighborhoods.
Ryan Kellman/NPR
hide caption
toggle caption
Advertisement
Ryan Kellman/NPR
The carpeted floor of the main theater at Vidiots is drizzled with popcorn as dozens of children and their families crowd around a puppet show. Show tunes blast over the speaker as a puppet named Yellow Cat (who is, indeed, a yellow cat) prances and twirls across the floor.
Vidiots is a historic theater in northeast Los Angeles, a few miles from where fires are still burning in the Altadena and Pasadena neighborhoods. Vidiots joined forces with the Bob Baker Marionette Theater nearby to give families and parents a way to take their minds off the devastation.
Diego Montoya shows off a marionette puppet.
Ryan Kellman/NPR
Advertisement
hide caption
toggle caption
Ryan Kellman/NPR
Advertisement
“The show was planned as a way to give families some relief, an opportunity to do something that’s fun and silly. To sit back and get away from the chaos of the world right now,” says Yellow Cat’s puppet master, Diego Montoya. Vidiots also screened movies and gave out pajamas and coloring books. Many of the families at the free event earlier this week are victims of the fire in one way or another — some have lost homes, others have children who have lost schools.
Three-year-old Leo Bane is one of the spectators of the puppet show. Part of his school burned down in the Eaton Fire, so this event is a welcome distraction for Leo and his mother, Tania Verafield.
“I think this is the only two hours I haven’t been constantly checking my phone and trying to get updates and I feel just some relief at watching my son giggle [as he watches] these amazing puppets,” says Verafield.
Iris Wong (left) sits with her mothe, Tina Yen, and Tania Verafield holds her son, Leo Bane, as they watch the show.
Ryan Kellman/NPR
hide caption
Advertisement
toggle caption
Ryan Kellman/NPR
Schools in the Pasadena and Altadena areas are largely closed as the fires continue to burn. The YMCA and local government are offering child care, but slots are filling up fast, and it’s falling on many families to look after their young ones. Many told me they’re relying on each other to get through this time.
Advertisement
“People don’t know LA. It’s an amazing community,” says Ursula Knudsen. Both of her children lost their school campuses to the fire, and her younger daughter saw her school in flames as she evacuated with her father. Their home was also severely damaged.
“It’s not like Altadena needed a tragedy to come together as a community. That’s what’s wild. It’s only showing up 100 times more than it already was,” Knudsen says.
Buster Balloon shows off a puppet to children at the Vidiots theater.
Ryan Kellman/NPR
hide caption
Advertisement
toggle caption
Ryan Kellman/NPR
Coming to this free event with puppets, movies, and even a 6-foot-tall roving giraffe mascot has brought a moment of relief for Knudsen and her friend, Kate Mallor, whose children’s schools were also severely damaged by the fire. “It’s been so beautiful to see other moms here and to see our classmates and be able to hug,” says Mallor.
The puppet show in the main theater draws to a close with a grand finale. Yellow Cat is dancing to Barbra Streisand’s “Don’t Rain on My Parade,” and that’s no coincidence, says Montoya, the puppeteer.
Advertisement
“It’s got a great message, you know, ‘Don’t rain on my parade, I’m going to have fun no matter what,’” Montoya says. “‘I’m going to do what brings me joy.’”
People walk by the exterior of Vidiots, which has a sign that says, “Here for you LA.”
Ryan Kellman/NPR
hide caption
toggle caption
Advertisement
Ryan Kellman/NPR
The California Newsroom is following the extreme weather from across the region. Click through to LAist’s coverage for the latest.