In years past, Brad Holmes has shown a willingness to move up and down in the first round. Big swings like 32 to 12 for Jameson Williams in 2022, or a willingness to move back and wait for his prospect to fall to him like Jahmyr Gibbs in 2023. But in 2025, Holmes let the board come to him with the Lions’ first-round pick.

The Detroit Lions selected Ohio State defensive tackle Tyleik Williams at pick No. 28, making him the fifth interior defender off the board and the 10th defensive linemen to be drafted in the first round. Earlier this week, ESPN’s Dan Graziano predicted there could be a run on defensive linemen on Thursday night, and while it didn’t happen all that early as Graziano forecasted, it still played out that way before the Lions’ pick.

Still, that didn’t deter Holmes, someone who’s been unafraid of bucking need for value, from taking Williams. Much like a year ago, the Lions were afforded the opportunity to let the draft shake itself out. And much like a year ago, there seemed spots where Detroit could make a move to go up and get a guy with a first-round grade on their board.

In the end, Holmes went with Williams, a massive piece for the middle of the Lions defensive line at 6-foot-3 and 330 pounds. Williams lined up mostly as a three-technique for the Buckeyes defense despite his unusual size for the position. Run defense is at the forefront of his player profile, something Brian Baldinger highlighted shortly after the Lions made him the pick.

It’s easy to see the long-term fit next to Alim McNeill: both capable of moonlighting in the middle of the defense at nose tackle, but also having unusual size plus footwork and agility to make plays in the backfield as a three-tech. In the short term, the Lions have a guy who could very well be ready to step in and be productive immediately while McNeill rehabs from his ACL injury.

Williams recorded an 88.6 run defense grade in 2024 according to Pro Football Focus, the eighth-best mark among 539 qualifying interior defenders in FBS. While he has all the physical tools—athleticism, size, and strength—to play the run as effectively as he does, many analysts (and Holmes) highlight the football intelligence Williams’ possesses. Dane Brugler of The Athletic highlighted that Williams “… has outstanding awareness to identify pre-snap clues and anticipate play design … he is one of the best run-defending linemen in the draft class because of his recognition skills and disciplined execution at deconstructing blocks.” For those reasons, as Holmes remarked on Thursday night to the media, he’s a natural fit for the Detroit Lions.

What’s not as evident in Williams’ game is his pass-rush plan. Despite playing more than 320+ pass-rushing snaps in each of his last two seasons at Ohio State, Williams never registered more than 22 pressures in either season. He tallied just 11.5 sacks in his four-year collegiate career with his freshman season being the most productive (5.0). In spite of fans pining for Detroit to add an edge defender, the Lions opted to go with Williams at pick No. 28. Detroit passed on higher-ranked edge rushers like Jihaad Campbell, who went just three picks later to Philadelphia, and with names like Mike Green and Donovan Ezeiruaku also still available, the Lions clearly prioritized interior disruption over edge help.

Could Holmes have afforded to be more patient with the board and wait on Williams, or a similarly-tiered player? The Los Angeles Rams were able to move back 20 spots and into the second round for a future first-round pick from the Atlanta Falcons. The Houston Texans added a third-round pick this year (99) and next year to move back from 25 to 34. It takes two to make a deal happen, and maybe it just wasn’t there for Detroit in the end.

Detroit upgraded their defensive line in the immediate and created a blueprint for the future of their interior. Williams is exactly the kind of player the Lions covet when it comes to his football smarts and ability to defend the run, and it’s easy to see his path to contributing. He is as much an identity pick as you’ll find in the first round. But it’s also fair to question if Holmes got the most value out of the 28th overall pick by selecting a prospect that checked in at No. 41 among the Top 300 of Arif Hasan’s Consensus Big Board.

Williams is a clear identity and scheme fit, and there’s no doubt he’ll help Detroit’s run defense right away. Questions about his upside as a pass rusher and draft value keep this pick from earning top marks, but the commitment to solidifying the interior of the defensive line make this a pick that’s hard to scrutinize too much.

My grade: B