Connect with us

Fitness

Yoga vs Pilates: A fitness expert reveals which exercise is actually right for you

Published

on

Yoga vs Pilates: A fitness expert reveals which exercise is actually right for you

Looking after ourselves is no longer something we do out of obligation; it’s now a part of our everyday lives. We’ve learned that when we exercise, we feel much better, and being active influences not only our physical state but our mental one too.

There are many types of exercises we can do to achieve these benefits. Among the most recommended activities are yoga and Pilates – two disciplines that, although sharing certain benefits, have key differences that can help you decide which one best suits your needs. 

As fitness expert Diego Moya, who holds a PhD in Physical Activity and Sport Sciences from the University of Valencia, explains, “Both disciplines bring together the power of connecting body, mind and breath.” This common element makes them highly effective tools for combating the tension accumulated in daily life.

With the fitness scholar’s help, we tell you how to incorporate them into your routine so you can choose which one you prefer – or maybe you’d like to give both a chance!

Breathwork and mindset: The shared foundations of yoga and Pilates

© Getty Images
Both yoga and Pilates help reduce stress – and both can be done at home

Yoga and Pilates share a fundamental pillar: conscious breathing. Focusing on breathwork not only helps to oxygenate the body but also encourages connection with the present moment, reducing stress and promoting a sense of inner calm. 

Advertisement

“Both yoga and Pilates bring together the power of connecting body, mind and breath”

Fitness expert Diego Moya

You can practise both yoga and Pilates at home, in a studio or outside (which is in line with current outdoor wellness trends). If you choose nature, the connection with the environment will undoubtedly enhance the experience. If you exercise indoors, meanwhile, listening to relaxing music can help create a space that’s conducive to concentration and serenity.

Why choose yoga? Benefits for stress relief and mental health

Yoga is an ancient discipline that combines physical postures (asanas), breathing exercises (pranayama), and meditation.

Yoga can help increase flexibility, reduce stress and improve© Getty Images
Yoga can help increase flexibility, reduce stress and improve self-esteem

The main goal of yoga is to achieve the union between body and mind, and its benefits go far beyond increasing flexibility. These include:

  • Stress reduction: Regular yoga practice can decrease levels of cortisol, the stress hormone, and improve mood.
  • Better sleep: Evening yoga sessions are ideal for relaxing the body and preparing the mind for a deep, restorative sleep.
  • Strengthened immune system: By reducing stress, yoga can also strengthen the body’s natural defences.
  • Increased self-esteem: The connection with the “inner self” helps to boost confidence and self-acceptance.

As Moya indicates, one of the key moments in yoga is Savasana, or the relaxation pose, performed at the end of each session. This pose allows the body to restore its energy balance and the mind to reach a state of deep peace. It is a simple yet powerful tool for eliminating accumulated tension.

Why choose Pilates? Benefits for core strength and posture

While yoga is about connecting the body and mind, Pilates focuses on strengthening the core and improving posture. 

Balance training through pilates © Shutterstock / BearFotos
Pilates helps to strengthen your muscles, including core strength, and improve your posture

This discipline, created by Joseph Pilates, is ideal for those looking to tone their body, prevent injuries and strengthen their back. Its benefits include:

  • Muscle strengthening: Pilates works all muscle groups in a balanced way, which improves physical strength and endurance.
  • Postural correction: It is especially useful for people with back pain or posture problems, as it reinforces stabilising muscles.
  • Greater flexibility: Although not its main focus, Pilates also contributes to improving muscle elasticity.
  • Injury prevention: By strengthening the core, it reduces the risk of injuries in daily or sports activities.

Unlike yoga, Pilates is more dynamic and physical, making it an excellent option for those seeking a more intense activity without losing the mind-body connection.

Both disciplines are compatible and can complement each other, so you might not have to choose between one and the other.

Yoga vs. Pilates: How to choose based on your fitness goals

The choice between yoga and Pilates depends on your personal needs and goals. 

Advertisement
  • If you are looking for a comprehensive practice that encompasses the physical, mental, and spiritual, yoga might be the best option. It is especially recommended for those who need to reduce stress, improve flexibility, or work on their inner connection.
  • If your priority is to strengthen your body, improve your posture, or complement a sports regimen, Pilates is an ideal choice.
Happy mature woman exercising at home on mat© Getty Images
Some moves are common in both Pilates and yoga

Keep in mind, however, that both disciplines are compatible and can perfectly complement each other in a weekly routine.

Pro tips: How to start your yoga or Pilates journey  

If you are keen to start practising yoga or Pilates, these practical tips can help you get the most out of them. For example, setting a fixed time for practice is key, as doing it first thing in the morning allows you to start the day with energy, while practising in the evening helps to release tension and relax before bed. 

Strength training, cardiovascular exercise, and gentler forms of movement like yoga and Pilates are key to a balanced routine
© Silke Woweries
Whether in a studio or at home, choose a space with tranquillity and soft light

It is essential to disconnect from distractions by turning off your mobile and other electronic devices to focus fully on the activity without interruptions. 

Furthermore, choosing an appropriate space is also important: look for a quiet place, preferably with natural light, and put on relaxing music if you are indoors. Finally, practising barefoot improves grip and stability in the postures, optimising the experience in both yoga and Pilates.

Fitness

Strategic Exercise Techniques to Maximize Mood Elevation – The Boca Raton Tribune

Published

on

Strategic Exercise Techniques to Maximize Mood Elevation – The Boca Raton Tribune
A Shift in Scientific Understanding Reveals That the ‘Runner’s High’ Stems from a Complex Cocktail of Chemicals, Including Endocannabinoids, Which Can Be Triggered by Adjusting Duration and Social Context. The widely reported phenomenon of exercise-induced euphoria—often known as the “runner’s high”—is rooted in specific alterations to neurochemistry that generate feelings of hope, calmness, and social […]
Continue Reading

Fitness

Do you have sore hips? I asked a pain specialist why this happens and how to improve it

Published

on

Do you have sore hips? I asked a pain specialist why this happens and how to improve it

Hip soreness is a terribly common issue—it’s something that I certainly suffer with—so I’m always trying to get to the bottom of where this soreness originates from and what you can do about it.

According to Dr Shady Hassan, MD, an interventional pain and sports medicine physician and the founder of NefraHealth, immobility is the root cause of this discomfort.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Fitness

“No Pain No Gain” May Be Wrong: Science Says Slow Eccentric Exercise Builds Stronger Muscles

Published

on

“No Pain No Gain” May Be Wrong: Science Says Slow Eccentric Exercise Builds Stronger Muscles

Modern exercise culture has spent years glorifying exhaustion. The harder a workout feels, the more effective people assume it must be. Sore muscles became badges of honor, while gentle movements were often dismissed as ‘not real exercise.’ 

A man lifting a dumbbell. Image credits: Andres Ayrton/Pexels

However, according to a new study, some of the most efficient ways to build muscle strength may happen during the slow, controlled moments people usually ignore—walking downstairs, lowering weights, or carefully sitting into a chair. 

Study author Kazunori Nosaka, who is the director of exercise and sports science at Edith Cowan University, argues that eccentric exercise—a type of muscle action that occurs while muscles lengthen under tension, may offer a more practical alternative. Its opposite, concentric exercise, is the shortening (lifting) phase where muscles produce force to overcome resistance.

Instead of demanding maximum effort, these movements appear to train muscles while placing less stress on the body.  

“The idea that exercise must be exhausting or painful is holding people back. Instead, we should be focusing on eccentric exercises which can deliver stronger results with far less effort than traditional exercise – and you don’t even need a gym,” Nosaka said.

Muscles work differently on the way down

The study examines decades of earlier research on eccentric exercise rather than presenting a single laboratory experiment. It focuses on a simple but often overlooked detail of human movement, which is how muscles behave differently depending on whether they are shortening or lengthening.

Advertisement

When someone lifts a dumbbell, climbs stairs, or rises from a chair, muscles shorten as they generate force. Scientists call this a concentric contraction. Eccentric contractions happen during the opposite phase—when the muscle stays active while stretching. 

Examples include lowering the dumbbell back down, descending stairs, or slowly lowering the body into a seated position. According to the review, muscles can tolerate and produce greater force during eccentric actions while using comparatively less energy and oxygen. 

“Eccentric contractions are distinguished by their ability to generate greater force than concentric or isometric contractions, while requiring less metabolic cost,” Nosaka notes.

Researchers believe this happens because muscles act more like controlled braking systems during lengthening movements, resisting gravity rather than directly overpowering it. As a result, people may gain strength without putting the same level of demand on the cardiovascular system. 

This difference could make eccentric exercise especially useful for individuals who find traditional workouts physically overwhelming.

“Eccentric exercise training provides numerous benefits for physical fitness and overall health, making it suitable for a wide range of individuals from children to older adults, clinical populations to athletes, and sedentary to highly active people,” Nosaka added.

Gravity may be doing more training than we realized

To support this argument, the study brings together findings from several earlier research works. For instance, one study from 2017 tracked elderly women with obesity who repeatedly walked either upstairs or downstairs over a 12-week period. 

While climbing stairs is normally considered the tougher workout, the women assigned to walk downstairs showed stronger improvements in measures including blood pressure, heart rate, and physical fitness. The results suggested that resisting gravity during downward movement may provide a surprisingly powerful training effect.

YouTube videoYouTube video

The review also discusses eccentric cycling, where participants resist pedals driven backward by a motor instead of pushing them forward in the usual way. 

Although the movement feels unusual and requires concentration, earlier studies found it improved muscle power, balance, and cardiovascular health while feeling less exhausting than standard cycling workouts.

Another important part of the review addresses muscle soreness, one of the main reasons eccentric exercise never became widely popular outside rehabilitation settings. People often experience delayed onset muscle soreness, or DOMS, after unfamiliar eccentric workouts. 

Advertisement

“Unaccustomed eccentric exercise is often associated with muscle damage characterized by delayed onset muscle soreness (DOMS) and a reduction in muscle force-generating capacity lasting more than a day. However, this effect diminishes or at least is attenuated when the same eccentric exercise is repeated (known as the repeated bout effect),” Nosaka explained

Many eccentric exercises require little or no equipment. Slow squats into a chair, heel-lowering movements, controlled wall push-ups, or even maintaining posture against gravity can activate eccentric muscle work. 

Moreover, some studies referenced in Nosaka’s review suggest that just a few minutes of these exercises each day can still produce measurable improvements in health and strength.

The future of fitness may feel less punishing

The findings challenge the mindset surrounding fitness itself. Many people abandon exercise routines because they associate physical activity with pain, fatigue, or lack of time. Eccentric exercise suggests that effective movement does not always need to feel extreme. 

If future research continues to support these findings, eccentric exercise could influence far more than gym routines. It may reshape physical rehabilitation, elderly care, injury recovery programs, and public-health recommendations aimed at increasing physical activity among sedentary populations. 

These exercises also place lower demands on the heart and lungs while still strengthening muscles. They could help people who are unable or unwilling to follow intense training programs.

Advertisement

Nosaka suggests that “we should establish eccentric exercise as standard practice, and make it common, accessible, and widely accepted as the ‘new normal’ of exercise to improve life performance and high (athletic) performance.”

However, this does not mean eccentric exercise is a universal replacement for all forms of physical activity. The current paper is a review of previous studies, and its findings still need to be validated through experiments and large-scale clinical trials.

Nosaka also notes that “Future studies should investigate mechanisms underpinning the effects of eccentric exercises in comparison to other types of exercises (e.g., isometric exercises, concentric exercises, aerobic exercises),”  

This could help scientists design safer and more personalized exercise programs for different age groups and health conditions.

The study is published in the Journal of Sport and Health Science.

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending