Movie Reviews
Memoir of a Snail movie review (2024) | Roger Ebert
What’s worse than the shells that other people place us in our lives? The shells that we place on ourselves. This idea of the intangible things that we carry on our backs like insecurity, depression, grief, and trauma is at the core of Adam Elliot’s moving stop-motion saga “Memoir of a Snail,” which is unlike any other animated film you will see this year. It’s a gorgeous film, but it’s also an emotionally intelligent movie, one that shifts and flows between comedy and tragedy, reminding us that life can only be lived forwards.
Sarah Snook of “Succession” fame delicately voices Grace, who is telling her life story to her favorite pet snail Sylvia after the death of the last person on Earth she cared about, her best friend Pinky (a wonderful Jacki Weaver). It’s a story of notable hardship. Mom died in childbirth. Dad was a paraplegic who didn’t live long enough to raise Grace or her twin brother Gilbert (voiced by Kodi Smit-McPhee in adulthood). The twins were split after dad passed, sending Grace to a pair of swingers—yes, this is a shockingly adult stop-motion movie, likely setting a new record for nudity in the form—and Gilbert to a family of religious fundamentalists on the other side of the country. Much of “Memoir of a Snail” consists of letters sent back and forth between Grace and Gilbert, vowing to return to each other as soon as they can escape the shells that life has placed on them.
Just because it’s stop-motion doesn’t mean “Memoir of a Snail” can’t be one of the most thematically dense films of the year. Elliot has crafted a whimsical world, one that feels inspired by the work of Marc Caro & Jean-Pierre Jeunet in films like “Delicatessen” and “Amelie”—an inspiration that gains even more likelihood with the inclusion of JPJ regular Dominique Pinon in the voice cast. There’s an exaggerated, fantasy aesthetic to some sequences, but it’s all grounded just enough in reality to allow its emotions to register. What I’m saying is don’t expect talking snails. This is a story of an ordinary life in many ways, made extraordinary in how beautifully it’s told. And while we’re on the technical acumen of this film, a brief aside to note one of the best scores of the year, by far, from Elena Kats-Chernin, so lovely that it almost becomes a character in the film. It’s essential to the spell this movie casts.
That spell is bursting to the seams with ideas, emotions, and references. It’s not every day you see a stop-motion animated film with nods to Sylvia Plath, Lord of the Flies, and Cahiers du Cinema, but the creator of the equally marvelous “Mary & Max” is also a phenomenal writer, something that is often underestimated in the visual form of animation. This is a carefully calibrated character arc—just as the bleakness of Grace’s story feels like it’s going to overwhelm you, Elliot pivots to revel in the unpredictable grace of life, reminding us that snails can’t move backwards, and neither can we. That’s kind of the point. Just when we think life is too much, a warm gesture from a stranger or a memory of a loved one or even just a good book or film can shift our perspective.
“Memoir of a Snail” is one of those tender films in which every frame and every line feels so carefully considered, and yet it’s somehow not over-written at the same time. Some may disagree and wish the film could allow for someone to emotionally catch their breath, but that’s not how a story like this works. By charting Grace’s entire life to this point, Elliot is allowed to explore so many different ideas from the childhood insecurity placed on Grace by bullies to Gilbert’s horrifically judgmental family to the way Pinky pushes away all of the things that try to hold her down. Pinky’s joie de vivre is essential to the success of “Memoir of a Snail,” a reminder of both Grace’s inherent kindness and how we must live every moment on this earth to the fullest.
Elliot’s script is so loaded with ideas that people will be able to take different aspects of it into their own lives, but it’s actually a line about Grace’s eventual husband that I’ll carry for a long time. His hobby is repairing broken pottery, but not in a way that hides that it was broken in the first place. “All things can be repaired, and our cracks celebrated.” When we discard the shells that we’ve placed on ourselves in life, we don’t do so easily. We can still see the cracks. But we can also choose to celebrate them.
This review was filed from Fantastic Fest. It opens on October 25th.
Movie Reviews
Michael Jackson documentary set to release after massive re-write
-
Fans reignite Drake vs Kendrick feud after album announcement
03:35
-
Now Playing
Michael Jackson documentary set to release after massive re-write
02:57
-
UP NEXT
Patrick Brammall on How He Got His Role in ‘Devil Wears Prada 2’
05:43
-
Henry Winkler on ‘Hazardous History’ S2, Zip lining With Grandkids
07:38
-
Did Harry Styles and Zoë Kravitz Get Engaged?
04:05
-
Ana Gasteyer on Role in ‘Schmigadoon!’ Musical: ‘I’m Very Mean’
06:03
-
Laufey Talks Children’s Book ‘Mei Mei the Bunny,’ Coachella, More
05:15
-
Shania Twain to Host the 2026 Academy of Country Music Awards
00:26
-
Colman Domingo and Nia Long Talk New Michael Jackson Biopic
04:50
-
Charlize Theron Talks Intense Training for New Thriller, ‘Apex’
06:30
-
Jimmy Kimmel Shares Photo of His Son to Mark His 9th Birthday
00:39
-
Could Rocky Score an Oscar for ‘Project Hail Mary’ Movie?
01:36
-
‘The Pitt’ Season 2 Finale Sees Huge Surge in Streams
01:23
-
‘Top Gun’ Movies Are Returning to Theaters for 40th Anniversary
01:24
-
Chicago collectible store is latest target in Pokemon card crime spree
01:59
-
Victoria Beckham Shares Hot Takes on Chores, Nicknames, More
07:34
-
John Legend Talks New Book, ‘The Voice’ Finale, Marriage, More
06:37
-
Victoria Beckham Talks Family, Marriage, Navigating Tough Times
07:58
-
Steve Schirripa Joins TODAY With Dog WillieBoy to Talk New Book
04:32
-
Stars of ‘Running Point’ Discuss What to Expect From Season 2
06:34
Top Story
-
Fans reignite Drake vs Kendrick feud after album announcement
03:35
-
Now Playing
Michael Jackson documentary set to release after massive re-write
02:57
-
UP NEXT
Patrick Brammall on How He Got His Role in ‘Devil Wears Prada 2’
05:43
-
Henry Winkler on ‘Hazardous History’ S2, Zip lining With Grandkids
07:38
-
Did Harry Styles and Zoë Kravitz Get Engaged?
04:05
-
Ana Gasteyer on Role in ‘Schmigadoon!’ Musical: ‘I’m Very Mean’
06:03
Hallie Jackson NOW
Stay Tuned NOW
Play All
Movie Reviews
Miyamoto says he was surprised Mario Galaxy Movie reviews were even harsher than the first | VGC
Nintendo’s Shigeru Miyamoto says he’s surprised at the negative critical reception to the Super Mario Galaxy Movie.
As reported by Famitsu, Miyamoto conducted a group interview with Japanese media to mark the local release of The Super Mario Galaxy Movie.
During the interview, Miyamoto was asked for his views on the critical reception to the film in the West, where critics’ reviews have been mostly negative.
Miyamoto replied that while he understood some of the negative points aimed at The Super Mario Bros Movie, he thought the reception would be better for the sequel.
“It’s true: the situation is indeed very similar,” he said. “Actually, regarding the previous film, I felt that the critics’ opinions did hold some validity. “However, I thought things would be different this time around—only to find that the criticism is even harsher than it was before.
“It really is quite baffling: here we are—having crossed over from a different field—working hard with the specific aim of helping to revitalize the film industry, yet the very people who ought to be championing that cause seem to be the ones taking a passive stance.”
As was the case with the first film, opinion is divided between critics and the public on The Super Mario Galaxy Movie. On review aggregate site Rotten Tomatoes, the film currently has a critics’ score of 43% , while its audience score is 89%.
While this is down from the first film’s scores (which were 59% critics and 95% public) it does still appear to imply that the film’s target audience is generally enjoying it despite critical negativity.
The negative reception is unlikely to bother Universal and Illumination too much, considering the film currently has a global box office of $752 million before even releasing in Japan, meaning a $1 billion global gross is becoming increasingly likely.
Elsewhere in the interview, Miyamoto said he hoped the film would perform well in Japan, especially because it has a unique script rather than a simple localization as in other regions.
“The Japanese version is a bit unique,” he said. “Normally, we create an English version and then localize it for each country, but for the first film, we developed the English and Japanese scripts simultaneously. For this film, we didn’t simply localize the completed English version – instead, we rewrote it entirely in Japanese to create a special Japanese version.
“So, if this doesn’t become a hit in Japan, I feel a sense of pressure – as the person in charge of the Japanese version – to not let [Illumination CEO and film co-producer] Chris [Meledandri] down.
“However, judging by the reactions of the audience members who’ve seen it, I feel that Mario fans are really embracing it. I also believe we’ve created a film that people can enjoy even if they haven’t seen the previous one, so I’m hopeful about that as well.”
Movie Reviews
‘I Swear’ Review – Heart Sans Sap, Cursing Aplenty
The sixth outing in the director’s chair for filmmaker Kirk Jones, I Swear dramatizes the real-life story of touretter John Davidson (played by Robert Aramayo). Tourette’s Syndrome, for those unfamiliar with the condition, is a nervous system disorder that causes various tics, the most prolific being erratic and explicit language. However, as I Swear expertly showcases, the syndrome is far more than ill-timed outbursts of curse words. Davidson’s story is one of societal frustration, finding your people (both with and without the condition), and using your voice to help others rise. The subject and subject matter are handled with absolute care and understanding under Kirk’s measured vision and Robert Aramayo’s BAFTA-winning performance.
The film kicks off with the greatest exclamation to democracy ever uttered (*%#! the Queen!), as a nervous John Davidson prepares himself before entering an awards ceremony hosted by Britain’s royal family. Right away, the film tells us what it is: a triumph over adversity that blends humor and human drama with education. It’s an important setup, as the film flashes back to Davidson’s 1980s youth, where we see his time as a star soccer recruit flatline as his condition takes hold. Davidson’s life spirals from there. Some aspects, like school bullying and accidental run-ins with authority figures, are expected but important to empathizing with young Davidson’s (young version, played with heart by Scott Ellis Watson) new everyday life. The more tragic, a complete meltdown of his family system, is unsettling if quick. His father (Steven Cree) is never given enough screen time to explore his alcohol coping tendencies. However, his mother Heather’s descent into easy fixes and blaming is crushing and convincing. Harry Potter series actress Shirley Henderson (Moaning Myrtle) gives a layered performance as Heather. Someone who loves her son, but also feels cursed by him as the entire family exits the picture. It’s bitter, she’s tired, and fills each conversation with ‘only medication and your mother can save you’ energy.
From there, the viewer and Davidson find refuge in a host of characters. Maxine Peake plays Dottie, the mother of a childhood friend and a retired mental health nurse. Screen vet Peter Mullan plays maintenance man Tommy Trotter. Together, they help Davidson build a life and an understanding of himself that carries the film forward into its second half. After that, the film is primarily a 3-actor show as director Kirk fills the screen with these tour-de-force performances. Peake and Mullan are great vessels to get the film’s main message across: patience, love, and a shared responsibility between the diagnosed and those who understand their struggle can help change the path for people quickly left behind by a normative world. Together, they are the soul of the movie, with the filmmakers clearly hoping the audience will follow their lead after they exit the theater (in my case, the beautiful Oriental Theater for the Milwaukee Film Festival). Both performances are perfectly warm and reflective and shouldn’t be left out in discussions of I Swear.
I say this because the movie is anchored by The Rings of Power actor Robert Aramayo, who leaves Elrond’s elf ears behind to bring an acute naturalism to his performance of main character John Davidson. Aramayo’s physicality and timing of the fitful Tourettes Syndrome never feel out of place or overplayed. In fact, the movie as a whole does an amazing job of never veering into sentimentality. While many moviegoers left with tissues dabbing their eyes, the filmmaking never felt like it was forcing that reaction out of audiences. It straddles the line between feel-good and reality with every story beat and lands squarely on the side of letting the real inform our feelings. Anyone with an ounce of empathy will grasp the film’s message and hopefully take it with them into life.
I Swear continues at the Milwaukee Film Festival on Tuesday, April 21st, and releases nationwide April 24th, 2026, courtesy of Sony Pictures Classics.
-
New York1 hour agoMamdani Considers Delaying Pension-Fund Payments to Ease Budget Gap
-
Detroit, MI2 hours agoThings to do in Metro Detroit, April 24 and beyond
-
San Francisco, CA2 hours agoCA to open 3 new state parks and expand others, including in Bay Area: Here’s where
-
Dallas, TX2 hours agoWild vs. Stars Game 3: Key takeaways as Dallas takes series lead on Wyatt Johnston’s 2OT winner
-
Miami, FL2 hours agoMiami-Dade deputies detain elderly father who they say shot and killed his son after a domestic dispute
-
Boston, MA2 hours agoBoston has one of the best public markets in the country, says USA TODAY
-
Denver, CO2 hours agoRed flag fatigue? Colorado sees near-record number of critical fire days
-
Seattle, WA3 hours agoFOLLOWUP: West Seattle pickleball players band together to save court access
