Montana

Audit report finds Ellsworth committed waste, abuse • Daily Montanan

Published

1 year ago

January 24, 2025

Audit report finds Ellsworth committed waste, abuse • Daily Montanan

Former Montana Senate President Jason Ellsworth abused his position of power in a contract he signed with a former associate and rushed the process to finalize it, resulting in a waste of state resources, according to a report by the Legislative Audit Division released Friday.

According to the report, the Department of Administration recognized a problem with a pair of contracts Ellsworth originally wanted approved. In an attempt to rectify the issue, the Department of Administration used an exception to roll the contracts together, but auditors said the process was not justified by state rules.

“The initial effort (by Ellsworth) to artificially bifurcate the contracts and the subsequent acceptance of decisions to forgo proper sole source exceptions and exigency procedures deprived the state of the financial benefits of open competition in procurement, and therefore constituted a waste of state resources,” the report said.

The audit came after news that Ellsworth in December quietly signed a $170,100 contract with a former associate as head of a committee pushing for judicial reform despite committee members considering the expense unwarranted. The contract is in the process of being terminated.

Current Senate President Matt Regier criticized the deal, first reported by the Montana State News Bureau, as improper. Regier referred it to the Legislative Audit Division, which subsequently released the report to Senate leadership on Friday.

Ellsworth did not respond to requests for comment on Friday, but on Wednesday told the Daily Montanan that the allegations amounted to a “political witch hunt.”

Senate leadership began weighing in on the matter Friday afternoon. Minority Leader Sen. Pat Flowers, who had been mostly quiet about the allegations of impropriety, released a prepared statement.

“We take any waste or abuse of taxpayer dollars very seriously. Furthermore, it is our responsibility to hold our colleagues accountable for their actions. It’s clear that Senator Ellsworth’s conduct fell below the high standards Montanans expect from their elected representative. This matter should be referred to the Senate Ethics Committee for further review and an appropriate resolution,” Flowers said.

Regier previously said that an ethics complaint was likely to follow the release of the audit report, but would not respond to questions on Friday.

“I’m reviewing the Legislative Auditor’s initial report in detail and I’m glad to see the Senate Minority finally expressing concern over the situation. I plan to speak more on this highly concerning issue on Monday,” he wrote in a statement.

On Wednesday, Ellsworth told the Daily Montanan he was “fully cooperating” with the audit.

However, the report said the same day, Ellsworth declined to talk with the Legislative Audit Division for the investigation and did not respond to written questions, citing the need to secure a lawyer.

“He did not respond to our written questions, and we have considered his public statements, where relevant, and have relied on the factual evidence of his actions as supported by official documents and witness interviews,” the report said.

In December, Ellsworth attempted to enter into two contracts totaling $170,100 to hire Bryce Eggleston, with Agile Analytics, to conduct analysis of 27 bills throughout and after the 69th Legislature. The bills all came from the Senate Select Committee on Judicial Oversight and Reform, which Ellsworth formed while he was president and led as chairman.

But the report said Ellsworth first pressed to have two contracts approved, both under $100,000. The pair of contracts, one governing 14 bills and the other 13, were written to have all of the money paid to Agile up front, for flat fees of $88,200 and $81,900.

The report found no “no logical reason” the contracts were split but said they were divided to “unlawfully avoid oversight of the contracts by the Division of Administration,” which oversees procurements of more than $100,000.

“State law specifically prohibits artificially dividing contracts to avoid the required procurement process. Thus, these actions constitute an abuse of his government position by the former Senate President,” the audit report said.

During a meeting of the Senate Select Committee in December, Ellsworth asked the committee about hiring someone to track the committee’s bills through the session and provide regular reports and analysis, but his ask was for “someone ‘cheap’ such as a college student,” the report states.

The report notes that “even that modest proposal was disfavored by the committee members,” and committee member Sen. Daniel Emrich earlier told the Daily Montanan he felt “lied to” by Ellsworth’s actions.

Thus, the subsequent $170,000 consulting expenses constituted abuse of his position, according to the report.

Ellsworth contracted Eggleston, of Agile Analytics, a company that filed with the Montana Secretary of State in 2024, to do the analysis. Eggleston and Ellsworth have a long history of personal and business relationships.

The report also called the timeline into question, as Ellsworth initially presented the two contracts to the Legislative Services Division on Dec. 26, a Thursday between two government holidays and just five days before the funds appropriated to the select committee would expire.

The timing “caused an inappropriate use of staff time during what otherwise would have been a weekend or holiday in impossible [sic] attempt to correct an illegal contract constituted a waste of state resources.”

Emails between Ellsworth and staff with Legislatives Services and Department of Administration show that staff worked until the afternoon of Dec. 31 to correct and submit the contracts.

Sen. Jason Ellsworth sits through a Senate committee during the 69th Montana Legislature. (Keila Szpaller/ Daily Montanan)

Report details

Legislative attorney Jaret Coles on Dec. 27 informed Department of Administration Director Misty Ann Giles the two contracts from Ellsworth were likely invalid, but worried since both contracts had been signed.

“‘Long story short, the president (Ellsworth) attempted to enter into 2 contracts without our support the day after Christmas,” Coles said on Dec. 27.

Giles, who was on vacation, referred the matter to Department of Administration’s procurement operations manager, who asked why the “two seemingly identical contracts were executed rather than one,” and the department decided to combine them.

It said the final contract was one “sole source” contract, requiring monthly payments, but it took extraordinary work to write the agreement for Ellsworth at the last minute and during the holiday. By law, a sole-source contract of more than $100,000 must be publicly noticed for 10 business days.

The report said that in a normal situation, the Department of Administration would have stopped the process, but staff felt they were working “under exigent circumstances” because the appropriation from the governor’s office (for that committee) expired on Dec. 31. It said there wasn’t enough time to post for 10 business days as required by the “sole source exception.”

“Giles stated that, because a separate branch of government was involved, they felt they had to respect the separation of powers and have a ‘softer touch,’” the report said. “While acknowledging that the legal definition of exigency did not really apply here, they treated it as an exigent circumstance due to the imminent expiration of the Governor’s Office appropriation.”

A department spokesperson told the Daily Montanan earlier this week that “the Department of Administration’s State Procurement Services Division takes its responsibility of stewarding taxpayer dollars seriously.”

The audit report concludes that due to the timeline, and initial splitting of the contract, it could not meet the state’s definition of an “exigent circumstance.”

After Ellsworth’s contract came to light, he requested a termination of the agreement, stating a desire from Eggleston to avoid politics. Agile had already submitted an invoice, but Legislative Services Division did not plan to pay it.

Ellsworth earlier said concerns about the contract were a “manufactured controversy” and continued to maintain he had not crossed ethical lines in executing the deal.

Source link

Click to comment

Montana

Missoula and Western Montana neighbors: Obituaries for March 22

Published

11 hours ago

March 22, 2026

Press Room

Missoula and Western Montana neighbors: Obituaries for March 22

State

Zip Code

Country

Source link

Montana

Cheerleaders showcase talent at Cheerfest

Published

23 hours ago

March 21, 2026

Press Room

Cheerleaders showcase talent at Cheerfest

LEWISTOWN — 27 teams of cheerleaders from across Montana gathered at Fergus High School for Cheerfest.

Justin Robicheau reports – watch the video here:

Cheerleaders showcase talent at Cheerfest

“It’s the largest interscholastic cheerleading competition for Montana. We’re very excited that schools can come and show what they’ve been working all season for. This is our state, this is our divisional. So we’re very excited and can’t wait to see what Montana brings to the mat,” Cheerfest Director Rayna Phelps said.

Phelps said this year’s event is different from last year.

“We were really focusing on ways that we can really up this experience for cheerleaders and dancers across the state of Montana. This year, we included a backdrop, and lots of beautiful accents all throughout. We have a judging table, so it looks really nice,” Phelps said.

“There’s a high school mascot competition. Junior high team competition. There’s all classes of high schools. Class B, class A, double A, small group and large group. There’s dance solos, dance teams from across the state. And we have a college showcase,” Phelps said.

Glasgow High School senior Annika Smith said her school finished third in last year’s Cheerfest.

“I’m so excited. This last year we got third. So I’m really excited to come back and really go and try and get first. And it’s a little sad because it’ll be my last year, but I’m really excited to go out and give it my all,” Smith said.

MTN News

For Fergus High School senior Miriam Pavlovick, being surrounded by other cheerleaders from across the state is uplifting.

“It’s nice to see, like, a lot so many cheerleaders who enjoy the same thing. So much. And we just all come together and support one another,” Pavlovick said.

“Obviously when we go travel for basketball and state, like that, we’re cheering on our team. And this is a cool opportunity to show what cheerleaders can do and our stunting on all of our dancing and really get to show off a different side of cheerleading,” Smith said.

Registration for next year’s competition will open after Christmas.