Idaho
Idaho Gov. Brad Little says JFAC’s budget changes could have unintended consequences – Idaho Capital Sun
![Idaho Gov. Brad Little says JFAC’s budget changes could have unintended consequences – Idaho Capital Sun Idaho Gov. Brad Little says JFAC’s budget changes could have unintended consequences – Idaho Capital Sun](https://idahocapitalsun.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/01/Gov-Little-240108r1-1890-med-1-scaled-e1706835728498.jpg)
Although he is prepared to work with whatever alterations legislators come up with, Idaho Gov. Brad Little said the changes that the Joint Finance-Appropriations Committee is making to the state’s budget process could have unintended consequences.
This year, the co-chairs of the budget committee, Sen. Scott Grow, R-Eagle, and Rep. Wendy Horman, R-Eagle, announced several new changes to JFAC. The co-chairs said the changes are designed to allow JFAC members to dive deeper into the budgets and spending requests, increase transparency and improve efficiency during the legislative session by moving budgets to the floor of the Idaho House of Representatives and Idaho Senate earlier in the session.
In an interview Wednesday at the Idaho State Capitol, Little said he doesn’t know exactly how JFAC’s budget and process changes will work or what some of the exact details will be in the end. One concern is it could make it more difficult to pass recommendations and requests for new funding
“But we don’t know what it is yet,” Little said.
The changes to JFAC include:
- The committee shortened the public portion of its daily budget meetings by about an hour and a half each day. Now, JFAC members spend about an hour and a half each day in public meetings where legislators listen to budget hearings led by a state budget analyst and have an opportunity to ask questions of department heads and agency directors. During the other hour and a half, JFAC members meet privately in smaller working groups, where they are actually writing the budgets.
- JFAC divided budgets up differently, separating out bare-bones maintenance of current operations budgets from the new spending recommendations and requests and line items that will now be considered separately. JFAC passed the bare-bones maintenance of operations budgets on Jan. 16 and will begin considering the line items this morning.
- JFAC and the Idaho Legislative Services Office staff launched a new budget information website that is designed to make more budget documents and presentations available to the public and legislators in one place.
- JFAC’s co-chairs will put spending limits in place that are designed to reduce the increases in state spending and leave funding available for legislative priorities that were not included in Little’s fiscal year 2025 budget request.
- As part of a change that started last year, JFAC votes are announced jointly as a committee and separately by legislative chamber. If a budget receives support from a majority of the committee but does not receive a majority of votes from JFAC members in one of the legislative chambers, then that budget can be sent back to be reworked. For example, if JFAC’s Senate members voted 7-3 to pass a budget but JFAC’s House members split 5-5 over the budget, the budget could be sent back even though the vote of the full committee was 12-8 in favor of passing the budget.
- In additional changes that will be implemented in the spring and the fall after the legislative session adjourns, JFAC members will participate in spring and fall working tours where they will go beyond the new spending increases and drill down into the “base” of the budgets to really scrutinize the existing components of each state agency’s budget.
Idaho governor says JFAC’s long-established previous rules worked well
JFAC is different from many legislative committees because it includes 10 members each from the Idaho House and Idaho Senate. Most committees, like the House Health and Welfare Committee, only include members of one legislative chamber or the other.
Before the changes were implemented, JFAC voted jointly as one committee. JFAC also considered the maintenance budgets and the new funding requests and line items together as one budget.
Idaho Legislature’s JFAC sets bare-bones ‘maintenance of current operations’ budgets
Little said JFAC’s previous procedures and rules that were in place before the new changes were time-tested and well respected – with Idaho consistently setting balanced budgets and the state recently posting record-breaking $2 billion state budget surpluses.
“It is the most replicated system in the nation,” Little told the Sun. “When they started the joint process it wasn’t too long before I interned there in 1976, and ever since then it’s been very, very replicated. So if you are going to make a change, what are the intended and the unintended consequences? (There is also) the issue of who gets to define ‘maintenance?’”
One unintended consequence Little sees is it could be more difficult to pass the line items and new budget requests because the maintenance budgets are separated out and the line items are isolated.
“Here’s my experience,” Little said. “If I’ve got an agency who wants to do line items and the line item increases spending by 7 or 8%, a lot of times they look at the rest of the budget and say ‘well if you’re going to do this, maybe we can cut this (other area) back.’ But if everything else is set, that option is more difficult. When I’m setting the budget and they come in with their request, the agency request, I do that. I look and say, ‘well, if they want to do this, can I make up this difference (elsewhere).’”
Two examples of new spending requests that are not in the maintenance of operations budgets are a $6.6 million request for the state’s response to invasive quagga mussels detected in the Snake River near Twin Falls and Little’s 10-year, $2 billion proposal to repair and replace Idaho’s aging, crumbling public school facilities.
Even as these new changes continue to play out, Little said he is confident the state budgets will get set this year and he and his staff will be able to work with new procedures and budget formats JFAC implements.
“Obviously it’s totally their process and my (Division of Financial Management) staff, we’ll honor whatever they want to do,” Little said. “
Idaho Freedom Caucus member voices support for JFAC changes
On Jan. 16, JFAC approved bare-bones, maintenance of current operations budgets that are designed to keep the lights on next year for state agencies. The maintenance budgets are basically a version of last year’s budgets put forward for next year with all of the one-time funding removed. The maintenance budgets reduce state general fund spending for next year by $46.6 million compared to the original budget JFAC set last year.
In an interview Tuesday at the Idaho State Capitol, Sen. Scott Herndon, R-Sagle, said he joins many of his constituents and fellow Freedom Caucus members in the Idaho Legislature in supporting JFAC’s changes.
Citing a presentation from Legislative Services Office budget and policy division manager Keith Bybee, Herndon told the Sun that JFAC only used to analyze about 19% of state spending. Meanwhile, Herndon said government spending grew by 54% between 2020 and 2024. JFAC’s new changes – from the working groups, to the maintenance budgets to the base budget deep dives – give legislators more ability to scrutinize the budget and zero in on new funding requests and line items.
“This really puts us more into what our role is supposed to be,” Herndon said. “I would classify myself as 100% satisfied.”
“Most members of the Idaho Freedom Caucus are very much in favor of the changes for the same reasons I like the changes,” Herndon added.
Herndon supports limiting growth in government spending and hopes to pass a new income tax cut this year, pushing the state’s flare tax rate of 5.8% even lower.
“I want to see the trend come back to normal,” Herndon said. “We cannot cut taxes unless we cut spending. That’s the bottom line.”
Separating the maintenance budgets makes it easier to drill down deep and analyze the new spending requests, Herndon said. Then, he can vote against the ones he disagrees with without voting against an entire budget.
For example, last year Herndon voted against the K-12 public schools operations budget, Senate Bill 1206. Herndon told the Idaho Capital Sun he agreed with a lot of what was in the budget, but he disagreed with one of the funding request line items that was included and voted against the entire budget.
Under JFAC’s new rules, Herndon already voted for the public schools maintenance of operations budgets. Now, he can vote against any new funding requests he disagrees with without having to vote against the maintenance of operations budgets.
“I suspect in future years agencies will be much more thorough in justifying their line item requests when they realize they will get a little more attention,” Herndon said.
Herndon told the Sun he thinks the dustup over JFAC’s rules and voting is just a distraction. Herndon said the rules and voting procedures work because JFAC used them to set the entire state budget last year. If it isn’t about rehashing rules and procedural debates, Herndon said the real reason might be because somebody is worried that their budget won’t pass or worried that their line items will get shot down.
What will it take to consider new spending requests in Idaho budgets?
Because funding is already provided for state agencies in the maintenance of operations budgets, JFAC members will likely have to vote to reopen each budget before considering the new funding line items.
JFAC’s co-chairs, Grow and Horman, previously told the Sun they will first ask for permission to reopen the budgets in what is called a unanimous consent request. If any JFAC members objects to the request, Horman and Grow told the Sun it would take a simple majority vote to reopen the budgets and consider the new funding requests.
Perhaps offering a glimpse into the behind-the-scenes debate over JFAC rules, votes and procedures, Sen. Janie Ward-Engelking, D-Boise, has said publicly that she believes it takes a two-thirds majority vote to reopen any budgets to consider new funding requests.
Ward-Engelking and other Democrats have told the Sun they are worried that JFAC’s new procedures to break the budgets into different pieces and separate out the maintenance budgets will make it harder to approve the new funding requests for next year’s budgets, and at the same time free up funding in the budget for legislative priorities that are not in Little’s budget, like a new tax cut or funding for school choice tax credits or voucher-like programs.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
![](https://newspub.live/wp-content/uploads/2022/03/np-logo.png)
Idaho
Following curtailment fight, Idaho water users seek long-term solution • Idaho Capital Sun
![Following curtailment fight, Idaho water users seek long-term solution • Idaho Capital Sun Following curtailment fight, Idaho water users seek long-term solution • Idaho Capital Sun](https://idahocapitalsun.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/05/South-Fork-Snake-River-BLM-photo-1024x683.jpg)
With the issue temporarily resolved for the year, Idaho water users continue to negotiate toward longer term water solutions that farmers hope will avoid shutting the water off during growing seasons.
The issue came to a head on May 30 when the Idaho Department of Water resources issued a curtailment order requiring the holders of 6,400 junior groundwater rights to curtail, or shut off, their water, the Idaho Capital Sun previously reported.
Ultimately, the curtailment order lasted about three weeks until water users reached an agreement for the 2024 irrigation season that the Idaho Department of Water Resources announced June 20.
The Idaho Department of Water Resources announced it paused enforcing the curtailment order on June 13 after it became obvious the two sides were working toward a settlement agreement.
While the agreement resolves the issue for this year, Gov. Brad Little has asked water users to come up with longer term solutions in the coming weeks.
Little issued an executive order on June 26 that outlines two new deadlines:
- By Sept. 1, the Eastern Snake Plain Aquifer Groundwater Management Plan Advisory Council has to submit a new groundwater management plan to be submitted to the Idaho Department of Water Resources.
- By Oct. 1, the surface water user and the groundwater users have to meet and establish an improved mitigation plan.
“Several negotiation meetings have taken place over the summer, and I’m confident that farmers will create the solutions that will avoid future water shortages no matter where you farm,” Little wrote in an opinion piece released Wednesday.
Little stressed that he would not mandate a solution.
“Because the only solution that is acceptable to me is one that is crafted by farmers,” Little wrote. “If we don’t do this together, then the EPA or the courts (or worst, Congress!) will determine our water destiny.”
Idaho’s lieutenant governor is helping facilitate water talks
Idaho Lt. Gov. Scott Bedke, R-Oakley, is helping facilitate a series of stakeholder meetings between surface water managers and groundwater managers. The two sides met Aug. 7 in Pocatello. Although they did not reach a long-term agreement at that meeting, Bedke said he is encouraged.
“We made substantial progress today,” Bedke said in an Aug. 7 phone interview. “In everyone I think there has been a decided shift in the thinking a little bit, this acknowledgement that we are all in this together and that we have the tools at our disposal to fix this and never have a repeat of what happened this spring.”
Bedke said the state’s May 30 curtailment order “was not our finest hour.”
“That’s certainly my commitment,” Bedke said. “I will not be a part of anything that puts one side of the state against the other. This is all Idaho. We are all in it together and think we have to end up having something we can work with.”
“Having said that, not everybody is going to get everything they want (in a new deal), but they will get everything they need,” Bedke added. “That is certainly my commitment.”
T.J. Budge, general counsel for the Idaho Ground Water Association, said he hopes for a new deal that protects the water for senior water rights holders and removes uncertainty and anxiety for junior groundwater rights holders. He also hopes the state can stabilize the aquifer for future longevity.
Drought in the West has cost hydropower industry billions in losses in two decades, analysis finds
“At a high level, we are in a place where the water users are in negotiations to try to develop a groundwater management plan that both sides can agree to and can provide a path forward to maintaining the aquifer and keeping farmland in production,” Budge said in a phone interview.
On Aug. 8, Idaho Department of Water Resources hydrologists reported that water levels in the Eastern Snake Plain Aquifer increased by 800,000 acre feet in the last year, according to a news release issued by the department. Despite the recent gain, the aquifer has been dwindling for decades. Since 1952, the storage capacity of the aquifer is down by more than 14 million acre feet of water, according to the Idaho Department of Water Resources.
Acre feet is a unit of volume used to indicate the amount of water needed to cover an acre of land one foot deep.
“Idaho is facing a water shortage underground,” Little wrote Aug. 14.
“Since 1952, we have lost the equivalent of five trillion gallons of water – enough for the domestic use for the total population of Idaho for the next 75 years,” Little added.
Budge wants to avoid water curtailment during growing seasons, when farmers need to water crops.
“What we learned is you have to curtail a lot of farmland to get a comparatively small benefit in terms of water coming out of the springs at American Falls,” Budge said. “… We think there are much more cost effective ways that don’t involve drying up hundreds of thousands of acres of farmland.”
“In-season curtailment of water for growing crops is problematic, and economically and socially devastating for the state,” Budge added.
Budge said one of the topics the two sides are still negotiating over is how to mitigate the senior water rights holders when there isn’t enough water to go around.
How do water rights work in Idaho?
Water issues in Idaho are governed by the doctrine of prior appropriation, which means “first in time, first in right.” In other words, the older senior water rights have priority over the more recent junior water rights when there is not enough water to go around.
The junior water rights holders have a mitigation plan that identifies how the junior water rights holders will prevent or compensate the senior water rights holders for water shortages.
This year, the director of the Idaho Department of Water Resources said six groundwater districts were not compliance with mitigation plans and issued a May 30 curtailment order that called for 6,400 junior water rights holders who pump of the Eastern Snake Plain Aquifer to shut off their water due to a predicted water shortage for senior water rights holders.
After three weeks, the two sides reached a settlement agreement that protected all members of groundwater districts from curtailment for the rest of this year’s irrigation season, the Idaho Department of Water Resources announced June 20.
Idaho
Obituary for Lyle Jay Cottle at Eckersell Funeral Home
Idaho
There will be an indoor farmers market this winter in Idaho Falls – East Idaho News
![There will be an indoor farmers market this winter in Idaho Falls – East Idaho News There will be an indoor farmers market this winter in Idaho Falls – East Idaho News](https://s3.us-west-2.amazonaws.com/assets.eastidahonews.com/wp-content/uploads/2024/08/winter-market-last-year.jpg)
IDAHO FALLS — A popular local outdoor farmers market will now be going year-round after announcing there will be an indoor market.
The Idaho Falls Farmers Market will be having a “Winter Market” during the months of November to April.
“Last year, I kind of came up with the idea, and we actually did a winter/Christmas market in mid-December. That was kind of a trial and it was very well attended, very popular,” said Cort Pincock, president of the Idaho Falls Farmers Market. “So we decided this year that we wanted to do more of a monthly market throughout the off-season.”
The Idaho Falls Farmers Market, which is on Memorial Drive by the Snake River and typically runs from May to October, has about 100 to 125 vendors weekly.
The Winter Market will be located somewhere warm rather than outside. It will be at the Snake River Event Center/Shilo Inn at 780 Lindsay Boulevard.
It will be once a month on Saturdays from 10 a.m. to 3 p.m. Check out the poster below for details.
Pincock said they hope to have about 75 vendors at the event space. There will also be food trucks outside.
He said it will be a little bit different from the summer months but there will still be plenty of options.
“In the middle of the winter, we are not going to have tomatoes and the fresh fruits and veggies like we do in the summer of the Idaho Falls Farmers Market, but we are going to have the amazing artisans and the food, and a lot of the agriculture vendors. Many of them will still be there with meat, cheese, and bread,” he said.
Pincock told EastIdahoNews.com he is looking forward to the fun atmosphere where people can bring their families and enjoy time together, especially since it is a free event during the winter months.
He is encouraging people to come and support local.
“Our goal is to help small businesses locally, and we are a nonprofit organization, so coming out and supporting our events, you are really supporting local small businesses,” he said.
=htmlentities(get_the_title())?>%0D%0A%0D%0A=get_permalink()?>%0D%0A%0D%0A=htmlentities(‘For more stories like this one, be sure to visit https://www.eastidahonews.com/ for all of the latest news, community events and more.’)?>&subject=Check%20out%20this%20story%20from%20EastIdahoNews” class=”fa-stack jDialog”>
-
Ohio6 days ago
Ohio taxpayers sent families $966 million for private school tuition: Capitol Letter
-
World1 week ago
What could an EU Commissioner do to tackle the housing crisis?
-
News7 days ago
Roger Stone says his email accounts were how the hackers got into the Trump campaign
-
Politics1 week ago
Trump legal cases in limbo after SCOTUS immunity ruling, freeing up schedule to campaign
-
News1 week ago
Full Trump-Musk Interview: Assassination Bid, Iran-Israel, Russia-Ukraine, Kamala-Biden, US Election
-
Politics1 week ago
Secret Service apologizes after breaking into Massachusetts salon to use bathroom before Harris fundraiser
-
Science7 days ago
Opinion: A route to safer chemotherapy
-
Politics1 week ago
Harris voters defend Democratic presidential nominee on Israel-Hamas conflict: ‘She’s married to a Jewish guy’