The Arizona Cardinals have made their first pick in the 2025 NFL Draft, taking Ole Miss defensive lineman Walter Nolen with the No. 16 pick in the first round.

Do NFL writers like the pick for Arizona?

Check out their early NFL draft grades for Arizona’s selection of Nolen, a 2024 Outland Trophy Finalist who spent one season with Ole Miss in which he started all 13 games at defensive tackle for a unit that racked up the most single-season sacks in program history.

Nolen finished the year with 48 tackles, 14 TFLs, 6.5 sacks, three passes defended and two fumble recoveries. Nolen played the two previous seasons for Texas A&M, where he appeared in 22 games (14 starts) and recorded 66 tackles, 11 TFLs, five sacks, one forced fumble, one fumble recovery and one pass breakup.

Watch 2025 NFL Draft on FUBO (free trial)

USA TODAY Sports: Cardinals get a B+ for Walter Nolen pick

Michael Middlehurst-Schwartz writes: “Monti Ossenfort is going all in on his defensive front in 2025. After adding edge rusher Josh Sweat and defensive linemen Dalvin Tomlinson and Calais Campbell in free agency, Arizona kept pushing by bringing on Nolen. A massively disruptive but still inconsistent interior penetrator, Nolen can ease into work and learn behind a fine mentor in Campbell, the 38-year-old who can help him unlock his full potential.”

Ayrton Ostly writes: “With Walker off the board, the Cardinals opt to address a need along the defensive line. Arizona signed both Calais Campbell and Dalvin Tomlinson in free agency but the team needs a long-term building block at the position. Nolen has incredible burst off the line with long arms for his 6-foot-4, 300-pound frame. He has a high ceiling as a pass rusher and can grow alongside 2024 first-round pick Darius Robinson.”

More: Arizona Cardinals pick Walter Nolen in 2025 NFL Draft: Scouting the 1st-round pick

For The Win: Cardinals land a B for Walter Nolen pick

Robert Zeglinski writes: “We’ve reached the point in the draft where players become more about projection and floor. For Nolen, he’s not an elite athlete. He’s not particularly imposing size-wise, too. And, he’s kind of one-note as a pass-rusher that does not need to be uniquely schemed for. However, Nolen does have clean hands to beat blockers, and he knows how to play and plug gaps, either to make a disruptive play himself or to help his linebackers do so. Nolen is the latest perfectly cromulent addition to an already competent Cardinals defense. Jonathan Gannon is building a depth chart and rotation with genuine depth, especially up front. In this regard, while his potential doesn’t seem all that high in the long term, Nolen was a solid value add. He should have a long career.”

Yahoo Sports: Cardinals receive a B+ for Walter Nolen selection

Charles McDonald writes: “The Cardinals got a lot more disruptive with this pick. Walter Nolen has all the upside in the world to be an impact 3-technique at the next level and has a higher floor than Robert Nkemdiche, the last Ole Miss defensive tackle they selected in the first round. Nolen’s play is a bit streaky, but the big-play potential with Nolen is here in droves.”

Sports Illustrated: Cardinals land a B for Walter Nolen pick

Gilbert Manzano writes: “Nolen showed flashes of being a game-wrecker in his lone season at Ole Miss. He’ll now join a revamped defensive line in Arizona that just added edge rusher Josh Sweat and defensive tackle Dalvin Tomlinson.  After two sluggish years at Texas A&M, it clicked for Nolen with his new team, becoming a consensus All-American and first-team All-SEC. Nolen had a team-high 14 tackles for loss and added 6.5 sacks. Developing consistency is key for Nolen, but there’s no denying his high upside after what he flashed at Ole Miss.”

CBS Sports: Cardinals earn a B for Walter Nolen selection

Pete Prisco writes: “Arizona has signed Calais Campbell and Dalvin Tomlinson after drafting Darius Robinson in the first-round a year ago. Jonathan Gannon is committed to fixing the defensive line and the Nolen is the latest addition. The former 5-star recruit is a quick penetrator that will be expected to bring down the opposing quarterback.”

NFL Draft 2025 draft recap: Tracker, picks, trades, reaction from first round Thursday

The 33rd Team: Cardinals receive a B+ for Walter Nolen selection

Ian Valentino writes: “Jonathan Gannon saw the value of multiple high-end defensive tackles in Philadelphia, so he’s rolling the dice on Walter Nolen. Nolen can be a foundational piece for this franchise if his motor runs consistently high. His pass-rushing ability is elite, and his fluidity is rare for the position.”

FOX Sports: Cardinals get a C+ for Walter Nolen pick

Rob Rang writes: “The most disruptive interior defensive lineman of the class, Nolen is an intriguing fit for the Cardinals, especially given the addition of edge rusher Josh Sweat in free agency. Nolen was terrific at Ole Miss in 2024, but wasn’t as impressive as expected at the Senior Bowl. As such, there is some undeniable boom-or-bust factor with Nolen.”

We occasionally recommend interesting products and services. If you make a purchase by clicking one of the links, we may earn an affiliate fee. USA TODAY Network newsrooms operate independently, and this doesn’t influence our coverage.

Reach Jeremy Cluff at jeremy.cluff@arizonarepublic.com. Follow him on X, formerly Twitter @Jeremy_Cluff.

Support local journalism: Subscribe to azcentral.com today.