Texas cannot secede from the US, despite popular myth

SAN ANTONIO – It’s a standard adage in Texas that we’re the one state that may secede from the U.S. — however is it true?

Briefly — no. Shocker proper? Each Texan born and raised in our nice state has heard the previous saying about Texas being the one state that may secede.

Nevertheless, a so-called Texit, or Texas exit from the union, is a standard fable mired in authorized points that might make secession controversial, if not outright unlawful.

Eric McDaniel, affiliate professor of presidency on the College of Texas at Austin, instructed the Texas Tribune in 2016 that “the legality of seceding is problematic. The Civil Struggle performed a really large function in establishing the ability of the federal authorities and cementing that the federal authorities has the ultimate say in these points.”

A Supreme Courtroom Case from 1868, Texas vs. White, additionally backs this up because the justices maintained that when Texas “grew to become one of many United States, she entered into an indissoluble relation.”

The court docket’s resolution meant that no particular person states at the moment are allowed to secede from the union.

“The union between Texas and the opposite States was as full, as perpetual, and as indissoluble because the union between the unique States. There was no place for reconsideration, or revocation, besides via revolution, or via consent of the States,” in response to the choice handed down by the justices.

Late Supreme Courtroom Justice Antonin Scalia responded to a screenwriter who posed the identical query in 2006 — can a state secede?

“To start with, the reply is obvious. If there was any constitutional concern resolved by the Civil Struggle, it’s that there isn’t any proper to secede. (Therefore, within the Pledge of Allegiance, ‘one Nation, indivisible’),” Scalia stated.

The Structure doesn’t make any provisions for secession.

Regardless of the authorized points, Texas Republicans have tried to get the legislature to permit Texans to vote on whether or not the state ought to secede from the US.

In early 2021, State Rep. Kyle Biedermann, R-Fredericksburg, filed a invoice that might give Texans the choice to secede and “develop a plan for reaching Texas independence.” The invoice didn’t move.

In June, a Platform & Resolutions Committee report from the GOP Conference acknowledged, partially, “Pursuant to Article 1, Part 1, of the Texas Structure, the federal authorities has impaired our proper of native self-government. Due to this fact, federally mandated laws that infringes upon the tenth Modification rights of Texas needs to be ignored, opposed, refused, and nullified. Texas retains the fitting to secede from the US, and the Texas Legislature needs to be referred to as upon to move a referendum constant thereto.”

So, with out consent from the U.S. or via revolution, Texas can’t secede from the union.

Wish to actually have your thoughts blown? Selecting bluebonnets isn’t unlawful.