Georgia
Ossoff’s report could leave Georgia with the same lousy child welfare system – only bigger • Georgia Recorder
As soon as Sen. Jon Ossoff released his report on massive failures at the Georgia Division of Family and Children Services, DFCS fired back, accusing Ossoff of “political gamesmanship.”
Actually, it’s worse.
There is every indication that Ossoff is sincere and genuinely wants to help vulnerable children. But that will only make it harder to persuade him that, because of a critical error in his analysis, his report may trigger a response that makes everything even worse. The report is likely to kick into overdrive the foster-care panic – the sharp sudden spike in needless removals of children – that started in the wake of high-profile news coverage of child abuse deaths in 2022. That year, nationwide, the number of children torn from their families declined by 11%. But in Georgia it increased by the same amount.
A foster-care panic makes everything worse because every problem the report identifies has the same counterintuitive root cause that Ossoff ignored: needless removal of children from homes that are safe or could be made safe if families received the right kinds of help. Often it happens when family poverty is confused with “neglect.”
In 2022, the most recent year for which data are available, 87% of the time Georgia children were placed in foster care in cases where there was not even an allegation of sexual abuse or any form of physical abuse. In 57% of cases there was not even an allegation of substance abuse. In contrast, 47% involved “neglect” which often means poverty. Indeed, in 20% of cases DFCS admits they took away the children because the family lacked housing – a tragedy exposed just weeks ago by WABE Public Radio and ProPublica.
The problem is compounded by the fact that Georgia uses the least harmful form of foster care – placement with relatives instead of strangers – at a rate 40% below the national average.
This does enormous harm to the children needlessly separated – and not just the inherent emotional devastation. Study after study finds abuse in one-quarter to one-third of family foster homes, and the rate of abuse in group homes and institutions is even worse. Ossoff’s own report cites the death of a child killed by his foster parents and the rape of a child in a group home. So it’s no wonder multiple studies find that in typical cases children left in their own homes typically fare better even than comparably-maltreated children forced into foster care.
All the time, money and effort spent harassing impoverished families and taking away their children is, in effect, stolen from finding the relatively few children in real danger. Yet in Ossoff’s entire 64-page report the word “poverty” does not appear even once. Perhaps that’s because birth parents and their lawyers were largely shut out of Ossoff’s investigation.
Consider the other failures Ossoff cites: Runaways? If you take children from poor but loving homes and consign them to the chaos of foster care with strangers, of course they’re more likely to run away. Sex trafficking? Group homes and institutions are magnets for sex traffickers – predators go where the prey is.
But because Ossoff ignored wrongful removal, his report is likely to generate another knee-jerk rush to take away even more children. As entries into foster care escalate, everyone will be even more overwhelmed and even more children in real danger will be missed.
Then DCFS will announce another tired “recruitment campaign” for foster parents and the Legislature might fund a caseworker hiring binge. That never works. All the new caseworkers wind up chasing all the new cases, and all you get is the same lousy system only bigger. Indeed, the last time this was tried, as a result of a class-action lawsuit settlement, DFCS actually took money away from poor people to finance making the family policing system even bigger.
And make no mistake – it is a policing system. It’s hard to imagine any of my fellow progressives issuing a report on policing without mentioning issues like racism and racial bias. But that, too, is entirely missing from Ossoff’s report. Like many other progressives, Ossoff seems to forget everything he believes in about civil liberties and due process as soon as someone whispers the words “child abuse” in his ear.
DFCS is every bit as bad as Ossoff says it is. But fixing it requires taking all the new money that might go to hiring caseworkers and plowing it instead into ameliorating the worst effects of poverty. New hires should work for community-based anti-poverty agencies not connected to the family police. It takes only a little financial help to make a big difference. Georgia also needs to bolster legal representation for families – not to get “bad parents” off, but to craft alternatives to the cookie-cutter “service plans” churned out by DFCS.
If, as I believe, Ossoff really wants to protect our most vulnerable children, he should go back to the drawing board and embrace real solutions.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
Georgia
Ex-Manchester City striker set to become Georgia's president – DW – 11/27/2024
Georgia’s ruling party on Wednesday announced that former Manchester City striker Mikheil Kavelashvili would be its candidate for the post of president in a mid-December electoral college vote.
Georgian Dream — which has in recent years deepened ties with Russia — has a majority in the 300-seat college, making the approval of Kavelashvili’s elevation to the mainly ceremonial post all but certain.
What the Georgian Dream party said
“Our team has unanimously decided to nominate Mikheil Kavelashvili for the post of the country’s president,” Georgian Dream’s honorary chairman, billionaire Bidzina Ivanishvili told a news conference.
“By his nature and habitus, he is the embodiment of a Georgian man,” the tycoon said, adding: “he will defend the interests of Georgia and its people, and will not serve foreign forces.”
Critics accuse Georgian Dream, established by Ivanishvili who made his fortune in Russia, of democratic backsliding and being too close to Moscow.
Kavelashvili is a founder member of People’s Power, a hardline splinter group of the Georgian Dream party, with a record of strong anti-Western statements.
Accepting the nomination, Kavelashvili — who played for City from 1996 to 1997 — pledged to unite Georgia, and accused outgoing president Salome Zourabichvili of having “insulted and ignored” the country’s constitution.
Why is a new president being elected?
Kavelashvili is set to succeed Zourabichvili, who was originally an ally of the governing bloc, at the end of her six-year term as president.
The president has since become a trenchant critic of Georgian Dream, accusing the party of deliberately derailing Georgia’s hopes of EU accession.
While Zourabichvili was elected directly by the people, constitutional changes mean that future heads of state are to be elected indirectly by the political college.
Georgia has suffered turmoil since a disputed parliamentary election on October 26 saw the party secure a new majority.
The vote was widely seen as a referendum on the country’s effort to join the European Union.
Although Georgian Dream says it wants Georgia to join the EU, Brussels has frozen Tbilisi’s application over newly passed laws on “foreign agents” and the curbing of LGBT rights.
The opposition said the election was rigged under Russian influence, with Moscow seeking to keep Georgia in its orbit. Georgian Dream is in favor of normalizing relations with the Kremlin after the brief war with Russia in 2008 over control of separatist Abkhazia and South Ossetia.
Opponents of Georgian Dream have since declared a boycott of parliament and Zourabichvili has denounced last month’s election as fraudulent.
Despite the protest, and amid challenges on whether the parliamentary procedure was legal, Georgia’s lawmakers on Tuesday set December 14 as the date for a presidential election under the new rules.
Last ditch effort to avoid the drop
The 53-year-old Kavelashvili is best remembered for scoring on his debut against cross-city rivals Manchester United in April 1996.
City had gambled on Kavelashvili to save them from the relegation buying him from Dinamo Tbilisi toward the end of the season.
The club had already had a hit with fellow Georgia international Georgi Kinkladze, who signed in the summer of 1995, earning widespread acclaim for his dazzling style of play.
Despite taking seven points from their final three games City were relegated on goal difference, having only taken two points from their first 11 games.
Although Kavelashvili played for City in the First Division, he did not play enough to have his work permit renewed and was loaned to Swiss side Grasshoppers before leaving City permanently.
Before joining City, the striker played for Georgian club Dinamo Tbilisi, with a later move to Russian club Spartak Vladikavkaz paving his way to the Premier League.
Other soccer stars also on Georgia’s political stage
Several other former footballers have also sought the political limelight in Georgia.
They include former AC Milan defender Kakha Kaladze, who was a Champions League winner in 2003 and 2007, and who has served as mayor of the capital Tbilisi since 2017.
Former Freiburg, Schalke and Hertha Berlin defender Levan Kobiashvili is a lawmaker in the Georgian parliament with Georgian Dream.
rc/msh (dpa, AP, Reuters)
Georgia
Georgia's governing party picks former soccer player as presidential candidate
TBILISI, Georgia (AP) — The governing party in Georgia on Wednesday picked a former soccer player as its candidate for president following a disputed victory in last month’s parliamentary election that has sparked protests and led to an opposition boycott of parliament.
The Georgian Dream party nominated Mikheil Kavelashvili, a 53-year old former national team and Premier League player, for the mostly ceremonial presidential post. He is all but certain to win the Dec. 14 vote by the electoral college controlled by the ruling party.
Georgian Dream retained control of the parliament in the Oct. 26 election that was widely seen as a referendum on the country’s effort to join the European Union. The opposition said the vote was rigged under the influence of Russia seeking to keep Georgia in its orbit, and declared a boycott of parliament.
European election observers said the balloting took place in a “divisive” atmosphere marked by instances of bribery, double voting and physical violence.
President Salome Zourabichvili, who has rejected the official results and refused to recognize the parliament’s legitimacy, on Monday snubbed the parliament’s opening session along with opposition parties.
Zourabichvili, whose six-year term expires next month, was elected by popular vote, but Georgia has approved constitutional changes that abolished the direct election of the president and replaced it with a vote by a 300-seat electoral college consisting of members of parliament, municipal councils and regional legislatures.
Georgian Dream has a majority in the college, making the approval of Kavelashvili’s candidacy all but certain.
Critics have accused Georgian Dream — established by Bidzina Ivanishvili, a shadowy billionaire who made his fortune in Russia — of becoming increasingly authoritarian and tilted toward Moscow. The party recently pushed through laws similar to those used by the Kremlin to crack down on freedom of speech and LGBTQ+ rights.
The EU suspended Georgia’s membership application process indefinitely in June after parliament passed a law requiring organizations that receive more than 20% of their funding from abroad to register as “pursuing the interest of a foreign power,” similar to a Russian law used to discredit organizations critical of the government. Kavelashvili was one of the bill’s authors.
On Wednesday, Ivanishvili presented Kavelashvili’s candidacy to parliament, describing him as “one of the most prominent members of our political team” and praising his “significant contribution to protecting Georgia’s national interests and strengthening the country’s sovereignty.”
Kavelashvili was a striker in the Premier League for Manchester City and in several clubs in the Swiss Super League. He was elected to parliament in 2016 on the Georgian Dream ticket. In 2022, he co-founded the People’s Power political movement, which has become known for its strong anti-Western rhetoric.
“Our society is divided,” Kavelashvili said in parliament, charging that “radicalization and polarization” in the country has been fueled from abroad. He accused Zourabichvili of violating the constitution and declared that he will “restore the presidency to its constitutional framework.”
Georgia
Georgia News and Notes for Tuesday
Georgia News and Notes for Tuesday
Running backs Branson and Roderick Robinson continue to make progress ahead of Friday night’s game with Georgia Tech, head coach Kirby Smart said after practice on Tuesday.
Branson Robinson (meniscus) has not played since Georgia’s win over Mississippi State, while Roderick Robinson has not played at all after undergoing preseason surgery to repair a turf toe injury.
“Rod [Robinson II] has done practice, contact. Has done taking reps. He’s looked good out there. Branson [Robinson] has too. Branson is taking some. I didn’t get to see the last part of practice to know how much Branson and Rod did early in practice,” Smart said. “They did take some reps in with the twos and rolled through there, just seeing where they are confidence level and where they are mentally, you know. They’ve been kind of out of contact for a while, but both of them did practice and did some good things.”
Meanwhile, Trevor Etienne – who has missed the past two games with a rib injury – remains unable to go, although he can get some running in.
“Trevor has been able to run. He’s running well. He hit 20-21 miles an hour yesterday, which is really good for him,” Smart said. “He looks good, but he hasn’t gotten to do anything with us.”
… Regarding defensive lineman Christen Miller (shoulder) and wide receiver Dillon Bell (ankle) Smart had this to say: “Christen Miller has not practiced much. He’s been banged up,” Smart said. “He’s recovering, running, doing some treatment stuff. Dillon Bell, he’s done a little bit. He’s done some walkthroughs with us and taking some reps. We’re just trying to get those guys healthy and ready.”
…Smart said he’s still unsure of the status of offensive lineman Earnest Greene III, who has missed the past two games. “He’s done more this week. He’s actually worked at right and left (tackle), Smart said. “I’m very pleased with the play at our left tackle. Outside of a probably two-quarter performance there at Ole Miss) where we had to throw the ball a lot. I think we played well at that position.”
Should Greene not be able to go, Monroe Freeling will start his third straight game at left tackle.
Tray Scott up for Broyles Award
Defensive line coach Tray Scott was tabbed Georgia’s nominee for the Frank Broyles Award, given annually to the nation’s top assistant coach.
“Yeah, he’s a rock. He’s a pillar at this place and he’s one of the guys that’s been here the longest, which I have a lot of respect for because we don’t do it easy around here. You know, we work a tough schedule, work a hard schedule, I’m very demanding of our coaches and I have high expectations and he meets those,” Smart said. “He is tremendous with his group. He’s tremendous with other groups. He inspires people with his story, but you know, he cares about these kids. He’s a tremendous father and husband. He’s really what college coaching is all about.”
Two more Bulldogs up for national awards
Two more Bulldogs are finalists for a pair of national awards, it was announced Tuesday.
The list includes:
…Malaki Starks: Starks is one of three finalists for the Paycom Jim Thorpe Award given to the nation’s top defensive back, according to an announcement from the Oklahoma Sports Hall of Fame and the Jim Thorpe Association Tuesday.
Starks, a native of Jefferson joins Texas’ Jahdae Barron and Ohio State’s Caleb Downs as the three finalists. While former Bulldog All-American Deandre Baker won the 2018 Thorpe Award, Starks was also a finalist in 2023.
He is tied for the team lead with 55 tackles, including four tackles for loss, and has an interception. Lining up at the Star position as well this season, he has started 39 consecutive games and has helped hold four opponents scoreless in the fourth quarter in 2024, including No. 1 Texas in Austin. In addition, Starks has had to fill in at punt returner and has four returns for 39 yards (9.8 avg.).
…Brett Thorson: Thorson is one of three finalists for the Ray Guy Award given to the country’s best punter, according to an announcement from the Augusta Sports Council Tuesday.
A native of Melbourne, Australia, Thorson joins Florida State’s Alex Mastromanno and USC’s Eddie Czaplicki as the three finalists. Jake Camarda was the last Bulldog finalist in 2020. Former Georgia All-American Drew Butler won the 2009 honor.
He stands fifth nationally with a 46.3 average and has forced 12 fair catches and dropped 19 within the 20-yard line. Bombing 13 at least 50 yards this season, Thorson has a season-long of 58 and has helped put the Bulldogs fifth nationally in Net Punting at 43.5. Opponents have had six returns for 18 yards, which also stands fifth nationally.
…Monday, linebacker Jalon Walker was named one of five finalists for the Butkus Award, which goes annually to the nation’s top linebacker.
…Long-snapper Beau Gardner is one of three finalists for the Patrick Mannelly Award given to the top snapper in the FBS, according to a recent announcement.
Gardner, a UCLA graduate transfer from San Francisco, Calif., joins Florida’s Rocco Underwood and Michigan’s William Wagner in the final group. Gardner is now the Bulldogs’ first semifinalist and finalist for the accolade in the award’s six-year existence.
More from Kirby Smart
… With Signing Day and the new Transfer Portal window getting set to hit, roster sizes shrinking to 105, the next 30 days are going to be crazy for college football coaches. That includes Smart, who said he has no idea how everything will unfold. “I can’t answer that question. I wish I could, we haven’t been told anything on the walk-ons in terms of if you guys don’t know,” Smart said. “I ask daily, and a lot of it is conference to conference. A lot of it is the legal case in California, how it resolves itself, and the timing of that. So, I don’t really know, I mean, it’s going to be a strange 30 days.”
… Smart said wide receiver London Humphreys is capable of getting more snaps than he is now. “He’s in good shape. He plays hard. He’s smart,” Smart said. “He plays multiple positions. He does a really good job.”
… Smart thinks Friday night’s game will resemble a heavyweight fight. “We have to have a seeking contact attitude and enjoyment of a street fight. Not everybody loves that,” he said. “So, it’s one of those things that you find out a lot about yourself when you get to play a really physical football team like these guys.”
… With the game on Friday, Smart said the team will have a Thanksgiving meal together on Thursday.
-
Science1 week ago
Trump nominates Dr. Oz to head Medicare and Medicaid and help take on 'illness industrial complex'
-
Politics1 week ago
Trump taps FCC member Brendan Carr to lead agency: 'Warrior for Free Speech'
-
Technology1 week ago
Inside Elon Musk’s messy breakup with OpenAI
-
Lifestyle1 week ago
Some in the U.S. farm industry are alarmed by Trump's embrace of RFK Jr. and tariffs
-
World1 week ago
Protesters in Slovakia rally against Robert Fico’s populist government
-
Health4 days ago
Holiday gatherings can lead to stress eating: Try these 5 tips to control it
-
News1 week ago
They disagree about a lot, but these singers figure out how to stay in harmony
-
Health2 days ago
CheekyMD Offers Needle-Free GLP-1s | Woman's World