Connect with us

Science

The Territory Is Tiny and So Is the Newborn Caterpillar Defending It

Published

on

The Territory Is Tiny and So Is the Newborn Caterpillar Defending It

When territorial animals are confronted by intruders, they instinctively protect their turf — no matter how small.

For warty birch caterpillars, that means patrolling one of the tiniest territories on Earth: the tips of birch leaves. Scientists observed the caterpillars warding off intruders with loud vibrations that advertise they are in command of a domain that stretches a few millimeters across.

“It’s like rap battles,” said Jayne Yack, a professor of neuroethology at Carleton University in Ottawa and an author of the study, which was published on Tuesday in The Journal of Experimental Biology.

Dr. Yack’s team is the first to observe an insect defending a leaf tip, a discovery that hints at a hidden world of territorial disputes playing out on small scales. These caterpillars are kings of the tiniest castles ever identified.

The behavior of warty birch caterpillars is unconventional. These insects seek turf as soon as they hatch, settling on leaf tips in a “dragon-like” resting stance. While other caterpillar species defend ranges at later developmental stages, they are not as vulnerable to predators and exposure as the warty birches.

Advertisement

“The remarkable thing about these guys is that they’re so small when they hatch, less than a millimeter,” Dr. Yack said. “The mortality rate for a small insect like that is very high, so usually they form groups to survive in that hostile world. But these guys always go to the tip of a leaf. That’s their strategy.”

Dr. Yack and her team collected eggs laid by two-lined hooktip moths, the adult form of the species, and set up new hatchlings on single birch leaves. The newborns overwhelmingly booked it to the tips.

After staking claims, the caterpillars made vibrational signals, called drums and buzz scrapes, produced by striking and scraping their bodies against the leaf. The vibrations are like a “no vacancy” sign that rumbles across nearby stems and branches.

Rival warty birch caterpillars were introduced onto occupied leaves over the course of 18 trial encounters. When confronted by intruders, the resident caterpillars dialed up the signal rate by about four times. If the intruder breached the perimeter of the leaf tip, the defenders escalated the signal rate by about 14 times.

Newborn caterpillars are too fragile to endure the sort of violent conflicts observed in other territorial animals, from ants to elephants, which can be deadly. But intruders did make body contact in eight of the trials. And such encounters highlighted why the tiny tyrants want to live on a leaf tip: It allows an easy getaway. Faced with insistent invaders they’d never defeat, the caterpillars can rappel off the tip on a silk thread, a strategy called lifelining.

Advertisement

It took only a light touch to drive a leaf tip’s resident to retreat on its lifeline, leaving the caterpillar literally hanging by a thread. In the other 10 encounters, the intruders heeded the warnings and left the resident in control.

Dr. Yack and her colleagues have since conducted experiments that suggest caterpillars can distinguish signals from different sources. They might even imitate vibrations made by predators, like spiders.

“The vibroscape of insects is really unexplored,” Dr. Yack said.

The new research opens a window into caterpillar communication. But along with evidence suggesting some wasps or aphids defend territory as small as the tip of a birch leaf, the study also shows that territorial conflicts come in all shapes and sizes.

“Territorial behavior is really important to animals, including humans, and there are a lot more strategies out there than we think,” Dr. Yack said.

Advertisement

Science

Commentary: ‘Stop exercising, you’re killing yourself.’ Not really, but try more nurture, less torture in 2026

Published

on

Commentary: ‘Stop exercising, you’re killing yourself.’ Not really, but try more nurture, less torture in 2026

One day my left foot hurt for no good reason. I stood up to shake off the pain and tweaked my right Achilles tendon, so I headed for the medicine cabinet, bent over like an ape because of a stiff back.

Actually, I lied.

It wasn’t one day. It’s pretty much every day.

None of this is severe or serious, and I’m not complaining at the age of 72. I’m just wondering.

Are my exercise routines, which were meant to keep me from falling apart, slowing my demise, or accelerating it?

Advertisement

What better time than the start of a new year to get an answer? In one poll, the top New Year’s resolution for 2026 is exercising more. Also among the top six resolutions are eating healthier, improving physical health and losing weight, so good luck to all you dreamers, and I hope you last longer than I have with similar resolutions.

Instead of a resolution, I have a goal, which is to find a sweet spot — if there is one — between exercise and pain.

Maybe I’m asking too much. I’ve had two partial knee replacements, I’ve got a torn posterior cruciate ligament, a scar tissue knob on a frayed Achilles tendon, a hideously pronated left foot, a right shoulder that feels like it needs an oil change, and a pacemaker that keeps on ticking.

But I decided to get some expert advice that might be useful for anyone who has entered this glorious phase of life in which it’s possible to pull a muscle while taking a nap, or pinch a nerve in your neck while brushing your teeth.

And I knew just whom to call.

Advertisement

Cedars-Sinai orthopedic surgeon Robert Klapper hosts an ESPN radio show called “Weekend Warrior.” This lab-coated Renaissance man, a surfer and sculptor in his spare time, also weighs in regularly on the radio with “Klapper Vision” — clear-eyed takes on all manner of twisted, pulled and broken body parts suffered by elite athletes and banged-up buzzards like me.

On “Weekend Warrior,” Klapper might be talking about knee replacement surgery one minute, segue to Michelangelo’s rendering of the human form, and then insist that a sandwich is not a sandwich without peperoncini. It isn’t necessarily all connected, but it doesn’t matter.

When I emailed Klapper about my aches and pains, he responded immediately to say he’s written one book on hips, another on knees and a third one is in the works with the following title:

“Stop Exercising, You’re Killing Yourself.”

No, he’s not saying you should never get off the sofa. In a phone conversation and later at his office, Klapper said the subtitle is going to be, “Let Me Explain.” He’s making a point about what kind of exercise is harmful and what kind is helpful, particularly for people in my age group.

Advertisement

Dr. Robert Klapper holds up his book about preventing hip surgery.

(Genaro Molina/Los Angeles Times)

My daily routine, I told him, involves a two-mile morning walk with my dog followed by 30 minutes of swimming laps or riding a stationary bike.

So far, so good.

Advertisement

But I also play pickleball twice a week.

“Listen, I make a living from pickleball now,” Klapper said. “Exercise is wonderful, but it comes in two flavors.”

One is nurturing, which he calls “agercise” for my demographic.

The other is abusive, and one of Klapper’s examples is pickleball. With all its starts and stops, twists and turns, reaches and lunges, pickleball is busting the Medicare bank, with a few hundred million dollars’ worth of injuries each year.

I know. The game looks pretty low key, although it was recently banned in Carmel-by-the-Sea because of all the racket. I had no idea, when I first picked up a paddle, that there’d be so much ice and ibuprofen involved, not to mention the killer stares from retirees itching for a chance to drill you in the sternum with a hot laser.

Advertisement

“This is a sport which has the adrenaline rushing in every 50-year-old, 60-year-old, 80-year-old,” Klapper told me in his office, which is the starting point in his joint replacement factory. The walls are covered with photos of star athletes and A-list Hollywood celebrities he’s operated on.

“I see these patients, but they’re not coming to me with acute injuries. They didn’t snap their Achilles tendon … like they do in tennis. They’re not snapping their ACL like they are in pickup basketball,” Klapper said. “They’re coming to me saying, ‘My shoulder is killing me, my knee is killing me.’ ”

Pickleball has obvious conditioning benefits for every age group. But it can also worsen arthritis and accelerate joint degeneration, Klapper said, particularly for addicts who play several times a week.

Not that he’s the first MD to suggest that as you age, walking, cycling and swimming are easier on your body than higher-impact activities. As one doctor said in an AARP article on joint care and the benefits of healthy eating, watching your weight and staying active, “the worst thing you can do with osteoarthritis after 50 is be sedentary.”

Still, I thought Klapper might tell me to stop pickling, but he didn’t.

Advertisement

“Pickleball is more than a sport to you … and all of your compadres,” he said. “It’s mental. You need it because of the stress. The world’s falling apart.… I want you to play it, but I want you to do the nurturing exercises so you can do the abuse.”

There’s no fountain of youth, Klapper said, but the closest thing is a swimming pool.

OK, but I already swim three times a week.

A woman is seated in a chair next to a man seated on a table.

Dr. Robert Klapper meets with patient Kathleen Clark, who is recovering from knee surgery.

(Genaro Molina/Los Angeles Times)

Advertisement

Klapper had different ideas.

“You need to be walking forward and backwards for half an hour,” he said. Do that three times a week, he told me, and ride a stationary bike three times.

Why the water walking?

“We as humans take over a million steps a year. Forget pickleball, just in … daily living,” Klapper said, so I’m well beyond 72 million steps.

“Think about that,” he said.

Advertisement

Do I have to?

Water walking will develop muscles and joints without the stress of my full weight, and that could “optimize” my pickleball durability and general fitness, Klapper said. Buoyancy and the touch of water on skin are magic, he said, but there’s science involved too.

“It’s hard to move your arms and legs and your body through water, and yet it’s unloading the joint,” Klapper said. “And finally — and this is the real X factor — when you close your eyes and straighten your elbow and bend your elbow, straighten your knee and bend your knee … your brain knows where your limbs are in space.”

This is called proprioception, Klapper said. Receptors in your skin, muscles, ligaments and tendons send messages to your brain, leading to better balance, coordination and agility and potentially reducing risk of injury.

There are lots of exercises for sharpening proprioception, but the surfing doctor is partial to bodies of water. At my age, he said, my proprioception “batteries are running low,” but I can recharge them with a short break from pickleball and a focus on the pool.

Advertisement

“You can’t guarantee anything in life and medicine,” Klapper said. “But I guarantee you, a month into it, you’re going to feel so much better than you do at this moment.”

It’s worth a try, and I’ll let you know how it goes.

In the pool and on the court.

steve.lopez@latimes.com

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Science

We Asked for Environmental Fixes in Your State. You Sent In Thousands.

Published

on

We Asked for Environmental Fixes in Your State. You Sent In Thousands.


It’s been a tough year for the environment. And yet, people all over the country are working hard to reduce greenhouse gases, reverse the harms of pollution, save imperiled species and restore pockets of nature. In our 50 States, 50 Fixes series this year we featured one success story from every state.

Advertisement

We also asked readers to share eco-friendly projects, big and small, underway in their communities. More than 3,200 submissions poured in, 14 of which we featured.

As 2025 draws to an end, we’re highlighting just a few more of the ideas that stood out but that did not make it into the series.

The following submissions have been edited and condensed.

Advertisement

Cara Buckley and Catrin Einhorn

Advertisement

Looking out for the little guys

I’ve been rescuing bugs from the trap of nighttime lighting, like the ones that flew into my aunt’s house last night when the doors were open, drawn in by the glow. Sometimes I can save 20 in an hour. It’s thrilling. It’s empowering.

And it makes you wonder: Why are we even here, if we’re letting animals die simply because we don’t notice them? If there’s one place you can be a hero, it’s your own house, your own backyard. You can save so many animals just by paying attention. It’s really a mindset shift.There’s so much magic in our neighborhoods. So much heartbreak, too. But wow, definitely some magic.

Advertisement

— Nicola Plowman, California


Advertisement

Greening the homeowner association

Our large homeowner association in Irving, Texas, has recently earned the National Wildlife Federation’s Community Wildlife Habitat certification. We switched to native plantings in nine parks and 20 common areas, converted four acres to native pollinator-friendly wildflowers and grasses, planted native trees and installed dark sky public lighting. We also educate residents, who have now certified 135 individual homes and a commercial property. Volunteers with the Valley Ranch Association’s green club did it with help and funding from the federal government, national nonprofits, local businesses, our H.O.A. and private donors. Our community is working hard to protect our urban wildlife and pollinators.

Advertisement

— Nancy Payne, Texas


Advertisement

A Nebraska-shaped solution

Advertisement

The Central Nebraska Public Power and Irrigation District

When we say Mary Bergstrom plants Nebraska, we mean that literally! Mary created a pollinator garden in the shape of Nebraska, including a walking path through the middle of the garden that replicates how the Platte River winds its way through the state.

Featuring 27 species of plants, flowers and grasses, many native to the Great Plains region, the garden, which was made possible by a 2023 grant from the PlantNebraska foundation, provides food and habitat to a legion of pollinators, from the monarchs that travel through Nebraska on their migration from Canada to Mexico, to native bees and more. Mary, who lives on the shores of Johnson Lake, Neb., spent 20 years as a librarian at Lexington High School and said she wanted to create a garden that could be a geography lesson, too.

— Michelle DeRusha, Nebraska

Advertisement


Advertisement

Protecting a pair of piping plovers

Chicago’s motto is “city in a garden,” but our cutest conservation success story has to do with two federally endangered piping plovers, Monty and Rose (named after Montrose Beach, where they nested). After settling on the beach in 2019 they were spotted by birders, and a little spit of land was protected for them to breed. They became the first successful pair of piping plovers to breed in the city in 71 years, and their offspring became famous, too.

— Rebecca Silverman, Illinois

In 2021, the Chicago Park District expanded the protected natural habitat around the plovers’ nesting ground by 3.1 acres, an area that was renamed the Monty and Rose Wildlife Habitat last year.

Advertisement


Advertisement

Planting an urban forest

Tree Fredericksburg is an organization of citizen volunteers dedicated to the restoration of the urban forest in Fredericksburg, Va. Since 2008, we have planted over 10,000 trees along the street, in the parks and in the schoolyard. We have also given away over 60,000 native trees and shrubs to the general public. Last fall, an inventory of the trees in the city was conducted and it showed that Tree Fredericksburg is responsible for 47 percent of the trees now growing in the city in the public right of way.

Volunteers have come from all walks of life, including Scouts, students from the local schools and university, churches, civic associations and even from as far away as Northern Virginia. We have had students from George Mason University and the local mosque in Manassas, Va.

We believe trees to be the answer for many problems in our city: the heat island effect, stormwater management, walkable city streets and just plain beauty. There was no city arborist from 2008 to 2023 and so Tree Fredericksburg was the de facto arborist for our city. We have had a strong partnership with the city of Fredericksburg and great support from our political leaders. We have been a Tree City for 37 years.

Advertisement

— Anne Little, Virginia


Advertisement

Bringing buffalo back

For over three decades, I’ve run the Black Feather Buffalo Ranch on 3,000 leased acres in Oglala Lakota County, S.D., on the Pine Ridge Reservation. Named after John Black Feather, who entrusted me with this legacy, the ranch represents far more than a business. It’s a living testament to our Lakota heritage, a way of bringing our people back to our most sacred relatives, the buffalo.

Advertisement

In the past few years, I’ve invested in new fencing to create a rotational grazing structure. Traditional, Native methods also encouraged buffalo to move around the land. Now it’s classified as a climate-smart activity by the U.S.D.A. When I look out over my herd, I think of my ancestral knowledge, and the generational knowledge my elders, including my uncle John Black Feather, passed down to me: that buffalo represent abundance and hope.

Each animal represents a living connection to our past and a promise for our future. As a single parent raising both my children and my buffalo, I’m proud to continue this sacred work. I wish my uncle was alive to see how much our herd has grown, how we’re bringing our buffalo back and we’re keeping our culture alive, one buffalo at a time.

— Virgil Two Eagle, South Dakota

Advertisement

Advertisement

Installing solar in low-income places

Southern Energy Management

In North Carolina, we are U.N.C. students who created the nonprofit SolarEquity to bring affordable renewable energy to low- to moderate-income communities. In the Southeast, it is difficult to implement renewable energy in affordable ways due to regulations and utility constraints, so we decided to be the intermediary between communities, affordable housing organizations and financial entities to bring solar and energy efficiency to places often left out of the energy transition, while decreasing carbon emissions.

— Kaya Johnson, North Carolina

Advertisement


Advertisement

Planting pollinators

Skateport is a rollerskating events and lessons service based in Connecticut. We had concrete poured in the heart of downtown in order to place a shipping container onsite to house our rental roller skates and decided to plant a public pollinator garden to offset the heat island effect and support our local ecosystem and pollinators!

— Takina Pollock Shafer, Connecticut

Advertisement


Advertisement

Celebrating the natural world

Procession of the Species Celebration is a 30-year-old event that highlights community-made art to celebrate and appreciate nature. Each year, the community has a parade or procession that includes floats, live music and dancing, with large-format art of different species. It was started by Earthbound Productions and is organized by the community. Leading up to the event, there are two months of free and open studios and workshops to create the collective artwork. Art, culture and community are essential in fostering an ethic of environmental stewardship and protection.

— Natalie Weiss, Washington

Advertisement


Advertisement

Teaching climate change in business class

Mike Belleme for The New York Times

Advertisement

Appalachian State is now requiring all undergraduates to take at least one class in the sustainability and climate literacy arena as a general education requirement. I teach the Walker College of Business’s version of the class. I really want my opening line to be in The N.Y. Times lol: “This class is not to discuss whether we think climate change is real or not, or who is to blame, that is a waste of oxygen. This class’s charge is to come up with better business processes to not treat the Earth like shit.”

— Scott Bowie Gray, North Carolina


Advertisement

Recycling rainwater

Advertisement

Brad Lancaster in Tucson, Ariz., has, for 30 years, advocated for and installed citywide rainwater harvesting infrastructure and planted thousands of trees native to the Sonoran Desert. The savings in deferred groundwater use run to the millions of gallons per year.

— Eric Wagner, Arizona

Mr. Lancaster said he’s helped neighbors plant more than 1,800 native food-bearing trees and thousands of understory plants, which are irrigated by more than one million gallons of stormwater harvested annually from neighborhood rain gardens.


Advertisement

Decomposing yard signs

Advertisement

In Berkeley, Calif., Berkeley High School parents and families stopped receiving lawn signs for free when their seniors graduated earlier this year. As a result, a group of parents began selling eco-friendly seed paper signs, which decompose and grow into native flowers after it rains, unlike typical plastic lawn signs. The idea for a biodegradable sign started with an opinion article in the high school newspaper, and the signs were sold to hundreds of parents and families in the district. It’s an idea that’s very small and the families hope it will incite a bigger movement.

— Sydney Lehrer, California

Ron Levi, a parent of a recently graduated senior, spearheaded the effort, and said leftover proceeds from the sale of the signs went to a nonprofit parent group that raises funds for the school.


Advertisement

Reducing fire risk

Advertisement

In Oakland, Calif., volunteers are busy reducing the risk of fire while restoring the open spaces. Parts of the hills here are classified as a high fire hazard zone where the forests are packed with overgrown underbrush and deadwood. But these open spaces are also beloved green oases in this highly urban city, used by thousands of bikers, hikers and picnickers. They need care, but the city doesn’t have the capacity to properly maintain them.

A nonprofit called Friends of Sausal Creek musters up scores of volunteers every weekend to steward multiple locations in the parks, removing invasive plants and shrubs, planting native plants, reducing the fire risks and maintaining Sausal Creek, where a small population of wild trout lives.

— Wendy Tokuda, California

Advertisement

Advertisement

Sharing vegan delights

I write a vegan recipe and educational column called Recipe for a Healthy Planet for our local newspaper, The Monadnock Ledger-Transcript. I worked on a web portal of the same name for our local environmental education center, the Harris Center. We’re educating people about how food choices affect the environment.

— Lisa Murray, New Hampshire

Advertisement

Advertisement

Building without gas

In terms of decarbonizing buildings, everybody despairs about getting America’s builders, HVAC contractors and homeowners to accept electrification. There are so many people to persuade! A big New Mexico developer has figured it out: He doesn’t put gas infrastructure into his new developments in the city of Las Cruces, which saves him millions of dollars in unnecessary infrastructure. Just like that, a development is on the path to being 100 percent decarbonized. He is in the middle of a 6,000-lot housing project now, with homes selling out quickly. He can’t figure out why more developers aren’t doing it.

— Don Kurtz, New Mexico

The developer, John Moscato, said not adding gas lines to developments saved him $3,000 per lot.

Advertisement

Advertisement

Running from plastic

I have been a runner for over 50 years. The vast majority of plastic is not recycled, and I don’t like the single-use plastic bottles given at races. I have been trying to get races to use paper cups with water canisters instead. Some smaller races in New York, New Jersey and Pennsylvania have made progress, like the Scott Coffee Moorestown 8K, the Cooper Norcross Run the Bridge 10K and the Finger Lakes Runners Club’s Twilight 5K. I have tried to get the Broad Street 10 miler in Philadelphia to give up plastic, as it would save nearly 100,000 plastic water bottles from the landfill or ocean. I speak to race directors at every race I attend.

I am 86.

— Sandra Folzer, Pennsylvania

This year, Ms. Folzer became the world record holder for women aged 85-90 in the indoor mile.

Advertisement


Advertisement

Keeping textiles out of the landfill

I thought you might be interested in a project near me in Kent, Ohio. It’s called The Socially Responsible Sweatshop of Kent. From their flier: “The Socially Responsible Sweatshop is committed to repurposing landfill-destined textiles into useful, beautiful items. These items are lovingly crafted and priced affordably. Proceeds from the sales of these items are donated to provide extra funds for food-insecure community members.”

They sell their wares at the Haymaker Farmers’ Market in Kent year round and online and a couple of local stores. I discovered this organization at the farmers’ market about a year and a half ago and ended up donating my late mother’s sewing machine to them. I have since donated fabric and other machines and sewing supplies when I can. Last year they raised $50,000, 100 percent of which went to the food-insecure of Portage County.

— Kyle A. Klever, Ohio

Advertisement


Advertisement

Grabbing trash on the go

Heidi Cramer/Piscataway Public Library

Advertisement

I’m writing on behalf of my friend, Douglas Johnston, who lives in Piscataway, N.J. An avid hiker, Doug serves his community and his environment by picking up trash from the trails. He never leaves the house without a trash bag and grabber. Doug knows I’m submitting this; he’s too humble to do it himself. He’s making a difference quietly.

— Kate Baker, New Jersey

Doug also picks up trash around Piscataway, often pulling over to clean up garbage from roadsides, and said he needs to wash out his car a lot.


Advertisement

Eating invasive species

Advertisement

Young, small-operation Rhode Island fishermen are fighting the European Green Crab invasion, spearheading new legislation and encouraging everyone to get out there and trap the crabs. A bill to create a more affordable, accessible license to commercially harvest the green crabs passed the R.I. General Assembly unanimously, and I, a 17-year-old, proposed it! The restaurant demand for the crabs is growing in the state, and there are a few fishermen leading the charge.

— Liam Cromie, Rhode Island


Advertisement

Imitating beaver dams

Advertisement

We are a small group of fly fishers concerned about cold, clean water. We have constructed more than 100 beaver dam analogues to keep more water on the landscape. These B.D.A.s not only store, cool and spread water but also provide habitat for many species of animals and plants.

— William Young, South Dakota


Advertisement

Pivoting careers

Advertisement

I left my cushy tech job at Adobe this spring to open a native plant nursery. In Utah, we are way behind the rest of the country when it comes to environmentally conscious landscaping. Kentucky bluegrass lawns continue to dominate residential landscapes even though we live in a high desert. I’ve only been in business for six months but I’ve already made over $100,000 in gross sales. I believe Utahns are ready and businesses like mine are emerging to meet the growing demand.

— Sara Southwick, Utah


Advertisement

Fighting for marine forests

Advertisement

In an effort to protect the coastline, Sebastian Ford, a high school student from Bainbridge Island, Wash., worked with the Seattle Aquarium, the Puget Sound Restoration Fund and tribes to raise awareness of bull kelp and get it designated as the state’s “marine forest.” His work became House Bill 1631 and was signed into law on April 16. He was also named Washingtonian of the day.

— Rebecca Robins, Washington

Sebastian Ford is the grandson of the reader who sent in this submission.

𓆑

Advertisement

Continue Reading

Science

‘Memory manipulation is inevitable’: How rewriting memory in the lab might one day heal humans

Published

on

‘Memory manipulation is inevitable’: How rewriting memory in the lab might one day heal humans

We often think of memories like the contents of a museum: static exhibits that we view to understand the present and prepare for the future.

The latest research, however, suggests they are more like well-thumbed library books that wear and change a little bit every time they’re pulled off the shelf.

Think of one of your happiest memories. For real. Sit with the recollection. Let your mind’s eye wander around the scene. See if you can feel a spark of the joy or hope you felt at the time. Let a minute pass. Maybe two.

If you played along with this experiment, you are physically different now than you were a few minutes ago.

When you began to reminisce, brain cells dormant just seconds before began firing chemicals at one another. That action triggered regions of your brain involved in processing emotions, which is why you may have re-experienced some feelings you did at the time of the event.

Advertisement

Chemical and electrical signals shot out to the rest of your body. If you were stressed before you began this exercise, your heart rate probably slowed and stabilized as levels of cortisol and other stress hormones decreased in your blood. If you were already calm, your heart rate may have quickened with excitement.

In either case, regions of the brain that light up when you get a reward jittered with dopamine.

The memory changed you. But by pulling this memory to mind, neuroscientist Steve Ramirez says, you also changed the memory.

Some elements of the memory heightened in importance. Others receded. Your brain snipped out and inserted details without your conscious knowledge. The mood you were in at the time of reminiscence left emotional fingerprints on the memory, as neurons activated by your mental environment synced up with those activated by the recollection.

Every time you revisit this heartwarming scene you change it a little bit, both as a subjective experience and a physical network of cells.

Advertisement

Humans have engaged in this two-way operation of memory revision for as long as we’ve been conscious. But over the last two decades, neuroscientists have found mind-bending ways to control this process (in mice, at least): implanting false memories, deleting real ones, resurrecting memories thought lost to brain damage, detaching the memory of an emotional reaction to one event and attaching it to the memory of another.

“It is all part of a larger revolution brewing in science to make memory manipulation a commonplace practice in the lab,” Ramirez writes in his recent book, “How to Change a Memory: One Neuroscientist’s Quest to Alter the Past” (Princeton University Press). “A memory may transform me entirely, but I have the power to transform it as well — both with my mind and with my science.”

In movies about stuff like this, there’s often a sinister air around the memory-tweaking scientist character. Ramirez, a Boston University professor, is friendly, earnest and keeps a giant inflatable T-rex named Henry in his office.

He sees this research not as the next frontier of coercive mind control but as another way to alleviate mental suffering, alongside medications and cognitive therapies.

“It’s amazing that we can do these things in contemporary neuroscience,” Ramirez said recently from his lab in Boston. “But the real-life, overarching goal of all of this is to restore health and well-being to an organism. … Memory manipulation is another antidote [that] can be part of our toolkit in the clinic.”

Advertisement

Memory is the reason Ramirez exists at all.

His father was once kidnapped at gunpoint by soldiers in his native El Salvador and falsely accused of being a left-wing guerrilla. (Their “evidence”: He had a beard.) He was spared execution when one of his captors took a second look at his face and recognized him as the generous schoolmate who used to share his lunch.

Both of Ramirez’s parents emigrated to the U.S. before his birth, and raised him and his older siblings in Boston. Ramirez got a bachelor’s in neuroscience from Boston University in 2010 and his doctorate from MIT in 2017. As a graduate student he joined the lab of Nobel laureate Susumu Tonegawa, where he was paired with a postdoc fellow named Xu Liu.

Both Ramirez and Liu were drawn to the study of memory as a possible therapeutic tool, and instantly hit it off as friends and lab partners.

Their first major breakthrough together came in 2012.

Advertisement

Three years earlier, a University of Toronto team identified the neurons that lit up when a mouse was exposed to a scary stimulus — in this case, a sound that earlier accompanied a shock. The Toronto researchers then injected the mice with a toxin that killed only those brain cells that lit up when they heard the sound.

The result: The treated mice no longer demonstrated a fear response when the sound was played. Essentially, the scientists had erased a specific memory.

If a memory could be deleted in the lab, Ramirez and Liu reasoned, one could be implanted.

For their experiment, the pair identified brain cells in a mouse hippocampus that activated when the animal received a startling shock. Then they took the mouse out of the enclosure where the shock occurred and placed it in a new box with no sights or other sensory cues associated with the memory of its old environment. Next, using millisecond-long pulses of light, they activated those same brain cells — without the physical shock of the earlier stimulus.

The mouse acted exactly as it had when the shock happened, even though no shock occurred.

Advertisement

You can’t interview a mouse about its memories. Researchers base their conclusions on the animal’s behavior. And in this case, it appeared that they’d turned a memory on.

“It just blew everyone away,” said Sheena Josselyn, a University of Toronto neuroscientist who led the 2009 work on erasing fear memories. “When you can do those sorts of things to memories, you know you have found the neural basis of a memory.”

In 2013, Ramirez and Liu set a mouse loose in a box — let’s call it, as Ramirez does in his book, Box A — and took note of the brain cells that activated as it explored the environment.

They then scooped it up and placed it in a second box, Box B. With minuscule pulses of light, they reactivated the cells that lit up in Box A, triggering a memory of that earlier environment as it explored the new one. At the same time, they gave the mouse a shock.

When they put the mouse back in Box A, a place where it had never been harmed, it froze in fear.

Advertisement

The mouse’s negative memory of being shocked in Box B had, essentially, been remapped to what was previously a neutral memory of Box A. The scientists had created a false memory, another seminal feat.

For their final project together, they put a mouse in an enclosure with other mice and took note of the neurons that fired as it responded positively to the social interaction.

Then they moved that mouse to a smaller cage than usual, where it was alone.

At first, this rodent equivalent of downsizing dimmed the mouse’s mood.

Given the choice between plain and sugary water, healthy mice prefer the latter. But when stressed or depressed, mice show no preference. That’s how Ramirez and Liu’s lonely mouse acted initially.

Advertisement

But when the scientists activated neurons associated with the memory of hanging out with other mice, the mouse’s behavior suddenly changed. It enthusiastically slurped the sweet water. Remembering better times had changed its behavior to resemble that of a healthy mouse.

The paper was published in 2015 in the prestigious journal Nature. But unlike their past shared achievements, this one couldn’t be celebrated together. As it was going through the review process, Liu died suddenly at the age of 37.

Grief, Ramirez writes, is not so different from memory: “Both endure across the entire lifespan, forever changing us, helping us to decide what matters most.”

Ramirez, now 37, opened his own lab at Boston University in 2017. In the years since, memory researchers have made impressive strides: restoring memories lost to amnesia, activating a memory while suppressing the emotions attached to it, detaching the emotional reaction to one memory and attaching it to another. The tools now exist to erase whole events and corresponding emotions from mouse brains, or to artificially jump-start memories and all the feelings that go with them.

But there is no expectation in the research community that laser-wielding doctors will one day artificially reshape human patients’ memories.

Advertisement

For one, these experiments are possible only with mice that have been genetically modified to have brain cells that light up when exposed to lasers. Genetically altering a human in this manner, researchers interviewed for this story said, is neither ethical nor practical.

It’s also not necessary.

“We don’t need to generate technophobic fears of a digital future where our memories will be distorted — our memories can already be distorted very effectively by nondigital means,” memory scientists Ciara Greene and Gillian Murphy wrote in “Memory Lane: The Perfectly Imperfect Ways We Remember,” published earlier this year.

Humans are suggestible creatures with extremely pliable memories. Armed with little more than a few leading questions, researchers have found that most humans can be easily manipulated into believing that they did or saw something they didn’t. We don’t need lasers to activate our memories, which can be summoned at will or triggered by any number of sensory cues, or to edit their contents, which our brains do constantly without any conscious input from us.

The real goal of research like his, Ramirez said, is to establish the biological mechanisms of memory and apply that knowledge to noninvasive therapies.

Advertisement

If researchers understand exactly how to retrieve a memory from a mouse hippocampus that brain damage has rendered inaccessible, for example, that information could be the basis for a drug that helps preserve or strengthen certain types of memory in people suffering from dementia or other cognitive disorders.

Understanding how an animal brain encodes memories and the emotional responses they evoke could lead to better cognitive therapies for post-traumatic stress disorder.

The obvious dark side of this line of research is that someone who understands how to boost well-being through memory manipulation could just as easily use the same knowledge for pernicious ends.

“The idea of artificially changing our own memories might elicit uneasy feelings of a dystopic future where relationships are erased, identities are replaced, and governmental powers implant thoughts in our heads to mind-control society,” Ramirez writes in his book. But, he said, any tool in existence can be used to harm or help, and he’d rather make well-intended progress than none at all.

“The idea of memory manipulation, to me, makes sense if we have an ethically bounded goal, and that ethically bounded goal is to restore health and nourish human well being,” he said. “Exercise is an antidote for the brain, and social enrichment is an antidote [and] a good night’s sleep is an antidote. What if toggling with memories in a therapeutic manner can also be an antidote? Then we’re in business.”

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending