Connect with us

Science

Humpback Whales Sing the Way Humans Speak

Published

on

Humpback Whales Sing the Way Humans Speak

The English language is full of wonderful words, from “anemone” and “aurora” to “zenith” and “zodiac.”

But these are special occasion words, sprinkled sparingly into writing and conversation. The words in heaviest rotation are short and mundane. And they follow a remarkable statistical rule, which is universal across human languages: The most common word, which in English is “the,” is used about twice as frequently as the second most common word (“of,” in English), three times as frequently as the third most common word (“and”), continuing in that pattern.

Now, an international, interdisciplinary team of scientists has found that the intricate songs of humpback whales, which can spread rapidly from one population to another, follow the same rule, which is known as Zipf’s law.

The scientists are careful to note that whale song is not equivalent to human language. But the findings, they argue, suggest that forms of vocal communication that are complex and culturally transmitted may have shared structural properties.

“We expect them to evolve to be easy to learn,” said Simon Kirby, an expert on language evolution at the University of Edinburgh and an author of the new study. The results were published on Thursday in the journal Science.

Advertisement

“We think of language as this culturally evolving system that has to essentially be passed on by its hosts, which are humans,” Dr. Kirby added. “What’s so gratifying for me is to see that same logic seems to also potentially apply to whale song.”

Zipf’s law, which was named for the linguist George Kingsley Zipf, holds that in any given language the frequency of a word is inversely proportional to its rank.

There is still considerable debate over why this pattern exists and how meaningful it is. But some research suggests that this kind of skewed word distribution can make language easier to learn.

If these word distributions evolved because they helped learning, scientists might also expect to find similar patterns in other complex, culturally transmitted communication systems. “And whale song is a great place to look,” said Inbal Arnon, an expert on language acquisition at Hebrew University and an author of the new study.

Male humpback whales sing long, elaborate songs, which are composed of a variety of sounds strung together in repeated phrases and themes. All the male whales in a particular humpback population sing the same song, but that song evolves over time — sometimes gradually and sometimes all at once.

Advertisement

“We have song revolutions, and that’s when a song is introduced from a neighboring population,” said Ellen Garland, an expert on humpback whale songs at the University of St. Andrews and an author of the new paper. “So the song type turns up, and then it completely takes over.”

Precisely how that happens remains a mystery, and whale song researchers face a challenge that human language researchers don’t: They’re not native speakers.

So the scientists’ first challenge was to divide the songs into meaningful units, determining where one “word” ended and another began. To do so, they used a quantitative approach inspired by human babies. Infants, research suggests, use basic statistical reasoning to identify discrete words in a continuous stream of human speech; syllables that occur together are likely to be part of the same word.

The researchers transformed humpback whale songs, recorded over eight years in the waters around New Caledonia, into long sequences of basic sound elements, including various types of squeaks, grunts, whistles, groans and moans. Then, they identified “subsequences” of sounds that frequently occurred together — such as a short ascending whistle followed by a squeak — and might be roughly analogous to a word.

The frequency with which these subsequences were used followed Zipf’s law, the researchers found. In 2010, for instance, groan-groan-moan was the most common subsequence, appearing about twice as often as the next most common sequence, which was a moan followed by three ascending cries. The most frequently used subsequences were also generally shorter than the rarer ones.

Advertisement

Humans and humpback whales are not closely related, and whale song does not carry the same semantic meaning that human language does, Dr. Garland said. But both communication systems are culturally transmitted, learned from others in the community and passed down over the generations. “So this really points to the crucial role of learning and transmission in the emergence of structure,” she said.

Shane Gero, a marine biologist who was not involved in the research, said that he found the study “elegant” and convincing. The results raise the possibility that linguistic laws derived from studies of human communication may actually be broader biological principles, he said.

“The fact that maybe they generalize if we know enough and we study long enough, then that’s really interesting,” said Dr. Gero, who is a scientist-in-residence at Carleton University. “Anytime we look deeper and listen longer, we find interesting complexity.”

Indeed, the next step is to determine whether the phenomenon extends to other animals with similar communication systems.

“We should find these statistical properties in any culturally transmitted system of sequential signaling,” Dr. Arnon said. “So we have bats to look at, we have songbirds to look at, we have elephants, maybe, to look at.”

Advertisement

The findings dovetail with another paper published this week, which found that the vocalizations produced by 11 species of dolphins and whales follow one of the efficiency rules observed in human language. The rule, known as Menzerath’s law, holds that the longer a sequence becomes, the shorter its individual components tend to be; long sentences, for instance, tend to have shorter words.

The study, which was published in Science Advances on Wednesday, documented this same pattern in a diverse array of cetaceans, including humpbacks, which produce melodic songs; sperm whales, which issue sequences of clicks; and bottlenose dolphins, which are known for their whistles.

“Regardless of what their vocalizations are used for, they all seem to try to communicate as efficiently as they can,” said Mason Youngblood, a postdoctoral researcher at Stony Brook University and the author of the study.

The pattern, which has also been documented in birds and nonhuman primates, may have evolved as a way to reduce the costs of communication.

“Things like bird song and whale song are very hard to learn,” Dr. Youngblood said. “And then when you sing, it’s very energetically costly. It can attract the attention of predators. And so because of that, you would expect communication systems to evolve to cut those costs wherever it’s possible.”

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Science

Video: SpaceX Launches NASA’s Crew-10 Mission

Published

on

Video: SpaceX Launches NASA’s Crew-10 Mission

new video loaded: SpaceX Launches NASA’s Crew-10 Mission

transcript

transcript

SpaceX Launches NASA’s Crew-10 Mission

The mission would allow Suni Williams and Butch Wilmore, two NASA astronauts, to return to Earth. Their brief scheduled visit to the space station last June was unexpectedly stretched to more than nine months.

“Ignition and liftoff.” [cheering] “[unclear] and liftoff as Crew-10 now soaring to International Space Station.” “Great callouts and incredible views there on your left-hand screen. In your left-hand screen, you can see a view from Stage 1.” [cheering] “The first stage making its way back down to Earth, and the second stage continuing to fire.” [cheering] “There, on the right-hand side of your screen, you can see some first images of Crew-10 inside the Dragon Endurance spacecraft, as they’re now successfully in orbit.”

Advertisement

Recent episodes in Science

Continue Reading

Science

Photos Show Blood Moon Lunar Eclipse Around the World

Published

on

Photos Show Blood Moon Lunar Eclipse Around the World

From Thursday night into Friday morning, the Earth’s shadow gradually overtook the moon’s typically bright white face, which took on a ruddy red hue. It was the first total lunar eclipse, also known as a blood moon, in more than two years.

A lunar eclipse occurs when the sun, Earth and moon align, in that order. There are different types of lunar eclipses, but total lunar eclipses cause the moon to shine red because sunlight must travel through the atmosphere before illuminating the moon. Blue wavelengths of light scatter more readily in our atmosphere, but redder wavelengths pass through, creating the blood-moon effect.

The blood moon was most visible this week in the Americas, western parts of Africa and Europe, New Zealand and some of Russia.

Local stargazing groups and planetariums in many cities hosted watch parties, while others got the chance to see it online. Totality, when the entire moon is engulfed in the darkest part of Earth’s shadow, was expected at 2:25 a.m. Eastern.

But anyone who missed it won’t have to wait long for another chance. Lunar eclipses can occur several times a year, though not all of them reach totality. According to NASA, the next total lunar eclipse will occur in September, most visible in Asia and parts of Europe, Africa and Australia. There will be another total lunar eclipse next March, followed by a partial lunar eclipse in August 2026.

Advertisement

Humanity’s well-documented and ancient fascination with the Earth’s only natural satellite means that stargazers across the planet last night participated in an activity as old as time: They turned their eyes to the sky. Here’s what that looked like in different locations around the world:

Katrina Miller contributed reporting.

Continue Reading

Science

Video Shows Mars and Deimos Close Up During ESA’s Hera Flyby

Published

on

Video Shows Mars and Deimos Close Up During ESA’s Hera Flyby

An asteroid-chasing spacecraft just swung past Mars on Wednesday. As it zipped by, it took hundreds of shots of the Red Planet, as well as several snaps of Deimos, one of the two small Martian moons.

The operators of the European Space Agency’s Hera spacecraft were bewitched by the sci-fi aesthetics of the pictures.

“We were waiting with impatience to get these images,” said Patrick Michel, the principal investigator for Hera, during a Thursday news conference at mission control in Darmstadt, Germany. When the first shots of the moon appeared, many of the Hera team members burst into cheers. “We’ve never seen Deimos in that way,” Dr. Michel said.

Navigators managed to fly Hera about 600 miles above Deimos, a craggy moon just nine miles long. The pass shows the object in remarkable detail — a small island gliding above the crater-scarred Martian desert.

During the news conference, Ian Carnelli, the Hera project manager, was misty-eyed. “I’m going to get emotional,” he said. “The excitement was such that we didn’t get any sleep.”

Advertisement

Hera was using Mars in what is known as a gravity assist, both accelerating the spacecraft and adjusting its flight path. But its mission operators also wanted to take advantage of the Martian flyby and use it to test the mechanical eyes that will allow Hera to study the asteroid it is targeting, Dimorphos.

In the coming days, the mission’s scientists will reveal more photographs from Hera’s encounter with Mars, which may include shots of Phobos, the planet’s other moon.

As with any planetary flyby, there were some nerves about whether Hera would conduct its maneuvers properly and end up on the right trajectory. “The spacecraft behaved very well,” said Sylvain Lodiot, the Hera operations manager. “We’re on track to the asteroid system.”

Hera is headed to Dimorphos as a follow-up to a 2022 NASA mission, the Double Asteroid Redirection Test. DART deliberately crashed a spacecraft into that asteroid, aiming to change its orbit around a larger asteroid, Didymos. That was a test of whether a dangerous space rock bound for Earth could be deflected in a similar manner.

The experiment successfully changed the orbit of Dimorphos. But the asteroid’s physical nature, and its full response to DART’s collision, remains unclear; some evidence suggests that it acted like a fluid when hit, rather than a solid, causing it to eject a lot of debris and reshape itself.

Advertisement

When it comes to stopping lethal asteroids from striking Earth, the more scientists know about their rocky enemies, the better prepared they will be should one come careening our way. To aid that effort, the European Hera mission will arrive at Dimorphos in late 2026 for a close-up study of the DART-impacted asteroid.

This Wednesday, during Hera’s flyby of Mars and Deimos, the spacecraft used three cameras — including a thermal infrared imager supplied by the Japan Aerospace Exploration Agency.

Mars’s two moons have mysterious origins. Both could be pieces of a disintegrating asteroid captured by the planet’s gravity, or perhaps the flotsam and jetsam leftover from a giant impact event on Mars.

Deimos is tidally locked, meaning one hemisphere permanently faces Mars. This near side is the one most commonly seen by spacecraft orbiting the planet, or by rovers driving across its surface. Hera managed to fly behind Deimos, meaning it caught a rare sight.

“It’s one of the very few images we have of the far side of Deimos,” said Stephan Ulamec, a researcher at the German Aerospace Center and member of the Hera team.

Advertisement

This opportunistic peek at Mars and Deimos was exciting. But the team is especially thrilled that Hera is now on its way to its asteroid destination. “We’re all looking forward to what Didymos and Dimorphos will look like,” Dr. Michel said.

Continue Reading

Trending