Pa. primary election 2023: A complete guide to the candidates for Commonwealth and Superior Courts

Highlight PA is an impartial, nonpartisan newsroom powered by The Philadelphia Inquirer in partnership with PennLive/The Patriot-Information, TribLIVE/Pittsburgh Tribune-Assessment, and WITF Public Media. Join our free newsletters.

HARRISBURG — In Could, Democrats and Republicans will select their events’ candidates for 3 vacant seats on Commonwealth and Superior Courts. The winners will compete within the November basic election.

Pennsylvania’s two intermediate appellate courts have the ability to affirm or reverse selections made in decrease courts. Their rulings may be appealed to the state Supreme Courtroom, Pennsylvania’s courtroom of final resort.

The one that wins the open seat on Commonwealth Courtroom may assist form Pennsylvania’s legal guidelines on every little thing from elections to firearms, whereas the 2 candidates who win seats on Superior Courtroom may resolve the outcomes of high-profile legal instances. Judges on each courts are sometimes prime candidates to fill openings on the Pennsylvania Supreme Courtroom.

The 2 intermediate appellate courts serve distinct roles within the commonwealth’s authorized system.

Commonwealth Courtroom presides over civil actions introduced by and towards the Pennsylvania state authorities and hears appeals primarily in instances involving state departments and native governments. Superior Courtroom handles legal, household, and civil instances which might be appealed by county Courts of Frequent Pleas.

Not all voters will be capable to take part within the upcoming judicial primaries, which will probably be held Could 16. Pennsylvania is one in every of 9 states that has closed primaries, which stop third-party and unaffiliated voters from collaborating in partisan elections. (Unaffiliated and third-party voters can, nonetheless, vote on poll questions, different referendums, and particular elections throughout a main.)

Pennsylvania is one in every of a handful of states that elect judges in partisan contests, which means candidates run below the banner of a political occasion, acquire endorsements, and lift cash.

There are a number of key variations between a judicial election and different political elections within the commonwealth, nonetheless. Potential judges can’t immediately ask for donations, although their marketing campaign committees can. In addition they can’t make guarantees that they’ll rule in sure methods.

As a result of judicial elections are likely to have comparatively low voter turnout, and since judges have much less direct contact with the general public than native representatives, occasion endorsements generally is a highly effective determinant of who wins a judicial main.

Rankings from the Pennsylvania Bar Affiliation may be equally essential. The bar ranks judicial candidates as “extremely really useful,” “really useful,” or “not really useful” primarily based on the candidate’s judicial document and interviews with a judicial analysis fee.

Commonwealth Courtroom

The nine-member Commonwealth Courtroom is the primary cease for a lot of high-profile instances.

Latest rulings embrace a 2022 choice that discovered the state’s mail voting regulation unconstitutional — a call later overruled by the state Supreme Courtroom — and a February opinion that discovered the state’s training funding system violated the rights of fogeys and college students in poorer districts.

Judges serve preliminary 10-year phrases, then face a nonpartisan retention vote, which often succeeds.

There may be one seat open on Commonwealth Courtroom this yr, and each events’ primaries have a number of candidates vying for the nomination. The courtroom presently has 5 judges who have been elected as Republicans and three elected as Democrats.

Democratic candidates

Bryan Neft

Neft is an legal professional primarily based in Mt. Lebanon who works in industrial litigation.

Neft beforehand ran for Superior Courtroom in 2021, in the end ending behind the 2 different candidates within the Democratic main.

A graduate of Boston College College of Legislation, Neft has predominantly spent his profession in non-public observe. He clerked for former Superior Courtroom Decide William Cercone in Pittsburgh from 1991 to 1995, drafting memorandums on civil and legal points.

Neft served as a committee member for the Mt. Lebanon Democratic Celebration from 2016 to 2020, when he resigned to run for Superior Courtroom. He was reappointed after his loss within the main however resigned once more in November 2022 for his present Superior Courtroom bid.

The Pennsylvania Bar Affiliation rated Neft as “really useful,” writing that friends considered him as “laborious working, sincere and dedicated to equal justice, equity and impartiality within the judicial system.”

Learn Neft’s solutions to the PBA questionnaire right here.

Matthew Wolf

Wolf is a decide on the Philadelphia Municipal Courtroom, the place he has served since 2018.

Previous to his election to the courtroom in 2017, Wolf ran a authorized observe primarily based in Cherry Hill, New Jersey, that targeted on employment regulation and civil rights. In his PBA questionnaire, he famous that his shoppers included “many ladies” concerned in being pregnant discrimination, hostile work setting, and sexual harassment instances.

Wolf spent years within the U.S. Military Reserve, serving as an officer from 2003 to 2020 and deploying to Afghanistan and Iraq. After resigning his fee in 2020, he enlisted within the Pennsylvania Military Nationwide Guard.

The Pennsylvania Bar Affiliation rated Wolf as “really useful,” saying that his writing is “clear and concise,” and noting that he has a historical past of public service.

Learn Wolf’s solutions to the PBA questionnaire right here.

Republican candidates

Megan Martin

A Cumberland County resident and Widener College regulation faculty graduate, Martin is the previous parliamentarian of the state Senate and is endorsed by the state Republican Celebration within the main race for Commonwealth Courtroom.

Because the secretary-parliamentarian, Martin suggested the chamber’s presiding officer on tips on how to run flooring proceedings in accordance with the state structure, regulation, and chamber guidelines.

Earlier than becoming a member of the chamber, she served as a staffer after which an legal professional for former GOP Govs. Tom Ridge and Tom Corbett, as an legal professional for the U.S. Navy, and as a regulation clerk for a Lancaster County decide.

The state bar affiliation rated her as “really useful,” saying that Martin’s “substantial administrative regulation expertise will serve her nicely.”

Learn Martin’s solutions to the PBA questionnaire right here.

Joshua Prince

A Berks County lawyer and Widener College regulation faculty graduate, Prince runs a agency that focuses on gun-related litigation.

Prince has sued town of Harrisburg to dam the enforcement of previous gun legal guidelines, and sued the state and federal governments to dam bans on bump shares and partial firearm frames that lack figuring out data, which opponents have labeled “ghost weapons.”

He has the endorsement of a handful of conservative rank-and-file GOP lawmakers, county sheriffs, and gun rights teams, together with Firearms House owners In opposition to Crime.

In February, Prince attended a Susquehanna County Republicans occasion and posed for a bunch picture that included Frank Scavo, a former Republican legislative candidate who was sentenced to 60 days in jail for collaborating within the Jan. 6 riot on the U.S. Capitol. GOP state Supreme Courtroom candidate Patricia McCullough was additionally within the picture.

Prince informed Highlight PA that he wasn’t conscious of Scavo’s background when he took the picture.

“It’s inconceivable to know everybody’s private background from a 1-minute interplay,” he mentioned.

Prince will not be really useful by the state bar affiliation, which discovered that he “lacks the depth and breadth of expertise and preparation essential to tackle the commanding position of decide on the Commonwealth Courtroom.”

In an e-mail, Prince mentioned he disagreed together with his score and pointed to the success of candidates who didn’t have the group’s blessing.

“I’ve confidence voters will as soon as once more see {that a} single organizational endorsement will not be the total measure of a candidate, and that they’ll base their choice on the totality of precise expertise, particularly within the courtroom,” Prince mentioned.

Learn Prince’s solutions to the PBA questionnaire right here.

Superior Courtroom

The 15-member Superior Courtroom handles all nongovernment-related legal and civil instances. Major voters will choose two candidates from their very own occasion; the 2 Democrats and the 2 Republicans with probably the most votes will transfer on to the November basic election.

The panel’s essential position is to assessment decrease courts’ verdicts. Notable latest selections embrace a 2019 opinion tossing out rapper Meek Mills’s conviction on drug and gun fees.

Judges serve preliminary 10-year phrases, then face nonpartisan retention votes, which often succeed.

There are two open seats on Superior Courtroom this yr. Its partisan make-up is presently cut up, with seven Democrats and 7 Republicans. The president decide of the courtroom is chosen via a vote by members of the Superior Courtroom and serves a five-year time period.

Democratic candidates

Jill Beck

Beck is a Pittsburgh-based legal professional who works in industrial litigation. She ran for Superior Courtroom in 2021 however was defeated within the main by Timika Lane.

Beck clerked for state Supreme Courtroom Justice Christine Donohue from 2016 to 2019, and for Donohue on Superior Courtroom from 2010 to 2015.

In her questionnaire for the Pennsylvania Bar Affiliation, Beck mentioned that in her time as a clerk on Superior Courtroom she drafted memoranda and printed opinions on practically 500 selections.

Beck has additionally labored at KidsVoice, a nonprofit company that advocates for kids within the baby welfare system in Allegheny County’s Juvenile Courtroom.

The state bar affiliation rated her “extremely really useful,” writing that Beck possesses “the very best mixture of authorized capacity, expertise and integrity.”

Learn Beck’s solutions to the PBA questionnaire right here.

Timika Lane

Lane has served as a Philadelphia Courtroom of Frequent Pleas decide since 2014.

Lane first ran for Superior Courtroom in 2021. She gained the first, beating Beck, however misplaced by 7 factors to Republican challenger Megan Sullivan.

Earlier than turning into a lawyer, Lane labored for 4 years as a public faculty trainer, then attended regulation faculty and spent a yr clerking for Decide Renée Cardwell Hughes within the Philadelphia Courtroom of Frequent Pleas.

She then spent a yr working primarily in non-public observe household regulation earlier than taking a job as an assistant public defender in Philadelphia from 2004 to 2009.

She additionally spent a number of years as authorized counsel for Democratic state Sen. Anthony Williams earlier than being elected to the Philadelphia Courtroom of Frequent Pleas in 2013. The trial courtroom hears appeals for civil, legal, and household issues.

The Pennsylvania Bar Affiliation rated Lane”extremely really useful,” saying that her “writing is well-reasoned, clear and concise.”

Learn Lane’s solutions to the PBA questionnaire right here.

Patrick Dugan

Dugan is a decide on the Philadelphia Municipal Courtroom, a trial courtroom the place civil and legal instances within the metropolis are first adjudicated. First appointed to the courtroom in 2007 by former Democratic Gov. Ed Rendell, Dugan was then elected to the courtroom in 2009 and retained in 2015. Dugan’s friends on the courtroom elected him president decide in 2019.

Dugan attended regulation faculty between two stints within the U.S. Military — first as an enlisted airborne infantryman within the Eighties after which as a civil affairs noncommissioned officer in Iraq and a decide advocate officer in Afghanistan. He held the rank of U.S. Military captain when he retired from the army in 2016.

In 2010, Dugan co-founded Philadelphia’s Veterans Courtroom, which handles instances through which present or former army members are charged with nonviolent misdemeanors. All judges who preside over the courtroom are veterans.

As of March 23, the Pennsylvania Bar Affiliation had not assigned Dugan a score.

Republican candidates

Maria Battista

A Clarion County resident who holds a regulation diploma from Ohio Northern College, Battista beforehand served as assistant basic counsel for the departments of Well being and State below former Govs. Tom Corbett, a Republican, and Tom Wolf, a Democrat. She additionally was a prosecutor in Franklin and Venango Counties, and was a contract specialist for the Division of Protection.

She has since left that job to run for workplace, in response to the Courier-Categorical, and now works as vp of state and federal contracting for The Decide Group, a Wayne-based consulting agency.

She is endorsed by the state Republican Celebration.

As of March 23, the Pennsylvania Bar Affiliation had not assigned Battista a score.

Harry Smail

Smail has been a Westmoreland County Frequent Pleas decide since former Republican Gov. Tom Corbett appointed him to the bench in 2014. Earlier than that, he was a personal observe legal professional who ran unsuccessfully for quite a few county workplaces. He acquired his regulation diploma from Duquesne College.

He’s endorsed by the state Republican Celebration. On its web site, the occasion factors to rulings Smail made in 2020 “that upheld important anti-fraud necessities for casting a mail-in poll.”

That yr, Smail dominated towards the Westmoreland County Board of Elections in a case introduced by a Republican candidate for state Senate in a particularly shut race.

He ordered the board to throw out 204 provisional ballots — these which might be forged when an individual’s registration can’t be instantly verified — it wished to rely. These 204 provisional ballots have been forged by individuals who have been wrongly informed by election staff that in addition they wanted to signal their precinct’s pollbook. By signing the e book, the voters as a substitute indicated they forged a poll utilizing a voting machine.

Smail dominated that the board of elections didn’t conduct due diligence in accepting these 204 votes with out “additional substantiating proof” that they hadn’t voted twice.

“Whereas the Courtroom is loath to impose the implications of a failure of the Board onto an harmless citizens … the courtroom should apply the provisions of the Elections Code persistently and as written by our legislature,” Smail wrote within the 12-page choice.

The bar rated Smail “really useful,” “primarily based on his in depth background, authorized capacity and temperament.”

Learn Smail’s solutions to the PBA questionnaire right here.

WHILE YOU’RE HERE… Should you realized one thing from this story, pay it ahead and develop into a member of Highlight PA so another person can sooner or later at spotlightpa.org/donate. Highlight PA is funded by foundations and readers such as you who’re dedicated to accountability journalism that will get outcomes.