Connect with us

Northeast

Five years after COVID lockdowns: The 5 most bizarre ‘Stop-the-Spread’ moments

Published

on

Five years after COVID lockdowns: The 5 most bizarre ‘Stop-the-Spread’ moments

As the U.S. nears the five-year mark since nationwide lockdowns turned toilet paper into a hot commodity, Fox News Digital took a look back at some of the most controversial mandates – those that sparked debate – and, to some, defied logic.

1. FAUCI’S CONTRADICTIONS

Former NIAID Director Anthony Fauci was a ubiquitous sight throughout the pandemic, during the administrations of both Donald Trump and Joe Biden. 

The octogenarian allergist, who had been with the government since 1968 and appointed head of the NIH’s infectious disease arm by former President Ronald Reagan, was often lambasted for contradictory or questionable medical orders.

Fauci drew heat for apparent contradictions in mask-wearing orders, with critics often locking onto the certainty with which the Brooklynite announced each countervailing development.

In March 2020, Fauci told “60 Minutes” about “unintended consequences” of wearing masks to prevent the spread of COVID-19. 

Advertisement

“People keep fiddling with the mask and they keep touching their face,” he said, suggesting germs and viruses could be spread by too much fidgeting.

Soon after, and for most of the rest of the pandemic, Fauci was adamant that Americans must wear masks nearly at all times in public. 

He raised eyebrows further when he told CNBC it might be time to double up on masks – a stance that clashed with claims from right-wing physicians who warned that excessive face coverings could obstruct breathing.

‘CUOMO CHIP’ LOOPHOLE CRUMBLES AS NY NOW WANTS ‘SUBSTANTIAL FOOD’ SOLD WITH BOOZE

Dr. Anthony Fauci (Getty)

Advertisement

“If you have a physical covering with one layer, you put another layer on it just makes common sense that it likely would be more effective,” Fauci said.

National Review writer David Harsanyi balked at the order at the time, quipping, “No, thanks, Dad.”

Current Secretary of State Marco Rubio also commented at the time about Fauci’s varied orders:

“Dr. Fauci is a very good public-health official. His job is to advise policymakers and inform the public, but his job is not to decide what we can do, where we can go or which places can open or close. His job is not to mislead or scare us into doing the [supposed] right things,” the Floridian said.

Pennsylvania’s most visible shutdown-opposing lawmaker, who later ran for governor on a related “Walk as Free People” slogan, regularly quipped in public remarks at people he would see driving alone in their cars on Interstate 81 while wearing a mask.

Advertisement

“You can’t make this stuff up,” Sen. Doug Mastriano often repeated.

2. WING NUTS 

New York City is known for its pizza, bagels, heros and chopped cheese – but western New York holds another food item just as dear – the Buffalo wing.

The COVID-19 lockdowns proved the love upstaters have for their chicken apps after then-Gov. Andrew Cuomo laid out what “substantive food” a watering hole has to offer in order for patrons to go out for a drink.

“To be a bar, you have to have food available. Soups, sandwiches – More than just hors d’oeuvres, chicken wings; you had to have some substantive food,” he said. 

Advertisement

New Yorkers used to sloshing Frank’s Red Hot on their chicken became Red Hot themselves and lambasted the governor for appearing to define their beloved dish as less than a meal.

The outrage led to a New York state communications official later tweeting a diagrammed-sentence breakdown of Cuomo’s comments, seeking to illustrate that the clause “more than just hors d’oeuvres” was an interjection and that “chicken wings” were to be associated with the “soups, sandwiches” mentioned – but the damage had been done.

In return, bars began charging a dollar or so each for a slice of deli meat, a handful of croutons or a single french fry in order to allow their patrons an end-round around the edict and have a cold one.

PENNSYLVANIA GOV. TOM WOLF THREATENS TO WITHHOLD CORONAVIRUS AID TO COUNTIES THAT DEFY LOCKDOWN ORDERS

Demonstrators gather around state Rep. Russ Diamond at a Reopen PA rally in Harrisburg, May 15, 2020. (IMAGN)

Advertisement

In neighboring Pennsylvania, Gov. Tom Wolf instituted a similar ban – requiring a meal to be purchased before alcohol could be served. The state police’s bureau of liquor enforcement patrolled towns to enforce the mandate and other regulations, warning small-town saloons that their liquor licenses were on the line.

When many restaurants were closed for eat-in dining in Pennsylvania, several lawmakers held a demonstration in Lebanon outside what was then the Taste of Sicily Italian Restaurant.

Several area lawmakers – state Reps. Russ Diamond, Frank Ryan and the late Dave Arnold – joined Mastriano and restaurant manager Mike Mangano to decry “stop the spread” orders that cut off family restaurants’ income.

Flanked by the others, Diamond read from Article I Sec. 2 of the Pennsylvania Constitution, which stated “all power is inherent in the people… and they have at all times an inalienable… right to alter, reform or abolish their government in such matter they see fit.”

“That means,” he said, “You can exercise your constitutional right to abolish the interminable b—- of this government, which happens to be the governor’s obtuse, stupid and bass-ackward orders.”

Advertisement

3. SUNDAY DRIVERS BEWARE

In Pennsylvania, Wolf and Health Secretary Rachel Levine were ubiquitous on the airwaves with their lockdown provisions and orders – from traffic-light color-coded maps instructing which counties’ residents could have varying levels of freedom, to Levine’s daily warning on TV to “stay home, stay calm, stay safe.”

Early in the shutdown period, the Wolf administration utilized a seven-decade-old state law aimed at blunting a syphilis outbreak as legal backing for some of their orders.

In April 2020, a York woman was charged under that statute when she tried to quell her cabin fever with a Sunday drive.

Anita Shaffer told local media at the time she had been returning home from a drive when she passed police parked in the town of Yoe. 

Originally stopped for a broken taillight, Shaffer was ultimately issued a $202 ticket for violating the Disease Prevention and Control Act of 1955, which was described to her as the “stay-at-home-act” in force at the time – to which she pleaded “not guilty.”

Advertisement

PENNSYLVANIA LAWMAKER SLAMS PA COVID LOCKDOWNS AS ‘KEYSTONE KOPS’

Supporters of Pennsylvania Sen. Doug Mastriano hold signs emblazoned with his anti-COVID-lockdown slogan, “Walk as Free People.”

Current Pennsylvania Attorney General David Sunday – a Republican who was then York County’s district attorney – later expressed opposition to the state’s lockdown orders and told the York Daily Record he wouldn’t prosecute businesses Wolf’s classifications deemed “nonessential” if they opened before Harrisburg said so.

Police said after the incident: “Sunday drives are not essential travel.”

Drivers on the state’s highways also encountered other unique COVID order roadblocks.

Advertisement

Mastriano spoke at several demonstrations in Harrisburg, Lancaster and beyond, and recounted some such experiences.

Pennsylvania rest areas were briefly closed to “stop the spread,” he noted, adding how incredulous it was to come upon an Interstate 81 rest area on his commute, see it barricaded closed, and then see several big-rigs parked dangerously close to traffic on the shoulder in a line for the ensuing mile.

Republicans in Pennsylvania later drafted a constitutional amendment ballot initiative seeking to claw back some of the restrictions. Some proponents cited what they called a biblical irony in the randomly-assigned bill number – SB 836 – which echoed John 8:36’s admonition “If Christ sets you free, you are free indeed.”

4. NO PARK-ING

Another stop-the-spread order that led to public outcry affected children more than those of-age to travel or drink.

Cities from California to New Jersey began dumping sand into skate parks, playgrounds, and public areas to prevent groups or crowds from the recreation sites.

Advertisement

Tons of sand were dumped into public skate parks in Los Angeles, which enraged professional and amateur shredders alike.

In April 2020, skaters were so fed up with the city of Los Angeles that they brought their own shovels to clear sand from the iconic Venice Beach skate park.

Professional skater Paul Rodriguez told “The Undefeated” at the time that the move was “a little stronger than [the city] needed to do.”

“I was like, damn, that’s aggressive… But as a human, I’m like, we’re going through a pandemic, I mean, we’ve got to do what we got to do,” Rodriguez said.

CA SKATEPARKS FILLED WITH SAND

Advertisement

The Venice Beach skate park was filled with sand to prevent people from using it during the coronavirus pandemic. (Getty)

Skate “bowls” in San Clemente, California, were also filled in with 37 tons of sand after skaters ignored several “No Trespassing” signs.

In Pittsburgh, skaters climbed over closed fences and cut locks, according to the public works department, when local media asked about its own decision to fill the parks with sand.

In other cities, public basketball hoops were removed from backboards, while 2x4s were nailed to cover other baskets in an effort to prevent people from congregating.

5. JUST A COKE, PLEASE

While lockdown policies in many states had either intentional or unintentional consequences on the consumption of alcohol, the Northeast was incongruently affected by such a change in social behavior.

Advertisement

In August 2021, as some states began slowly slackening some of their orders, others retained a tough stance to “stop the spread.”

Virginia, Pennsylvania and several other states employ “state stores” or “ABC” outlets to sell alcohol that is effectively solely available from the state government. 

One state that doesn’t is Delaware. With its regional tax-free shopping mecca in Christiana and the availability of liquor in mega-stores like Total Wine, it is often a draw for higher-tax or socially-stricter states around it.

COVID-19 made the First State no different, as Pennsylvania continued to keep its state stores closed, Philadelphians and others tried to find new ways to get their alcohol legally.

Just as Pennsylvania’s side of its state lines is dotted with fireworks outlets geared toward out-of-state visitors, a liquor superstore stands just yards inside Delaware at I-95 and DE-92.

Advertisement

The store began seeing a major influx of out-of-state patrons who snuck across from Marcus Hook – until Delaware instituted a travel ban and then-Gov. John Carney’s administration gave police authority to pull over any out-of-state-tagged vehicle.

The parking lot of the Total Wine was a hub for such activity, as thirsty Pennsylvanians converged on the market to purchase their drinks of choice and zip home.

DSP Cpl. Michael Austin responded to the situation in a statement to the Delco Times: 

“The primary intent and goal of the Delaware State Police is to uphold their sworn duties by providing information to the public that we serve, in order to gain voluntary compliance with the mandates, and to promote, and further ensure public safety and health.”

Advertisement

Similar dynamics occurred across state lines around the country as well, but not to the high-profile nature media-wise of the “Naamans Road checkpoint.”

Read the full article from Here

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

New Hampshire

From farm to… freezer? A new approach could help close N.H.’s local food gap. – The Boston Globe

Published

on

From farm to… freezer? A new approach could help close N.H.’s local food gap. – The Boston Globe


“This process takes our product to a whole different level,” said Zydenbos. And, she said, it tastes delicious.

Vermont has the highest percentage of local food sales in the region (10.7 percent), followed by Maine (4.9 percent), with New Hampshire coming in third (4.6 percent), according to 2024 data from New England Feeding New England, a partnership of New England organizations advocating that the region produce 30 percent of the food it consumes by 2030. Massachusetts comes in fourth, with 3.6 percent of food spending on local items.

Stephanie Zydenbos, founder and CEO of Micro Mama’s, right, and her sister, COO Samantha Cleveland, chat in their Weare, N.H. workshop.Pat Greenhouse/Globe Staff

New Hampshire is second to last in New England when it comes to the value of vegetable sales ($23 million) and the value of agriculture ($209 million). Many farmers in the state struggle to turn a profit.

“Generally speaking, New Hampshire is a little bit behind,” said Shawn Menard, executive director of Seacoast Eat Local, a local food nonprofit, and board president at the Concord Food Co-op. Menard said other New England states have more robust infrastructure for food processing, purchasing, and distribution that supports local food production.

Since 2012, Zydenbos has operated Micro Mama’s, one of New Hampshire’s first fermented vegetable companies, sourcing local produce and transforming it into fermented vegetables sold at more than 50 locations around New England, including about 30 Whole Foods stores.

The Silly Dilly Carrot Prebiotic & Probiotic Fermented Vegetables, left, will become Micro Mama’s first fermented freeze-dried blend, according to Stephanie Zydenbos.Pat Greenhouse/Globe Staff

Now, Zydenbos wants to try something new, by making more processing equipment available for farmers and producers in New Hampshire and using it to introduce novel local food products. Among them: freeze-dried kimchi, a new take on a traditional Korean dish made with spicy fermented vegetables like napa cabbage and radishes.

With a $96,000 federal grant from the US Department of Agriculture in hand, she purchased new equipment, including an individual quick freezer and a freeze dryer. Food experts said the cost of the equipment is one barrier that’s prevented other small local businesses from offering similar products.

Jennifer Chadbourne, a clinical associate professor in agriculture, nutrition, and food systems at the University of New Hampshire, said freeze-dried kimchi is not widely available.

Advertisement

“It could be a really novel idea for the manufacturer,” she said.

Traditional kimchi and other fermented vegetables offer certain health benefits, like probiotics that can aid gut health, according to Chadbourne. She said freeze-drying can preserve the nutritional value of food since it doesn’t rely on a high heat during processing, but there’s not yet robust evidence on the nutritional profile of a new food like freeze-dried kimchi. She said flash freezing is another effective way to preserve the peak nutrients of a freshly harvested food.

For the consumer, these products are a convenient way to buy nutritious local produce outside the limited months of New England’s growing season.

“Especially here in New England, where we have such drastic seasons that impact how long we can grow food, any type of novel preservation technique is going to help us maximize our crops during the seasons where we can grow,” said Chadbourne.

The individual quick freezer Zydenbos acquired is different from a typical household freezer. It freezes produce in about 20 minutes as opposed to 48 hours, Zydenbos said. And rather than locking produce into one solid chunk, it freezes berries or broccoli as individual pieces, which makes it easier to use at home.

Advertisement

If freeze-dried kimchi seems a little out there, that’s a challenge Zydenbos has faced before. When she started her fermented food business in 2012, kimchi was still on the fringes of food culture in New England. Zydenbos said she had to work with state agencies as they learned how to regulate the food. Then she toured the state’s farmers markets educating consumers and evangelizing the benefits of fermented foods.

Even before that, there were her own doubts to overcome.

“When you first do it, you’re like, Oh, my god, this goes against everything that you’ve been taught,” she said. “You’re basically leaving vegetables out on the warm shelf to transform.”

“I’m going to kill somebody,” she remembers thinking while fermenting a batch for her own consumption after attending a kimchi-making workshop.

Micro Mama’s refrigerator trailer outside the processing facility in Weare, N.H.Pat Greenhouse/Globe Staff
Micro Mama’s fermenting tanks inside the temperature-controlled fermenting room in Weare, N.H.Pat Greenhouse/Globe Staff

Zydenbos came to fermenting in search of healing. For years, she relied on copious quantities of probiotic supplements to ease digestive issues. When she started making kimchi, that became her new cure.

From there, a kimchi empire was born.

Advertisement

“In terms of somebody who really put it on the map in this region, I think Micro Mama’s is a huge player in that,” said Menard. He was the produce manager at the Concord Co-op when Zydenbos landed her account there. Menard said he hadn’t had kimchi before, but he was blown away by the flavor of her product, which was well received among the co-op’s customers.

By 2017, Zydenbos had built a facility in Weare on a property that had been in her family since the 1970s. The fermenting dens now contain 40,000 pounds of vegetables in production, all subject to strict federal and state safety regulations. She sourced stainless steel fermenting tanks from Italy and Germany to avoid using plastic containers.

When Whole Foods first came to New Hampshire, Zydenbos put her line of products forward – including kimchi, sauerkraut, and fermented carrots and beets, sourced from New Hampshire farms. The food safety work she had done with state agencies paid off, Zydenbos said, when she was able to show Whole Foods her quality control measures.

Now, with her new equipment, Zydenbos is planning to add freeze-dried kimchi to her lineup, as well as launch a spice line and food that will appeal to hikers, campers, and preppers.

“The possibilities are endless,” she said.

Advertisement

With the individual quick freezer, she can produce frozen carrots, beets, potatoes, and French-fry cut potatoes, which could be sold at local grocery stores or to New Hampshire restaurants.

Zydenbos views these efforts as a way to help farms access markets they haven’t been able to reach given a lack of processing equipment, licensing, or capital. She said the demand already exists.

Bruce Wooster of Picadilly Farm in Winchester, N.H., has been selling produce to Zydenbos for about five years. He said her new endeavor with flash frozen and freeze-dried produce could help growers extend their selling season.

“All the local farms have their crop coming all at once,” he said. “It can be tough to spread out those sales, but by freezing you can spread things out and not be like, ‘Hey, we’ve got to sell it this week before it spoils.’”

The Concord Food Co-op is one local grocery store that’s eager to include local frozen produce on its shelves.

Advertisement

“We have frozen vegetables that fly off the shelf,” said Josh Belanger, the store’s former general manager. “I think if we had them locally they’d do even better.”

Josh Marshall, assistant commissioner of the New Hampshire Department of Agriculture, Markets, and Food, said the new equipment will help make more local food available.

“For a small producer to be able to buy directly from small, New Hampshire farmers, and do this, this seems relatively cutting edge,” Marshall said.


Amanda Gokee can be reached at amanda.gokee@globe.com. Follow her @amanda_gokee.





Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

New Jersey

7 Of The Most Welcoming Towns In New Jersey

Published

on

7 Of The Most Welcoming Towns In New Jersey


New Jersey’s most welcoming towns pair walkable main streets with year-round arts calendars and centuries of preserved history. Some carry deep Revolutionary War legacies. Others grew up around an art museum or a resident orchestra. Free jazz fills Nishuane Park. The Mayo Performing Arts Center hosts touring Broadway shows. Expect Victorian beach streets, summer Shakespeare, and old battlefields. All places where strangers get treated like neighbors.

Cape May

Washington Street Mall at Cape May, New Jersey. Image credit: Jonathan W. Cohen / iStock.com

Cape May built its hospitality on its bed-and-breakfast district. Longtime innkeepers remember returning guests by name. The city holds one of the largest collections of 19th-century frame buildings in the country. That Victorian architecture earned it National Historic Landmark status in 1976. Cape May stands at the southern tip of the state’s coast, where Delaware Bay meets the Atlantic Ocean.

Beach access stretches past Cove Beach and Poverty Beach to the central stretch near Beach Avenue. The Washington Street Mall handles shopping and dining inland. The 1859 Cape May Lighthouse still operates at the southern point. Visitors can climb its 199 steps for a view of the bay and ocean below.

Princeton

Shoppers and pedestrians near a Tudor style building on Witherspoon Street in Princeton, New Jersey
Shoppers and pedestrians near a Tudor style building on Witherspoon Street in Princeton, New Jersey. Image credit: Benjamin Clapp / Shutterstock.com

Princeton turned its university art museum into a public town square. The free museum opened a new building in October 2025 and holds more than 117,000 works. Princeton University began as the College of New Jersey in 1746, among the oldest in the country. Its collegiate Gothic campus stays open for self-guided architectural tours.

Bookstores and cafés line Nassau Street and Witherspoon Street downtown. Princeton Battlefield State Park preserves the ground where George Washington beat British troops in January 1777. The Delaware and Raritan Canal State Park follows the old canal corridor nearby. Level paths there suit walking and biking.

Advertisement

Morristown

Overlooking Morristown, New Jersey.
Overlooking Morristown, New Jersey.

Morristown holds the country’s first national historical park. Established in 1933, it preserves the site where the Continental Army camped through the brutal winter of 1779-1780. The town carries one of the deepest Revolutionary War legacies anywhere. The National Trust for Historic Preservation named it a Dozen Distinctive Destination. The Ford Mansion served as George Washington’s headquarters and stays open for tours. Acorn Hall, Historic Speedwell, and the MacCulloch Hall Historical Museum round out the historic-house circuit.

The Mayo Performing Arts Center on South Street books classical music, touring concerts, and Broadway shows year-round. The Morristown Green gathers the downtown restaurant and shopping scene around one public square.

Madison

A huge clock in the main street of Madison, New Jersey downtown on a sunny afternoon
A huge clock in the main street of Madison, New Jersey downtown on a sunny afternoon. Image credit: Wirestock Creators / Shutterstock.com

Madison hosts the Shakespeare Theatre of New Jersey at Drew University. It is the state’s only professional company devoted to Shakespeare and the classics. Performances fill the F.M. Kirby Shakespeare Theatre through a long summer season. The town stands about five miles east of Morristown.

Independent cafés, bakeries, and boutiques fill Main Street and Waverly Place. The Museum of Early Trades and Crafts occupies the 1900 James Library building. Its displays show the tools New Jersey artisans used in the 18th and 19th centuries.

Montclair

Park Street in downtown Montclair.
Park Street in downtown Montclair.

The free Montclair Jazz Festival fills Nishuane Park each year. Emerging and established players make it one of the larger jazz gatherings in the region. The town rests on the eastern slope of the Watchung Mountains. It keeps one of New Jersey’s busiest arts calendars. The Montclair Art Museum on South Mountain Avenue centers its collection on American and Native American art.

The Alexander Kasser Theater at Montclair State University books dance, music, and theater all year. Restaurants and shops line Bloomfield Avenue in the Montclair Center district. The restored 1922 Wellmont Theater hosts touring concerts and comedy.

Westfield

Outdoor dining in Westfield, New Jersey
Outdoor dining in Westfield, New Jersey.

The New Jersey Festival Orchestra calls Westfield home and plays venues around town all year. Shops, boutiques, and restaurants fill the Union County downtown along East Broad Street and Elm Street. The 1922 Rialto on East Broad Street was long the town’s movie house. It is being reborn as the Center for Creativity, a community arts venue for film, performance, and exhibitions.

Mindowaskin Park holds a pond, walking paths, and picnic spaces near downtown. The Spring Fling and FestiFall events bring music, food, and family activities to the blocks each year.

East Brunswick

Aerial view of single family homes, a residential district East Brunswick New Jersey
Aerial view of single family homes in a residential district of East Brunswick, New Jersey.

Giamarese Farm and Orchards keeps a pick-your-own operation in East Brunswick. It offers seasonal fruit and vegetable picking, a corn maze, and autumn hayrides. The Middlesex County town leans toward families. Butterfly Park sets aside green space for butterfly conservation. Crystal Springs Family Waterpark gives a summer cooling-off spot.

Playhouse 22 stages community theater, plays, and concerts year-round. The East Brunswick Public Library hosts programs and exhibits as a cultural hub. Bicentennial Park and the Tamarack Golf Course cover the sports side. Route 18 puts New Brunswick and the central Jersey corridor within easy reach.

Advertisement

Hospitality You Can Walk To

Hospitality here shows up in small, repeatable ways. The Morristown Green fills with the same faces every weekend. Princeton opens its new art museum to everyone for free. The New Jersey Festival Orchestra tunes up in Westfield. Giamarese Farm hands East Brunswick families a basket every fall. None of it is staged for outsiders. These towns built their welcome for the people who live there. The rest of New Jersey keeps showing up anyway.



Source link

Continue Reading

Pennsylvania

Half of child deaths left unreviewed in Pa. since 2020 as counties struggle with ‘unfunded mandate’

Published

on

Half of child deaths left unreviewed in Pa. since 2020 as counties struggle with ‘unfunded mandate’


Many Pennsylvania counties are failing to review the death of every child in their area, despite a 2008 state law that requires them to do so.

The problem, advocates and program participants say, is a lack of both state assistance in collecting data and time for volunteers to run the local panels.

Gov. Josh Shapiro wants the legislature to approve $2.5 million to improve this work, but it’s unclear if the request will be considered a priority this year.

The effort to study the deaths of Pennsylvania children dates back about two decades, when the state passed a law mandating counties host a local board of healthcare professionals, law enforcement officials, child protective service providers, and a coroner or medical examiner to review the deaths of every resident under the age of 21. The law was one of several initiatives spurred by the murder of Berks County toddler Maxwell Fisher in 1996.

Advertisement

Based on the information county boards gather, members are charged with creating strategies for local and state policymakers to prevent similar deaths.

But reports shared with Spotlight PA by the Pennsylvania Department of Health show that since 2020, roughly half of childhood deaths statewide have not been reviewed. Those lapses are especially prominent in rural counties, where local teams are more likely to falter or not exist.

Policymakers have known about the program’s issues for years.

A multiyear East Stroudsburg University evaluation of the program commissioned by the state Department of Health concluded in 2024 that the Child Death Review program is “an unfunded mandate.” It issued a long list of recommendations to rectify the program’s shortcomings, including creating regional teams for rural areas.

“Staffing turnovers and pandemic disruptions were detrimental to maintaining complete teams in many regions of Pennsylvania,” researchers wrote. “Some have since begun to rebuild while other teams have yet to meaningfully reengage in (Child Death Review).”

Advertisement

Still, lawmakers have failed to adopt legislation — or even introduce any, according to a search of the state General Assembly’s website — to address the issues facing the 2008 law.

The status quo could change this year.

Steven Shapiro, a pediatrician and longtime member of the Montgomery County review team, told Spotlight PA that he and fellow pediatrician Erich Batra, of Lebanon County’s review board, have been urging state officials to improve the “flawed” Child Death Review system. They want a coordinated effort to improve data collection and remove some burdens from counties’ responsibilities.

“If you just unpack how the child succumbed, then you begin to learn about how you can protect other children from enduring the same fate and parents enduring the same fate,” Shapiro said.

Shapiro’s son, Gov. Josh Shapiro, happens to be in a position to help get the program some state funding. Though the elder Shapiro said he does not “try to influence” policy when speaking with his son, some topics come up “over table talk at dinner sometimes.”

Advertisement

Earlier this year, for the first time, the governor proposed using a new $2.5 million from the state’s general fund to support the program. The Department of Health said in an emailed April statement that the money would be used to adopt some of the report’s recommendations. Those include adding health department staff to assist county teams with data collection and prevention strategies, creating a grant that counties could use to “enhance local CDR operations,” and expanding public education campaigns geared toward preventing child deaths.

The Department of Health’s statement did not specify how many positions would be added to improve the program’s organization.

Steven Shapiro said he and Batra are also working on a “cogent, complete and cost-effective” proposal to “redo” how the state is involved in Child Death Review data collection that would not require new legislation. He wouldn’t share details on how that new system might work, but said some funding from the state is essential.

Batra told Spotlight PA the $2.5 million in state funding the governor is proposing would be a good starting point. He envisions it helping counties with data collection and funding local prevention efforts, which can include things like adding signs at dangerous intersections, leading a smoke detector campaign in neighborhoods experiencing fires, or holding fundraisers for a local Cribs for Kids branch.

“A lot of the way Child Death Review works is what I call the intangibles,” Batra said. “It’s the community coming together and working together in a way that they might not always do on a day-to-day basis.”

Advertisement

But Cathleen Palm, founder of the Center for Children’s Justice and a longtime advocate for improving Child Death Review, told Spotlight PA she’s not convinced Gov. Shapiro’s funding pitch alone is a game-changer.

She said that if improving Child Death Review were truly a priority for policymakers, there would be more fanfare around the funding proposal from the Shapiro administration.

Palm also criticized lawmakers for their inaction on addressing issues within the program that have been known for years.

“Why do we create a law if we don’t want to follow it?” Palm said.

In a year where so many competing interests are fighting over a limited amount of state funds, Palm worries Shapiro’s proposal may go overlooked by lawmakers.

Advertisement

“Investing in improvements to the CDR process will further allow the Administration to expand public education and outreach, with a focus on preventable causes of child death,” Rosie Lapowsky, Gov. Shapiro’s spokesperson, said in a statement. “The Governor is hopeful the General Assembly shares that mission of protecting children and ensuring their safety.”

The annual proportion of reviewed child deaths plummeted during COVID-19 and has not fully rebounded, even though there has also been a reduction in the total number of deaths, according to annual reports from the Department of Health.

In the history of the review requirement, county boards have never succeeded in studying every death. The closest they got was in 2013 — statewide, about three-quarters of the 1,931 child deaths that happened that year were reviewed.

That rate dropped to an all-time low in 2019, when 43% of that year’s 1,907 child deaths were reviewed. The drop is often associated with the COVID-19 pandemic, because deaths tend to get reviewed many months after the fact.

The review rate climbed back to nearly 60% in 2023 (of 1,551 deaths), the most recent year for which data are available.

Advertisement

However, local teams across the state left more than 600 deaths unreviewed in 2023.

Unreviewed deaths stem directly from members being “stretched thin with resources” and being “pulled in so many different directions,” according to Christina Phillips, who organized the Child Death Review program from 2018 until her retirement earlier this year.

Phillips said she worked as a “one-person project” at the state level to coordinate with counties about which deaths to review. Part of the reason the Department of Health commissioned East Stroudsburg University to do its 2022-24 study of the program is because Phillips raised concerns, she told Spotlight PA.

Most of the people who serve on local review teams are volunteers who do this work alongside their regular paid positions. Phillips said many rural counties meet as little as once or twice a year.

What they need, she said, is help from state staff to request medical records, synthesize findings into data entry, and translate any patterns they find into prevention strategies.

Advertisement

Phillips said she was unsure why lawmakers have not tried to address advocates’ concerns, given they have received an annual report that highlights those problems for multiple years.

“Preventing kids from dying is never a partisan issue,” Phillips said. “Preventing kids from dying is possible if there are more resources for Child Death Review.”

East Stroudsburg University researchers sorted counties into categories: ones that already have strong review programs; ones that could improve in various ways; and ones that need to be redeveloped.

They identified 20 rural counties that should at least consider organizing under regional offices to maximize their resources, and 22 counties — 6 urban and 16 rural — that must regroup because although they experienced “sufficient deaths to justify a local team,” they saw inconsistent participation from members.

The 15 “strong” counties were a mix of urban and rural, from Philadelphia to a regional operation between Susquehanna and Wyoming Counties, according to researchers. They suggested that 10 other counties, including Allegheny, build on their current processes.

Advertisement

Many of the program’s issues stem from data collection. Researchers at East Stroudsburg found that facilitating data collection falls onto volunteer team chairs. In other states, like Maryland and Delaware, there are paid staff at the state level who coordinate data collection efforts prior to meetings, according to researchers.

Roy Hoffman, medical director of Philadelphia’s Fatality Review Program, told Spotlight PA that even for his team of roughly 15 city employees working on death review, data collection is “a pain” and “time-consuming.”

Philadelphia has operated its own death review group since the 1990s, Hoffman said, and saw few differences following the 2008 law.

“I can imagine for some of these smaller counties with coroners, with not having done this, this must be a big pull and hard to do,” Hoffman said.

The most recent state Child Death Review annual report, analyzing 2023 data, found that Black or African American children died at twice the rate of white children — a statistic in line with national trends.

Advertisement

Roughly 47% of the reviewed deaths in 2023 were caused by medical conditions, including prematurity. “External causes,” including bodily force or a weapon, accounted for about 45% of deaths that year.

Palm pointed to the Department of Health’s finding that roughly one-third of child deaths in 2023 were flagged by local teams as “preventable.”

“All of us as a society want to keep our kids alive and healthy and well,” Palm said. “In order to do that, we have to study the kids who died to figure out how we prevent the next child from dying.”

Palm wants the state to foster the same level of research toward preventing gun safety, motor vehicle crashes, drowning, accidental overdoses, and abuse or violence against kids as it and other institutions direct toward studying youth cancer rates.

Researchers at East Stroudsburg recommended that lawmakers amend current law to require a minimum number of quarterly meetings for each local team, boost training for local and state team members, mandate a specific timeframe for a death review to be completed, and require local teams to include representatives from school districts and “underrepresented community groups.”

Advertisement

They also urged lawmakers to reduce the age cap to trigger a mandated review, from 21 to 18, and to include an “enforcement provision” to encourage counties to participate in the program.

None of the researchers’ suggested changes to Child Death Review have been proposed in the General Assembly, according to a review of introduced bills on the legislature’s website.

The original bill establishing the program was sponsored by Republican state Sen. Lisa Baker. She told Spotlight PA in response to emailed questions that it’s likely time to reevaluate the system with input from state and local stakeholders to “address evolving needs.”

“Given children are potentially falling through the cracks, a closer examination and review of the program is certainly warranted,” Baker said.

Beth Rementer, a spokesperson for Democratic state House Majority Leader Matt Bradford, noted that the chamber passed Shapiro’s budget proposal in April, which included the $2.5 million for Child Death Review.

Advertisement

“We are open to discussions with the administration and stakeholders about improving the program to ensure all children are safe,” she said.

A spokesperson for Republican state Senate Majority Leader Joe Pittman did not respond to questions regarding potential changes this year to Child Death Review.

___

This story was originally published by Spotlight PA and distributed through a partnership with The Associated Press.

Advertisement



Source link

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending