Northeast
Confusion erupts in Karen Read murder trial as jurors backtrack on verdict announcement
NEWYou can now listen to Fox News articles!
There was confusion surrounding a potential verdict in the Karen Read murder trial Wednesday, according to Judge Beverly Cannone, who called the sides back around 2 p.m. only to tell them jurors had backtracked.
“I received word from a court officer that the jury had knocked on the door, indicating that they had a verdict,” Cannone said in court. “But before I could even summon everybody into court…shortly thereafter, they knocked again and said they didn’t have a verdict.”
She sealed the unseen verdict slip and entered it into evidence without anyone other than the jurors having seen it.
KAREN READ JURY QUESTIONS SUGGEST SAME LEGAL DILEMMA AS LAST YEAR’S MISTRIAL
WATCH: Judge Cannone explains confusion in court over potential Karen Read verdict
“So we do not have a verdict, because as we all know, there is no verdict until it is announced and recorded in open court,” she said. “So we are still awaiting a verdict.”
She asked everyone to remain in the courthouse for the rest of the day.
Karen Read signs to supporters as she leaves Norfolk Superior Court, Tuesday, June 17, 2025, in Dedham, Mass. Read is charged with killing her Boston police officer boyfriend by intentionally driving her SUV into him. (Richard Beetham for Fox News Digital)
Read, 45, is accused of killing boyfriend John O’Keefe, 46, in a drunken hit-and-run Jan. 29, 2022, outside a party in Canton, Massachusetts.
Were Karen Read’s unorthodox media interviews a next-level strategic move from her defense?
Maybe, according to one Massachusetts legal expert following the case.
After her first trial, which ended with a deadlocked jury last year, she sat down with multiple reporters to tell her side of the story, a move many legal experts have called ill-advised. But it may have a payoff because jurors appear focused on a lesser charge that she may have admitted to on video.
Karen Read signs to supporters while exiting Norfolk Superior Court for lunch Tuesday, June 17, 2025, in Dedham, Mass. (Richard Beetham for Fox News Digital)
“She was ‘testifying’ when she made those statements, knowing they could be used in court,” said Grace Edwards, a criminal defense trial attorney. “Crazy as it seems, this may have been a strategy to give the jury something to hang their hat on and find her guilty of the OUI and get this done.”
She was referring to the charge of operating under the influence, a topic jurors asked multiple questions about Tuesday during the third day of deliberations after more than 30 days of trial testimony.
KAREN READ’S VERDICT COULD COME FAST – OR NOT: HERE’S WHAT OTHER CASES SHOW
WATCH: Prosecution in Karen Read trial uses Read’s own words to dismantle defense’s theory
“That’s an interesting theory – fall on the sword for the OUI to spare her the more serious offenses,” said Randolph Rice, the Maryland legal analyst and attorney who represents the family of slain mother of five Rachel Morin. “That would be a risky play for the defense.”
Read the amended verdict slip for Count 2:
GET REAL-TIME UPDATES DIRECTLY ON THE TRUE CRIME HUB
Still, he said, the common thinking is that defendants should avoid speaking to the media.
“I’m sure the Karen Read camp is feeling good right now,” he added. “Cautious optimism.”
Read the original verdict slip:
The top charge against Read, second-degree murder, could land her a life prison sentence if she’s convicted. Lesser charges include drunken driving, manslaughter and leaving a deadly accident.
WATCH: Karen Read recounts night of drinking at local bar in 2024 television interview
FOLLOW THE FOX TRUE CRIME TEAM ON X
The manslaughter charge also includes additional lesser charges that jurors could find her guilty of, including operating a motor vehicle under the influence of liquor, which carries a much lighter sentence and doesn’t include the homicide charge.
Read did not take the stand in her own defense but spoke to reporters outside court almost every day. After her mistrial last year, she sat for numerous news and documentary interviews and even invited a magazine writer to stay at her house for a weekend.
Murder defendant Karen Read speaks with reporters after leaving the courthouse in Dedham, Mass., June 6, 2025. (Richard Beetham for Fox News Digital)
SIGN UP TO GET THE TRUE CRIME NEWSLETTER
Special prosecutor Hank Brennan subpoenaed the unedited source material from reporters and played a handful of clips in court in front of the jury.
In one, which appeared to be related to what jurors had questions about, Read discussed spiking her own drinks in the hours before O’Keefe’s death because she didn’t think the bartender was making them strong enough.
“The drinks that they were pouring me at McCarthy’s, which was where I consumed most of the alcohol, was the weakest vodka tonic,” she said. “It tasted just like all soda water with lime, not that I need it to be a martini, but it might have a splash of vodka in it.”
Officer John O’Keefe (Boston Police Department)
Jurors asked the judge four questions Tuesday, many of them focused on the OUI charge.
- “What is the timeframe for the OUI charge? 12:45 or 5 a.m.?”
- “Are video clips of Karen’s interviews evidence?”
- “Does convicting guilty on a subcharge, for example offense 2 No. 5, convict the overall charge?”
- “If we find not guilty on two charges but can’t agree on one charge, is it a hung jury on all three charges or just one charge?”
Jurors failed to reach a verdict by the end of the day Tuesday. Deliberations resume Wednesday morning at 9 a.m. ET.
“I still think it’s good for her right now,” Rice told Fox News Digital. “Reading between the lines, I think they can’t find the intent needed for two counts and are trying to figure out the reckless component.”
Read faces up to life in prison if convicted on the most serious charge of second-degree murder. Some of the OUI-related charges also carry multi-year penalties, Edwards said.
Read the full article from Here
Pittsburg, PA
Carmen Mlodzinski Shows Pirates How Much They Need Him
PITTSBURGH — The Pittsburgh Pirates have looked for reliable bullpen arms and right-handed pitcher Carmen Mlodzinski displayed exactly what they need this season.
Mlodzinski earned a four-inning save for the Pirates in the 5-1 win over the Houston Astros in the series finale at Daikin Park on June 5, playing a big role in a massive road series win.
He allowed just one run and four hits, while posting three strikeouts, shutting down a strong Astros offense for an important win.
Mlodzinski has a new role with the Pirates, but it’s one they need more performances like this one to help out an area of weakness on their pitching staff.
How Mlodzinski Shut Down the Astros
It wasn’t a great start for Mlodzinski, who gave up a solo home run to Astros third baseman Isaac Paredes to lead off the bottom of the sixth inning.
Mlodzinski threw just his second pitch, a 94.6 mph four-seam fastball that was in the top part of the strike zone, which Paredes sent 101.3 mph off the bat and 356 feet into the left field seats.
The Pirates pitcher then got out of the inning quickly, with two ground outs and a fly out to end it.
Mlodzinski faced some adversity in the bottom of the seventh inning, giving up back-to-back singles with one out and faced Astros designated hitter Yordan Alvarez, who was 7-for-11 and drove in five RBI prior to this at-bat.
He managed to get Alvarez out on a sinker at the top of the zone, that Mlodzinski noted postgame as, “unintentional”, and then got a ground out to strand both runners.
Mlodzinski got a 1-2-3 eighth inning and then after giving up a single in the ninth inning, he got a double play to end the game on a backdoor slider.
it was an outing that Mlodzinski relied less on striking batters out and more on inducing weak contact and relying on his defense to get the job done.
He allowed just five hard hits on 12 batted ball events and saw some nice defensive plays made, including a diving catch from left fielder Jake Mangum and a good stop from third baseman Nick Gonzales and then the pick from first baseman Spencer Horwitz for a big out.
“Yeah it was fun,” Mlodzinski said postgame to DK Pittsburgh Sports. “Not ideal second pitch in. I just felt like trusting my stuff to go right after guys. We had a five-run lead, so the thought was, ‘Let’s be efficient.’ Kind of had an idea going in that I might be able to finish this one, so efficiency was definitely in the back of my head and no walks and the defense made some plays behind me. Just pitching to the game, in a sense.”
Mlodzinski Filling New Role Admirably for Pirates
It wasn’t an easy week prior to this game for Mlodzinski, who lost his spot in the starting rotation after two months, following the return of Jared Jones from inury.
Jones took Mlodzinski’s role and the Pirates placed Mlodzinski on the restricted list for the 9-3 win over the Minnesota Twins in the series finale at PNC Park on May 31.
Mlodzinski came back off the restricted list the following day and eventually resumed his role in the bullpen, where he followed Jones in this game.
Jones had thrown five scoreless innings in his second start back and Mlodzinski came through with a solid outing for himself.
This is a big moment for the Pirates, who now have Jones improving and able to take on a bigger workload each time he comes out, while Mlodzinski is an effective reliever that can fill that bulk role after Jones.
Pittsburgh managed to give the seven other bullpen arms a rest, crucially important as they take on the Atlanta Braves at Truist Park, a weekend road series against the team with the best record in baseball at 42-21.
The Pirates bullpen had just blown a 9-5 lead in the eighth inning the game prior, in a 11-9 loss to the Astros on June 3, which marked their 13th blown save of the season.
Pirates manager Don Kelly now has one of his best arms back in his bullpen and will want to see more outings like this one from Mlodzinski as the season continues, who will help the Pirates maintain leads and give them a chance to make comebacks as well.
“We’re gonna be smart with it,” Kelly said postgame to SportsNet Pittsburgh. “He’s extremely important to us, with the starts he’s made, coming out of the ‘pen, filling four.
“We’re going to smart about the usage with him and it keeps him stretched out. It’s not to say we might not see some shorter, but the ideal length is probably for him to get up there in pitches and to do exactly what he did tonight.”
Make sure to visit Pirates OnSI for the latest news, updates, interviews and insight on the Pittsburgh Pirates!
Follow
Connecticut
Early morning forecast for June 5
Maine
Most Mainers oppose AI data centers in their communities, poll finds
Just one day after Maine Gov. Janet Mills announced a new state council tasked with studying the impacts of AI data centers in Maine, a new poll suggests a majority of Mainers oppose their construction.
A new poll from UMass Lowell found that 72% of Mainers are against AI data centers being built in their communities.
That includes 51% who strongly oppose the projects, while only 28% support them.
In April, Mills vetoed a bill that would have paused all large-scale AI data center projects in the state, citing a planned facility in Jay.
Since then, several Maine communities have adopted moratoriums of their own. The latest is Scarborough, which enacted its moratorium earlier this week.
-
Indianapolis, IN1 minute ago
100+ free concerts in and around Indianapolis this summer
-
Pittsburg, PA4 minutes agoCarmen Mlodzinski Shows Pirates How Much They Need Him
-
Augusta, GA9 minutes agoDriver, passenger killed in crash on Gordon Highway
-
Washington, D.C16 minutes agoDC weather: Code Orange Air Quality Alert Friday, sunny and hot with highs in the 90s
-
Cleveland, OH19 minutes agoFBI launches Most Wanted Fraudsters list, establishes partnership in Ohio to fight fraud
-
Austin, TX24 minutes agoLeif Johnson Ford of Austin Brings Certified Vehicle Maintenance Directly to Customers Through Ford Mobile Service
-
Alabama31 minutes agoHow much will the special primary election cost Alabama?
-
Alaska34 minutes agoTrump administration to auction oil drilling rights in Alaska wildlife refuge