MONTPELIER — The Vermont State Police trooper who shot and killed a mentally ill man in Putney last July was justified in his use of fatal force, the Vermont Attorney General’s office said Tuesday afternoon, concluding its almost 12-month investigation into the shooting.
Attorney General Charity Clark, in a lengthy press release, outlined the events of July 6 and 7, 2025, which resulted in the shooting death of Scott Garvey, 55, by Vermont State Police Trooper Peter Romeo. Garvey was not armed with a firearm at the time he was shot; a metal pipe which he used to resemble a rifle, was found near his body.
Clark said she would not be filing criminal charges against Romeo, but expressed sympathy for the Garvey family, which she had met with earlier in the day.
“This event was a tragedy. We cannot imagine the pain that the Garvey family has endured and continues to experience, and our hearts go out to them during this time,” Clark said in a statement.
Shawn Garvey, 61, Scott Garvey’s older brother, said Tuesday the family was dissatisfied but not surprised with the conclusion of the lengthy investigation, which Garvey said basically blamed his brother for his death.
“Do you blame someone with cancer for their death? My brother had a mental illness,” he said.
He said he, his mother and his sister were not surprised at the investigation’s conclusion, and he pointed to the Vermont record of never charging officers in fatal shootings.
Since 1977, he said, there have been 48 cases where police killed someone, he said, and police have always been found justified.
“That 100 percent record is still intact,” he said.
He said the state police did not follow its own policies of de-escalation in such cases, and to seek alternatives to lethal force.
“My brother was by himself, he was sitting in his living room when they barged in,” he said of the police, who did have multiple warrants, including one for his arrest for criminal threatening and disorderly conduct.
Scott Garvey had only moved to Vermont a couple of days earlier from Memphis, Tenn., and he was going to live at the Putney Landing apartment complex, with his elderly mother, Judy. His sister Kara lived nearby in Dummerston.
Garvey had a long history of mental illness, including bi-polar disorder and schizophrenia, and according to earlier statements from his family, it included several psychiatric hospitalizations. The Garvey family said they brought him to Vermont to be closer to family and to get what they hoped would be better mental health care.
Since the shooting, the family has hired a Los Angeles law firm to sue the state of Vermont, and Shawn Garvey has been very active criticizing the state for its handling of the case. Just Monday, Judy Garvey, 85, conducted a vigil outside the Vermont State Police barracks in Westminster, drawing attention to her son’s death, and the lack of action by police.
The attorney general’s office, along with the Washington County State’s Attorney’s office because of the inherent conflict with the Windham County prosecutors’ office, had conducted separate investigations in the July 7, 2025, fatal shooting, with both investigations concluding the use of fatal force was justified and that there would be no criminal charges filed against Romeo.
The AG report included a lengthy narrative and timeline of July 6 and 7, with the focus on July 7, and what it said state police did to de-escalate the situation and bring Scott Garvey under control.
Police believed Garvey was carrying a weapon, which they believed was a rifle, and their efforts to get him to show them his hands were ignored.
Garvey was carrying a metal pipe, which police believed was the barrel of a rifle, and his brother said was his cane. Scott Garvey refused to show his hands to police as requested multiple times, during the fatal confrontation in his apartment, the report stated.
“Trooper Romeo ordered Mr. Garvey to show his hands three times and ordered Mr. Garvey to ‘put it down twice.” When asked what he had seen by Sergeant Hughes, Trooper Romeo responded “I don’t know.” Trooper Romeo again instructed Mr. Garvey to show his hands three times and said “don’t [expletive] do this s***” to Mr. Garvey.
Trooper Romeo again told Sergeant Hughes he was unsure whether the object was a gun when asked by Sergeant Hughes. Mr. Garvey responded by telling Trooper Romeo, “[expletive] you” and to “shoot me in the head,” multiple times while Trooper Romeo further commanded Mr. Garvey to show his hands an additional four times, then to “move,” and then to show his hands three more times.” the report stated.
Police said they spent more than four hours that day either talking to Garvey through the closed door of his apartment or on the telephone, and they were hopeful that he would allow police inside to make sure he didn’t have any weapons.
Police received a search warrant for Garvey’s apartment, as well as an arrest warrant for him and a warrant for an involuntary mental health hearing, and shortly afterward entered Garvey’s apartment with a key.
They encountered Garvey in a dimly-lit downstairs room and according to the timeline outlined by the attorney general’s office, five state troopers, lined up and tried to enter the apartment from both the front and back doors, after discussing various strategies.
Police said they agreed they couldn’t leave Garvey in the apartment complex at Putney Landing, because he had threatened his new neighbors, and told them that voices in his head were telling him to kill them.
Earlier in the day, a Vermont state trooper, along with the police’s embedded mental health clinician, went to apartment 103 to speak to Mr. Garvey, the report stated.
“They spoke with Mr. Garvey through his front door as he refused to open it. At times, Mr. Garvey indicated he had a firearm.
The embedded mental health clinician relayed that Mr. Garvey “said he had a gun” and “if he came out, you would have your guns drawn, and he would have his as well,’” the report stated.
Additional VSP officers arrived and after considering the evidence from the neighbors, determined that there was probable cause to arrest Mr. Garvey, the report stated.
At one point, Garvey had told a mental health screener that he wanted to be killed by the police.
The attorney general’s report did not answer the Garvey family’s questions and furthered its frustration, Shawn Garvey said.
Shawn Garvey said his family had for the past year tried to meet with Gov. Phil Scott to discuss state police training, and had never received a call back or any acknowledgment. He said his family wanted to work with the Vermont government on changes, so that shootings like that don’t happen again.
Garvey said he had worked with Rep. Michelle Bos-Lun, D-Westminster, on proposed legislation to address some of the family’s concerns.
Romeo, who at the time of the shooting had been with the state police for a year, was placed on paid administrative leave after the shooting. After a couple of weeks, he has been working at the Westminster barracks in administration for most of the past year and he is now returned to full duty. He is still assigned to the Westminster barracks.
“Under our policy in effect since 2018, troopers involved in critical incidents initially are placed on a period of administrative leave in the immediate aftermath of an incident, followed by a transition to administrative duty status while a case is under review. Upon a ruling by the Attorney General’s Office that a trooper’s use of deadly force was justified, the trooper returns to full duty. Trooper Romeo remains assigned to the Westminster Barracks,” Adam Silverman, a spokesman for the Vermont State Police wrote in an email Tuesday afternoon.
Contact Susan Smallheer at ssmallheer@reformer.com.
