Connect with us

Fitness

Are Resistance Bands or Dumbbells Better for Building Strength? A Physical Therapist Explains

Published

on

Are Resistance Bands or Dumbbells Better for Building Strength? A Physical Therapist Explains

There’s more than one way to get stronger. And, sometimes, less is more when it comes to building functional strength.

It all depends on your goals and your fitness level, a physical therapist explains. While some people will do best with heavy weights in their strength training plan, that doesn’t mean that’s the right approach for everyone.

For those who are focusing on building functional strength, as well as those recovering from an injury or navigating limited mobility, another option may be better.

Fitness Tip of the Day: How to Choose Between Dumbbells and Resistance Bands

You might assume that something with a constant level of weight (in the form of a dumbbell) is more effective for building strength.

And, while that is true sometimes, there are situations when resistance bands are actually the better choice, Erika Mundinger, an orthopedic clinical specialist and physical therapist, told TODAY.com recently.

Advertisement

When it comes to functional strength training, don’t overlook the value of resistance bands.

“Can you get toned, can you get strong, can you get a good workout with resistance bands and hit weight-loss goals? Absolutely,” she said.

Why It Matters

The difference between these two types of equipment comes down to the way they engage your muscles.

A dumbbell provides a isotonic resistance, which is a consistent, static level of resistance throughout the exercise, Mundinger explained. Meanwhile, because of the elasticity of resistance bands, the resistance they provide changes as you’re performing an exercise, which is known as isokinetic resistance.

“(When) I grab that resistance band to do a bicep curl toward me, that resistance is going to get harder on the top and easier as I bring my hand back down,” she said. “The more we are going through the motion, the resistance actually changes.”

Advertisement

But one approach isn’t inherently better than the other — they just strengthen your muscles differently.

So, to get the most effective workout, pay attention to what type of move you’re doing and what your overall goals are. That will help you select the best tool for the job.

How to Get Started

First, think about your fitness goals. If you’re interested in building functional strength, Mundinger recommended opting for resistance bands over dumbbells.

Using resistance bands naturally forces you to engage your stabilizing core muscles, Mundinger said, and the bands are especially helpful when coming back from an injury or working through a mobility limitation. People with lower back issues who can’t safely load their lumbar spine can still get a great strength workout by using resistance bands.

However, if you’re training for power or trying to add muscle mass, then you’ll need to progressively increase the weight you lift in the form of dumbbells, kettlebells or barbells, Mundinger said. That goal also requires tracking your progress, which is easier to do with weights than bands, she added.

Advertisement

But keep in mind that these two tools actually complement each other well. After using resistance bands, “when I go back to those big foundational moves like the bench press or the squat or the deadlift, I am stronger because I have those accessory muscles now engaging more,” Mundinger said.

TODAY’s Expert Tip of the Day series is all about simple strategies to make life a little easier. Every Monday through Friday, different qualified experts share their best advice on diet, fitness, heart health, mental wellness and more.

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Fitness

Mere minutes of daily vigorous exercise can cut your risk of 8 diseases | CNN

Published

on

Mere minutes of daily vigorous exercise can cut your risk of 8 diseases | CNN

Move more. Sit less. For many years, that’s been accepted guidance for people wanting to get healthier.

Now that message is getting refined, with a growing body of research suggesting that certain types of movements may be more beneficial than others when it comes to health benefits.

The intensity of your exercise may matter as well. A new study published in the European Heart Journal found that a small amount of vigorous activity may be linked to lower risk of eight different chronic diseases.

The findings raise questions about why intensity matters and how people can incorporate more intense exercise routines into everyday life. To better understand the study’s implications, I spoke with CNN wellness expert Dr. Leana Wen, an emergency physician and clinical associate professor at George Washington University. She previously served as Baltimore’s health commissioner.

Before beginning any new exercise program, consult your doctor. Stop immediately if you experience pain.

Advertisement

CNN: What did this study examine about exercise and its relationship to chronic disease?

Dr. Leana Wen: This investigation looked at how the intensity of physical activity is related to the risk of developing a range of chronic diseases. Researchers analyzed data from two very large groups in the UK Biobank, which is a long-term health study in the United Kingdom that tracks medical and lifestyle information from hundreds of thousands of participants. One group included about 96,000 people who wore wrist activity trackers that objectively measured their movement, and the other included more than 375,000 people who self-reported their activity.

The researchers followed participants over an average of about nine years and examined the development of eight conditions: major cardiovascular events, atrial fibrillation, type 2 diabetes, immune-related inflammatory diseases, fatty liver disease, chronic respiratory disease, chronic kidney disease and dementia, as well as overall mortality.

The key finding was that the proportion of activity done at vigorous intensity mattered. People who had more than about 4% of their total activity classified as vigorous had substantially lower risks of developing these conditions compared with people who had no vigorous activity at all. The numbers were stunning, with the participants having the following results:


  • 63% lower risk of dementia,

  • 60% lower risk of type 2 diabetes,

  • 48% lower risk of fatty liver disease,

  • 44% lower risk of chronic respiratory disease,

  • 41% lower risk of chronic kidney disease,

  • 39% lower risk of immune-mediated inflammatory diseases,

  • 31% lower risk of major cardiovascular events,

  • 29% lower risk of atrial fibrillation, and

  • 46% lower risk of death from any cause.

These results are amazing. Imagine if someone invented a medication that could reduce the risks of all these diseases at once — it would be very popular! Crucially, even people who exercised a lot still benefited if the proportion of time they spent doing vigorous physical activity was increased. Conversely, people who were relatively inactive also benefited from adding just a little bit of higher-intensity exercise to their daily routines.

CNN: What counts as “vigorous” physical activity?

Advertisement

Wen: Vigorous activity is generally defined as exercise that substantially raises your heart rate and breathing. A simple way to gauge it is the “talk test.” If you can speak comfortably in full sentences while exercising, you are likely in the low to moderate range. If you are so out of breath that you can only say a few words at a time, that is vigorous.

Running, cycling, lap swimming or climbing stairs quickly could count. But this also depends on people’s baseline fitness. For some individuals, taking longer strides with walking can be vigorous exercise. Others who are already fairly fit would need to do more. It’s also important to remember that vigorous activity doesn’t have to be in the context of a structured exercise plan. Short bursts of effort in daily life, such as rushing to catch a bus or carrying heavy groceries upstairs, can also qualify if they raise your heart rate and make you breathless.

CNN: Why might higher intensity exercise provide additional health benefits?

Wen: Higher intensity activity places greater demands on the body in a shorter period. This type of movement can improve cardiovascular fitness, increase insulin sensitivity and support metabolic health more efficiently than lower-intensity activity alone. Some studies have also linked vigorous activity with cognitive benefits.

Greater intensity may have distinct benefits across different organ systems. The researchers found that some conditions, such as immune-mediated inflammatory diseases, appeared to be more strongly linked to the intensity of activity than to the total amount. On the other hand, type 2 diabetes and kidney disease were influenced by both how much activity people did and how intense it was. Why this is the case is not yet known, but intensity appears to have a significant impact across diseases affecting multiple organs.

Advertisement

CNN: How much vigorous activity do people need?

Wen: The threshold for people seeing a benefit appears to be relatively low. The researchers found that once people reached more than about 4% of their total activity as vigorous, their risk of developing chronic diseases dropped substantially.

To put that into practical terms, we are not talking about professional athletes dedicating their lives to hours of high-intensity training. Everyday people may see benefits from just doing a few minutes of vigorous effort daily.

CNN: How can people realistically incorporate vigorous activity into their daily routines?

Wen: One helpful way to think practically is that vigorous activity does not have to happen all at once. It can be accumulated in short bursts throughout the day.

Advertisement

People can take the stairs instead of the elevator and do so at a faster pace than usual. When they are heading to work, they can add some speed walking. They can park farther away when grocery shopping and walk briskly while carrying groceries.

Structured exercise also can incorporate intervals where people alternate between moderate and more intense effort. If you’re swimming laps, you can warm up at a more leisurely pace, then do a few laps at a faster pace, then again at a leisurely pace and repeat. This suggestion applies to any other aerobic exercise: Aim for multiple intervals of at least 30 seconds to a minute each where your body is working hard enough that you feel noticeably out of breath.

CNN: What about someone who is older or has mobility issues?

Wen: Not everyone can or should engage in high-intensity activity in the same way. Vigorous activity is relative to that person’s baseline. For someone who is not used to exercise, even a short period of slightly faster walking or standing up repeatedly from a chair could be considered high intensity. And not everyone may be able to walk. In that case, some exercises from the chair can have aerobic benefits.

Individuals who have specific medical conditions should consult with their primary care clinicians before embarking on a new exercise routine. People with mobility issues also may benefit from working with a physical therapist who can help to tailor exercises appropriate to their specific situation.

Advertisement

CNN: What is the key takeaway for people trying to improve their health?

Wen: To me, the main takeaway from this study is that it’s not only how much total exercise you get but also how hard you push yourself that matters. And you don’t have to have a lot of high-intensity exercise: Adding just a little has substantial health benefits across a wide range of chronic health conditions.

At the same time, exercise needs be practical. People should look for opportunities to safely increase intensity in ways that fit their daily lives. The most effective approach to physical activity is a balanced one: Exercise regularly, incorporate more challenging activities when you can and build habits that are sustainable over time.

Get inspired by a weekly roundup on living well, made simple. Sign up for CNN’s Life, But Better newsletter for information and tools designed to improve your well-being.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Fitness

‘Not what the fitness industry is trying to sell you’: this is the one simple move everyone really needs to be doing, according to an exercise scientist

Published

on

‘Not what the fitness industry is trying to sell you’: this is the one simple move everyone really needs to be doing, according to an exercise scientist

Ask any exercise scientist what they would prescribe to someone serious about staying strong into their 50s and beyond, and the answer is rarely what you’d hope for — and certainly not what the fitness industry is currently trying to sell you.

It isn’t long sessions on one of the best under-desk treadmills or a stationary bike like the Peloton, nor the kind of machine-based exercises that isolate muscles without ever teaching them to work together.

Continue Reading

Fitness

Ellie Kildunne built her powerful body by keeping things simple – focusing on these fundamentals

Published

on

Ellie Kildunne built her powerful body by keeping things simple – focusing on these fundamentals

Despite being named World Rugby’s Women’s 15s Player of the Year, England rugby star Ellie Kildunne admitted on an episode of Just As Well that the ‘gym was never easy’. In order for her to feel her best, she sticks to a no-nonsense approach to training and nutrition that focuses on the fundamentals: consistent exercise and eating enough.

‘If I haven’t put the work in, if I’ve skipped reps, if I haven’t eaten the right amount for the game, I would feel anxious,’ she says in her cover interview for Women’s Health UK. ‘But I’ve never put myself in that position because I want to be the best.’

What does being the best mean to her? ‘I want to become world player of the year twice. That’s my focus. Anything else that happens is by the by.’

On her episode of Just As Well last year, she said strength training now makes her ‘feel powerful’, while she ‘hates running’ – but a lot of her training involves speed, agility and endurance practice for her time on the pitch. That mix of conditioning and strength means she has built a strong, fast and resilient body.

Speaking of her physical transformation, she admits her personal body image hasn’t always been positive: ‘Body image is such a mental challenge,’ she tells Women’s Health UK. ‘My body is what made me World Player of the Year… I’ve got to remind myself of that.’ Visibility helps too: ‘We’re in that transition phase… social media is starting to lean more towards athletic women… I see people that look like me now.’ Now, Ellie says when she sees a muscular person, she thinks, ‘Respect. Because I know exactly what goes into that.’

Advertisement

Headshot of Bridie Wilkins

As Women’s Health UK’s fitness director and a qualified Pilates and yoga instructor, Bridie Wilkins has been passionately reporting on exercise, health and nutrition since the start of her decade-long career in journalism.

After earning a first-class degree in journalism and NCTJ accreditation, she secured her first role at Look Magazine, where she launched the magazine’s health and fitness column, Look Fit, before going on to become Health and Fitness writer at HELLO!

Since, she has written for Stylist, Glamour, Cosmopolitan, Marie Claire, Elle, The Metro, Runner’s World and Red. Today, she oversees all fitness content across Women’s Health online and in print, spearheading leading cross-platform franchises, such as ‘Fit At Any Age’, which showcases the women proving that age is no barrier to exercise.

She has also represented the brand on BBC Radio London, plus various podcasts and Substacks – all with the aim to encourage more women to exercise and show them how. Outside of work, find her trying the latest Pilates studio, testing her VO2 max for fun (TY, Oura), or posting workouts on Instagram.   

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending