Connect with us

Movie Reviews

Film Review: 'Society of the Snow' is a Respectful Yet Intense Look at Tragedy and Survival

Published

on

Film Review: 'Society of the Snow' is a Respectful Yet Intense Look at Tragedy and Survival
Netflix

On the surface, another version of this story seemed unnecessary. After all, Alive already did it in a decent, if unremarkable manner. Hollywood had its swing, and many a project has referenced the events. So, seeing filmmaker J.A. Bayona opt to tackle it seemed odd. Then, I saw Society of the Snow. In a way, he’s been building his whole career to tell this story. Armed with all of his tools, he makes it engrossing and riveting, a true tribute to survival.

Society of the Snow is intense yet respectful. Survival and tragedy are hand in hand, but never fighting. There’s a bleakness here, but also hope. It’s a definite tightrope that Bayona and company walk. Thankfully, he was more than up to the challenge, making for a film that’s as much a large-scale epic as it is an intimate character piece.

Netflix

This is the true story of Uruguayan Air Force Flight 571. In 1972, the plane, which had been chartered to fly a rugby team back home to Chile, crashed. Ending up in the middle of the Andes, it’s a massacre. Out of the flight’s 45 passengers, only 29 survive the crash. After the accident, it seemingly only gets worse, as they’re trapped in a part of the world where there’s almost nothing to help in their survival. To live, extreme measures must be taken.

The survivors aren’t the only ones we’re following, as the narrator of the film is one of the deceased, in law student Numa Turcatti (Enzo Vogrincic). He had initially opted out of the flight, though we see him being ultimately convinced. Numa watches over the story, as the living players do their best to wait out the cold, until somewhat warmer weather allows two of them, Nando Parrado (Agustín Pardella) and Roberto Canessa (Matías Recalt), to attempt a ten day hike towards Chile. We know where things are going, but watching it unfold is largely captivating.

Netflix

The cast certainly gets your empathy, even if there aren’t really any standouts. Enzo Vogrincic is best in show, with an obvious ethereal quality to him. Agustín Pardella and Matías Recalt are solid as well, as you easily get engrossed in their journey. This is the opposity of something like Alive, where movie stars were the focus. Here, it’s the story and the honoring of the actual people. Supporting players in the film include the likes of Valentino Alonso, Esteban Bigliardi, Fernando Contigiani García, Agustín Della Corte, Rafael Federman, Simón Hempe, Esteban Kukuriczka, Felipe Otaño, Blas Polidori, Andy Pruss, Felipe Ramusio, Francisco Romero, Diego Vegezzi, and Tomás Wolf.

Director J.A. Bayona is so deeply invested in honoring the victims as well as the survivors, it leads to some very interesting choices. The script he co-wrote with Nicolás Casariego, Jaime Marques, and Bernat Vilaplana not only has a ghost essentially narrating from above, whenever anyone loses their life, they’re honored on screen. It’s incredibly respectful, while also being creative. At the same time, Bayona the director makes the crash absolutely thrilling. Armed with a strong score from composer Michael Giacchino, those moments work very well alongside the quieter ones. The pacing is a little slack, but this moves faster than you’d expect a two and a half hour movie to.

Society of the Snow is a tough movie to sit through at times, but it’s a rewarding one in the end. It’s probably not what you’re expecting, though that’s meant as a compliment. It zigs when other projects would have zagged, opting for emotion and respect, even reverence, as opposed to just thrills. It makes for a more complete motion picture, overall.

Advertisement

SCORE: ★★★

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Movie Reviews

MOVIE REVIEW: Robbie Williams’ rock star monkey business

Published

on

MOVIE REVIEW: Robbie Williams’ rock star monkey business

Better Man, Hollywood’s first musical biography where the pop star is depicted as a chimpanzee, works surprisingly well and has several incredible musical numbers

The Snapshot: Phenomenal music numbers bring needed fun, style and reasoning to Robbie Williams’ life story, seen through the eyes of an ape.

Better Man

7 out of 10

14A, 2hrs 15mins. Music Biography Fantasy.

Directed by Michael Gracey.

Starring Jonno Davies, Robbie Williams, Steve Pemberton, Raechelle Banno, Kate Mulvany and Alison Steadman.

Advertisement

Better Man, at the very least, is the best musical biography movie with the main character depicted as a CGI chimpanzee that I’ve ever seen.

Robbie Williams’ life story is a mix of (literal) money business along with great showmanship and outstanding scenes of Williams’ music. Unlike the common knowledge of most musical biopics, it’s also enjoyable to actually learn something new about the main character and their real history.

Director Michael Gracey (best known for 2017’s megahit The Greatest Showman) has conceptualized the life of English pop star Robbie Williams in an unusual way. While it follows the expected formula of a singer’s life story as so many movies do, it quite unexpectedly features Williams through his life as a monkey.

At first, the idea didn’t make much sense. What’s the point of changing Williams’ species? What could it possibly add to the story? And how would it influence the rest of the film?

The answer is revealed early, however, and wisely reinforces the main theme. The real Williams narrates the film, describing how he’s regularly felt “othered” and misunderstood as a person through his public life. 

Advertisement

So the story is imagined in this Hollywood film as Williams not just living with his private self-imposed isolation, but with an obvious public one as well. Being a chimpanzee, it’s slightly familiar in his possible humanity, but as also unfamiliar with his struggle to identify with others now shown as an interspecies conflict.

Fortunately, none of this takes away from the heart of Williams’ story rising as a music superstar, nor does it overshadow the spectacular musical numbers and sequences.

I reviewed Michael Gracey’s work on his well-known The Greatest Showman, and I stand by my heavy criticism of the bad script and songs that pandered to the audience. But here, he’s got much richer and clearer writing that feels more nuanced and less stylized, which is a better match for his glamorous directing style.

Read more here: Review – The Greatest Showman is far from great

Gracey got his start as the director of music videos, and that skill is amplified here in Better Man with several truly inventive and eye-popping songs. “Rock DJ”, celebrating a new record deal, is one of my favourite scenes I’ve seen from any movie in the last year. It’s a single take of song and dance mayhem that’s gratuitously fun.

Advertisement

If you can get over the barrier of seeing Williams as a large ape, there’s great songs and a compelling (if overlong) story to see here. 

It’s still over-the-top, but most of it is also a lot of fun – and a great intro to a musical talent we here in North America have maybe overlooked for too long.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

Movie Review: Teen Temptress, Femme Fatale, or Victim? “Nahir”

Published

on

Movie Review: Teen Temptress, Femme Fatale, or Victim? “Nahir”

“Nahir,” a brooding, glamourized and sexed-up account of a notorious Argentine murder case, is a mystery thriller that aims for engrossing and immersive that never falls short of quite watchable along the way.

Screenwriter Sofia Wilhelmi and director Hernán Gu

erschuny take great pains — with flashbacks and flashbacks within flashbacks — to show us several versions of the title character’s account of what happened the fateful night in which she allegedly killed her allegedly abusive lover.

We’re treated to backstory which dissects the aloof and mysterious teen beauty who either planned a crime of lover’s revenge, carried it out and took some pains to cover up her involvement, or didn’t. Not in the ways the earliest versions of her account of that fateful night played out, anyway.

Valentina Zenera plays Nahir as a vain beauty confident in her allure, even at her (seen in a flashback) quinceañera. Nahir dreams of riding the premiere float at Gualeguaychú’s famed carnival parade and riding that to fame as a model.

Not that she says much of this out loud. Nahir is depicted as inscrutable, controlled and controlling. All the boys fancy her and no one gets more of her attention, and manipulation, than 20 year-old Federico (Simon Hempe).

Advertisement

Nahir says they’re broken up. Then they’re together. As the narrative jumps back and forth from “before the crime” (in Spanish with English subtitles) to “after the crime,” we see both their torrid affair — “torrid” at least in his eyes — and her “No, we weren’t dating” way of describing it to her friends and eventually to the cops.

Because one night, Federico rides his motorbike to his doom.

We see how Nahir takes the “news” of his death. “Poker-faced” barely does that reaction justice. We watch the early questioning, the tear she tries to summon up or fake with a tissue.

And we learn that Nahir’s adored and adoring Dad (César Bordón) is a pistol-packing police officer. If there’s one thing that’s become accepted wisdom the world over in recent years, it’s the idea that police in most any country all consider themselves experts in one thing — knowing what they can get away with, and how.

When Dad says “I’ll get you out of here…I’m working on it. You’ll be home by New Year’s,” Nahir believes it. Is it because of what she knows, or what she knows that he knows?

Advertisement

As we see Nahir’s (perhaps) ex-beauty queen mother (Mónica Antonópulos) primp and prep her for a pageant and for a TV prison interview, we pick up on the dynamic of the household and the narcissism of our heroine.

“No crying,” Mom insists before her interrogation. Or did she? Federico’s come-ons are punctuated with a macho “I get anything I want.” Dad wasn’t shy about showing his pistol to would-be stalkers who stare at Nahir in crowds. His icy “princesa” never betrays any emotion at any of this.

The court case reveals more than just the lovers’ exchanged “love of my life” texts. Protesters demand “justice” for Federico, but witnesses paint a more complicated picture of their on-and-off romance. And as her situation isn’t quickly resolved — one way or the other — and her “story” changes, we wonder what really happened.

I like the way the story’s jumps backwards and forwards in time to wrongfoot the viewer. We’re given just enough information to decide on guilt or innocence, and then new information is brought to light. Think again.

Now on Amazon Prime, “Nahir” was longer when it played in Argentina, and reviews of this “true” story there weren’t the best. Perhaps it’s tighter, as the Prime cut of the film is 14 minutes shorter. Or perhaps Argentines are more invested in the story and uninterested in the doubts “Nahir” suggests.

Advertisement

Zenere, underplaying in ways that hint at the character’s similarities to Amanda Knox — accused because she underreacts to news of a murder — makes her character believably guilty or possibly innocent. And whatever verdict, she ensures the narcissistic Nahir is never seen with a hair out of place or eye shadow and earrings that aren’t perfectly matched, even behind bars.

Rating: TV-16, violence, sex, profanity

Cast: Valentina Zenere, Simon Hempe, Mónica Antonópulos and César Bordón

Credits: Directed by Hernán Guerschuny, scripted by Sofia Wilhelmi. An MGM release on Amazon Prime.

Running time: 1:48

Advertisement

About Roger Moore

Movie Critic, formerly with McClatchy-Tribune News Service, Orlando Sentinel, published in Spin Magazine, The World and now published here, Orlando Magazine, Autoweek Magazine

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

Red Rooms – Review | Psychological Serial Killer Thriller | Heaven of Horror

Published

on

Red Rooms – Review | Psychological Serial Killer Thriller | Heaven of Horror

Watch Red Rooms on Shudder

This new dark psychological thriller is written and directed by Pascal Plante, who previously made Les faux tatouages (2017) and Nadia, Butterfly (2020). While I feel I have to describe Red Rooms as slow-burn, it really doesn’t feel like a slow movie.

It packs a real punch. Just in a different way!

Every cast member in this movie delivers a strong performance, but for me, it’s still very much about Juliette Gariépy as Kelly-Anne. She’s the character we experience everything through. Even in long scenes, she’s always in the background. Watching and evaluating everything.

This is a Canadian movie (org. title: Les chambres rouges) which means the trial setting is different from the typical US setting. Instead, it’s more like the UK and French (for obvious reasons) trials you may have seen. However, this is another element that works perfectly.

Red Rooms premiered at the Karlovy Vary International Film Festival. After its premiere, it went on to screen at several leading global film festivals. Including the Fantasia Film Festival, Busan International Film Festival, and the BFI London Film Festival.

Advertisement

Red Rooms begins Streaming On Shudder on January 14, 2025.

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending