Connect with us

Education

Opinion | State’s ‘Misguided Takeover’ of Houston Schools

Published

on

Opinion | State’s ‘Misguided Takeover’ of Houston Schools

To the Editor:

Re “Anger Rises in Houston Over the State’s Schools Takeover” (news article, Aug. 13):

The politically motivated and downright misguided takeover of the Houston Independent School District sets a deplorable example for struggling school districts nationwide.

The solution to poorly performing schools should not be to close libraries and force misbehaving students to watch videos in those repurposed spaces. It should be to expand libraries into centers of learning and to recruit dynamic educators who can, through their passion and skills, engage students who are acting out for a reason: because they’ve been underserved and shortchanged.

To place them in closed libraries and force them to watch videos of their classes only confirms for those students that they’re troublemakers and that reading lacks value. A punitive approach will not work.

Advertisement

Superintendent Mike Miles, a former Army ranger “who has no official certification,” is better suited to run an Army base, not schools. His plan to compensate teachers for improved scores on standardized tests is also imprudent, for such tests provide a limited measure of students’ aptitude, are often biased and narrow the scope of classroom instruction.

Assessment of student understanding and skills must be more comprehensive, using a wider range of measures, such as performance-based and authentic evaluations that mirror real-life situations.

The new state-run administration’s plan to shift “time-consuming tasks” is also unwise. Staff members who do not teach classes should not be the ones grading work or writing lesson plans. Teachers are the only ones equipped to grade work and write lesson plans. It’s part of their job, however laborious those tasks may be.

Gov. Greg Abbott’s takeover of the Houston Independent School District may be radical, but it’s clearly political and inequitable. And it won’t work.

Gary J. Whitehead
Tenafly, N.J.
The writer is a high school English teacher.

Advertisement

To the Editor:

Mike Miles, the new superintendent of schools, plans to address the achievement gaps between Houston students and those in the rest of the state by focusing on improving reading and math scores. His strategy includes the elimination of a number of school libraries. If that isn’t counterintuitive, I’m not sure what is!

Perhaps instead of prioritizing standardized test scores, Mr. Miles should spend a few minutes talking to one of the librarians he is laying off about how they instill a love of reading in children.

Eve Wolfsohn
New York
The writer is a school librarian.

To the Editor:

Advertisement

Two things stand out in this article.

First, far-right politicians in Texas have decided that if you can’t remove books from school libraries, you can close the libraries to achieve the same result.

Second, far-right politicians preach parental empowerment and control of schools until that empowerment conflicts with the far-right agenda. In this case the governor replaced the elected school board and administrators who didn’t support his conservative vision of education.

Greg Vouros
Seattle

To the Editor:

Advertisement

I am a proud liberal Democrat and one of those Harvard Law School graduates Republicans love to hate. Yet as much as I think Donald Trump deserves to spend significant jail time, I harbor serious doubts about what it will take to get there. The country and Mr. Trump himself might be best served by a plea deal, if that is even possible.

The country badly needs to be rid of Mr. Trump and Trumpism. The Republican Party badly needs a restart. And even Mr. Trump must now realize the likelihood that one of the impending trials could well result in jail time. There’s nothing like the thought of a jail cell to focus the mind.

We can expect years of little else in the press — years of appeals and most likely an appeal to a Republican-dominated Supreme Court on the meaning of free speech. America needs less of this, not more.

Is a plea deal possible? Normally prosecutors would insist on an admission of guilt. But we could settle for less to be rid of this constant and continual stain on our national and international reputation as well as a divided public and a paralyzed national politics.

I would settle for an admission of responsibility for inappropriate actions and inactions, a bar from seeking political office, and home confinement. It’s not adequate, but it could be enough. Otherwise, the national consensus could crack, if it has not already done so, and that’s not good for anyone.

Advertisement

It’s a divisive and a dangerous time and needs to end. This could be the quickest way.

David Love
Newton Centre, Mass.

To the Editor:

We’ve all heard the term ambulance chasers, referring to unsavory personal injury lawyers who hover at accident scenes waiting to find victims to represent at the worst possible times. Apparently a similar occurrence is happening in Lahaina on the island of Maui, with a slight difference. Instead of lawyers, repugnant realtors and developers are drooling over the possible opportunity to buy property from victims of the tragic firestorm that reduced this historic town to ashes.

Advertisement

Is it any wonder that the locals are not asking but demanding that these leeches leave? If these situations aren’t nauseating and cruel, what is? With more than 100 dead and more than a thousand still missing, the prediction by some bureaucrats that Lahaina can be rebuilt in six months is downright laughable, if not so sad.

Donate to the proper charities and then leave the folks alone, to search for the living and to grieve the dead, as they live one day at a time. I would imagine that the word rebuild is at this juncture far from residents’ minds. Lahaina Strong.

Bruce G. Levitta
Phoenix
The writer is a former police investigator on the island of Oahu.

Guiding clients on big mountains, and especially K2, almost has a “Lord of the Flies” meets “Bonfire of the Vanities” edge to it.

It’s one thing for clients to accept the risks and their fate if things go sideways, but it’s another when the people who get them there are literally stepped over as they lie dying and sacrificed so that the client’s prized summit can be another notch in their belt.

Advertisement

Jon Heshka
Kamloops, British Columbia
The writer is an associate professor and co-chair of the adventure studies department at Thompson Rivers University.

To the Editor:

Re “The Fleeting Magic of Summer Camp,” by Josephine Sittenfeld (Opinion guest essay, Aug. 13):

Ms. Sittenfeld’s camp photographs made me remember the stinky sneakers, the swimming hole, picnics in a country graveyard, the bottle of ketchup consumed by six omnivores at every table during every meal, the smell of canvas tents, the sway of my bunk bed, 70 years later.

What a treat! Thank you, Ms. Sittenfeld.

Advertisement

Eleanor Sterling
Santa Barbara, Calif.

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Education

Video: Protesters Scuffle With Police During Pomona College Commencement

Published

on

Video: Protesters Scuffle With Police During Pomona College Commencement

new video loaded: Protesters Scuffle With Police During Pomona College Commencement

transcript

transcript

Protesters Scuffle With Police During Pomona College Commencement

Pro-Palestinian demonstrators tried to block access to Pomona College’s graduation ceremony on Sunday.

[chanting in call and response] Not another nickel, not another dime. No more money for Israel’s crime. Resistance is justified when people are occupied.

Advertisement

Recent episodes in U.S.

Continue Reading

Education

Video: Police Use Pepper Spray on Protesters on G.W.U.’s Campus

Published

on

Video: Police Use Pepper Spray on Protesters on G.W.U.’s Campus

new video loaded: Police Use Pepper Spray on Protesters on G.W.U.’s Campus

transcript

transcript

Police Use Pepper Spray on Protesters on G.W.U.’s Campus

Police officers arrested 33 pro-Palestinian protesters and cleared a tent encampment on the campus of George Washingon University.

“The Metropolitan Police Department. If you are currently on George Washington University property, you are in violation of D.C. Code 22-3302, unlawful entry on property.” “Back up, dude, back up. You’re going to get locked up tonight — back up.” “Free, free Palestine.” “What the [expletive] are you doing?” [expletives] “I can’t stop — [expletives].”

Advertisement

Recent episodes in Israel-Hamas War

Continue Reading

Education

How Counterprotesters at U.C.L.A. Provoked Violence, Unchecked for Hours

Published

on

How Counterprotesters at U.C.L.A. Provoked Violence, Unchecked for Hours

A satellite image of the UCLA campus.

On Tuesday night, violence erupted at an encampment that pro-Palestinian protesters had set up on April 25.

The image is annotated to show the extent of the pro-Palestinian encampment, which takes up the width of the plaza between Powell Library and Royce Hall.

Advertisement

The clashes began after counterprotesters tried to dismantle the encampment’s barricade. Pro-Palestinian protesters rushed to rebuild it, and violence ensued.

Arrows denote pro-Israeli counterprotesters moving towards the barricade at the edge of the encampment. Arrows show pro-Palestinian counterprotesters moving up against the same barricade.

Police arrived hours later, but they did not intervene immediately.

Advertisement

An arrow denotes police arriving from the same direction as the counterprotesters and moving towards the barricade.

A New York Times examination of more than 100 videos from clashes at the University of California, Los Angeles, found that violence ebbed and flowed for nearly five hours, mostly with little or no police intervention. The violence had been instigated by dozens of people who are seen in videos counterprotesting the encampment.

Advertisement

The videos showed counterprotesters attacking students in the pro-Palestinian encampment for several hours, including beating them with sticks, using chemical sprays and launching fireworks as weapons. As of Friday, no arrests had been made in connection with the attack.

To build a timeline of the events that night, The Times analyzed two livestreams, along with social media videos captured by journalists and witnesses.

The melee began when a group of counterprotesters started tearing away metal barriers that had been in place to cordon off pro-Palestinian protesters. Hours earlier, U.C.L.A. officials had declared the encampment illegal.

Security personnel hired by the university are seen in yellow vests standing to the side throughout the incident. A university spokesperson declined to comment on the security staff’s response.

Mel Buer/The Real News Network

Advertisement

It is not clear how the counterprotest was organized or what allegiances people committing the violence had. The videos show many of the counterprotesters were wearing pro-Israel slogans on their clothing. Some counterprotesters blared music, including Israel’s national anthem, a Hebrew children’s song and “Harbu Darbu,” an Israeli song about the Israel Defense Forces’ campaign in Gaza.

As counterprotesters tossed away metal barricades, one of them was seen trying to strike a person near the encampment, and another threw a piece of wood into it — some of the first signs of violence.

Attacks on the encampment continued for nearly three hours before police arrived.

Counterprotesters shot fireworks toward the encampment at least six times, according to videos analyzed by The Times. One of them went off inside, causing protesters to scream. Another exploded at the edge of the encampment. One was thrown in the direction of a group of protesters who were carrying an injured person out of the encampment.

Advertisement

Mel Buer/The Real News Network

Some counterprotesters sprayed chemicals both into the encampment and directly at people’s faces.

Sean Beckner-Carmitchel via Reuters

Advertisement

At times, counterprotesters swarmed individuals — sometimes a group descended on a single person. They could be seen punching, kicking and attacking people with makeshift weapons, including sticks, traffic cones and wooden boards.

StringersHub via Associated Press, Sergio Olmos/Calmatters

In one video, protesters sheltering inside the encampment can be heard yelling, “Do not engage! Hold the line!”

In some instances, protesters in the encampment are seen fighting back, using chemical spray on counterprotesters trying to tear down barricades or swiping at them with sticks.

Advertisement

Except for a brief attempt to capture a loudspeaker used by counterprotesters, and water bottles being tossed out of the encampment, none of the videos analyzed by The Times show any clear instance of encampment protesters initiating confrontations with counterprotesters beyond defending the barricades.

Shortly before 1 a.m. — more than two hours after the violence erupted — a spokesperson with the mayor’s office posted a statement that said U.C.L.A officials had called the Los Angeles Police Department for help and they were responding “immediately.”

Officers from a separate law enforcement agency — the California Highway Patrol — began assembling nearby, at about 1:45 a.m. Riot police with the L.A.P.D. joined them a few minutes later. Counterprotesters applauded their arrival, chanting “U.S.A., U.S.A., U.S.A.!”

Just four minutes after the officers arrived, counterprotesters attacked a man standing dozens of feet from the officers.

Twenty minutes after police arrive, a video shows a counterprotester spraying a chemical toward the encampment during a scuffle over a metal barricade. Another counterprotester can be seen punching someone in the head near the encampment after swinging a plank at barricades.

Advertisement

Fifteen minutes later, while those in the encampment chanted “Free, free Palestine,” counterprotesters organized a rush toward the barricades. During the rush, a counterprotester pulls away a metal barricade from a woman, yelling “You stand no chance, old lady.”

Throughout the intermittent violence, officers were captured on video standing about 300 feet away from the area for roughly an hour, without stepping in.

It was not until 2:42 a.m. that officers began to move toward the encampment, after which counterprotesters dispersed and the night’s violence between the two camps mostly subsided.

The L.A.P.D. and the California Highway Patrol did not answer questions from The Times about their responses on Tuesday night, deferring to U.C.L.A.

While declining to answer specific questions, a university spokesperson provided a statement to The Times from Mary Osako, U.C.L.A.’s vice chancellor of strategic communications: “We are carefully examining our security processes from that night and are grateful to U.C. President Michael Drake for also calling for an investigation. We are grateful that the fire department and medical personnel were on the scene that night.”

Advertisement

L.A.P.D. officers were seen putting on protective gear and walking toward the barricade around 2:50 a.m. They stood in between the encampment and the counterprotest group, and the counterprotesters began dispersing.

While police continued to stand outside the encampment, a video filmed at 3:32 a.m. shows a man who was walking away from the scene being attacked by a counterprotester, then dragged and pummeled by others. An editor at the U.C.L.A. student newspaper, the Daily Bruin, told The Times the man was a journalist at the paper, and that they were walking with other student journalists who had been covering the violence. The editor said she had also been punched and sprayed in the eyes with a chemical.

On Wednesday, U.C.L.A.’s chancellor, Gene Block, issued a statement calling the actions by “instigators” who attacked the encampment unacceptable. A spokesperson for California Gov. Gavin Newsom criticized campus law enforcement’s delayed response and said it demands answers.

Los Angeles Jewish and Muslim organizations also condemned the attacks. Hussam Ayloush, the director of the Greater Los Angeles Area office of the Council on American-Islamic Relations, called on the California attorney general to investigate the lack of police response. The Jewish Federation Los Angeles blamed U.C.L.A. officials for creating an unsafe environment over months and said the officials had “been systemically slow to respond when law enforcement is desperately needed.”

Fifteen people were reportedly injured in the attack, according to a letter sent by the president of the University of California system to the board of regents.

Advertisement

The night after the attack began, law enforcement warned pro-Palestinian demonstrators to leave the encampment or be arrested. By early Thursday morning, police had dismantled the encampment and arrested more than 200 people from the encampment.

Continue Reading

Trending