West Virginia voters will play a heavy role in shaping the state Supreme Court, which has two of five seats on the ballot.

Although this is a primary election for many other races, it’s the final say-so for these two seats on the state’s highest court.

One election is for an unexpired term to fill the seat formerly held by Justice Beth Walker, who retired last year. The term expires in 2028. Two candidates are running for this seat.

The other election is for an unexpired term to fill the seat formerly held by Justice Tim Armstead, who died last year. Candidates are running to fill out the term that expires in 2032. Five candidates are vying to fill this seat.

Former Walker seat, two years on term

Thomas Ewing was appointed by Gov. Patrick Morrisey to fill the unexpired term until the election.

“What I’ve done is public record,” he said on MetroNews Talkline.

“I’m not running from that. It’s sort of my resume or my statement to the voters. I’ve demonstrated to you how I’ll do this job.”

Ewing served as circuit court judge in Fayette County for eight years before being appointed to the Supreme Court last year.

As a circuit judge, he presided over the Fayette County Adult Treatment Court. He also established and presided over several other programs, including the Fayette County Family Treatment Court, the Fayette County Teen Court and the Fayette County Truancy Diversion Program.

“I think it’s important to continue to have someone with circuit court experience on the Supreme Court,” he said.

He grew up in Hico and is a graduate of Midland Trail High School. He graduated college from Glenville State, where he was captain of the basketball team, and then the West Virginia University College of Law.

From 2004 until 2018, he practiced law with the firm Kay, Casto & Chaney.

“For me, my personal integrity matters, and if you don’t have personal integrity, if you don’t hold yourself personally accountable, then I don’t see how you can uphold the integrity of the judiciary,” he said.

Bill Flanigan is the other challenger for the seat vacated by Walker.

Flanigan is a Wheeling attorney and a Republican member of the West Virginia House of Delegates representing Ohio County. The Supreme Court race is nonpartisan.

“What I tried to do as a legislator and what I want to do on the court is that our laws should be written in a way that are clear and precise, easily applied and within the purviews of the Constitution as it was originally constructed,” he said on Talkline.

He was first appointed to the House of Delegates in 2016 as a Republican representing Monongalia County, but a cancer diagnosis at that time prevented him from seeking election to the seat.

Flanigan and his family moved from Monongalia County to Ohio County so his son could participate in a program for students with dyslexia. After moving to Ohio County, Flanigan was elected to the House in 2024 and currently serves that district.

Flanigan earned his bachelor’s degree from Salem Teikyo University and his law degree from the West Virginia University College of Law.

“I fell in love with the Constitution. I fell in love with the law — how it affects us, what it does for us and how it can apply to each of us as citizens,” he said.

Former Armstead seat, six years on term

Gerald Titus III was appointed by the governor to fill the unexpired term until the election.

“For me, courts, judges should not legislate, should not wade into policy issues — they should let those leaders lead and simply apply the law,” he said on Talkline.

“My job is very simple. It doesn’t mean it’s easy. There are times that it’s weighty and challenging. But for our government to function properly, I think the court plays a vital but limited role.”

Titus, a Charleston attorney, has 22 years of experience in law practice.

Before his appointment to the Supreme Court, he was an attorney with the Charleston-based law firm Spilman Thomas and Battle

He previously served as an assistant U.S. Attorney for the Southern District of West Virginia, where he worked in the Violent Crime Division.

He is a graduate of Washington and Lee University in Virginia, where he earned both a bachelor’s degree in politics and American history and his law degree.

“I just found myself in a place where I wanted to do more, where I wanted to put that experience to use. I’m in the absolute prime of my legal career. I feel like I have the most to give now as I ever will,” he said.

Laura Faircloth is a veteran attorney who has served as a circuit judge in the Eastern Panhandle for nearly a decade.

She was first elected in 2016 to the 23rd Judicial Circuit covering Berkeley, Jefferson, and Morgan counties and then was elected in 2024 to the newly created 27th Judicial Circuit, which serves Berkeley and Morgan counties.

“I am the only independent registered to run in this contested election in division one. I’m also the only woman who is running,” Faircloth said on Talkline, referring to her personal voter registration.

“I’m not a good old boy, and I don’t subscribe to backroom politics, which is where deals are made oftentimes. That’s never going to happen in my courtroom, and it will not happen if I’m a justice on the Supreme Court of West Virginia.”

Before her time on the bench, she led her own six-person law firm in Martinsburg.

She earned a bachelor’s degree in political science from Shepherd University and got her law degree from the WVU College of Law.

“We are like umpires in a baseball game: We call fouls, strikes and balls. We call outs and safe. And that’s it. And to do anything more is trying to assume a role that we are not permitted to assume because the sanctity of the judiciary is not to allow that,” she said.

Todd Kirby is is a circuit judge in Raleigh County and a former Republican member of the House of Delegates.

In the House, he represented the 44th District in Raleigh County starting in 2023.

He was appointed to the bench by then-Gov. Jim Justice in July 2024 to fill a vacancy and successfully won election to the seat that same year.

“There’s a long history of West Virginia Supreme Court justices having served in the Legislature,” Kirby said on Talkline.

Earlier this year, Kirby appeared at a Health Freedom Day rally at the West Virginia Legislature that focused on school vaccination requirements. But he said his appearance was an expression of his principles and should not be interpreted as him taking a stance on specific cases that might come before the court.

Kirby recused himself from a school vaccine exemptions case in Raleigh Circuit Court last year because of votes he had taken at the Legislature.

Kirby opened his own law practice in Beckley in 2011. His career has been heavily focused on child welfare, including serving as an assistant prosecuting attorney in Raleigh County handling child abuse and neglect cases. He has also worked as a guardian ad litem and as an attorney representing foster parents and respondent parents.

He graduated from Marshall University and got his law degree from Liberty University.

“My area of expertise has been the law and of course now as a circuit court judge. I feel like I have the experience as an assistant prosecutor, as an attorney for respondent parents, for foster kids, as guardian ad litem, my time on the House Judiciary Committee,” he said.

“My conservative credentials and my background, I feel like I’m the right candidate for the state at this time in its history.”

H.L. “Kirk” Kirkpatrick  is a senior status judge and a long-time circuit court judge in Raleigh County with more than 30 years of experience on the bench.

“I decided I had plenty of life in me and I could serve West Virginia by serving on the Supreme Court,” Kirkpatrick said on Talkline.

He was first appointed to the bench in Raleigh County by then-Gov. Gaston Caperton in 1995 and was then elected in 1996. He served as the chief judge of the Raleigh County circuit and retired in December 2024.

“I look at myself as a referee,” Kirkpatrick said. “We are required to be impartial and be fair and apply the law in a fair manner.”

Kirkpatrick administered the Raleigh County juvenile drug court for 10 years. He also served on the state Judicial Investigation Commission, which is responsible for enforcing the Code of Judicial Conduct for judges and justices.

After retirement, he was appointed as a senior status judge, a role that allows him to be recalled for temporary assignments.

That way, he presided over the high-profile murder trial of Natalie Cochran, a pharmacist convicted of using insulin to fatally poison her husband. He also filled a vacancy on the Fayette County Circuit Court when Thomas Ewing was appointed to the Supreme Court.

He is a graduate of the University of Kentucky and earned his law degree from West Virginia University.

“My strong suit is my experience,” Kirkpatrick said. “I’ve presided over every conceivable type of trial and case from speeding ticket appeals to murder trials. I’ve handled just about anything that could come down the pike.”

Martin “Red Hat” Sheehan is a veteran Wheeling attorney with 45 years in the legal profession, during which he says he has done a little bit of everything.

Sheehan is a former assistant U.S. attorney and federal prosecutor. He has been in private practice since 1990.

He is the former chairman of the Ohio County Republican Executive Committee and has previously run for a seat in the West Virginia House of Delegates as a Republican.

Sheehan, speaking on Talkline, said he has been motivated by a backlog in the judicial system.

“I think that’s the big issue for me in this particular campaign is to try to get action by the court in a more timely way,” Sheehan said.

“The court loses its moral authority to help the circuit courts to manage their caseloads as well by not being able to take care of its own house.”

Sheehan notably sued the West Virginia Judicial Investigations Commission in federal court, challenging a rule that prevents judicial candidates from speaking publicly about issues likely to come before the court. He argued the rule is unconstitutional.

“I think I’m dedicated to trying to get something done,” he said. “The problem is it’s very hard for the judges to campaign. I’ve also brought suit, somewhat unsuccessfully at this time, to declare a couple of cannons in the judicial code unconstitutional because they limit the ability to have contact with the public as candidates.

“What you’ll see is, everybody running for the Supreme Court says they’re people of integrity, people of experience, whatever, and nobody is talking about any serious issues about how to fix things at the court.”

Sheehan got his bachelor’s degree from Tufts University and his law degree from Duquesne.

While he appears with the nickname “Red Hat” on the ballot, he was previously known on ballots as “Red Shoes” because of his choice of flamboyant footwear.