Seattle woman paralyzed by car crash from alleged police chase denied new trial

SEATTLE — Heartbreak for a neighborhood girl who was severely injured throughout an alleged police pursuit after she was denied one other trial from King County.

Choose Michael J. Scott denied a brand new trial for Channary Har throughout a listening to on the King County Courthouse on Friday. Choose Scott stated he discovered no new proof in Har’s crew’s declare.

In 2006, Channary Har was in a automobile crash close to Seward Park that left her paralyzed. Har sued the Metropolis of Seattle, alleging officers ought to have by no means initiated a chase which result in a automobile crash. The choose dominated the fault belonged to the driving force of the automobile that crashed, Omar Tammam.

Har’s crew additionally believes that the officer concerned, Aaron Grant, lied beneath oath on account of stress from metropolis lawyer’s workplace, in response to an article from The Information Tribune. Grant died by suicide two years after leaving the Seattle Police Division and going to Lakewood Police Division. The article alleges he felt like he had lied beneath oath about what occurred on Might 18, 2006.

“So, I don’t know the way a lot clearer proof there may very well be from any individual that stated they didn’t inform the reality on a crucial difficulty throughout a trial,” Peterson stated.

“There has not been a good trial. There was no justice for Channery,” Har’s lawyer Colleen Durkin Peterson stated.

Attorneys representing the Metropolis of Seattle stood agency on their authentic case.

“Tammam, the driving force on the time he was driving down Seward Park, couldn’t have heard the siren,” one lawyer stated.

The town additionally argued that Grant’s inconsistent ideas after the trial didn’t imply they or town dedicated perjury.

“Did something that he stated exterior the courtroom quantity to fraud? As conduct or misrepresentation and meet the burden of proof that Har has submit? Not,” she stated.

Throughout our conversations previous to the listening to, Har says the final 17 years have been extremely laborious.

“How would I describe it? It’s been hell,” Har stated.

“And it’s fixed, you recognize. Each time you’re feeling you’re getting a break, right here comes one thing else. And right here you might be within the hospital once more,” Har stated.

“And the results of that’s Channery is a quadriplegic,” Peterson stated.

Whereas Friday’s listening to didn’t go the best way they needed, Peterson says they plan to proceed to struggle for a brand new trial for Har.

“Proper now, simply centered on Channery has a proper for the reality to be instructed in her trial. It was not,” Peterson stated.

©2023 Cox Media Group