Opinion | CNN Visits San Francisco

Received robbed. Once more. @jasonkCNN & I have been at metropolis corridor in San Francisco to do an interview for @CNN. We had safety to look at our rental automobile + crew automobile. Thieves did this in beneath 4 seconds. Safety stopped the jerks from stealing different luggage. However seriously- that is ridiculous

The CNN correspondent added that she was headed to the airport to try to board a flight “with out ID or passport since they have been each stolen” and famous:

BTW; @jasonkCNN and I are in San Francisco doing a narrative about voter discontent bc of rampant road crime #irony

On second thought maybe it’s not ironic given how typically such crimes happen within the Metropolis by the Bay. The exact same day, expertise entrepreneur Snehal Antani tweeted:

A teammate visiting San Francisco for an offsite referred to as me frantically final night time. After dinner at Fisherman’s Wharf they got here again to a smashed automobile window and a couple of stolen backpacks. $10K in gear misplaced, passports gone, and so forth. #SanFrancisco…

So now I want to incorporate a pre-visit safety temporary to individuals touring San Francisco. It is a huge motive I’m hesitant to open an workplace within the metropolis versus protecting a distant group and sometimes assembly up at a location to whiteboard… And my teammates can be scarred perpetually, being robbed hits you at your core, particularly when it’s hundreds of {dollars} of loss. There isn’t any downtown restoration with out an aggressive push for security @LondonBreed

London Breed is San Francisco’s mayor. Interesting to the mayor to make sure secure streets after such an incident would appear to be an inexpensive response by Mr. Antani. However after all the town’s flight from affordable public discourse on crime and policing is a giant motive such crimes have change into so widespread. As a result of it’s San Francisco, former police commissioner John Hamasaki responded to Mr. Antani on Twitter:

Fascinating. Would getting your automobile window damaged and a few stuff stolen depart you “scarred perpetually”?

Is that this what the suburbs do to you? Shelter you from fundamental metropolis life experiences in order that once they occur you’re damaged to the core?

Making an attempt to offer Mr. Hamasaki each good thing about the doubt, one may be tempted to suppose that he’s preaching some type of rugged self-reliance. However he’s a dedicated leftist who helps common fundamental revenue and a number of different excessive nanny-state applications.

His description of crime as a “fundamental metropolis life expertise” should certainly make native residents blissful that he’s a former public workplace holder fairly than a present one. Final yr voters correctly rejected Mr. Hamasaki’s bid to change into the town’s district legal professional following the recall of Chesa Boudin. In November Cade Cannedy famous for SFGate:

… of their elementary disposition towards the town’s facilities of energy, Hamasaki and Boudin are very related: Each are dedicated to the elemental reformation of our policing system and imagine the present situations of crime and poverty are largely a manifestation of racialized capitalism and white supremacy.

As for the thefts reported Friday on Twitter and Mr. Hamasaki’s response, SFGate’s Eric Ting has been throughout this story and has revealed an enlightening interview with the previous D.A. candidate:

SFGATE: There’s fairly a bit of knowledge on the market displaying San Francisco suffers larger charges of automobile break-ins than different main cities. Had been you conscious of these figures?

Hamasaki: Sure. So one in all my different posts was about how one in all my assistants had her window damaged out actually final week. She’s from the Bay Space and stated, “That’s what I get for leaving my bag in my automobile.” All of the locals find out about our excessive price of property crime and comprehend it’s not secure to depart issues of their automobiles, however vacationers don’t at all times know that. It’s positively an actual problem we face. However we’re letting that eclipse the whole lot else in regards to the metropolis. We don’t see lovely sunsets going viral, so do we actually need this to outline what San Francisco is? I don’t suppose it ought to, and we must always push again to indicate how lovely the town is, and the optimistic features of the town.

SFGATE: Aren’t there individuals who argue that the town is gorgeous and has many good issues, and that’s why we’ve got to deal with property crime, in order that it’s not a blight?

Hamasaki: I don’t see that messaging turning into distinguished. I see, “That is what liberals have executed, liberals are ruining San Francisco, we are able to’t depart issues in our automobiles.” That’s most of what I’ve seen. I see posts that go viral nationally, and everybody from the correct desires to imagine San Francisco is a hellscape as a result of it’s supposedly a progressive metropolis. Everybody from Fox Information to Ted Cruz likes to push ahead this dominant narrative of San Francisco.

I’ve been a sufferer of a number of crimes in San Francisco; I’ve had my home windows damaged 4 occasions. It’s sadly against the law that’s generally dedicated, and we shouldn’t have to face for it or tolerate it, however I don’t suppose that ought to outline the town.

The fantastic thing about Mr. Hamasaki’s self-refuting reply is that at the beginning he seems to be organising a straw man to rebut however then inadvertently confirms together with his personal expertise and that of others that the town’s critics are proper on the right track. With progressive politicians like this, how can advocates for secure streets not be optimistic in regards to the alternatives for reform?

***

James Freeman is the co-author of “Borrowed Time: Two Centuries of Booms, Busts and Bailouts at Citi” and in addition the co-author of “The Price: Trump, China and American Revival.”

***

Observe James Freeman on Twitter.

Subscribe to the Better of the Internet e mail.

To counsel objects, please e mail finest@wsj.com.

(Lisa Rossi helps compile Better of the Internet. Due to Steve Glanville.)

***