Montana
Montana SupCo agrees media coalition can make case for accessing trial documents • Daily Montanan
A coalition of Montana press outlets will be allowed to make its argument for unsealing court documents in the trial of a man’s alleged killing of four Anaconda residents last summer, following an order from the Montana Supreme Court.
The order, handed down last week by Chief Justice Cory Swanson and signed by four other justices, reverses a district court order that had denied the press’ request to take part in the lawsuit to bring the sealed records into public view.
“The record reflects that the District Court entered the modified sealing order without participation by the media; without an evidentiary hearing; and without specific findings addressing the statutory requirements,” the order states. “We conclude the District Court proceeded under a mistake of law.”
On Aug. 1, Michael Brown walked into the Owl Bar in Anaconda and opened fire, killing four people before fleeing the scene, according to law enforcement. Federal, state and local law enforcement captured Brown following a week-long manhunt.
Prior to Brown’s apprehension, District Court Judge Jeffrey Dahood sealed all legal documents in the court case, at the request of Anaconda-Deer Lodge County Attorney Morgan Smith, a move considered unusual by legal experts.
Dahood unsealed some of the documents on Aug. 29 following a move to modify the sealing order by the state and defendant, but certain pretrial proceedings and records remain inaccessible to the public and the media.
A group of media organizations sought to become part of the case in a limited capacity, asking the court to vacate its August order, which modified which records remained sealed, arguing that the order violates Montana law and “fails to balance the public and Press’s constitutional right to examine public documents,” but Dahood denied the request.
The coalition of media organizations comprises The Daily Montanan, Montana Free Press, The Montana Newspaper Association, Montana Broadcasters Association, Lee Enterprises, Inc., which owns and operates five of the state’s largest print newspapers, and the Montana Freedom of Information Coalition.
Swanson wrote in his March 24 order that Montana’s constitution balances the requirement of the public’s right to know and a defendant’s right to a fair trial, but there are procedures and precedents that must be followed to determine the correct balance.
One mandatory procedure before records may be sealed is that “the media must be afforded an opportunity to be heard,” according to the court order.
“The District Court’s refusal to allow (the Press) to be heard directly conflicts with this controlling precedent,” Swanson wrote.
Swanson also adds the media coalition submitted a motion to appear, which the clerk of court did not add to the public court record, instead transmitting it directly to the district court, which subsequently denied it.
“The failure to docket (the Press’) motion — despite its submission with the required filing fee — resulted in a judicial ruling on a matter not entered into the public record,” Swanson wrote. “This procedure is inconsistent with Montana law.”
While the order will allow the coalition of press to make their case for unsealing the court documents, the high court did not immediately vacate the modified sealing order, “noting that certain sealed materials may implicate the defendant’s right to a fair trial.”
The matter is remanded back to the district court for an evidentiary hearing and entry of appropriate findings, with the media organizations allowed to argue to unseal the records.
Editor’s Note: The Daily Montanan is a part of the media coalition to enter the case.
If a furry, playful, hugg-able, lovable kitten would be a great addition to your place, now’s the time to visit the Humane Society of Western Montana.
MEET BAKER AND BUSBOY
It was another Take Me Home Tuesday at the radio stations with the Humane Society. Katie brought in “Baker” (black kitty) and “Busboy” (gray kitty), who along with their two siblings “Chef” and “Cook” form a Fantastic Four of pure joy.
These two-month-old little ones were found in the Polson area and surrendered to the shelter. They just had their spay/neuter surgeries Monday (July 13) and they will be looking for their forever homes starting Wednesday (July 15).
Whether you are looking for one kitten or the whole “kitchen,” visit the shelter and fall in love with Baker, Busboy, Chef and Cook.
EVER CONSIDERED BEING A FOSTER HOME FOR SHELTER PETS?
It is kitten season at the Humane Society of Western Montana. The Humane Society is always looking for Fosters to take care of tiny kittens until they are old enough to be adopted. They currently have some that are with mom cats, and some that are bottle babies. And there is always a need for volunteers willing to nurture them until they are of adoption age.
And of course one of the perks of being a Foster is, if you fall in love with a kitten, you pretty much get first dibs.
READ MORE: Volunteers Hit ‘The Ridge’ To Improve Montana Elk Hunting Opportunities
So, whether you are looking to adopt or would like more information about being a foster home, be sure to visit the Humane Society of Western Montana soon. They are open from 1:00 – 6:00 pm Wednesdays through Sundays at 5930 Highway 93 South in Missoula. See more cats AND dogs waiting to be adopted on the shelter’s ADOPT webpage here.
LOOK: Can you tell the difference between these common pets?
Can you tell the difference between a hamster and a guinea pig? How about a betta and a guppy? Test your pet ID skills in our cute quiz.
Gallery Credit: Stephen Lenz
HEBGEN LAKE, Mont. — A man was rescued after nearly drowning while swimming in Rainbow Point, located 10 miles north of West Yellowstone.
The Gallatin County Sheriff’s Office, along with Hebgen Basin Rural EMS personnel and Montana Fish, Wildlife and Parks, responded to reports of a swimmer in distress.
Officials say bystanders saw a man become unresponsive while swimming roughly 100 yards off the shoreline.
They, along with a boating group, located the man, pulled him out of the water, and performed life-saving measures until first responders arrived.
The man was airlifted to Eastern Idaho Regional Medical Center. Officials say he is in critical condition.
The Gallatin County Sheriff’s Office released the following information:
-
Delaware3 minutes agoHarrington-area man killed after truck hits him after lying on roadway
-
Florida9 minutes agoMan, 74, becomes oldest inmate executed in Florida in state’s 10th lethal injection this year
-
Georgia15 minutes agoAthlon Sports tabs Florida-Georgia among SEC’s best games in 2026
-
Hawaii21 minutes ago4,000 troops lose air conditioning in Hawaii
-
Idaho27 minutes agoIdaho is home to the nation's first DarkSky Reserve. Now it's home to the nations first DarkSky Certified Resort
-
Illinois33 minutes ago2 teens hospitalized after being rescued by bystanders from Lake Michigan at Illinois Beach State Park near Zion
-
Indiana39 minutes ago‘Big Boy’ locomotive returns for overnight stay in northeast Indiana
-
Iowa45 minutes agoMeet the 3 Best New Food at the Iowa State Fair finalists for 2026
