Idaho
Idaho tobacco settlement secures millions in funds, rather than spending years to litigate payments • Idaho Capital Sun
Idaho Attorney General Raúl Labrador reached a new settlement with tobacco companies to immediately get a big chunk of disputed funds, but it will leave millions on the table.
That’s instead of duking it out in litigation that can last over a decade.
Idaho’s settlement — reached in March — resolved years of complicated litigation, and it’s similar to ones 38 other states and territories reached, the Idaho Office of the Attorney General says.
Those are long-running cases over disputed payments by cigarette manufacturers, stemming from a quirk in a massive 1998 settlement. That earlier deal, called the Master Settlement Agreement, requires a handful of the largest cigarette manufacturers to pay states billions of dollars annually.
Instead of risking arbitration panels potentially denying Idaho full access to around $58 million in disputed payments by major cigarette manufacturers, Idaho’s new deal settles for $37 million — and an even higher share of future disputed funds.
“This settlement avoids decades of expensive litigation and eliminates risk that could threaten millions of dollars of Idaho’s annual … payment” from the original 1998 settlement, Labrador said in an April news release. “I’m committed to ensuring that the tobacco companies meet their obligations to Idaho under the (Master Settlement Agreement) without delay or uncertainty.”
As a result, Idaho is expecting a more “even payment stream year to year” from the settlement, Deputy Attorney General John Olson told a panel of lawmakers last week in a presentation before the Joint Millennium Fund Committee. The committee recommends how Idaho should spend its tobacco settlement funds.
Idaho lawmakers are gearing up to dole out more of the tobacco settlement funds toward youth drug prevention efforts, Boise State Public Radio reported. Over the years, Idaho lawmakers have directed the funds toward a range of issues, including toward public health districts, substance abuse treatment, the Idaho Meth Project and more, according to reports by the Idaho State Treasurer.
GET THE MORNING HEADLINES DELIVERED TO YOUR INBOX
New settlement resolves decades of litigation over disputed tobacco company payments
In 1998, Idaho and states across the U.S. reached the landmark Master Settlement Agreement meant to reduce smoking.
The settlement set up decades of payments by tobacco companies to states. But some of those payments went into disputed accounts that states would have to arbitrate to access.
That stems from the “non-participating manufacturer adjustment,” one of several adjustments in the 1998 master settlement agreement, Olson told lawmakers last week.
Each year, tobacco companies claim that the adjustment applies to reduce their payments to states, Olson explained, pooling about $3 million to $5 million of Idaho’s tobacco settlement payments into the disputed fund annually.
Idaho has spent years litigating to access those funds. Just this year, Idaho was litigating to access disputed funds from 2005, Olson said.
Whether Idaho would win in arbitration depended on if it could convince an arbitration panel of judges that Idaho “diligently” enforced the terms of its law passed in accordance with the 1998 settlement.
James Simeri, the chief of the attorney general’s office’s Consumer Protection Division, which handles the litigation, told the Idaho Capital Sun in an interview that the settlement eliminated the risk of losing disputed funds. And it means Idaho will receive payments now, rather than waiting a decade or longer for litigation over individual years’ payments to resolve, he said.
“The attorney general’s looking out for the people of Idaho,” Simeri said. “And getting most of the money, but not all the money, but eliminating the risk of losing the money — seems desirable on the whole, in the circumstances, given the risks.”
And the office had to pay attorneys and staff for the litigation, he added.
Why Idaho reached the new tobacco settlement
This year, Idaho is getting around $74 million in tobacco settlement funds. That includes the up-front payments for past disputed funds that the new settlement secured, along with Idaho’s $23.3 million payment originating from the 1998 settlement this year, Olson told lawmakers.
When Idaho reached the new settlement, around $58 million was in its disputed payments account from funds withheld through 2020, Simeri told the Sun in an email.
The new settlement also sets Idaho up to receive 75% of future disputed payments from 2015 through 2031, according to a February letter by Labrador, outlining the new settlement.
In the past, Idaho has won in arbitration. But the Attorney General’s Office says future success isn’t guaranteed, referencing a recent loss for the state of Washington.
Need to get in touch?
Have a news tip?
If Idaho lost its arbitration for those disputed funds, it could lose access to those funds — and maybe even lose more, through a reallocation provision in the settlement, Simeri told the Sun.
“It’s less than you could have gotten with a total victory. But if you compare it to a total defeat, it’s a lot more,” Simeri told the Sun in an interview.
Whether settling over the disputed funds is beneficial “is in the eyes of the beholder,” Brett DeLange, former chief of the Idaho Office of the Attorney General’s Consumer Protection Division, told the Sun in an interview.
He thinks some states are essentially saying: “‘a bird in the hand is worth two in the bush.’ … That having a lesser amount now is better than waiting so long to get the full amount.”
And he praised Olson and David Young — two Idaho deputy attorneys general on the tobacco settlement litigation — as “outstanding lawyers.”
Idaho
How Come Nobody Else Warned Idaho is Broke?
Of all my on-air guests, Dorothy Moon probably takes the most fire, and from all directions.
A couple of months ago, Idaho’s Republican Party Chairwoman told me the state could be staring at an upcoming billion-dollar budget shortfall. I posted Dorothy Moon’s comments online, and didn’t see much reaction. A few days later, I mentioned it on-air to Idaho House Minority Leader Ilana Rubel. Expecting her never to brush aside a possible route of attack on the majority Republicans, I waited for a pithy answer. She warned of a deficit, but seemed to downplay the one billion dollar figure.
I’ve been on vacation for a couple of weeks. While I was away, this story appeared in the Idaho Capital Sun. While one billion may not happen, it could, according to people reviewing the figures. For those who claim some Republicans are squishes, it looks like they’ve found a method for greatly reducing government. Because 2026 is a major election year, nobody in the GOP is going to raise your taxes to balance the books!
I’m not writing this to forecast where the cuts will take place. Old media will be sharing sob stories for the next several months to paint Republicans as Simon Legree. Democrats will be portrayed as an outnumbered army of saints. Rinse and repeat.
What I do want to mention is that Dorothy Moon was prescient. The 2024 Idaho Republican Party Presidential Caucus is long in the rearview mirror, but remember that was her effort. Granted, it included many dedicated volunteers (one locally even named Grant) and was a Herculean task, but Dorothy was the CEO of that effort. Take a moment to consider the scope and her budget predictions, and you’ll find she has the skills that corporate America needs.
Under Fire from All Directions
The media and its fellow travelers despise her because she’s not a socialist. When I see stories reminding readers about her involvement in the John Birch Society, the goal is to paint her as a dangerous extremist. You’re led to believe that JBS was the equivalent of the Klan. Even the commies at the Southern Poverty Law Center rate Birchers as benign patriots, but in modern newsrooms, the goal is to plant seeds for the left-wing narrative.
She’s also under constant attack from the Gang of Nate. Members who believe the party should have its thumb on the scales to benefit their candidates. The same quality found in Moon’s predecessors, the gang whined about, and rightly so. If it was wrong then, why would it be right today? Dorothy called the gang out when they were insinuating that some good, newly elected Republican legislators weren’t sufficiently Christian. By the gang’s definition of Christian. “Be careful that you don’t practice your religion in front of people to draw their attention,” comes to mind. As one member of the outfit has said, people knew what they were getting when they voted. She wouldn’t be the first to misinterpret a vote for change as a mandate from heaven.
That’s the sad part, because by misreading the outcome of ’24, they may have overplayed their hand, and we’ll see a return of the establishment in ’26. If their followers are reduced to making that argument above all others, I would say there could be trouble ahead.
Don’t Overplay Your Hand
That struck me when I saw a first responder label the gang in an online post as the “hateful eight”. The opposition will come up with all manner of twists to parody their armor-wearing avatars. Defining the opposition is built on repetition, and with a touch of humor, it can be devastating. Some of the people I’ve been criticizing were once friends, but lack self-awareness. If a hundred people repeatedly fawn over you, it’s easy to get the impression you’ve hit the sweet spot, but what if the 100 are in a minority? I’ve been a broadcaster for most of the last 40 years, and the people who don’t like me generally leave me alone. Aside from a vocal few.
When I’m shopping, people who approach me are generally friendly. Come to think of it, over the past 20 years, I’ve only had one person tell me he didn’t like the content, and he was polite. I offered him some other options on the dial, and he said he would give them a listen. The thing is, the overwhelming number of people I pass in the grocery store or when leaving church don’t stop to talk.
Which gets me back to Dorothy. She has worked diligently to provide a fair platform for Republican candidates. Her reward has been vilification by the old guard because it doesn’t favor their lobbyist/government complex. Old allies froth at the mouth because she won’t tilt the machine, yet none of them can approach her organizational skills, her outreach to remote party committees, and her willingness to be publicly available.
Here’s an idea for legislators of all stripes. Solve a billion-dollar puzzle. Don’t waste our time bellyaching about someone else’s campaign in a far-away district. Be focused on doing a good job and on your own constituents. This isn’t brain surgery. It’s politics.
A similar version of this essay appeared on Substack.
10 Best Restaurant Gumbo in Acadiana
We asked, and you responded. Here are your favorite restaurants in the Acadiana area to get good gumbo.
Gallery Credit: Chris’ Poboys, Facebook / Canva
Idaho
Crash temporarily impacts rush hour traffic at Kimberly intersection
KIMBERLY, Idaho (KMVT/KSVT) — Idaho State Police troopers are reminding drivers to exercise caution when entering or crossing U.S. Highway 30 between Kimberly and Twin Falls after a crash on Monday.
Around 4 p.m., a black sedan and a red hatchback crashed at the intersection of the highway and North 3400 East, according to a trooper on scene. One person in the black car was left with minor injuries.
The black sedan suffered extensive damage to the front bumper, while the red hatchback was sent over a ditch into a nearby field.
Troopers said they had to temporarily close westbound lanes and North 3400 East at the intersection before completely clearing the scene just before 5 p.m.
The intersection between U.S. Highway 30 and North 3400 East is one of the Magic Valley’s most dangerous intersections, according to a trooper on scene. ISP urged drivers to exercise caution and think twice before entering or crossing the highway.
Copyright 2025 KMVT. All rights reserved.
Idaho
Idaho Seeks Private Investment In Nuclear Energy Supply Chain Ventures
Idaho is seeking private investment and advice from companies interesting in developing the state’s nuclear energy supply chain.
The Governor’s Office of Energy and Mineral Resources issued a request for information to private industry to learn more about nuclear development incentives that can attract investments.
The office is seeking comprehensive feedback by Dec. 12 “from industry leaders to better understand the factors that influence location decisions and to identify specific initiatives that would make Idaho the preferred destination for nuclear investments,” the RFI stated.
Companies involved in the nuclear energy supply chain, including nuclear energy developers, are being asked to identify key factors influencing site selection and convey preferences about:
- Business incentives such as tax and non-financial support,
- Infrastructure,
- Workforce needs,
- Public-private partnerships, and
- Regulatory and permitting requirements.
The state is also seeking information about potential investment barriers
“This RFI does not constitute a commitment by the State of Idaho to provide any specific incentives or support. All future agreements will be subject to separate negotiation and approval processes,” the state noted.
The Idaho National Laboratory Transient Reactor Test Facility in Idaho Falls, Idaho.
Associated Press
Idaho is already a national leader in advanced nuclear energy research thanks to its Idaho National Laboratory, a unit of the U.S. Department of Energy. There in Idaho Falls scientists and researchers are working on the latest nuclear power developments.
Nuclear Energy Advisory Task Force Created
Gov. Brad Little underscored the state’s commitment to backing advanced nuclear energy technologies—such as small modular reactors and next-generation reactors—as key to future economic prosperity.
Little issued Executive Order No. 2025-06 in September to create the “Idaho Advanced Nuclear Energy Task Force.”
The order says the task force is to “assess, recommend, and support strategies that advance Idaho’s leadership in nuclear energy innovation, deployment, and workforce development.”
Topics to advise the governor about include nuclear energy policy, spent nuclear fuel, and energy resiliency and security. Other issues it would delve into are fuel creation, enhancement and minimization as well as legislative and regulatory reforms to promote safe development of advanced nuclear projects.
Another responsibility of this organization is to create “marketing materials that position Idaho as a national hub for nuclear innovation, research, and private-sector development.”
Little also noted in his order that the group should also examine deploying in Idaho advanced nuclear technologies like small modular reactors, microreactors and molten salt reactors.
-
News17 hours agoTrump threatens strikes on any country he claims makes drugs for US
-
Politics16 hours agoTrump rips Somali community as federal agents reportedly eye Minnesota enforcement sweep
-
World17 hours agoHonduras election council member accuses colleague of ‘intimidation’
-
Technology7 days agoNew scam sends fake Microsoft 365 login pages
-
Politics6 days agoRep. Swalwell’s suit alleges abuse of power, adds to scrutiny of Trump official’s mortgage probes
-
Business1 week agoStruggling Six Flags names new CEO. What does that mean for Knott’s and Magic Mountain?
-
Ohio1 week agoSnow set to surge across Northeast Ohio, threatening Thanksgiving travel
-
News7 days ago2 National Guard members wounded in ‘targeted’ attack in D.C., authorities say
