Connect with us

Maryland

Maryland Supreme Court: Attorney disbarment; self-representation

Published

on

Maryland Supreme Court: Attorney disbarment; self-representation


Listen to this article

Criminal; self-representation

BOTTOM LINE: Where a man did not express a desire that the trial court could reasonably conclude was a request for self-representation or to discharge counsel, it did not have an obligation to question him further to determine whether the he wanted to invoke the right to self-representation.

CASE: Goodrich v. State, No. 8, Sept. Term, 2025 (filed Oct. 24, 2025) (Justices Fader, WATTS, Booth, Biran, Gould, Eaves, Killough).

FACTS: After a trial by jury at which he was represented by counsel, Mr. Goodrich was found guilty of attempted second-degree murder, armed robbery and use of a firearm in the commission of a felony or crime of violence and sentenced to imprisonment. The Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed the conviction.

Mr. Goodrich contends that he made a request to represent himself and the judge denied the request in violation of his constitutional rights and Maryland Rule 4-215. According to Mr. Goodrich, his responses to the administrative judge’s inquiry required the judge to ask additional questions of him to ascertain whether he truly wanted to represent himself, and to make a ruling under Maryland Rule 4-215(e) as to whether a request to discharge counsel was meritorious.

Advertisement

LAW: Under the circumstances of this case, the circuit court complied with the requirements set forth in case law concerning the constitutional right to self- representation and Maryland Rule 4-215(e).

Where a trial court has been advised by defense counsel that a defendant wants to represent himself at trial, the court is required under case law concerning the constitutional right to self-representation to conduct an inquiry to determine whether the defendant clearly and unequivocally invoked the right to self-representation and under Maryland Rule 4-215(e) to permit the defendant to explain the reasons for the request to discharge counsel.

Here, in response to a court’s reasonable inquiry, a defendant does not express a desire that the court could reasonably conclude is a request for self-representation or to discharge counsel, the court does not have an obligation under case law or Maryland Rule 4-215(e) to question the defendant further to determine whether the defendant wants to invoke the right to self-representation.

In this case, where, in response to the court’s inquiry, Mr. Goodrich advised the court that he wanted an attorney and did not reasonably apprise the court of a desire for self-representation or to discharge counsel. Neither the Supreme Court’s holding in Faretta v. California, 422 U.S. 806 (1975), nor this court’s holding in Snead v. State, 286 Md. 122 (1979) or the provisions of Maryland Rule 4-215(e) required the court to question him further. Under the circumstances of the case, the court’s inquiry was reasonable and complied with case law governing assertion of the right to self-representation and Maryland Rule 4-215(e).

Judgement of the Appellate Court of Maryland affirmed.

Advertisement

BOTTOM LINE: Where an attorney violated multiple Maryland Attorneys’ Rules of Professional Conduct arising out of his representation of 14 clients in the bankruptcy court, as well as conduct in connection with his own bankruptcy filings and tax matters, he was disbarred.

CASE: Attorney Grievance Commission of Maryland v. Mintz, AG No. 21, Sept. Term, 2025 (filed Oct. 24, 2025) (Justices Fader, Watts, BOOTH, Biran, Gould, Eaves, Killough).

FACTS: The Attorney Grievance Commission of Maryland, acting through bar counsel, filed a petition for disciplinary or remedial action against David B. Mintz, arising out of his representation of 14 clients in the bankruptcy court, as well as conduct in connection with his own bankruptcy filings and tax matters.

The hearing judge assigned to this matter found by clear and convincing evidence that Mr. Mintz committed all but one of the violations alleged by the Commission. The hearing judge also determined the presence of eight aggravating factors and one mitigating factor. Neither party filed exceptions. Bar counsel recommended the sanction of disbarment, which this court imposed by per curiam order on Sept. 4, 2025, following oral argument, which Mr. Mintz did not attend. The court now explains the reasons for its order.

LAW: The hearing judge concluded that there was clear and convincing evidence that Mr. Mintz had committed all but one of the violations charged by the Commission. Neither Mr. Mintz nor the Commission filed any exceptions.

Advertisement

Based on this court’s independent review of the record and the hearing judge’s conclusions, it agrees with the hearing judge and concludes that clear and convincing evidence demonstrates that Mr. Mintz violated Rules 1.1 (competence), 1.3 (diligence), 1.4 (a) and (b) (communication), 1.5(a) (fees), 1.16(a) (declining or terminating representation), 3.2 (expediting litigation), 3.4(c) (fairness to opposing party and attorney), 8.1(b) (bar admission and disciplinary matters) and 8.4(a), (c) and (d) (misconduct).

In accordance with Maryland Rule 19-727(e)(3), the hearing judge made findings as to aggravating and mitigating circumstances. The hearing judge found one mitigating factor present, which was that Mr. Mintz had no prior disciplinary history. The court concludes that the record supports the hearing judge’s finding of the single mitigating factor by a preponderance of the evidence.

With respect to aggravating factors, the hearing judge found by clear and convincing evidence the following: a pattern of misconduct; multiple offenses; bad faith obstruction of the disciplinary proceeding by intentionally failing to comply with rules or orders of the disciplinary agency; substantial experience in the practice of law; refusal to acknowledge the wrongful nature of the misconduct; victim’s vulnerability; indifference to making restitution or rectifying the misconduct’s consequences; and likelihood of repetition. The court agrees with the hearing judge that these aggravating factors are present.

The Commission recommended disbarment as the appropriate sanction given Mr. Mintz’s numerous violations of the Maryland Attorneys’ Rules of Professional Conduct, asserting that Mr. Mintz “completely and utterly abandoned fourteen separate clients, causing them considerable financial and emotional distress.” The Commission pointed to Mr. Mintz’s repeated failure to obey orders from the bankruptcy court, his failure to appear for hearings and complete required filings and his litigation tactics, which the Commission described as “‘gaming’ the bankruptcy system for his personal gain.”

The court agrees with the Commission that the totality of Mr. Mintz’s misconduct “demonstrates a complete indifference” to the duty owed to his clients, to the court and to the legal profession. Mr. Mintz’s neglect of clients’ cases, and his failure to communicate with his clients—all of whom were in the vulnerable and stressful process of filing for bankruptcy—and his continued failure to fully respond and participate in bar counsel’s investigation seriously undermine the integrity of the legal profession.

Advertisement

Mr. Mintz’s wholesale abandonment of his clients and his flagrant disregard for court orders is troubling, to say the least. Mr. Mintz’s misconduct not only harmed his clients, but also erodes basic public confidence in the legal system and the rule of law.

So ordered.



Source link

Maryland

Gov. Moore seeks disaster relief for farmers hit by April cold snap

Published

on

Gov. Moore seeks disaster relief for farmers hit by April cold snap


Gov. Wes Moore has requested a federal disaster declaration to help farmers recover from their losses after temperatures dipped into the 20s in April, devastating some of Maryland’s agriculture industry.

Temperatures dipped into the low to mid 20s for several hours, causing widespread damage to crops, wine grapes, berries, peaches and apples in some parts of the state.

“We had 6, 7 hours I believe here under 32 and that’s just a lot of stress on those small fruits and buds,” said Ben Butler, the farm manager of Butler’s Orchard in Germantown back in April.

Moore asked for the U.S. agriculture secretary to declare a federal disaster using Maryland Farm Service Agency data to back up the request. According to the agency, there were historic losses, including 94% of the apple crop, 99% of the peach crop and 98% of the barley in several jurisdictions.

Advertisement

The Maryland Wineries Association says 36% of grape acreage sustained total losses, with a $24.4 million projected deficit in wine sales for the 2026 vintage.

“For the majority of the varieties, the yield, the 2026 crop yield, will essentially be zero,” said Robert Butz, the owner of Windridge Vineyards.

The hours-long deep freeze in April left grapes at Windridge Vineyards in Germantown dead on the vine.

News4 visited Windridge Vineyards just a few days after the disaster. Butz said not only were there grape losses, some of the vines were damaged as well. He called the devastation “catastrophic.”

It’s challenging, but he said he’s pleased with the support being given to local farmers and the disaster declaration request.

Advertisement

“This announcement by the governor is further evidence of that, right,” Butz said. “Marylanders care about their farmers. That’s great.It’s incredibly gratifying for those who do this work.”

Moore is asking the agriculture secretary for a quick decision so emergency loans and relief programs are made available right away so farmers can prepare for the next growing season.



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Maryland

Anne Arundel County Executive Democratic candidates make their case ahead of Maryland primary

Published

on

Anne Arundel County Executive Democratic candidates make their case ahead of Maryland primary


ANNE ARUNDEL COUNTY, Md. — Five candidates are running to replace Anne Arundel County Executive Steuart Pittman, with four Democrats competing for their party’s nomination ahead of the Maryland primary.

Republican Dave Crawford is the only candidate on the GOP side, meaning he automatically advances from the primary. Democratic voters, however, face a choice between four candidates: county council members Allison Pickard and Pete Smith, Pittman administration Special Assistant James Kitchin, and city and regional planner Kyle Nembhard.

Pickard is serving her second term as councilwoman for the Second District.

 

Advertisement

Anne Arundel County executive democratic candidates make their case ahead of Maryland primary

Anne Arundel County executive race heats up ahead of Maryland primary

 

“I’m excited to move forward into the executive branch where we really get to execute and implement, uh, all of the policies that we’ve put forth,” Pickard said.

Advertisement

Smith has served on the county council for 14 years on and off.

“You will see that there is a crystal clear option in this race, uh, when you look at our resume when you judge me on my report card, you will see that I’ve been doing my homework for this county for the last 14 years,” Smith said.

Kitchin has served as special assistant in the Pittman administration for the past 7 years.

“I have the most relevant experience and I am the most ready on day one to come in and create a smooth transition from the Pittman administration into the next 4 years,” Kitchin said.

Nembhard has worked as a city and regional planner in the transportation field since 2002.

Advertisement

“I am literally an average citizen, like the majority of, of folks in Anne Arundel County, actually all the folks in Anne Arundel County. Um, who just like them, feel like their voices aren’t heard,” Nembhard said.

Where the candidates agree — and differ

All 4 Democratic candidates share similar positions on many of the county’s major issues, including housing affordability, public safety, mental health services, and education funding. Their approaches, however, differ.

On housing, Pickard emphasizes supply and transit-oriented development.

“I’ve been wholly focused on redevelopment and transit oriented development, which is exciting about creating cool spaces, uh, around our Mark station. Or our light rail stations so that maybe we’ll attract those younger folks who want to have walkable communities and really neat spaces — and be closer to where they work,” Pickard said.

All 4 candidates support increasing public safety staffing. Smith pointed to specific numbers to illustrate the strain on current personnel.

Advertisement

“In fact, on the police side of the house we’re about 809 positions. The reality is 1200 is where we should be at with this current population here in Anne Arundel County. We got about 850 to 900, uh, fire department personnel, uh, who are answering well over 100,000 calls every single year. That’s significant,” Smith said.

All 4 candidates also support funding mental health services and violence interruption programs. Both Nembhard and Smith expressed a personal connection to the issue and called for more community policing. Nembhard described the impact of officers who knew their neighborhoods.

“Where I grew up we were fortunate, I don’t know if that was by design or by chance, but like me and my friends, we knew the folks who, you know, walked the beat in our neighborhood. So, that intimate knowledge, that integration can make the difference between a good student who’s just in the wrong place at the wrong time getting shot,” Nembhard said.

On education, all 4 candidates support maintaining funding growth for county schools. Kitchin is the only candidate in the race endorsed by the teachers union.

“Like I’m a pro-education candidate, um, come from a pro-education family, and that didn’t change because I got their endorsement,” Kitchin said.

Advertisement

Public financing

Anne Arundel County has a public financing system for campaigns. Kitchin is the only candidate in this race using it.

“I’m not taking any corporate money, any PAC money, no developer money. I’m also not taking any union money,” Kitchin said.

All 4 candidates support the public financing system and said they would like to see more political candidates use it in the future.

Why vote for me?

With so much common ground among the candidates, voters may find it difficult to choose. Each candidate made their case.

Kitchin pointed to his experience inside the current administration.

Advertisement

“I have the most relevant experience and I am the most ready on day one to come in and create a smooth transition from the Pittman administration into the next 4 years,” Kitchin said.

Nembhard framed his candidacy around his connection to everyday residents.

“I don’t see voters. I see my neighbors, I see friends, I see family, the same people that I’m in the trenches all the time, all day, going to county council meetings and speaking up on their behalf and fighting to be heard, you know, like just, just to be heard, to have a seat at the table,” Nembhard said.

Pickard highlighted the support she has built across the county.

“I’m really proud of the coalition I’ve built, and I feel like it’s a real testament to my track record of getting results for our community,” Pickard said.

Advertisement

Smith pointed to his long record of service.

“You will see that there is a crystal clear option in this race, uh, when you look at our resume when you judge me on my report card, you will see that I’ve been doing my homework for this county for the last 14 years,” Smith said.

Early voting begins June 11. The Maryland primary is June 23. Whoever wins the Democratic nomination will face Crawford in the November general election.

JAMES KITCHIN

 

Full interview with Anne Arundel County Executive candidate James Kitchin

Advertisement

Meet the candidates for Anne Arundel County Executive: James Kitchin

 

Key Campaign Message:
Kitchin positions himself as the candidate of government reform and transparency, emphasizing his unique use of the county’s new public financing system. As the only candidate refusing corporate, developer, PAC, and union money, he frames his campaign around eliminating special interest influence in county government.

Core Qualifications:

  • Executive Experience: Seven-plus years in the Pittman administration, including roles in budget, legislative affairs, and communications
  • Education Background: Former teacher and current spouse of a 4th-grade teacher
  • “Ready on Day One”: Claims unique preparation for executive role through administrative experience

Policy Priorities:

  • Housing: Rejects “supply-side” approach, insists on building specifically affordable units rather than hoping market-rate construction reduces costs
  • Education: Strongly supports record $72.8 million education increase; endorsed by Teachers Association of Anne Arundel County
  • Environment: Proposes “no net loss of forest” program and opposes one-size-fits-all bulk regulations
  • Immigration: Strongest advocate for expanding Family Protection Initiative

Notable Positions:

  • Only candidate using public financing system
  • Most detailed critique of supply-side housing theory
  • Emphasizes upstream public safety investments over enforcement-only approach
  • Supports using rainy day fund to address potential federal cuts

KYLE NEMBHARD

 

Full interview with Anne Arundel County Executive candidate Kyle Nembhard

Advertisement

Meet the candidates for Anne Arundel County Executive: Kyle Nembhard

 

Key Campaign Message:
Nembhard presents himself as the “average citizen” candidate bringing fresh perspective and community empowerment to county government. He emphasizes transparency, community engagement, and reducing barriers between government and residents.

Core Qualifications:

Advertisement
  • Professional Background: City and regional planner with development experience
  • Community Advocacy: Extensive volunteer work and community organizing
  • Outsider Status: Only candidate without prior elected office experience

Policy Priorities:

  • Housing: Supports increased supply but emphasizes affordable units near transit corridors to reduce car dependency
  • Education: Advocates for maximum 20 students per classroom; child of union member though not endorsed by teachers
  • Transportation: Strong focus on transit-oriented development and reducing car dependency
  • Public Safety: Emphasizes community integration of law enforcement, drawing from personal positive police relationships

Notable Positions:

  • Late entry candidate who couldn’t access public financing due to timing
  • Most detailed focus on transit and transportation solutions
  • Unique emphasis on empowering communities through government transparency
  • Economic argument for protecting immigrant workers

PETE SMITH

 

Full interview with Anne Arundel County Executive candidate Pete Smith

Meet the candidates for Anne Arundel County Executive: Pete Smith

 

Key Campaign Message:
Smith emphasizes his proven track record and deep institutional knowledge, positioning himself as the candidate who has “done the homework” through 14 years of council service and 28 years of military experience.

Advertisement

Core Qualifications:

  • Legislative Experience: 14 years on county council (with breaks), including budget committee work
  • Military Service: 28 years as Marine, including overseas deployments
  • Institutional Knowledge: Claims deepest understanding of county operations and needs

Policy Priorities:

  • Public Safety: Most specific staffing targets – wants 1,200 police officers (currently ~809) and 1,200-1,300 firefighters (currently 850-900)
  • Housing: Supports county “driving the train” rather than leaving to market; backs cottage home bill creating $200k homes
  • Economic Development: Strong emphasis on P3 partnerships and reducing federal dependency
  • Education: Detailed history supporting education funding since 2012, including Blueprint implementation

Notable Positions:

  • Most specific public safety staffing numbers
  • Created stormwater remediation fund
  • Personal story about police officer saving his life
  • Opposes 287G immigration enforcement based on experience and human dignity

ALLISON PICKARD

 

Full interview with Anne Arundel County Executive candidate Allison Pickard

Meet the candidates for Anne Arundel County Executive: Allison Pickard

 

Advertisement

Key Campaign Message:
Pickard presents herself as the “successful legislator” who gets things done through coalition building and bipartisan cooperation. She emphasizes governing as a “team sport” and her proven ability to pass significant legislation.

Core Qualifications:

  • Legislative Track Record: Two terms on county council with major bill passage
  • Education Experience: Former Board of Education member during significant reforms
  • Coalition Building: Emphasizes bringing together labor and private sector supporters

Policy Priorities:

  • Housing: Strong “supply-side” advocate supporting zoning changes, transit-oriented development, and smaller lot sizes to increase overall housing stock
  • Environment: Proudest of creating Resilience Authority and securing federal partnerships
  • Education: Former Board of Education member supporting teacher pay increases and continued funding growth
  • Federal Relations: Strongest emphasis on leveraging federal partnerships and funding

Notable Positions:

  • Most detailed legislative accomplishments (Resilience Authority, education reforms)
  • Strongest advocate for market-based housing solutions
  • Helped create public financing system but chose traditional fundraising route
  • Most experience with federal grant acquisition and partnerships

This story was reported on-air by a journalist and has been converted to this platform with the assistance of AI. Our editorial team verifies all reporting on all platforms for fairness and accuracy.





Source link

Continue Reading

Maryland

Comfortable and nice weather across Maryland into the weekend

Published

on

Comfortable and nice weather across Maryland into the weekend



Refreshing and dry weekend weather in Maryland

Plunging humidity levels and dry weather will be around through the rest of the workweek. Highs Thursday and Friday will top out in the upper 70s with a mixture of clouds and sunshine. 

Advertisement

This-coming weekend is looking much drier and better for all outdoor plans across the Mid-Atlantic, compared to Memorial Day Weekend. The First Alert Forecast is mostly dry and seasonable on Friday, Saturday and Sunday. 

Plan on a mix of sun and clouds each day. Saturday and Sunday begin with temperatures in the 50s, followed by afternoons spent in the 70s. Humidity remains low, too.

The chance of rain increases a bit during the beginning of next workweek. The next chance of wetter wet arrives on Monday. The WJZ First Alert Weather Team will be fine-tuning the return of rain in the forecast… keeping you updated on WJZ, streaming on CBS News Baltimore and on-the-go in the CBS News App. 



Source link

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending