OPINION: Closing Atlanta’s jail doesn’t make dollars or sense

Final 12 months, federal immigration authorities eliminated prisoners from the Irwin facility due to deplorable situations. And it could value $80 per prisoner per night time, which means it could value $15 million a 12 months if Labat shipped 500 prisoners down there.

And, after all, this might be a burden on prisoners’ households, however that is the place we’re.

Three miles away from Fulton’s overcrowded jail sits the 1,300-bed, barely used Atlanta Metropolis Detention Middle (ACDC for brief), owned by town of Atlanta.

For years, soft-hearted metropolis council members and the previous mayor wished to shut the concrete fortress and switch it into an “fairness middle,” the place individuals might obtain social companies like psychological well being or assist to amass job abilities or inexpensive housing.

This, after all, could be a facility the place the workplaces would have very thick cement partitions and slits for home windows and maybe even metal bathrooms in the midst of the room — as a result of it was constructed to be a JAIL!

The trouble to shut and “re-imagine” Atlanta’s jail has paused with a mayoral regime change and a public that previously couple of years has swung from calling for a reallocation of police funding to “rattling, these road racers are annoying.”

Rising, violent crime has once more solid a lock-’em-up mindset within the public. In line with Atlanta police stats, violent crime (homicide, rape, aggravated assault and theft) is up 39% within the first 22 weeks of this 12 months in comparison with the identical interval in 2019, the final non-COVID 12 months.

However the close-the-jail effort lives on. Just lately, metropolis council members heard that sentiment from an auditorium full of individuals.

Residents holding indicators demanding “Care not cuffs” strolled to a podium for 2 hours at a finances assembly, telling council members to defund town jail. On the assembly attended by medical doctors, legal professionals, activists and college students, Councilmember Liliana Bakhtiari, who’s new, stated she is in solidarity with the audio system and urged them to foyer Mayor Andre Dickens on the difficulty.

“In some ways, we’re manufacturing a human disaster,” she stated.

Councilmember Jason Dozier, who can be new, largely agrees with Bakhtiari.

“I sit up for seeing or not it’s closed and renewed right into a diversion help service,” he stated in an interview, including that town should goal the basis explanation for crime. “I’d hate to take a step again. I wish to make choices based mostly on knowledge, not on public notion.”

Fulton County Sherrif Patrick Labat seems over the road exterior the Fulton County Courtroom in the course of the collection of the particular grand jury to research allegations that former President Donald Trump criminally interfered with Georgia’s elections in 2020. Monday, Might 2, 2022. Miguel Martinez /miguel.martinezjimenez@ajc.com

Advertisement

Credit score: Miguel Martinez

Credit score: Miguel Martinez

Fulton County Sherrif Patrick Labat seems over the road exterior the Fulton County Courtroom in the course of the collection of the particular grand jury to research allegations that former President Donald Trump criminally interfered with Georgia’s elections in 2020. Monday, Might 2, 2022. Miguel Martinez /miguel.martinezjimenez@ajc.com

Credit score: Miguel Martinez

Credit score: Miguel Martinez

Town jail, which opened in 1995, has grow to be an absurd, even weird scenario. Town is searching for $16 million this 12 months to run the ability, regardless that it homes a mean of solely 46 prisoners every night time. It operates at a 4% capability.

The explanation the jail is so empty is as a result of the council in 2018 voted to permit a lot of the prisoners introduced there (who’re arrested on metropolis ordinance violations, no more critical state felony prices) to be launched with out having to submit money bail.

And, not surprisingly, a lot of these arrestees don’t present up in court docket. In line with a Channel 2 Motion Information report, “failure to look” circumstances have jumped 80% for the reason that coverage was enacted.

“The deconstruction of the Atlanta Metropolis Detention Middle was methodically carried out by individuals who had their very own agenda,” stated Labat, who ran that jail earlier than getting elected sheriff in 2020.

Councilmember Michael Bond, who as soon as was a guard on the metropolis jail and has, off-and-on, served on the council for 30 years, contends that the cries to shut the jail “should not reflective of the citizenry of Atlanta.” He stated town jail might readily settle for 500 prisoners from Fulton, which is becoming as a result of some 80% of these within the county jail had been arrested by Atlanta police.

“The best way the (metropolis) jail is, we’re not getting the financial system for the taxes we’re paying,” Bond stated. “If the sheriff is pressured to make these preparations (to ship away prisoners), effectively, those that wish to shut the jail are creating unintentional penalties.”

I spoke with Devon Holloway, who moved into the Pittsburgh neighborhood in 2015, throughout the road from a retailer recognized for shootings. It’s higher nowadays within the neighborhood simply south of downtown. And he’d prefer it to remain that approach.

He agrees with Bond and Labat.

“I believe the county ought to get it, versus turning it over to grow to be a homeless shelter,” Holloway stated. “Public security is the highest concern on everybody’s record. These individuals who do issues have to be held accountable.”

Looks like Atlanta ought to simply hand over the keys.