Vermont
A Yale grad from Newport studied Vermont’s school mergers. She found they don’t save much.
While studying economics and education at Yale University, Grace Miller found a surprise topic on the agenda: Vermont’s one-of-a-kind school funding formula.
The 22-year-old from Newport and her classmates learned about the “Brigham decision,” a 1997 Vermont Supreme Court case that found the state’s education finance system was unconstitutional.
In response to the case, the state Legislature passed Act 60, which created a funding system that allowed towns to pay equal tax rates for equal spending, regardless of local property wealth.
When Miller heard about this history in class, it took her aback.
“They were like, Vermont had this crazy court case. And you know, now they finance their education system in a really, really unique way, and it’s really equitable,” she said. “I had never heard of any of that.”
Inspired, Miller decided to dive into Vermont’s education finance system as part of her undergraduate thesis. Her topic: do school district mergers, like the ones prompted by the passage of Act 46 in 2015, save money?
Not exactly, she found.
Miller’s analysis focused on 109 school districts — 49 that underwent mergers and 60 that did not — tracking spending in a variety of categories both before and after mergers.
“I didn’t find any significant savings in spending per pupil between the merged and the non-merged districts,” she said, summarizing her findings.
In Vermont, lawmakers hoped school district mergers would streamline governance, improve educational outcomes and opportunities, and create cost efficiencies.
Miller did find that merging reduced administrative costs — about $387 per pupil. Merging also reduced the costs of contracted services (such as part-time special ed help) by $2,169 per pupil, according to her analysis.
Yet cost reductions were mostly nullified by increased spending elsewhere, Miller found, particularly on salaries, benefits and transportation.
And overall, according to her analysis, merged districts saw a slight dip in tax rates in the first year following the merger, compared to non-merged districts, but there was no significant difference in tax rates after that.
Understanding that her quantitative work could only go so far, Miller also sought to understand mergers qualitatively, interviewing superintendents and principals about their experiences.
One effect Miller found was rhetorical. People began thinking about “our district” rather than “our school,” she said, which led to more equitable decision making across a district.
But some school leaders said mergers, and with them, merged school boards, made “conversations more difficult” with more decision makers involved. Mergers also led to budgets with a higher overall dollar amount, which could lead to sticker shock for voters, even if spending per student didn’t actually rise.
In one instance, two principals in the same district provided conflicting takes on whether or not their merger saved money, Miller found.
“A lot of people just said merging did nothing,” she said.
Regardless of individual opinions on mergers, Miller found that school and district leaders felt passionately, and were eager to talk in a year when school spending has dominated local and legislative conversations across the state.
“Education finance is the conversation, and everyone has a lot to say,” she said.
As Miller began her senior year project, she said she was “shocked just how difficult it was” to procure data and find contacts for school leaders across the state. With the help of the Vermont Agency of Education, she received school district expenditure information from 2009-2023.
Few people seemed to agree on the exact purpose of Vermont’s school district mergers, Miller said.
“Everyone is on a different page, and the lack of quantitative data doesn’t help at all,” she argued.
And if an additional goal is to better student outcomes, Miller said further research will need to determine whether that has happened, starting with deciding what the best metrics are to measure those outcomes.
Fresh off graduating this spring, Miller has moved to Tennessee, where she’ll work as a public school teacher. She said she hopes to do more work on education finance in the future — perhaps in graduate school — acknowledging that her work as an undergrad could only go so deep.
Part of that drive to dig deeper comes from wanting a bigger library of research regarding Vermont’s education finance system, she said. The topic is, after all, personal to her.
Going to school in the Northeast Kingdom’s North Country Supervisory Union, “We are very keenly aware of how the state and others interact with our district versus the others,” Miller said.
North Country’s residents decided not to merge, leaving about a dozen individual school districts. That leads to increased local control, Miller ventured, but also a perhaps unwieldy web of districts.
“We do kind of have an insane system,” she said, “And I can see the thought process for trying to reorganize these educational governance structures.”
Vermont
Vermonters reimagine solar farms with sheep and pollinators
Via Community News Service, a University of Vermont journalism internship, in partnership with Vermont Public
🎧 This story was produced for the ear. We highly recommend listening to the audio. We’ve also provided a print version of the story below.
On solar farms, the ground beneath the solar panels is often planted with turf grass and left alone. But some Vermonters are experimenting with productive ways to use that land: grazing livestock, growing crops, and creating habitat for threatened pollinators and birds.
Solar makes up about 16% of the energy Vermont generates, and that number has been growing for over a decade. As solar grows, so does Vermont’s capacity for agrivoltaics — the dual use of land on solar farms for agriculture.
Lewis Fox is a sheep farmer in Leicester, Vermont. With his wife, Niko Kochendoerfer, he runs a business called Agrivoltaic Solutions. They are hired by solar companies to manage the vegetation on solar farms. “We’re in charge of keeping the vegetation within certain limits, and the sheep are the tools that we use to do it,” Fox said.
Maeve Fairfax
/
Community News Service
Fox said that sheep are ready-made for solar farms. “They’re pretty short stature, so they can really fit into nooks and crannies,” he said. “They’re also not really interested in chewing on wires or jumping on panels.” The panels also provide sheep with protection from the elements and shade, which means that the sheep don’t need to drink as much water on hot days.
Fox and Kochendoerfer work with farmers from Buffalo, New York to Bangor, Maine, helping them learn the ropes of solar grazing. Fox is also a founding member of the American Solar Grazing Association, an organization that promotes solar grazing and provides educational materials for farmers who want to get into it.
In the winter, when there is no grazing to be done, Fox and Kochendoerfer breed the sheep and sell grass-fed lamb. Fox said that the additional revenue they earn from agrivoltaics is a huge help financially. “For us as livestock producers, being able to use the animals in another way is very significant in terms of farm viability,” he said.
Solar grazing has exploded in recent years. There are currently about 130,000 acres of solar arrays in the United States grazed by sheep. “We think it’s got a bright future,” Fox said.
Maeve Fairfax
/
Community News Service
Sheep aren’t the only animals that can find food on a solar farm.
The Weybridge-based nonprofit Bee the Change is turning solar fields into habitat for bees and other pollinators. Since 2015, they’ve created habitat on 30 solar sites.
Mike Kiernan is a co-founder of Bee the Change. He said one of the organization’s main goals is to support Vermont’s native bees, many of which are threatened by loss of habitat, disease or pesticides.
Kiernan said that although some invasive plant species can be helpful to pollinators, the team at Bee the Change tries to plant native species at these sites. “Our goal is to get the highest percentage possible of native plants, because they have the longest relationship with these species,” Kiernan said.
And their efforts are working.
Maeve Fairfax
/
Community News Service
Through careful monitoring, the leaders at Bee the Change have seen pollinator populations on their sites increase dramatically in both number and diversity.
Supporting pollinators also helps support the plants they pollinate, which helps people, too. “We’re all actually connected, and our survival is connected,” said Kiernan. “And when people see a habitat that is enriched with pollinators, they are appreciative.”
Encore Renewable Energy, a Vermont-based B Corp, has hired both Kiernan and Fox to manage the vegetation on its solar sites. The company specializes in community-scale solar projects.
Chad Farrell is the co-CEO of Encore Renewable Energy. He said the company prioritizes using agrivoltaics because it’s good for local economies and good for the environment.
Solar grazing is often cheaper than mowing, and it cuts down on emissions because mowers, which run on fossil fuels, are not needed as often.
Planting native plants to build pollinator habitat can increase the soil’s potential to store carbon by 65%. It’s also good for the soil’s overall health — potentially paving the way for future agriculture on the land. “At the end of the useful life of the project, we’re actually able to return that land in a better condition than what we found,” Farrell said.
Maeve Fairfax
/
Community News Service
Some Vermonters don’t like to see agricultural land repurposed for energy production, but agrivoltaics can help alleviate this tension. “Everybody loves driving by one of our projects and seeing a bunch of sheep out there doing their thing,” Farrell said.
Lewis Fox, the sheep farmer, agrees.
“It’s often difficult for people to see solar being built on ag land, for various reasons, and I think you could argue the merits either way,” he said. “But we can help bridge the gap in that. What we’re able to do is have solar production coexist with agriculture. And it’s not just window dressing. It’s real agriculture.”
Vermont
Tourism Leaders To Gather In Killington For Vermont Tourism Summit
Vermont
Vermont residents remain concerned over potential environmental provisions
This week, a bill that would make changes to Vermont’s Act 181 is receiving testimony in the House Committee on Environment. Certain provisions in Act 181 could trigger a permitting process through Vermont’s land use protection law, Act 250. A rule related to road building and some lands identified as “critical natural resource areas” by the state’s land use review board are expected to take effect this year. Last month, legislation passed the Senate and is currently in the House to push those deadlines back by a few years. For Corinth resident Neil Ryan, that not enough. “The group of people that was largely left out of the process: Rural Vermonters are having this imposed upon them with no say,” he said. Ryan and his family have built their own farms for generations. He believes if the provisions take effect, it would be very difficult for future generations to accomplish what he has. “The difficulty of the Act 250 process, the costs associated with the Act 250 process, we wouldn’t have started those farms likely,” he said. However, Ryan said he does support the portion of Act 181 that allows towns to opt into being exempt from the permitting process altogether. This is meant to assist housing development. On Tuesday, regional planning commissions told lawmakers that many towns have opted in. Still, Vermont is not on track for its goal of 40,000 + homes by 2030. “We’re not saying rural housing growth should stop or slow,” Executive Director of the Northwest RPC Catherine Dimitruk said. “Were saying those additional units that we need, we should be doing all we can to encourage and incentivize.”The bill will remain in House environment for the foreseeable future.
This week, a bill that would make changes to Vermont’s Act 181 is receiving testimony in the House Committee on Environment.
Certain provisions in Act 181 could trigger a permitting process through Vermont’s land use protection law, Act 250.
A rule related to road building and some lands identified as “critical natural resource areas” by the state’s land use review board are expected to take effect this year.
Last month, legislation passed the Senate and is currently in the House to push those deadlines back by a few years. For Corinth resident Neil Ryan, that not enough.
“The group of people that was largely left out of the process: Rural Vermonters are having this imposed upon them with no say,” he said.
Ryan and his family have built their own farms for generations. He believes if the provisions take effect, it would be very difficult for future generations to accomplish what he has.
“The difficulty of the Act 250 process, the costs associated with the Act 250 process, we wouldn’t have started those farms likely,” he said.
However, Ryan said he does support the portion of Act 181 that allows towns to opt into being exempt from the permitting process altogether. This is meant to assist housing development.
On Tuesday, regional planning commissions told lawmakers that many towns have opted in. Still, Vermont is not on track for its goal of 40,000 + homes by 2030.
“We’re not saying rural housing growth should stop or slow,” Executive Director of the Northwest RPC Catherine Dimitruk said. “Were saying those additional units that we need, we should be doing all we can to encourage and incentivize.”
The bill will remain in House environment for the foreseeable future.
-
Atlanta, GA4 days ago1 teenage girl killed, another injured in shooting at Piedmont Park, police say
-
Culture1 week agoDo You Know Where These Famous Authors Are Buried?
-
Movie Reviews1 week agoVaazha 2 first half review: Hashir anchors a lively, chaos-filled teen tale
-
Georgia2 days agoGeorgia House Special Runoff Election 2026 Live Results
-
Pennsylvania2 days agoParents charged after toddler injured by wolf at Pennsylvania zoo
-
Education1 week agoVideo: We Put Dyson’s $600 Vacuum to the Test
-
Milwaukee, WI3 days agoPotawatomi Casino Hotel evacuated after fire breaks out in rooftop HVAC system
-
Entertainment1 week agoInside Ye’s first comeback show at SoFi Stadium