Connect with us

New York

Read the Ruling on the Judgment Against Trump in the E. Jean Carroll Case

Published

on

Read the Ruling on the Judgment Against Trump in the E. Jean Carroll Case

Case: 24-644, 09/08/2025, DktEntry: 134.1, Page 28 of 70

statements at issue in this case were made three years earlier than the statement

in Carroll II, the statements were identical in material respects because both

accused Carroll of fabricating the sexual assault allegations for improper
purposes. Compare supra pp. 6-8 (June 2019 statements), with supra pp. 13-14 (October 2022 statement). 14
The truth or falsity of Trump’s statements in both 2019 and 2022
turned on whether Carroll was lying, that is, whether Trump sexually assaulted Carroll in 1996, irrespective of the specific sexual act committed. 15 The jury in

14



For example, in the 2022 statement which the Carroll II jury determined to be false — Trump stated, among other things: “I have no idea who [E. Jean Carroll] is.” Carroll, 690 F. Supp. 3d at 401. In the June 21, 2019 statement at issue here, Trump said: “I’ve never met this person in my life.” App’x at 1887. Moreover, in the 2022 statement, Trump said: “She completely made up a story that I met her . . . and, within minutes, ‘swooned’ her. It is a Hoax and a lie,” “it never happened,” and “for the record, E. Jean Carroll is not telling the truth, is a woman who I had nothing to do with, didn’t know, and would have no interest in knowing her if I ever had the chance.” Supp. App’x at 108. In the June 21, 2019 statement, Trump said: “Shame on those who make up false stories of assault to try to get publicity for themselves,” “I would like to thank Bergdorf Goodman for confirming that they have no video footage of any such incident, because it never happened,” and “[f]alse accusations diminish the severity of real assault.” App’x at 1887.

15

In other words, the application of issue preclusion to the falsity element is proper because Trump’s 2019 and 2022 statements did not turn on the specific sexual act he committed. He did not deny, for example, digital penetration specifically. In all statements, he denied any sexual assault, full stop. The Carroll II jury found Trump’s 2022 statement to be false because it found that he sexually abused Carroll. See Tannerite Sports, LLC v. NBCUniversal News Grp., a division of NBCUniversal Media, LLC, 864 F.3d 236, 242 (2d Cir. 2017) (Under New York law, “to satisfy the falsity element of a

28

New York

Metropolitan Diary Challenge Day 1: What Is Your N.Y. Story?

Published

on

Metropolitan Diary Challenge Day 1: What Is Your N.Y. Story?

Welcome to the Metropolitan Diary challenge, part of our 50th anniversary celebration for a column that, by design, could only have gotten this far with readers’ contributions. Metropolitan Diary is a weekly collection of New York experiences that capture the essence of this remarkable metropolis at its best — and it is composed entirely of submissions from readers sharing short personal stories.

In the next two days, the plan is to help you carry us to the 100-year mark. We want your New York story! Today, we’ll help you jog your memory to find a good one. Tomorrow, we’ll offer tips for how to turn it into a great written submission.

Advertisement

Metropolitan Diary is a grab bag with one constant: Every story is set in the city. Odd snippets overheard on the street; snappy comebacks from waiters; random encounters with strangers that illuminate human kindness; and, of course, the occasional celebrity sighting. It’s all column fodder.

So what’s your Metropolitan Diary story? First, a few basic parameters: It must be true, something you saw or experienced firsthand and be a tale you can tell in no more than 300 words (we are quite strict about that). We keep politics, and pretty much anything else that could be divisive, out. Also, nothing vulgar and, generally, no “kids say the darndest things.” Again, when we say “Metropolitan,” we really do mean a story about New York City.

Advertisement

Beyond that, it’s up to you. It’s almost certainly true that the submissions we wind up publishing begin with something that stuck in the author’s head for whatever reason — for a day, a week or 20 years — and made them think, “that’s New York to me.” It’s something you can’t wait to share with a partner, parent or friend over coffee or drinks. And very often, it’s something that others can easily relate to because there is something familiar in the details.

A story like this may already be in the back of your mind or on the tip of your tongue. If you’re unsure of how to begin the process of writing it down, consider these durable Diary categories as potential starting points. Here are some popular standbys:

Advertisement

Getting From One Place to Another

New York’s mass transit system, that great urban unifier, is a reliable source of items. Virtually everyone rides the subway or buses. Do you recall something funny that happened on the train? Ever see something unexpected during your daily commute? Did running late (or early) put you in a spot to meet someone you otherwise wouldn’t have?

Advertisement

Advertisement

The Kindness of Strangers

Did a stranger ever do you a good deed or vice versa?

Advertisement

Nostalgic Places

Advertisement

Do you have a memory of a special moment tied to one of the city’s well-known landmarks or neighborhoods? Is there a particular room at the Met or a favorite diner in Queens where you once had a memorable encounter?

Memorable Lines

Advertisement

Do you still laugh about something you overheard a passer-by say? Did a waitress or counterman ever respond to your order with a snappy comeback dripping with New York attitude?

Did these stories remind you of anything? Spend some time today thinking about it. Once you have some ideas, jot them down. Come back tomorrow for Day 2 of the Metropolitan Diary challenge and we’ll help you develop one of them into a full story.

Advertisement

Continue Reading

New York

Video: Historic Brooklyn Church Destroyed in Fire

Published

on

Video: Historic Brooklyn Church Destroyed in Fire

new video loaded: Historic Brooklyn Church Destroyed in Fire

The South Bushwick Church in Brooklyn was engulfed in flames on Friday, and the cause of the fire is still under investigation. The church was built in 1853 and is Bushwick’s oldest landmark, according to an expert.

By Meg Felling

June 22, 2026

Continue Reading

New York

How a Security Guard Lives on $46,000 a Year in the East Bronx

Published

on

How a Security Guard Lives on ,000 a Year in the East Bronx

How can people possibly afford to live in one of the most expensive cities on the planet? It’s a question New Yorkers hear a lot, often delivered with a mix of awe, pity and confusion.

We surveyed hundreds of New Yorkers about how they spend, splurge and save. We found that many people — rich, poor or somewhere in between — live life as a series of small calculations that add up to one big question: What makes living in New York worth it?

Advertisement

Maruf Abubakari Sadick left Ghana for New York in April 2023, confident he was prepared for chilly weather.

When he arrived that morning, the temperatures were in the 50s. He might as well have arrived during a snowstorm.

Advertisement

“‘It’s really cold,’” he told his brother, who laughed and reminded him it wasn’t even winter. His brother brought him a warm jacket, sparking a love affair with outerwear, as well as clothes and colognes.

Three years later, these are the little luxuries on which Mr. Sadick splurges when he is not working two jobs as a security officer in the city.

“I really like to look good, and I like to smell good,” Mr. Sadick, 37, said. “I just tell myself ‘I work too hard. It’s self care.’”

Advertisement

Together, his security jobs bring in close to $46,000 a year, which pays for rent, remittances to his family in Ghana, Wi-Fi, his phone bill and groceries. At the end of the month, he squirrels away what he can so he can one day pay for nursing school.

His rent is $700 a month, which affords him a room in a four-bedroom, one-bathroom apartment in the East Bronx that he shares with two other men and one woman.

Advertisement

“Funny enough, we don’t have a schedule for the bathroom,” Mr. Sadick said. “It’s not easy.”

He buys a 30-pound bag of rice for $30 from the nearby bodega that lasts him about three months and a 40-pack of Poland Spring water for $20 so he can bring a bottle to work.

The housemates often share food, usually fish stews and okra soups that Mr. Sadick pours into a thermos, along with the rice, which he then takes to work. It helps him avoid paying for takeout which can cost more than $20.

Advertisement

Mr. Sadick said he learned quickly that to survive in New York, you need to share.

Two Jobs, Little Sleep

Advertisement

Mr. Sadick makes $17 an hour at both jobs, earning the current minimum wage in the city. By next year, he could be making at least $22.20 an hour, with two weeks of paid vacation and paid holidays.

The bump in pay is part of the Aland Etienne Safety and Security Act, a city law that Mayor Zohran Mamdani signed shortly after he took office that set a minimum wage for security guards. The law, which also requires employers to contribute to paid time off and health benefits, was named after the security officer who was fatally shot in July 2025 at 345 Park Avenue by a gunman who killed three others before killing himself.

Mr. Sadick did not know Mr. Etienne, but he said his death terrified him and other security officers, who realized how vulnerable they were at work.

Advertisement

The job “seems easy,” he said. “It seems quiet. Then, one moment, it’s all chaos.”

From Tuesday to Friday he works a four to eight-hour shift when he guards a sprawling office complex in Long Island City, Queens.

Advertisement

On weekends, he guards a drug and alcohol rehabilitation center in East Harlem from 8 a.m. to 4 p.m. When his shift ends, he takes the subway for a 40-minute commute back to the office complex in Queens, where he works 12-hour overnight shifts on Saturday and Sunday.

Three days a week he takes GED classes in the morning, which are free to state residents. Mondays are his one day off, which he uses “to make up for the two days that I don’t sleep,” Mr. Sadick said.

During the summers, when school is not in session, he tries to make some money selling bus tours to tourists around Times Square. On a good day, he will make $250 to $500 in commissions. On bad days, he will spend five hours in the heat with nothing to show for it.

Advertisement

He said he was exhausted, but driven to pursue a career in medicine.

“I like to take care of people,” he said.

Advertisement

Sending Help Home

A big part of Mr. Sadick’s salary goes to his family in Ghana. On average, he will send $500 a month to help pay for his parents’ food, his grandmother’s health aide and his sister’s schooling.

Advertisement

Last month, he sent a $1,200 so that his parents could buy two sheep. He sent the money through Taptap Send, an app that lets people send money to countries in Africa, Asia, the Caribbean and Latin America.

The sheep should provide enough meat to last them a couple of months, he said. His brother sent over $2,000 around the same time so that their extended family could buy a bull.

Sending money home is “expected,” Mr. Sadick said, adding that he feels “very good” about being able to help.

Advertisement

“We are brought up in a system where it’s all about family,” he said. “You are brought up to provide.”

Self-Care Is Worth the Splurge

Advertisement

When Mr. Sadick has extra money in his pocket, he will pop into Zara or Macy’s, where he shops for shoes, jackets and button-down shirts.

He has six bottles of cologne. His favorites are Al Rehab Lord Eau De Parfum and Mountain Woody Forest from Zara. The Al Rehab cologne, which sells for $10.95 an ounce on Amazon, is for daytime. He saves the Mountain Woody Forest — $74.99 on Amazon — for special occasions.

Advertisement

He owns 18 pairs of shoes, including red and white Air Jordans that he bought for $200 and a pair of brown, suede boots from Zara that cost $100.

“These are my favorites,” he said, stroking the soft Zara boots. “I look a bit professional in them.”

He is still trying to figure out what he will do when his salary goes up.

Advertisement

Most likely, he said he would keep working both jobs so that he could save more money. But he daydreams about quitting one of them.

It would be nice, Mr. Sadick said, to get more sleep, have time to play soccer and visit art museums.

Advertisement

What he would really like is more time to take long walks.

One of his favorite places to walk is Dumbo, where he worked briefly guarding a construction site and fell in love with the sweeping views of Manhattan and the cool breeze that comes off the water.

A place in Dumbo, he said, would be the ultimate indulgence.

Advertisement

“That would be a dream come true,” Mr. Sadick said. “It’s so nice there.”

We are talking to New Yorkers about how they spend, splurge and save.

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending