New Jersey
Best hidden gem restaurants in New Jersey? 15 spots worth the trip
Hidden gem restaurants across New Jersey
From restaurants behind gas stations to bakeries tucked on side streets, these are the hidden gems worth visiting across New Jersey.
You already know about the bar pie at Star Tavern in Orange and have splurged on the chef’s tasting at Elements, a Princeton farm-to-table eatery that’s been called the best restaurant in New Jersey.
You’ve enjoyed the steak at The Butcher’s Block in Long Branch, and gathered with friends and family for prime rib and the salad bar at The Pub in Pennsauken.
These are the New Jersey restaurants, among so many others, that earn heaps of attention and praise — and deservedly so. But our state is peppered with hidden gems that fly under the radar, quietly putting out excellent food and great service without all the fanfare.
Here are 15 to try.
Café on the DL, Laurel Springs
Chef and owner Dan DiGiuseppe opened Café on the DL in a Marlton corporate office buliding in 2022.
But the restaurant quickly outgrew that space.
“Things took off for us in 2023 and 2024 and it allowed us to outgrow the small, restrictive space in Marlton,” DiGiuseppe said. “We shifted everything to Laurel Springs, opening there in January of 2025.”
At the 40-seat Café on the DL, which serves lunch and dinner, popular dishes include the “Chicken Italiano” and “Truff, Buff & Crispy Honey” sandwiches, the “Off the Walldorf” salad, and short rib grilled cheese, garlic-parm tots, and “anything short rib,” DiGiuseppe said.
“Our short rib is a 16-hour prep start to finish, fall-off-the-bone tender and very popular,” he said.
DiGiuseppe still has the Marlton space, now called Greentree on the DL. It is a grab-and-go satellite location serving breakfast and lunch takeout on weekdays.
Go: 415 N. White Horse Pike, Laurel Springs; 856-656-9282; instagram.com/cafeonthedl
The Cubby Hole, Moorestown
Tucked away on Main Street, The Cubby Hole is a lovely little breakfast, brunch and lunch spot in Moorestown.
Owned by township couple Tyler and Aimee Dahl, The Cubby Hole, which originally opened in a smaller space down the street, moved to its current location in 2020. The space is cozy and intimate with a handful of tables, plus outdoor seating. If you venture in, you will likely be pleased with the made-from-scratch offerings and bright, welcoming atmosphere.
The menu boasts apple cinnamon and banana walnut pancakes, blueberry ricotta lemon pancakes, crêpes, Greek yogurt, huevos con salsa, spicy avocado toast, omelets, breakfast sandwiches and wraps. There also are seasonal specialties such as strawberry shortcake French toast and honey butter pancakes.
Fresh coffee, cold brew, lattes, chai and more are served, too.
Go: 37 East Main St.; 856-234-4372; instagram.com/thecubbyholemoorestown
Fresh Tiki Bar, Somerville
A small-but-mighty sweet tooth’s paradise, Fresh Tiki Bar offers unique handcrafted desserts, with new options added all the time. Holidays are especially festive, as seasonal delights are always on the menu, too.
Its creations include waffles on a stick with warm butter glaze, toppings and drizzles; ice cream sandwiches made with doughnuts and bubble waffles; and hot cocoa in flavors like Nutella, butterscotch and mint.
The desserts are served in a space that is just as fun as the menu. Pink walls are adorned with tropical touches in every corner, including neon flamingos, fluffy pink rugs, wicker chairs topped with plush pink cushions, and palm tree backdrops.
Go: 5C Division St., Somerville; 908-307-6002, instagram.com/freshtikibar
Haute Feast, Barnegat
You will have to wait until spring to enjoy a meal from Haute Feast, but the dishes crafted by Chefs Pablo Toxqui and Josh Blanco are worth the wait.
Located on the waterfront property of Barnegat Oyster Collective, a nursery-to-harvest oyster operation, the seasonal, farm-to-table BYOB is led by Toxqui, previously of Heirloom at the St. Laurent in Asbury Park and One Willow in Highlands, and his wife, Carey Semprevivo.
They showcase local oysters by serving them raw, cooking them over fire on an outdoor grill and dotting them with butter, or turning them into chowder. Local vegetables are put to use in dishes like “Fancy Toast,” made with grilled Benchmark Breads sourdough topped with mint pea hummus, pickled turnips, green garlic and chive blossoms, and a teres major filet with beet horseradish cream and potato cheddar foam.
Go: 483 East Bay Ave., Barnegat; hautefeast.com
Kimchi-Hana, South Plainfield
Don’t let the half-lit “SUSHI” sign at Kimchi-Hana in the Burlington Coat Factory strip mall fool you. This Korean barbecue eatery in South Plainfield is usually filled with a savory smell and (mostly) Korean customers, eating marinated meats cooked over an open charbroiler on their individual tables.
Although there are lots of options for Korean entrees at Kimchi-Hana, such as seafood hot pots full of cod and vegetables as well as rice bowls and noodle dishes, the go-to is the Korean barbecue, which can go bite-for-bite against any revered New York City Korean barbecue spot.
For two people, choose two or three meats (our favorites are wang kal bi, or marinated beef short rib, and beef tongue). These meats are accompanied by lettuce wraps and 10-plus plates of traditional side dishes including kimchi, made from fermented and seasoned vegetables.
Go: 6101 Hadley Road, South Plainfield; 908-755-0777, kimchi-hana.com
Koon Thai Eatery, Hillsdale
Thai dishes are turned on their heads, renamed and reinvented at Koon Thai Eatery in Hillsdale, because at this 2 year-old Bergen treasure, putting a contemporary twist on comfort classics is the driving vision.
Instead of pad see ew, Thai fried rice and satay chicken, (though they still have those, if you want), you’ll see “Hunger” (a flat, wide rice noodle dish topped with shrimp, sausage, chili jam and cashews), “Holy Fried Rice” (featuring garlic, sweet peppers, corn, basil, two types of soy sauce and more) and satay tacos (finished with peanut sauce and pickled vegetables).
From the fried Brussels sprouts drowning in whipped coconut milk to the crispy “Chicken Bomb” dripping with tamarind lime sauce, the chef’s specialties on the menu are entirely unique.
When we visit, we most enjoy the tempura-style red snapper with fried shallots; it’s tender, crunchy and reflective of that old-meets-new thesis. The crispy chicken thigh pad Thai, though, is a close second.
Go: 126 Broadway, Hillsdale; 551-246-3646, koonthaieatery.com
La Vita Italian Specialties, Sparta
Hidden in a bowling alley strip mall, La Vita Italian Specialties is a European provisions shop turning out some of the most delicious lunches in Sussex County. Run by the husband and wife-duo Wade Moises and Alexandra Hast — alumni of Del Posto, Rosemary’s and other powerhouse New York City restaurants — the tiny “deli” serves Michelin Bib Gourmand-caliber food in entirely unsuspecting digs.
Offered on a daily basis are fresh pastas, artisan sandwiches, house-made sausages, vegetable antipasti and more. The seafood specials, when served, come in varieties from tomato-glazed calamari glassato (with capers, raisins, garlic and chili) to slow-poached octopus, and the light-and-fluffy focaccia may be the best in the state. Opt for a sandwich, and you’ll end up with a top-notch showstopper featuring spice-rubbed lamb shoulder, chicken cutlets brined in mozzarella whey or even porchetta (with caramelized fennel).
And for dessert? Expect decadent sweets like ricotta bomboloni and chocolate espresso tiramisu.
Go: 83 Woodport Road, Sparta; 973-826-4624, lavitasparta.com
Loving Indian Kitchen, West Creek
You can count on one hand the number of Indian restaurants in Ocean County, which makes the addition of Loving Indian Kitchen, which opened less than a year ago in the tiny town of West Creek, so exciting.
The restaurant, which seats about two dozen diners, is a blink-and-you’ll-miss-it kind of place behind Brennan Fuels on Route 9. But gas station food, this is not. The menu is packed with authentic dishes, and the dining room is decorated with a floor-to-ceiling map of India.
Start with potato and pea-stuffed samosas, which come dusted with chaat masala and alongside mint and tamarind chutneys, or shrimp tandoori marinated in yogurt, spices and ginger. Chicken biryani is tender, fragrant and perfectly spiced, and cheese-stuffed garlic naan is perfect for dipping in butter chicken.
Go: 331 Main St., West Creek; 732-851-2955, loving-kitchen.com
Luca’s Ristorante, Somerset
Forget the tired Italian-American plates of chicken Parmesan and spaghetti and meatballs when you visit this authentic Italian restaurant, tucked into an unassuming Route 27 strip mall.
True to its motto, this 20-year-old family-owned restaurant offers an authentic yet modern taste of Ischia, an island in the Bay of Naples, with dishes like short rib chuck and ground beef meatballs with pine nuts and golden raisins, and cocoa agnolotti stuffed with butternut squash in an herb sauce.
The restaurant’s ambiance is just as flavorful as its fare, with an intimate space decked out with exposed brick walls, Italian murals and an old grape press.
Go: 2019 Route 27, Somerset; 732-297-7676, lucasristorante.com
Pierogies House, Morristown
Pierogies House owner Evelina Berc was born and raised in Leżajsk, Poland, where she learned family recipes (many from her grandmother) that are now on the menu at this cozy Morristown eatery, blocks off the Green.
The menu at Pierogies House includes pierogi (of course), bigos, stuffed cabbage, potato pancakes and more, all made from recipes passed down for decades in Berc’s family. They were recipes worth passing down: Everything here is delicious, from the classic pierogi of potatoes and cheese and kielbasa and sauerkraut to the modern culinary creations of Philly cheesesteak and vegan butternut squash varieties.
Order a bunch for the table, get a side of some world-class applesauce to go with the potato pancakes, don’t skip out on the bigos (hunter’s stew), and most certainly order a few stuffed cabbage rolls.
Go: 145 Morris St., Morristown; 973-432-8270, pierogieshouse.com
Shokra Soups, Willingboro
Shokra Soups, which focuses on vegan food, is a welcoming respite on a cold winter day.
Why? It’s in the name.
Soup offerings include navy bean, plant-based gumbo, plant-based wonton and much more. The restaurant also makes vegan and gluten-free lasagna, a plant-based lentil cheesesteak, smoothies, and wraps with fillings like jackfruit and plant-based tuna.
Shokra Soups is owned by Willingboro couple Cory and Ada Cottingham, and their eatery is not just a restaurant. The Cottinghams are part of wellness and educational empowerment workshops in town and have participated in food drives, too.
The restaurant also shares kitchen space with The Supreme Sweets Dessert Shop, which is located behind Shokra Soups in East Ridge Plaza and is known for its banana pudding and bean pies. Both are Black-owned businesses.
Go: 621 Beverly-Rancocas Road, Suite 2C; 609-614-1912, instagram.com/shokrasoups
Shoti Bread House, Fair Lawn
Georgian food may be the new “it” cuisine in America’s biggest cities, but in New Jersey, a good Adjaruli khachapuri — the country’s iconic boat-shaped, egg yolk-topped cheese bread — is harder to come by. Residents of Bergen County, however, are lucky to call their stomping ground home to a humble hole-in-the-wall serving authentic versions of all of the nation’s edible staples.
Shoti Bread House is an Eastern European fan favorite acclaimed for its made-to-order cheese breads, such as Imeruli, a pizza-sized round bread filled with sulguni cheese; Royal khachapuri, which is similar but boasts a flaky, phyllo-reminiscent dough; and the aforementioned Adjaruli.
Saluting only the restaurant’s breads, though, would be doing it a disservice, as the chefs also whip up killer khinkali (Georgian soup dumplings), savory khashi (a beef soup rumored to cure hangovers) and flavorful grilled meat skewers, to name a few.
Go: 14-29 River Road, Fair Lawn; 201-272-1900, instagram.com/shoti_bread_house
Tulip Tree Cafe, Howell
If dining in a pretty, homey and soothing space is something you enjoy, head to Tulip Tree Cafe.
The breakfast and lunch restaurant, which serves dinner on occassion, operates inside a farmhouse at Calgo Gardens, a garden center and gift shop in Howell. Dining inside feels like eating at a friend’s house, with low lighting, soft music, dining room tables and bench seating, and freshly baked muffins on the counter. When the weather is nice, opt for an outdoor patio in the garden.
The menu is full of familiar breakfast dishes — omelets with toast and fruit, challah French toast, and avocado toast with smoked salmon — that are made from family recipes, from scratch and with produce grown on the property. For lunch, a popular choice is a sandwich of thinly sliced avocado, roasted red peppers, tomato, arugula and sweet balsamic glaze, with a side of tangy, dilly potato salad, and other options include egg salad made with local eggs, and Waldorf chicken salad.
Go: 462 Adelphia Road, Freehold (physically in Howell); 732-256-9649, tuliptreecafe.com
Versac Main Street Cafe, Hackettstown
Just outside of downtown Hackettstown lies the hidden gem that is Versac Main Street Cafe, a Colombian-American spot with a huge menu and even bigger portions.
Go for breakfast, lunch or dinner; it’s all good. Breakfast offerings include a long list of omelets, a variety of breakfast arepas, huevos rancheros and more. Lunch includes American and Colombian sandwiches and wraps, and dinner brings fantastic entrées like lomo saltado, shrimp in garlic sauce, plantain patacones, steaks, seafood and much more.
Wrap up your meal with some Colombian sweets and pastries and you’ll be making plans to return to this spot.
Go: 103 Main St., Hackettstown; 908-850-7678, mainst-cafe.com
West Milford Airport Diner, West Milford
Hobby aviators in North Jersey may know West Milford Airport Diner well, but those unfamiliar with this casual eatery with an expansive, evolving menu ought to make plans to visit. You don’t need a plane, but you will need a car to travel through the forested, rolling hills that lead to the airport.
Like all great diners, the ambiance is immaculate, the service is friendly and quick, and the menu is robust. Unlike most diners, there’s a giant model airplane attached to the building. That alone is a sight worth seeing, but go on a calm day and you’ll see planes take off and land on the adjacent runway while you dine.
And what dining there is: all your diner favorites, plus a rotating list of inventive menu items and specials like maple chili chicken and waffles, a grilled mango and pineapple yogurt bowl, a falafel sandwich, a scrapple skillet, and barbecue chickpea and avocado flatbread.
Go: 126 Airport Road, West Milford; 973-506-6020, facebook.com/WMAirportDiner
New Jersey
Woman charged with theft for taking dog outside N.J. home, police say
A woman has been charged with theft for taking a dog outside a Clifton, New Jersey, home in April, police say.
Last month, William Chan told CBS News New York his dog, a 7-year-old Shih Tzu-Yorkshire Terrier mix named Rocky, somehow got out of the house on April 5 while his nephew was dog-sitting.
The Clifton Police Department said investigators determined that while Rocky was loose, he ran down the street and was running in or near the road at times.
Video shows Rocky did eventually return to his own yard, and a child holding a blanket can be seen chasing the dog before a woman gets out of a black SUV parked in the road. Rocky then runs onto the back porch of his home, where the woman and child corner him, grab him with a blanket, take him back to the SUV, and drive away.
The family said Rocky was wearing a harness and ID tag at the time.
Police said the woman did not make any attempt to talk to anyone inside the home or any neighbors, and neither animal control nor police received any calls about a loose dog being found on that day.
Chan called police on April 6 to report that Rocky had possibly been stolen, and investigators were later able to identify 29-year-old Mery Cepeda-Chevalier, of Newark, as a person of interest.
Officers spotted Cepeda-Chevalier’s vehicle in Passaic on April 8 and pulled her over, police said.
According to police, Cepeda-Chevalier cooperated with detectives, admitted she had Rocky, and agreed to have the detectives follow her back to her home. She then handed over the dog, and detectives reunited Rocky with his family.
On Thursday, Cepeda-Chevalier was charged via summons with one count of theft of a domestic companion animal.
New Jersey
Browns Hand Out New Jersey Uniform Numbers for All 10 Draftees, Plus a Dozen UDFAs
The Cleveland Browns announced jersey numbers for all 10 draftees, as the team’s rookie minicamp is underway at the CrossCountry Mortgage Campus.
While First-round picks Spencer Fano and KC Concepcion had already shown off their numbers — 55 and 17, respectively .. at their introductory press conference a few days ago, the jersey numbers for other rookies hadn’t been disclosed until today.
Second-round wideout Denzel Boston will now wear No. 12, quarterback Shedeur Sanders’ old number. Sanders, a fifth-rounder last year, had previously announced a switch to his old college No. 2 beforehand.
Fifth-round linebacker Justin Jefferson has been assigned jersey No. 10, which was used by last year’s second-round running back Quinshon Judkins. No announcement has been made yet on Judkins possibly changing his number, though. He wore No. 1 at Ohio State.
Not all jersey numbers are available in Cleveland, as the team has officially retired five of them: 14 (Otto Graham), 32 (Jim Brown), 45 (Ernie Davis), 46 (Don Fleming) and 76 (Lou Groza).
|
Jersey |
Round |
Pick |
Name |
Position |
School |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
|
55 |
1 |
9 |
Spencer Fano |
OT |
Utah |
|
17 |
1 |
24 |
KC Concepcion |
WR |
Texas A&M |
|
12 |
2 |
39 |
Denzel Boston |
WR |
Washington |
|
28 |
2 |
58 |
Emmanuel McNeil-Warren |
S |
Toledo |
|
58 |
3 |
86 |
Austin Barber |
OT |
Florida |
|
52 |
5 |
146 |
Parker Brailsford |
C |
Alabama |
|
10 |
5 |
149 |
Justin Jefferson |
LB |
Alabama |
|
18 |
5 |
170 |
Joe Royer |
TE |
Cincinnati |
|
15 |
6 |
182 |
Taylen Green |
QB |
Arkansas |
|
48 |
7 |
248 |
Carsen Ryan |
TE |
BYU |
At this point in time, eiht of the 10 rookies drafted by Cleveland in last months 2026 NFL Draft have signed their contracts. The only still-unsigned draftees are wideout Concepcion and safety Emmanuel McNeil-Warren.
In these cases, players sign a participation agreement that covers the team’s liability during the event, ensuring players are covered for injury.
Browns officially add 12 undrafted free agents
Cleveland also announced the formal signing of 12 undrafted free agents to complete it’s rookie class.
The most notable name on this list appears to be Logan Fano, a defensive end out of Utah who just happens to be Spencer Fano’s brother.
All undrafted free agent rookies were also assigned their numbers for the Browns’ rookie minicamp.
|
Jersey |
Name |
Position |
School |
|---|---|---|---|
|
29 |
Davon Booth |
RB |
Mississippi State |
|
34 |
Zion Washington |
S |
Boise State |
|
36 |
TJ Harden |
RB |
SMU |
|
36 |
Wes Pahl |
P |
Oklahoma State |
|
38 |
Kole Wilson |
WR |
Baylor |
|
43 |
Nate Evans |
CB |
Delaware |
|
47 |
DeCarlos Nicholson |
CB |
USC |
|
60 |
Izavion Miller |
OT |
Auburn |
|
64 |
Tyreak Sapp |
DE |
Florida |
|
66 |
Bernard Gooden |
DT |
LSU |
|
90 |
Khordae Sydnor |
DE |
Vanderbilt |
|
97 |
Logan Fano |
DE |
Utah |
Other players that have reportedly accepted invites to Browns’ rookie minicamp include Utah State quarterback Bryson Barnes, West Virginia linebacker Reid Carrico, Fordham linebacker James Conway, and Bowling Green tight end Jyrin Johnson.
Follow
New Jersey
Crash closes Route 38 in Hainesport, New Jersey
A serious crash in Hainesport, New Jersey, has forced Route 38 to close Thursday night.
The crash happened on Route 38 near Creek Road at around 9:30 p.m. Chopper 3 was over the scene, where two cars were badly damaged.
According to Burlington County dispatch, several people were injured in the crash.
This is a developing story and will be updated.
-
Lifestyle19 seconds agoHe’s your ex, not your son. Unconditional love does not apply
-
Politics6 minutes agoCommentary: For all the chatter by mayoral candidates, can anyone fix L.A.’s enduring problems?
-
Sports18 minutes agoPrep talk: Southern Section Division 1 semifinals features matchup of boys’ volleyball powers
-
World30 minutes agoEurope Day: 40 years of ties between Spain and the European Union
-
News1 hour agoFrontier Airlines plane hits person on runway during takeoff at Denver airport
-
New York3 hours agoMan Dies in Subway Attack; Mamdani Orders Inquiry Into Suspect’s Release From Bellevue
-
Detroit, MI3 hours agoPatchy dense fog turns to stronger thunderstorms for Metro Detroit to start the weekend
-
San Francisco, CA3 hours agoWhere to watch Pittsburgh Pirates vs San Francisco Giants: TV channel, start time, streaming for May 9