Connect with us

News

Post Office’s lawyers instructed investigator to defend faulty IT system, inquiry told

Published

on

Post Office’s lawyers instructed investigator to defend faulty IT system, inquiry told

Unlock the Editor’s Digest for free

A Post Office investigator said he was taking instruction from the company’s lawyers when he claimed there were no problems with the Horizon IT system and denied acting like a “mafia gangster” in his dealings with some of the sub-postmasters caught up in the scandal.

Appearing before the long-running public inquiry into one of Britain’s biggest miscarriages of justice, which resumed on Thursday, Stephen Bradshaw said law firm Cartwright King, which was acting for the Post Office, wrote a statement signed by him in 2012 defending the faulty IT system.

The statement dated November 2012 said: “The Post Office continues to have absolute confidence in the robustness and integrity of its Horizon system.”

Advertisement

Asked if it was appropriate to declare “confidence” in the IT system, whose faults were responsible for accounting shortfalls that the Post Office had blamed on hundreds of sub-postmasters, he said: “I was given that statement by Cartwright King and told to put that statement through. In hindsight . . . there probably should have been another line stating, ‘These are not my words’.”

Bradshaw had earlier told the inquiry he was not “technically minded” and was not equipped to know whether there were bugs or errors in the Horizon system.

Bradshaw’s evidence marks the return of the inquiry into the Post Office-Fujitsu scandal after the winter break. During the recess the ITV series Mr Bates vs The Post Office lead to widespread outrage about a scandal that has been mired by cover-ups and inertia for decades, forcing the government to intervene this week.

More than 700 sub-postmasters were prosecuted using data from faulty Horizon software between 2000 and 2014; only 93 convictions have been overturned. 

In a written statement to the inquiry Bradshaw, who joined the Post Office in 1978 and began working as an investigator in 2000, denied claims he and others had “behaved like Mafia gangsters” in their dealings with sub-postmasters falsely accused of wrongdoing. “I refute the allegation that I am a liar,” he wrote.

Advertisement

Sub-postmaster Jacqueline McDonald has previously accused Bradshaw of “bullying” her during interviews conducted to ascertain whether she had engaged in any financial misconduct or theft, and said investigators had acted like “mafia gangsters”.

Asked if this approach was appropriate, Bradshaw said the interviews were conducted at “pace” and were not supposed to be “nice”. Earlier he had told the inquiry: “The investigations were done correctly.”

Inquiry counsel Julian Blake pointed to a transcript of one interview with McDonald in which Bradshaw accused her of telling a “pack of lies”.

One of the most serious allegations levelled at Post Office investigators is that they repeatedly told sub-postmasters they were the only ones experiencing issues with the Horizon system and accounting shortfalls when in reality hundreds of people were alerting the Post Office to problems.

A transcript was shown of an interview with McDonald in which she was told by another investigator present that she was the only one with shortfalls in their balance, which Bradshaw did not query.

Advertisement

He told the inquiry he was just a “small cog in the system” and that any concerns about the Horizon IT system the Post Office might have had were not passed down to him by his superiors.

The statutory inquiry began in 2021 and is chaired by retired judge Sir Wyn Williams. It previously probed the human impact of the scandal and the rollout of the Horizon system and is now looking at the action taken against sub-postmasters.

News

Reflections on America’s 250th birthday

Published

on

Reflections on America’s 250th birthday

The nation’s capital may be the focal point of the 250th Independence Day celebration, but people all across America have plans to mark the occasion, from boisterous public parades to quiet personal reflections on history.

Julia Demaree Nikhinson/AP


hide caption

toggle caption

Advertisement

Julia Demaree Nikhinson/AP

As the United States turns 250 years old, Americans across the country are spending the holiday thinking about what the big birthday means to them, with reflections and celebrations as diverse as the nation itself.

NPR’s member station reporters fanned out to collect snapshots of the occasion from sea to shining sea.

In one ‘City of Presidents,’ Main Street is decorated for a party

At least two cities in the U.S.call themselves the “City of Presidents” and Cuba City, in Wisconsin, is one of them, largely due to its patriotic Main Street decorations. Every year from Memorial Day through Veteran’s Day, red, white, and blue shields, one for each U.S. president, are prominently displayed high up on the light poles lining Main Street.

Advertisement

It’s a tradition that began in 1976 to commemorate the country’s bicentennial, says Donna Rogers, who is president of the ongoing project but admitted that when it first started, she wasn’t particularly tuned-in to the display.

“I was raising three little boys and working at John Deere, so I didn’t really pay too much attention to community service at that time,” she said.

Donna Rogers shows off one of Cuba City's presidential lampposts.

Donna Rogers shows off one of Cuba City’s presidential lampposts.

Susan Bence/WUWM


hide caption

Advertisement

toggle caption

Susan Bence/WUWM

A few years later, she was tapped to help keep the initiative alive.

When she thinks of the country’s history, she says the signing of the Declaration of Independence and abolition of slavery top her list, plus a current event–

Advertisement

“Of course, now, our nation’s 250th birthday. I think those three would be the three most important things in history to me,” she said, quickly adding “[the] right for women to vote, don’t forget that, right?”

Rogers and Cuba City are pulling out all the stops for the 250th, with a parade and a mac-and-cheese festival, because “that was some of our founding fathers favorite foods, along with turkey and cranberries and other items.”

She laughed and admitted she googled that. True or not, Rogers says they’ll go all-out to celebrate the 250th in her “City of Presidents”.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

News

Family-owned company prepares to put on the largest fireworks display in history: “It is the biggest show that we’ve ever done”

Published

on

Family-owned company prepares to put on the largest fireworks display in history: “It is the biggest show that we’ve ever done”

Washington — There are fireworks, and then there’s what’s in store for Saturday in Washington, D.C.

When the sun goes down on Independence Day, the skies of Washington are expected to fill with a record-setting 850,000 individual fireworks for a 40-minute spectacle like no one has seen before.

A company called Pyrotecnico will attempt the biggest fireworks show in history, using five generations of family know-how and a background in Super Bowls and large musical acts to help America celebrate its 250th birthday with a bang.

“I mean, it is the biggest show that we’ve done,” Rocco Vitale, president of Pyrotecnico, told CBS News. “…My earliest memories of fireworks displays and doing the Fourth of July was here.”

Pyrotecnico has been planning this year’s show since January, using computers to simulate the display. But now it’s time for the real thing.

Advertisement

Vitale gave CBS News an exclusive look at his not-so-secret weapons: eight barges out on the Potomac River, each one ready to light up the night sky.
 
“Each firing location has a communication device, and its all set on GPS. And once the time of the show is put into the system, it goes at that time,” Vitale explained.

According to Freedom 250, the organizer of the “Salute to America 250 Celebration & Fireworks” on the National Mall, President Trump will deliver remarks at 9:45 p.m. Eastern Time, and the fireworks display will get underway at 10:45 p.m. The event is expected to draw hundreds of thousands of people.


Join CBS for “The Great American Block Party 250,” a primetime special on Saturday, July 4, hosted by CBS Evening News anchor Tony Dokoupil and Entertainment Tonight’s Nischelle Turner, featuring live musical performances, celebrations around the country, and the largest fireworks show in history in the skies over the nation’s capital. Tune in July 4 at 8 p.m. ET on CBS and stream it on Paramount+ and CBS News 24/7.

Continue Reading

News

Oregon ER doctors win a ‘David and Goliath’ battle against a national company

Published

on

Oregon ER doctors win a ‘David and Goliath’ battle against a national company

A national physician staffing firm tried to take over the contract held by Eugene Emergency Physicians to work in local hospitals. The local physicians used a new state law to oppose the move.

sorbetto/Digital Vision Vectors/Getty Images


hide caption

toggle caption

Advertisement

sorbetto/Digital Vision Vectors/Getty Images

For the latest stories on the science of healthy living, subscribe to NPR’s Health newsletter.

In between shifts in the emergency room, Dr. Dan McGee was in an Oregon courtroom. He was fighting for his practice — Eugene Emergency Physicians (EEP). The group of more than 40 doctors and physician assistants work at multiple emergency departments; it was being replaced by a national company.

“This was big time, David and Goliath stuff,” McGee said. “You see 14 of their lawyers sitting there and you see three of ours.”

Advertisement

Those lawyers argued that ApolloMD, the national company, violated Oregon’s corporate practice of medicine law. The 2025 law bans corporations from taking control of a medical practice’s operations and finances.

The case garnered national interest because Oregon’s new law targets the loopholes large staffing firms have been employing to circumvent state corporate medicine laws.

Money for control

Most states have laws requiring that doctors own medical practices, not corporations. These rules aim to put patient interests ahead of profit motives. Over the last several years, companies have used a model where a doctor technically owns the local practice, but as Erin Fuse Brown, a professor at Brown University, explains, those physician owners are often not involved in care and cede hiring, firing and other operational functions to the corporation.

Fuse Brown said these arrangements are attractive to hospitals because these companies often promise more revenue and take over the responsibilities that come with running an ER.

“There’s worry that these investors or these corporate management companies should not be totally controlling the operations and the clinical decisions of those who are trained to deliver patient care,” Fuse Brown said.

Advertisement

The connection to patient care concerned Dr. Jonas Pologe, who works for Eugene Emergency Physicians, in the Eugene, Ore., area. ApolloMD offered local doctors jobs, but Pologe worried that if he pushed back on decisions ApolloMD made, he could lose work hours.

Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending