Connect with us

News

How a film about fearless Indian female reporters made it to the Oscars

Published

on

How a film about fearless Indian female reporters made it to the Oscars

The transition from print to digital at Khabar Lahariya, a Hindi information portal staffed totally by girls in rural north India, has hit an sudden roadblock. Shyamkali, one of many much less skilled reporters, confesses she remains to be struggling to know the keypad on her new smartphone as a result of it requires e-mail addresses be typed in English. Meera, chief reporter, appears to be like momentarily exasperated however then leads the crew via a one-hour class on the alphabet. “It’s the letter with the stick and a bindi [the dot worn above the eyebrows],” says Meera. She is explaining the letter i.

Later in Writing with Fireplace, one in every of 5 contenders for this yr’s Oscar for Finest Documentary and the primary Indian-made movie to be nominated, Shyamkali has develop into an completed reporter. (The movie took 5 years to make.) Alongside the way in which, she has coped with the travails of an abusive husband who pockets her earnings and questions why she comes residence from work late. She information a home violence case and leaves him, a path unimaginably troublesome in India’s villages.

The genius of Delhi-based administrators Rintu Thomas and Sushmit Ghosh is to alternate between the ladies on their typically harmful and troublesome reporting beats — murders by unlawful mining mafia; interviews with victims of rape — and at residence, the place they negotiate the expectations of a patriarchal society. “[The women] you see on display develop into extra than simply brave journalists,” says Thomas.

In a single scene, Meera, who has levels in schooling and political science, returns residence from a satisfying day at work to face her nagging partner. She asks him what he would do if he needed to handle residence and work. He would consider home tasks, comes the pat reply, however the digicam pans to indicate him unable to look her within the eye. Meera has already gained the argument. The one scene captures the deep-rooted reluctance to permit girls to work in a lot of north India. It additionally partly explains why the nation has simply one-fifth of ladies working outdoors the house, among the many lowest labour participation charges within the growing world.

Suneeta has to struggle chauvinism and corruption © BBC/Black Ticket Movies

Writing with Fireplace is thus a movie about rather more than journalism. Having began as a Hindi newspaper funded by a Delhi-based NGO in 2002, Khabar Lahariya is now primarily a YouTube channel with greater than 550,000 subscribers and 10mn web page views a month. The portal is funded through subscriptions and commissioned content material it sells to information organisations in India and abroad. Though many don’t use a final title as a result of it’s typically a marker of caste, the employees are largely from the bottom tier of India’s complicated caste system and are referred to as Dalits. Shyamkali admits with amusing that if somebody she is interviewing says they’re Brahmin, she bluffs and says she is Brahmin too.

Advertisement

The film-makers Thomas, 35, and Ghosh, 39, met in movie college in New Delhi and shaped Black Ticket Movies greater than a decade in the past to make documentaries, regardless that the style receives no state help. Tellingly, their new movie is but to make it into cinemas in India and even on to Netflix or Amazon Prime, whose record of Hindi-language choices is of decidedly variable high quality. Thomas says there was no curiosity from digital streaming platforms in India. This isn’t uncommon for documentaries in Bollywood-obsessed India, however nonetheless appears weird provided that Writing with Fireplace has gained a number of worldwide awards, together with on the Sundance Movie Pageant, and is now an Oscar contender.

Ghosh says that Writing with Fireplace was their first try at an “observational documentary”. This meant filming for 4 years in order that the twists and turns within the characters’ lives inform the story. They navigate the complexities of a society deformed by patriarchy, caste and sophistication inequalities with out the usage of voice-overs and even typical speaking heads. “We determined we are going to try to not do sit-down interviews, we are going to try to not do explainers,” says Ghosh. “And the way do you clarify one thing as complicated as caste, not simply to an Indian viewers but in addition to a world viewers?”

A man and a woman sitting down smiling
Administrators Sushmit Ghosh and Rintu Thomas met at movie college © Capital Photos

One vignette reveals a reporter, Suneeta, battling with the chauvinism of males in a village whereas reporting on the area’s highly effective mining mafia. They initially refuse to speak to her as a result of she has not arrived in a TV van however are finally gained over by her pluck. Later at a press convention when she, the lone girl reporter, is the one one to ask the police about why they’re gradual to behave in opposition to the mafia, a male reporter patronisingly tells her that she ought to begin with flattery when talking to authorities officers. Suneeta briskly replies that the male reporters had achieved sufficient of that already.

Such scenes weren’t simple to return by. Thomas and Ghosh returned each quarter to comply with the ladies for weeks at a time. The film-making relied on what Ghosh describes as “a choreography of persistence. The much less you pull out your digicam, the extra individuals will belief you. It permits life to play out.” Filming the journalists needed to be a two-way course of, explains Thomas: “We would have liked to spend time for them to ask us questions.”

The movie focuses on the native reporting achieved by the organisation in Uttar Pradesh, India’s largest province with a inhabitants of greater than 240mn, and spends comparatively little time on the area’s polarised politics. Even so, this week Khabar Lahariya issued a puzzling assertion distancing itself from the movie and asserting that previously 20 years it had reported on all political events and their shortcomings with equal vigour.

A woman sits and films a man in a green plastic chair with her phone
Chief reporter Meera interviewing a person in a village in Banda, Uttar Pradesh © BBC/Black Ticket Movies

Violence and even murders of reporters masking the mining mafia should not unusual, however fortunately the ladies within the movie weren’t attacked over time that the cameras adopted them. Suneeta confronted threats and was supplied bribes for her reporting. Meera interviewed a younger militant Hindu whereas he unsheathed his sword for the digicam, however she shows such sensitivity and craft that the viewer finally ends up feeling momentarily sorry for him.

Nonetheless, Writing with Fireplace is permeated with a palpable sense of menace, resembling when the ladies return residence on darkish roads or interview the victims of mafia brutality. It begins with a deeply unsettling scene during which a girl recounts being repeatedly raped by a gaggle of village males. Her husband, an image of mute desolation, has tried to report the assaults to the police solely to be rebuffed with beatings. Meera’s newspaper is their solely hope for justice. The braveness of Khabar Lahariya’s sorority is immense. “The true hazard is what may occur,” says Thomas. “How do you operate . . . in that atmosphere of an absence of private safety?”

Advertisement

Writing with Fireplace is a genre-defying masterpiece, one second paying homage to a dogged detective film, the subsequent recalling the good surround-sound reportage of Tom Wolfe and Joan Didion within the Sixties. As Wolfe wrote: “Solely via probably the most looking out types of reporting was it potential in non-fiction to make use of entire scenes, prolonged dialogue, point-of-view and inside monologue. Ultimately, I and others can be accused of ‘getting into individuals’s minds’.” Greater than half a century on, Thomas and Ghosh’s empathy and persistence obtain simply that type of impact.

On BBC iPlayer within the UK now and premieres on PBS within the US on March 28. The Oscars are on March 27

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

News

Takeaways From Marco Rubio’s Senate Hearing

Published

on

Takeaways From Marco Rubio’s Senate Hearing

Marco Rubio, the Republican senator from Florida named by Donald J. Trump to be the next secretary of state, was warmly welcomed by senators from both parties at his confirmation hearing on Wednesday. He has served for years on the Foreign Relations and Intelligence Committees in the Senate, and is known as a lawmaker devoted to the details of foreign policy.

“I believe you have the skills and are well qualified to serve as secretary of state,” Senator Jeanne Shaheen, Democrat of Hampshire, said in her opening remarks.

The notable lack of tension at the hearing indicated that Mr. Rubio would almost certainly be confirmed quickly.

From the lines of questioning, it was clear what senators want Mr. Rubio and the Trump administration to focus on: China, Russia, North Korea and Iran. Mr. Rubio himself pointed to those four powers — what some call an “axis” — in his opening remarks.

They “sow chaos and instability and align with and fund radical terror groups, then hide behind their veto power at the United Nations and the threat of nuclear war,” he said. As permanent members of the U.N. Security Council, China and Russia have veto power over U.N. resolutions.

Advertisement

Mr. Rubio repeatedly singled out the Chinese Communist Party for criticism, and, unlike Mr. Trump, he had no praise for any of the autocrats running those nations.

He did say the administration’s official policy on Ukraine would be to try to end the war that President Vladimir V. Putin of Russia started, and that leaders in both Kyiv and Moscow would need to make concessions. U.S. officials say Russia has drawn its allies and partners into the war, relying on North Korea for troops and arms, Iran for weapons and training, and China for a rebuilding of the Russian defense industrial base.

Mr. Rubio defended Israel’s conduct in the war in Gaza, blaming Hamas for using civilians as human shields and calling the deaths of tens of thousands of Palestinians in Gaza, most of them non-combatants, “one of the terrible things about war.”

He expressed concern about threats to Israel’s security. “You cannot coexist with armed elements at your border who seek your destruction and evisceration, as a state. You just can’t,” he said.

When asked whether he believed Israel’s annexing Palestinian territory would be contrary to peace and security in the Middle East, Mr. Rubio did not give a direct answer, calling it “a very complex issue.”

Advertisement

Mr. Rubio’s hearing was about two hours in when the committee’s chairman announced that Israel and Hamas had sealed an agreement to begin a temporary cease-fire and partial hostage release in Gaza. An initial hostage and cease-fire agreement, reached in November 2023, fell apart after a week.

Mr. Rubio called the North Atlantic Treaty Organization, which Mr. Trump has repeatedly criticized, “a very important alliance” and insisted that Mr. Trump was a NATO supporter. But he also backed Mr. Trump’s argument that a strong NATO requires Europe to spend more money on its collective defense.

The United States, he said, must choose whether it will serve “a primary defense role or a backstop” to a self-reliant Europe.

Some prominent Trump supporters remain distrustful of Mr. Rubio. They recall his vote to certify the 2020 election results despite Mr. Trump’s false claims of election fraud. And they consider Mr. Rubio’s foreign policy record dangerously interventionist.

Mr. Rubio has long been a hawkish voice on national security issues, often in ways that clash with Mr. Trump’s views, even if the ideas are conventional ones among centrist Republican and Democratic politicians.

Advertisement

In the past, Senator Rand Paul, Republican of Kentucky, has criticized Mr. Rubio for advocating aggressive American intervention overseas. Mr. Paul has been outspoken in pushing for less use of U.S. troops abroad and is skeptical about whether economic sanctions can lead to positive outcomes.

On Wednesday, Mr. Paul pointedly asked Mr. Rubio whether he saw any way to work with China rather then persisting in attacks on Beijing, and he also questioned the wisdom of many American and European policymakers who insisted that Ukraine must be admitted to NATO.

Continue Reading

News

Gaza ceasefire announced after 15 months of war

Published

on

Gaza ceasefire announced after 15 months of war

Israel and Hamas have agreed a ceasefire to halt the 15-month war in Gaza and free the remaining hostages, mediators said, raising hopes of an end to a devastating conflict that has shaken the Middle East and the world beyond.

But, despite celebrations erupting across the region, the office of Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu warned that some details still had to be finalised as of Wednesday night.

The multiphase agreement, due to take effect on Sunday, a day before Donald Trump returns to office as US president, was announced by Qatari Prime Minister Sheikh Mohammed bin Abdulrahman bin al-Thani. However, he noted that the parties still had to give final approval.

The agreement offers hope of a halt — and potentially an end — to a brutal war that has become the deadliest chapter in the decades-long history of the Israeli-Palestinian conflict, leaving Gaza in ruins, consuming Israeli society, and pushing the Middle East to the brink of a full-blown war.

The fighting was triggered by Hamas’s brutal October 7, 2023 attack on Israel, during which fighters from the Palestinian militant group killed 1,200 people, and took 250 hostage, in the deadliest day for Jews since the Holocaust.

Advertisement

Israel responded with a ferocious offensive in Gaza that has killed more than 46,000 people and fuelled a humanitarian catastrophe in the enclave.

Previous attempts to broker a deal to end the conflict and secure the release of the 98 mainly Israeli hostages still in Gaza — not all of whom are alive — had repeatedly foundered when Israel and Hamas refused to make the necessary concessions.

Supporters of Israeli hostages kidnapped during the October 7 2023 attack by Hamas © Ronen Zvulun/Reuters

But the re-election of Trump — who threatened that there would be “all hell to pay” if the hostages were not released before his inauguration — injected renewed momentum into the long-stalled talks.

Trump was among the first leaders to hail the deal on Wednesday, writing on his Truth Social platform ahead of the formal announcement: “WE HAVE A DEAL FOR THE HOSTAGES IN THE MIDDLE EAST. THEY WILL BE RELEASED SHORTLY.”

He added his national security team would “continue to work closely with Israel and our Allies to make sure Gaza NEVER again becomes a terrorist safe haven”.

Advertisement

In comments of his own hailing the deal, US President Joe Biden described the Doha-based talks as “one of the toughest negotiations I have ever experienced”.

He added that the agreement would “halt the fighting in Gaza, surge much needed-humanitarian assistance to Palestinian civilians, and reunite the hostages with their families after more than 15 months in captivity”.

But Netanyahu’s office said shortly after Trump’s announcement that there were “still several sections left open in the proposal and we hope that the details will be finalised tonight”.

A person close to the talks said a deal had been done after the Qatari prime minister had met Hamas and Israeli negotiators separately in a final push for an agreement.

But the person added that, while Hamas had agreed to the deal, conceding on one of its final demands, Israel had since “raised a new outstanding issue”. They said: “Mediators are working to resolve it.”

Advertisement

An Israeli official said that the final details which Netanyahu’s office said still needed to be finalised related to the identity of those Palestinian prisoners set to be released in exchange for hostages.

Israel’s government is due to vote on the deal, which is based on a three-phase proposal first outlined by Biden last year. Far-right ministers, including national security minister Itamar Ben-Gvir, have expressed opposition, but are not expected to be able to block the deal.

The first phase will involve a 42-day truce, during which 33 Israeli hostages — including children, all female prisoners, the sick and elderly — will be freed in exchange for Palestinian prisoners held in Israeli jails and a dramatic increase in humanitarian aid deliveries into Gaza.

The two parties would begin negotiating the second phase no later than day 16 of the truce. During this period the remaining hostages, including male soldiers, are meant to be released in exchange for more Palestinian prisoners.

If fully implemented, the second phase will also lead to a permanent ceasefire and the full withdrawal of Israeli troops from Gaza. 

Advertisement

The final phase would involve the return of all the bodies of hostages who died, and the reconstruction of Gaza, under the supervision of Egypt, Qatar and the UN.

The talks over a deal intensified in mid-December after a ceasefire between Israel and Hizbollah in Lebanon.

A senior Biden administration official said one issue impeding the completion of the talks was Hamas’s refusal to acknowledge how many hostages it was holding and which ones would come out in the first phase of a deal.

The Palestinian group agreed at the end of December to a list of some 33 hostages, accelerating the end of the talks.

Biden’s top Middle East adviser Brett McGurk was joined in the last days of the talks by Trump’s Middle East envoy Steve Witkoff. A senior Biden administration official called it “a historic and crucial partnership” to finalise the arrangements. 

Advertisement

The talks ran into the early hours of Wednesday, with McGurk, Witkoff and Egyptian and Qatari officials upstairs with the Israeli negotiators, and Hamas downstairs, nailing down dozens of final details.

Abu Shukri, a community organiser sheltering in the Maghazi refugee camp in Gaza, said people in the neighbourhood had lined the streets and balconies in anticipation of the announcement of the ceasefire deal. As news reached them, people shouted and shot in the air in celebration. 

“We just thank God,” Abu Shukri said of the news. “But we’ve given our children, we gave our parents.” 

Additional reporting by Malaika Tapper in Beirut and Neri Zilber in Tel Aviv

Advertisement
Continue Reading

News

LA fires are still raging, but forecasters expect calmer winds in the coming days

Published

on

LA fires are still raging, but forecasters expect calmer winds in the coming days

An urban search and rescue team from Mexico combs through the ruins of a beachfront house searching for victims in the aftermath of the Palisades Fire in Malibu, Calif., on Tuesday.

Valerie Macon/AFP via Getty Images


hide caption

toggle caption

Advertisement

Valerie Macon/AFP via Getty Images

This is a developing story. For the latest local updates head to LAist.com and sign up for breaking news alerts.

Another day of fierce winds gusting to 65 mph in mountainous areas of Los Angeles and Ventura Counties in Southern California was expected on Wednesday, but weather more conducive to firefighting operations is expected soon.

The National Weather Service (NWS) issued another red flag warning for the area until 3 p.m. PST, cautioning of more of the windy and dry conditions that have fed raging fires for more than a week. The strong Santa Ana winds have helped push the deadly blazes through the Los Angeles suburbs, killing at least 25 people and leveling expensive real estate in Pacific Palisades and Altadena.

Advertisement

All told, the fires have engulfed more than 40,000 acres (more than 62 square miles), according to Cal Fire.

“The good news is that for the last two days we’ve had no increase in acreage at the Eaton Fire and it remains estimated at 14,117 acres with 35% containment,” Los Angeles County Fire Chief Anthony Marrone said of one of the largest fires. 

The Palisades fire, which spans more than 23,000 acres, is just 19% contained, according to Cal Fire.

On Tuesday, meteorologists initially called for particularly strong winds that turned out to be lighter that expected, according to NPR member station LAist.

But a reprieve in the high winds was expected from Thursday into Saturday. NWS meteorologist Ryan Kittell noted that the service is worried about “one last [wind] enhancement” through Wednesday and that peak winds would be highest in Ventura County.

Advertisement

Speaking at a news conference on Wednesday, Los Angeles Mayor Karen Bass had difficulty describing the devastation that has befallen her city.

“The massive, massive destruction. Is unimaginable until you actually see it,” Bass said. Even so, she said, it was time “to begin to think about how we rebuild.”

Since the fires broke out last week, responders from across the U.S., Canada and Mexico have come to the aid of Southern California. “Yesterday, I also had the opportunity to meet with our international partners from Mexico to express our heartfelt gratitude for their assistance. The outpouring of support from both near and far, I tell you, is absolutely remarkable,” LA Fire Chief Kristin Crowley said.

Of the 25 dead, 17 were killed in the Eaton Fire and eight in the Palisades Fire, LAist says. Officials said of the 13 still listed as missing, two bodies had been recovered but not yet positively identified.

More than 55,000 customers were without power on Wednesday in Los Angeles and Ventura counties, according to PowerOutage.us.

Advertisement

How to help and stay safe

Resources to help stay safe:

➡️ With fire danger still high, authorities implore you to follow evacuation orders

➡️ What to do — and not do — when you get home after a fire evacuation

➡️ Is smoke in your home? Here’s how to make an air purifier from a box fan

➡️Trying to stay safe in a wildfire? There’s an app that can help

Advertisement

Ways to support the response and recovery:

➡️ Want to help fire victims? Here’s what experts say does the most good and places seeking volunteers

➡️ Wildfire donations and volunteering: How and where to help

➡️ Share: These are the steps fire victims need to take to make an insurance claim

The California Newsroom is following the extreme weather from across the region. Click through to LAist’s coverage for the latest.

Advertisement
Continue Reading

Trending