Connect with us

News

Defense Lawyers Seek to Block Special Counsel Report in Trump Documents Case

Published

on

Defense Lawyers Seek to Block Special Counsel Report in Trump Documents Case

Defense lawyers asked both the Justice Department and a federal judge on Monday night to stop the special counsel, Jack Smith, from publicly releasing a report detailing his investigation into President-elect Donald J. Trump’s mishandling of classified documents after he left office in 2021.

The two-pronged attempt to block the report’s release arrived as Mr. Trump was only two weeks away from being sworn in for a second term as president. With the case against Mr. Trump already dismissed, the report would essentially be Mr. Smith’s final chance to lay out damaging new details and evidence, if he has any.

Mr. Trump’s lawyers, in an aggressively worded letter to Attorney General Merrick B. Garland, said they had recently been shown a draft copy of Mr. Smith’s report, calling it an example of the special counsel’s “politically motivated attack” against Mr. Trump. They demanded that Mr. Garland not allow Mr. Smith to make the report public and “remove him promptly” from his post.

“The release of any confidential report prepared by this out-of-control private citizen unconstitutionally posing as a prosecutor would be nothing more than a lawless political stunt, designed to politically harm President Trump,” the lawyers wrote. In separate court papers, lawyers for Mr. Trump’s two co-defendants in the classified documents case, Walt Nauta and Carlos De Oliveira, sought a more direct path toward stopping the release of Mr. Smith’s report. They asked the judge who oversaw the case, Aileen M. Cannon, to issue an emergency order to bar Mr. Smith from making the report public until the case “has reached a final judgment and appellate proceedings are concluded.”

Both attempts to block Mr. Smith could face an uphill battle.

Advertisement

Mr. Trump’s lawyers have no power to force Mr. Garland to stop the report from coming out, and their letter amounted to little more than a belligerent request. It is also unclear whether Judge Cannon would have the authority to tell the attorney general how to handle a report by a special counsel that he himself appointed, especially when the case is technically out of her hands and in front of an appeals court.

That happened because Judge Cannon threw out the case in its entirety in July, ruling, in the face of decades of precedent, that Mr. Smith had been unlawfully appointed as special counsel. Mr. Smith and his deputies challenged that decision, and it was being considered by a federal appeals court in Atlanta when Mr. Trump won the election in November.

Citing Justice Department policy against prosecuting a sitting president, Mr. Smith dropped the appeal where Mr. Trump was concerned, effectively ending his role in the case. But he did not drop the appeal against Mr. Nauta and Mr. De Oliveira, and federal prosecutors in Florida now plan to pursue it when Mr. Smith steps down, likely before Inauguration Day on Jan. 20.

Mr. Smith has also moved to dismiss the other federal case he brought against Mr. Trump, accusing him of plotting to overturn the 2020 election. It remains unclear when Mr. Smith plans to file a report in that case and whether it will accompany the report on the documents prosecution or be contained in a separate document.

The effort by Mr. Trump’s lawyers to block the release of the report was only their latest attempt to kill or push back any legal filings or proceedings that might be embarrassing or damaging to the president-elect.

Advertisement

Earlier on Monday, a state judge in Manhattan rejected Mr. Trump’s most recent attempt to delay his sentencing on 34 felony charges, saying that the hearing would go on as scheduled on Friday.

Justice Department regulations call for all special counsels to file reports to the attorney general explaining why they filed the charges they did, and why they decided not to file any other charges they might have been considering. The attorney general can then decide whether to release the report to the public.

It remains unclear when Mr. Smith was planning to finish his report in the classified documents case. But the lawyers for Mr. Nauta and Mr. De Oliveira said in their court papers that the report was likely to be released “within the next few days.”

Should either or both reports eventually see the light of day, it is possible they will not contain much in the way of new or revelatory information.

The report in the classified documents case could be complicated by the fact that it would likely have to undergo a careful review by the intelligence community for any classified information it contained. The report in the election interference case might not break significant new ground, if only because in October Mr. Smith filed a sprawling, 165-page brief laying out the evidence he planned to offer at trial.

Advertisement

Still, in their letter to Mr. Garland, Mr. Trump’s lawyers complained that the draft report in the classified documents case said that Mr. Trump had “harbored a ‘criminal design’” and was the “head of the criminal conspiracies” detailed in the indictment. The draft also said, the lawyers wrote, that “Mr. Trump violated multiple federal criminal laws.”

Mr. Trump’s lawyers turned the tables on Mr. Smith, accusing him of “unethical” conduct and “improper activities.” Those accusations had possible implications for future retribution against Mr. Smith, given that two of the lawyers who signed the letter to Mr. Garland, Todd Blanche and Emil Bove, have been chosen by Mr. Trump to serve in high positions in his Justice Department.While Mr. Garland has not said publicly whether he intends to release either report by Mr. Smith, he has done so in the past with other reports by other special counsels.

In February, for example, Mr. Garland permitted the release of a report by the special counsel Robert K. Hur concerning President Biden’s handling of classified materials after he served as vice president. The report concluded that criminal charges were not warranted, but also offered an unflattering assessment of Mr. Biden’s memory and cognitive capacity in the middle of the 2024 presidential campaign.

Continue Reading
Advertisement
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

News

Photos: Pacific Palisades Wildfire Engulfs Homes in an L.A. Neighborhood

Published

on

Photos: Pacific Palisades Wildfire Engulfs Homes in an L.A. Neighborhood

A fire in Los Angeles grew with dizzying speed on Tuesday and by the afternoon had engulfed many homes in Pacific Palisades, an affluent coastal neighborhood on the city’s west side.

The fire grew from 300 acres to almost 3,000 by the evening. It was fueled by a fierce windstorm, and the worst could be yet to come: Gusts of up to 100 miles per hour, the strongest Southern California has seen in a decade, were forecast through Wednesday.

The evacuation of Pacific Palisades, home to about 24,000 people and many celebrities, stalled traffic along Sunset Boulevard. Some people abandoned their vehicles and escaped on foot. The Los Angeles Fire Department said it would use a bulldozer to move about 30 abandoned vehicles.

“By no stretch of the imagination are we out of the woods,” Gov. Gavin Newsom said at a news conference on Tuesday afternoon.

Continue Reading

News

Indonesia places a $28bn bet on free school meals

Published

on

Indonesia places a bn bet on free school meals

This article is part of the FT’s Financial Literacy and Inclusion Campaign joint seasonal appeal with Magic Breakfast

Before dawn in the highlands of West Java, dozens of kitchen staff are hard at work making free meals for more than 3,000 schoolchildren in the Indonesian town of Warungkiara.

From 3am, as rain pours outside, employees arrive at a kitchen in a one-storey building to chop and cook hundreds of kilogrammes of fruit, vegetables, rice and eggs. From about 7am, when the town’s children start heading to schools, the kitchen is ready to begin distributing food to students.

Warungkiara’s kitchen is a pilot project. Thousands like it will be rolled out across the country beginning this month as part of President Prabowo Subianto’s flagship programme to provide free lunch for all school children and pregnant mothers. 

Fully implemented, it will be one of the world’s largest free meals programmes, reaching more than 82mn people at an estimated cost of $28bn a year.

Advertisement

It is a sum expected to strain Indonesia’s already-stretched government finances. But Prabowo, who took office in October, has touted the programme as a solution to improve children’s nutrition and boost local economies — which he hopes will have a ripple effect on economic growth and development in the world’s fourth most-populous country.

“This is a long-term investment in human capital,” said Dadan Hindayana, head of the newly created national nutrition agency, which will oversee the free meals programme. 

“Children who have never seen balanced meals will get to enjoy [such meals] at least once a day, every day. It will impact their growth,” he told the Financial Times in an interview in Jakarta. 

Nasrudin, a field co-ordinator for the free nutritious meal programme © Mas Agung Wilis Yudha Baskoro/FT
Yuni Munggaranti stands in the kitchen, holding a tray with compartments containing various food items.
Yuni Munggaranti, a nutritionist working with the programme © Mas Agung Wilis Yudha Baskoro/FT

Dadan also said the programme would boost productivity across Indonesia as the government increases sourcing of food products.

That could help Prabowo meet his ambitious goal of boosting annual growth from 5 per cent to 8 per cent — though economists say other reforms and investments are also needed.

Prabowo promised the free lunches during his election campaign, but the pledge was dismissed by critics as a populist measure. However, others say there are real benefits, particularly for children’s health and academic performance.

Advertisement

Feed the future

Support the Financial Literacy and Inclusion Campaign’s joint seasonal appeal with Magic Breakfast

Stunting — impaired growth and development in children from poor nutrition and repeated infections — has been an issue in Indonesia for decades. Government data shows the prevalence of stunting dropped from 37 per cent in 2013 to 21.5 per cent in 2023, but it remains a problem with longer-term impact. 

The OECD says stunting can lead to lasting impairments to physical and cognitive abilities, as well as disadvantages for health, life expectancy, skills and jobs.

It says infant malnutrition has contributed to poor education performance in primary schools: in 2022 as in previous years, Indonesian students scored significantly worse than the OECD averages in mathematics, reading and science.

The free lunch programme, along with other efforts, “will better prepare children for learning and growing”, the OECD said in a report in November.

A worker in a test kitchen prepares meals by distributing a mixture, possibly scrambled eggs, into compartmentalised trays
The kitchen feeds about 3,000 students every day © Mas Agung Wilis Yudha Baskoro/FT

The pilot project at Warungkiara, a town of 66,000, got under way shortly before Prabowo won February’s presidential election, and illustrates the kind of social and economic impact that the government hopes to trigger. 

Run by a think-tank called Indonesia Food Security Review, which is advising the government on how to implement the programme nationally, it employs about 50 people including cooks, drivers and cleaners. It distributes meals to 20 schools, six days a week. A nutritionist helps design the meals.

Advertisement

Pahmi Idris, the kitchen manager, said the pilot project had created local jobs and boosted income for staff who were previously housewives, unemployed or worked in the informal sector. All produce is sourced from local farmers and suppliers, Pahmi said.

“Locals who previously did not have income now work here,” he told the FT. Farmers, hawkers and small retailers in the town have seen their income double and farmers are expanding to meet the kitchen’s demand, he added. 

Fahmi Idris stands in a kitchen in Warungkiara Village
Kitchen manager Pahmi Idris: ‘Locals who previously did not have income now work here’ © Mas Agung Wilis Yudha Baskoro

Schools that receive the free meals also said they had seen an improvement in attendance.

“Over time, the absence rate has been decreasing. This also influences the learning process,” said Iswah Ismatullah, principal at the Himmatussalam Islamic high school, which has 109 students.

Primary school head Atmaja, who goes by one name, said some students take a portion of the free meals home to share with siblings or their parents, most of whom are farmers or do odd jobs. 

The Warungkiara kitchen is seen as the benchmark for the programme’s national rollout, but expansion across the vast archipelago of 17,000 islands will face many challenges.

Advertisement

Indonesia will have to avoid the pitfalls seen in India, which runs the world’s largest free meals programme, catering to 118mn students. Indian government officials and others say the programme has been mismanaged in some places.

Setting up kitchens, sourcing food and distribution in some remote islands could also prove difficult. Dadan from the national nutrition agency said the government could rope in the police, military and non-governmental organisations to help. Indonesia plans to set up nearly 30,000 kitchens, each serving about 3,000 students, when the programme reaches full scale by 2027.

“This is a massive programme that will need the involvement of all parties,” he said.

Two young students smile and enjoy a free lunch
Students at Warungkiara have a free lunch of noodles and vegetables © Mas Agung Wilis Yudha Baskoro/FT

Another big hurdle is finance. An average meal is expected to cost Rp10,000 per day, and the total $28bn cost is expected to include setting up the kitchens and other operational costs.

Indonesia has budgeted Rp71tn ($4bn) for the first year of the programme, but expanding it will test Jakarta’s fiscal strength. Rating agencies say more borrowing could hurt the country’s credit rating.

“The gradual rollout of the free meal programme may add to some recent pressures on Indonesia’s government finances,” said Thomas Rookmaaker, head of Asia-Pacific sovereigns at Fitch Ratings.

Advertisement

On a recent visit to China, Prabowo signed an agreement with Beijing to support funding for the programme, though the governments did not provide details. 

Any fiscal strains are a distant concern in Warungkiara. Eneng, who works in the pilot kitchen, said the programme had helped increase her family’s income.

“This (kitchen] really helps. The women around here previously did not have any income. Now that we’re working here, we can help our husbands and children,” she said, peeling garlic along with other women in preparation for the next day’s meals.

“As for our children, we are assured that they will have healthy meals. It gives parents peace of mind.”

Advertisement
Continue Reading

News

Palisades fire: 'Worst is yet to come' as winds gain speed

Published

on

Palisades fire: 'Worst is yet to come' as winds gain speed

Firefighters are in for a long and dangerous night battling the Palisades fire as fearsome winds are forecast to grow even stronger and could hinder efforts to fight the blaze by air.

The fire ignited at Piedra Morada Drive at 10:30 a.m. and — fueled by intense wind gusts — had scorched 2,921 acres by early evening, forcing more than 30,000 residents to flee their homes. The extreme wind event blasting Southern California is forecast to peak between 10 p.m. Tuesday and 5 a.m. Wednesday, posing a serious challenge to overnight efforts to combat the growing blaze.

“This event is not only not over, but it is just getting started and will get significantly worse before it gets better,” UCLA climate scientist Daniel Swain said in a briefing just after 4 p.m. Tuesday.

The strongest and most widespread winds are “yet to come,” Swain said, as is the lowest humidity.

Winds were expected to pick up into the evening, possibly making an air attack unfeasible if sustained wind speeds break 30 to 40 mph, said L.A. County Fire Chief Anthony Marrone around 4 p.m. Tuesday.

Advertisement

Although it might be frustrating for residents to see firefighting aircraft grounded, extreme winds can make those efforts less effective, as water or retardant that is dropped is immediately dispersed by the wind, said Gov. Gavin Newsom, who visited the site of the Palisades fire Tuesday.

“We can be up there all day, making people feel good,” he said, “but we’re not doing any good.”

The combination of extreme winds and critically low humidity create a dangerous recipe for new fires to break out overnight.

“We are anticipating — hopefully we’re wrong — but we’re anticipating other fires happening,” said Newsom, adding that the state had strategically positioned resources in areas of high fire risk.

Swain echoed the governor, saying, “Unfortunately, I do think that is likelier than not that that does, in fact, occur.”

Advertisement

By around 6:30 p.m. Tuesday, that prediction had come true as a fire broke out in the foothills of Pasadena and quickly grew to 20 acres, according to Pasadena spokeswoman Lisa Derderian. The Pasadena Fire Department was on scene and concerned about the potential for rapid spread amid the fierce winds.

Another fire broke out Tuesday night in the hills above Altadena near Eaton Canyon. The fire has burned around 400 acres by 8:14 p.m. and prompted evacuations in the area west of the Eaton Canyon Golf Course, according to the U.S. Forest Service.

Meanwhile, the Palisades fire continued to charge forward, threatening thousands of homes and scores of businesses.

On Tuesday afternoon, crews were racing to save the Getty Villa and Palisades Charter High School from flames lapping their grounds. The Reel Inn, a seafood restaurant that has been a Malibu institution for more than three decades, appears to have burned in the fire.

The National Weather Service predicts that the ongoing windstorm will be the most destructive to have hit the Los Angeles region since 2011.

Advertisement

The weather service issued a “particularly dangerous situation” warning for extreme fire danger in wide swaths of Los Angeles and eastern Ventura counties, prior to the ignition of the Palisades fire. That warning is set to expire Thursday.

Although the worst of the winds are expected Tuesday night and Wednesday morning, fire danger will remain high throughout the week.

“The vegetation will become progressively drier the longer the wind event goes on,” said Swain. “So some of the strongest winds will be at the beginning of the event, but some of the driest vegetation will actually come at the end, and so the reality is that there’s going to be a very long period of high fire risk.”

Recent rainfall patterns are exacerbating the fire danger, said Alex Hall, director of the UCLA Center for Climate Science.

“Southern California has experienced a particularly hot summer, followed by almost no precipitation during what is normally our wet season,” he explained. “And all of this comes on the heels of two very rainy years, which means there is plenty of fuel for potential wildfires.”

Advertisement

Climate change has a part to play in this particularly dangerous event, Swain said.

There’s not much evidence that climate change has increased the likelihood of extreme wind events. There is evidence, however, that it is increasing the overlap between these wind events and periods of extremely dry vegetation conditions during what would typically be the wet season, he said.

Newsom echoed the sentiment that fire danger is no longer contained to a fire season.

“We were here not too long ago [for] the Franklin fire and, a few weeks prior to that, the Mountain fire,” he said. “November, December, now January — there’s no fire season. It’s fire year. It’s year round.”

Advertisement
Continue Reading
Advertisement

Trending