Connect with us

North Dakota

Upstream landowners ponder discrepancies between North Dakota, Minnesota F-M Diversion payouts

Published

on

Upstream landowners ponder discrepancies between North Dakota, Minnesota F-M Diversion payouts


CHRISTINE, N.D. — Josh Granholt has spent much of his life on quiet farmland tucked into the bends of the Red River.

His family has farmed land near Christine for more than 100 years. Those fields give way to forested groves along the river, where he and his parents live today.

Despite their proximity to the river, the main houses on the Granholt family’s farmsteads have never flooded, even in years where cities to the north were inundated with water.

“The old timers put a house where it made sense and didn’t flood, not where it looked cool, because they didn’t want to deal with it,” Granholt said.

Advertisement

The construction of the

Fargo-Moorhead Area Diversion

upstream will change how Granholt’s land floods. He hopes to get compensated fairly for newly flooded land — and equally to landowners on the Minnesota side of the river.

Josh Granholt, a farmer near Christine, N.D., said most of the buildings on his family’s land, as seen on Monday, March 3, 2025, have never flooded, but now with the F-M Diversion nearing completion, there is potential for flooding for landowners upstream of the diversion.

Chris Flynn / The Forum

Advertisement

The diversion is a $3.2 billion flood control project designed to protect the Fargo-Moorhead metro from extreme floods. When operational, the project will hold water south of the metro behind a 22-mile earthen embankment. Three gated structures will control the release of floodwater into the Red River, the Wild Rice River and a 30-mile diversion channel that arcs west around the cities.

In order to hold water south of the embankment, the Metro Flood Diversion Authority, a governmental entity that oversees parts of the project, needs to secure property rights to store water on the land south of the dam. It has been doing so in the form of flowage easements. Property owners are paid for giving the Diversion Authority the right to flood their land.

The Granholt family properties are among those the Diversion Authority is in the process of securing property rights for through the eminent domain process, which allows a government to take land for public use.

Proposed flowage easements on Granholt family land pay for flooding in places that have never flooded before. But on the Minnesota side of the Red River, flowage easements cover far more land and stretch farther south along the river.

Advertisement

Josh Granholt, a farmer near Christine, North Dakota, shows where his family land is on a map of Richland County at his office on Monday, March 3, 2025.

Josh Granholt, a farmer near Christine, N.D., shows where his family land is on a map of Richland County at his office on Monday, March 3, 2025.

Chris Flynn / The Forum

Different states, different rules

In Minnesota, maps for the project show the Diversion Authority is acquiring flowage easements well into Wilkin County, about 30 miles south of Moorhead.

Advertisement

In North Dakota, a majority of flowage easements are in Cass County. Flowage easements in Richland County are along the Red River or waterways that flow into the Red River. The southernmost flowage easements in North Dakota are southeast of Christine, across the river from Wolverton, Minn. Wolverton is about 22 miles south of Moorhead.

Differences in flowage easements between North Dakota and Minnesota come down to the fact that the project involves two different states with different permitting requirements, Diversion Authority Executive Director Jason Benson said.

The Minnesota Department of Natural Resources permit requires property mitigation for up to a tenth of a foot of impact of the principal maximum flood, Benson said, which is “kind of the biblical flood, something that’s hard to comprehend.”

On the North Dakota side, the state requires mitigation for up to a half foot to the 100-year or 500-year flood levels, whichever is a higher impact, he said. A 100-year flood has a 1% chance of happening in any given year, while a 500-year flood has a 0.2% chance of happening in any given year.

“We’re applying Minnesota permit and regulations and rules for Minnesota residents and land mitigation on the Minnesota side. We’re applying North Dakota rules, regulations and law for land that we’re mitigating on the North Dakota side,” Benson said.

Advertisement

Permitting differences are the

basis of landowner countersuits in the eminent domain process.

Landowners represented by attorney Cash Aaland began filing counterclaims in eminent domain proceedings in February, alleging that North Dakota landowners are not being paid for all the water that could be displaced onto their property, or for the resulting damages, when the diversion’s southern dam holds back a maximum amount of water.

While the permit requirements are different in the two states, Granholt thinks Minnesota and North Dakota landowners should receive the same treatment.

“If Minnesota gets paid for everything, for an inch and above, not only do I think we should be compensated, but we should know where that is,” Granholt said.

Advertisement

Further, Granholt worries that if 6 inches of water did fill the flowage easement area, more shallow areas of water would stretch farther onto his property.

“Does that mean there’s going to be 5 inches someplace we’re not getting compensated for?” Granholt said. “Because whether it’s 1 inch or 1 foot in your basement, it’s still water in there, isn’t it?”

Josh Granholt, a farmer near Christine, North Dakota, lives near the Red River, as seen on Monday, March 3, 2025, which is upstream of the FM Diversion and could potentially flood his land.

Josh Granholt, a farmer near Christine, N.D., lives near the Red River, as seen on Monday, March 3, 2025, which is upstream of the F-M Diversion and could potentially flood his land.

Chris Flynn / The Forum

Advertisement

Ken Knudsen lives a couple miles north of Granholt, northeast of Christine. His land is similar to Granholt’s — a grove of trees in one of the Red River’s loops, with a house built high enough to avoid flooding.

With the proposed flowage easements on his land, Knudsen expected to negotiate an amount for the water that could be stored on his land and a payout for the tear-down of a garage turned “man cave.” Finding out that Aaland thinks that water could go higher was not good news.

“I don’t want to move, and I don’t want to sell and I don’t want to fight floods that I’ve been told shouldn’t happen to our place,” Knudsen said.

The land Knudsen lives on was one of the original farmsteads in the area, he said, meaning that the brothers who moved there got to pick the best plot of land.

“I’d like to see that our farm doesn’t flood and we can just stay there, and it’s a beautiful place to live and pass it onto our kids and whatever,” Knudsen said. “If we’re going to end up having to fight floods every time they use the dam, then we’d have to think differently.”

Advertisement

The Diversion Authority does have a mechanism for landowners to bring forward claims if diversion operations flood more land than flowage easements cover. In such cases, landowners will be able to bring claims to a dispute resolution board created by the Diversion Authority. That board will determine if damage was caused by the project.

Granholt said he’s aware of that process.

“It’s usually easier to get it the first time than to come back and ask for more,” Granholt said.

Josh Granholt, a farmer near Christine, North Dakota, lives upstream of the FM Diversion near the Red River, which could potentially flood his land, as seen on Monday, March 3, 2025.

Josh Granholt, a farmer near Christine, N.D., lives upstream of the F-M Diversion near the Red River.

Chris Flynn / The Forum

Advertisement





Source link

Continue Reading
Click to comment

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

North Dakota

Today in History, 1970: North Dakota faces population decline with the hope of a new decade

Published

on

Today in History, 1970: North Dakota faces population decline with the hope of a new decade


On this day in 1970, a Forum staff writer assessed North Dakota’s promise and challenges entering the new decade, highlighting opportunities in resources, industry, modernization, and recreation while warning that population decline, outdated government, and deep inequities—especially on reservations—would shape whether the 1970s became a boom or a setback.

Here is the complete story as it appeared in the paper that day:

Heavenly Seventies in N.D.?

By PIIL MATTHEWS
Staff Writer

Advertisement

North Dakota enters the 1970s with footings solidly built for the future:

Lots of wide open spaces when many parts of the nation are hurting for room. The promise of abundant water from Garrison diversion for irrigation and municipal and industrial use. A tax climate favorable for new industry and for the diversification of the state’s economic base. And its major resource — an intelligent and dependable people.

But how North Dakotans respond to their opportunity will determine whether the next ten years will be the heavenly seventies or a decade of decline.

Faced with a decreasing population, low farm prices, disappearing farms and small towns, North Dakotans may well be forced to take vigorous action if the trends are to be reversed.

See more history at Newspapers.com

Advertisement

The blueprint for tomorrow already is off the drawing boards. The roads, schools and colleges, the productive land and the natural resources of oil and lignite are already here.

“Our environmental setting is good for industrial development,” said a prominent Republican. “The depopulated Midwest states will find reversal of the trends of large-scale movements from the rural to urban centers. People want to get away from the smog and the crush of the cities and find someplace where there is clean air.”

A group of Eastern delegates arriving in Fargo for a convention were amazed because they could not see the air. Air, to them, was the smog of the cities. All they could see here was blue sky.

“There is tremendous disillusionment of life in the cities,” the Republican spokesman continued. “They are not nice places to live in. People want to get away. And to go someplace where there is clean air.”

Advertisement

But the overriding question is whether the opportunities will be seized. Do we want to trade our clean skies and wide-open spaces for the pollution and smog and congestion of industrial progress? Or is there an alternative?

North Dakota enters the new decade with some disturbing features marring its potential. Population which reached about 650,000 in the mid-60s, is on the decline. On July 1, 1969, the United States Census Bureau estimated the state’s population at 615,000.

The trend toward fewer and larger farms continues and is expected to continue in the years ahead. While there were 84,000 farms in the state in the 1930s, there are 43,000 today. Increased mechanization and reduced farm population spell a continued decline in the small towns.

Political Pains

In government and politics the state continues to struggle along with an outdated Constitution and laws that hamper instead of enhance its steps toward progress.

Advertisement

Grave concern is expressed across the state about the survival of a two-party system in North Dakota as the result of flounderings in the Democratic party both at the national and state level.

And when North Dakotans boast, “We have no ghettos,” someone can aptly point out, “Your ghettos are on the Indian reservations.”

The plight of the Indian is unquestionably the gravest problem confronting the state as it enters the decade. And the people are responding with a frenzy of activity to find new ways to cure old ills.

An Indian tribal leader observed, “With all the various governmental programs under way, you would think that life on the reservation is a utopia. But it isn’t. The people are confused. They are being pulled in many different ways by the various agencies working in different directions. This fragmentation of services is not good. It leaves the Indian confused.”

One glimmer of hope in this proliferation of proposed remedies is the United Tribes Employment Training Center that opened at Bismarck in 1969. By enrolling whole Indian families in the program, the Center aims to provide the breadwinner with job skills while at the same time instructing the parents and children in school subjects and personal living — a wholesale attack on the total problem.

Advertisement

“We’ve put all our eggs in one basket,” said the Indian leader. “This is a new concept — Indians training Indians. When Indian trainees walk in here and see a non-Indian, they feel resentment. They’ll respond to you when they won’t respond to me.”

He is enthusiastic about the Center and predicts it will flourish in the years ahead.

“It’s not what the people can do for the Indians,” he remarked. “It’s what the Indians can do for themselves. They have sat on their haunches, their arms folded and listened long enough to what the other people are going to do for them. It’s about time they start doing their own thinking and stop being a political football.”

He said the Center program is aimed directly at the root of the interrelated problems of unemployment, family disintegration and despair.

As new directions are being charted for the Indian, there are movements elsewhere in the state that augur well for the future.

Advertisement

A legislative leader said there is a mood across the state for government reorganization aimed at more streamlined and efficient services.

“The 1970s will see strides taken to reorganize government by making the executive branch stronger,” he said. “Instead of 14 elected state officials, we will be electing only five or six.”

North Dakotans will vote this year on the question of whether a constitutional convention should be held to redraft the Constitution. The legislative expert said the convention would present an opportunity to make a basic set of laws more suitable to the times than a document enacted in 1889.

He foresaw more interstate cooperation for providing costly services for the woman prisoner, the psychotic child, the hardened juvenile, the tubercular patient, the criminally
insane.

He envisioned more inter-governmental cooperation in the sharing of services:
“I think county government will remain close to the local level much as it is today, but economies will be realized by having one county official serve more than a single county — as is already being done by some county school superintendents.

Advertisement

The computer center in the Capitol, he explained, will be utilized in many ways to do a lot of jobs more efficiently and more accurately. A central data bank of common information needed by several departments of government will become a reality, he said, in place of many duplicating sets of files in various offices containing the same information.

The North Dakota Century Code of laws, comprised of 14 volumes, probably will be placed on tape, he said, for easy access via the computer. This will speed up code searches, drafting and enrolling of the bills.

“North Dakota will become one of the leaders in using computer for its state government operations,” he predicted.

Other changes in governmental affairs are in the wind, in the opinion of other state leaders. Both the Republican and Democratic spokesmen saw the implementation of revenue sharing from the federal government which would become a source of tax relief for North Dakota.

The state sales tax was raised to 4 per cent this year to provide replacement revenue for the abolition of the personal property tax.

Advertisement

“I would be opposed to increasing the sales tax any more,” said the Republican. “If there were any consideration of an increase I would be absolutely in favor of exempting all food and lower-cost clothing.”

A labor leader saw the government taking a more vigorous role in providing jobs for the young people and in providing vital services.

“The railroads want to discontinue certain trains and branch lines because they aren’t making any money in that particular operation,” he said. “But the railroads are a service. It would be like the post office saying they aren’t going to deliver mail to a certain part of town because it doesn’t make a profit there.”

The labor leader contended that the government would have to socialize distribution and transportation functions where the problems of private ownership have become burdensome.

“Either the government will have to subsidize or take over these operations — so what’s the difference? If a private organization serving the public fails to do the job because it can’t make a profit, then the government will have to take over and run it as a service.”

Advertisement

He said the state could halt the exodus of young people by establishing some industries that free enterprise does not see fit to do.

“If we can operate a state mill and a state bank, it would seem to me that we would be able to operate other state industries — such as the processing of our farm products,” he said.

Another proposal he raised would serve to maintain a more uniform cycle in the construction industry. Because of weather and climate there is high unemployment at certain times of the year. “By some general planning promoted by organized labor and the contractors with the state government participating, it could spread out the work throughout the seasons of the year. It would be a benefit to the worker and to the economy as a whole,” he said.

State government is assuming a more active role in providing employment and business opportunities. The Municipal Industrial Development Act contains provisions for property and income tax exemptions for up to five years for certain new ventures.

A business economist pointed out that new manufacturing plants are being added in North Dakota at the rate of about one a week. There are about 600 manufacturing plants in the state and he expected the growing trend to continue during the decade.

Advertisement

The diversion of water from Lake Sakakawea will not only see the beginning of irrigation farming but will also provide abundant supplies of water for municipal and industrial uses, which will prove beneficial to the economy.

North Dakota has the largest lignite coal reserves in the nation and three large plants have tapped this resource for producing electric power. More plants will be established.

Recreation is due to have a growing economic impact in the years ahead, in the opinion of many state leaders. The age of the snowmobile is making winter sports the “in” thing and states with four seasons will offer a variety of leisure activities the year around.

But even with opportunities glittering on the horizon, there is the question of whether the people will exploit them. Some prefer the state as it is. Some like to make their money here but choose to spend it elsewhere.

A North Dakota historian observed, “We live in a small state and therefore we feel defensive, even inferior. There is an attitude of fatalism. With the present declining population, we tend to think that this trend is bound to continue.”

Advertisement

He said there is a need for larger and less governmental and geographical units in the state, but that, too, can reach a point of diminishing returns. School district reorganization, he noted, often faces a great deal of resistance from people who want their small towns to survive: “They want to have a sense of community, a sense of belonging.”

But as the life in the big cities becomes more unbearable, he said, the life in the small towns and rural areas will become more desirable.

A Fargo housewife saw great hope for North Dakota because of the quality of life it can offer its people.

“In North Dakota we still have time to preserve and improve our surroundings,” she said. “The flower beds along the Red River — that’s the best thing that has happened here for years. We’re so busy pulling down trees and putting up architectural monstrosities and allowing these horrible strip developments along the highways.”

“There is every opportunity to attract and hold the young people by offering a good place to live rather than the lure of big money,” she contended.

Advertisement

Because North Dakota does not have the problems of the industrial and metropolitan centers, she advocated strong control to preserve and protect the environment as it is.

“We still have a clear sky, the wide open spaces and a lot of do-it-yourself opportunities. It’s that quality of life that will attract,” she said.

Advertisement





Source link

Continue Reading

North Dakota

Today in History: December 29, 1959 – Sioux ice champs North Dakota team of the year

Published

on

Today in History: December 29, 1959 – Sioux ice champs North Dakota team of the year


Today in History revisits the Tuesday, December 29. 1959 edition of the Grand Forks Herald and highlights a story on the UND Hockey team being names North Dakota team of the year.

The University of North Dakota hockey team was named “Team of the Year” after winning the NCAA Championship in a 4-3 overtime victory over Michigan State. Forward Reg Morelli was voted the tournament’s Most Valuable Player. Runner-up honors went to the Bismarck High basketball team for winning its third straight Class A title.

Sioux Ice Champs N. D. Team Of Year

By THE ASSOCIATED PRESS (as published by the Grand Forks Herald on Dec. 29, 1959)

Advertisement

North Dakota hockey stock reached a peak early in 1959 when the University sextet captured the NCAA championship with a 4-3 overtime victory over Michigan State.

The feat earned the Sioux icemen the accolade of “team of the year” in the annual Associated Press poll of sports editors and sports directors.

Runner-up honors in the balloting went to the Bismarck high school basketball team, which won its third straight Class A high school title.

The St. Mary’s high school football team, which came from no- where to win the Class A grid crown, won third place.

The University hockey team had taken western championship for the first time the year before, and finished second to Denver in the 1957-58 NCAA tournament.

Advertisement

As the 1958-59 campaign rolled around there were many problems to be solved if the Sioux were to maintain their position atop the college hockey world.

One by one the questions were resolved, and on March 14, at Troy, N. Y., North Dakota went into overtime to cop the coveted NCAA title.

Tremendous spirit marked the Sioux climb to the top. The North Dakota team won four games during the season in overtime, including two in the NCAA meet.

Members of the championship team included George Gratton and Bob Peabody, goalies; Ralph Lyndon, Julian Butherta, Pete Gaze- ly and Bob Began on defense; and Jerry Walford, Stan Paschke, Guy LaFrance, Art Miller, Ed Thomlinson, Joe Poole, Les Merrifield, Ron King, Bart Larson, Bernie Haley, Garth Perry and Reg Morelli, forwards.

Morelli Voted Most Valuable

Advertisement

Morelli was voted most valuable player in the NCAA tourney. Morelli and Thomlinson were on the first team and Lyndon and Poole on the tournament’s second team.

The Bismarck basketball feat of three straight state championships tied a record set by Fargo in 1922- 23-24. The Demons had an overall 21-3 record, averaged 61.6 points per game and held opponents to 49.3 per tilt on the season.

Starters were Ron Carlson and Bob Smith at forward, Rod Tjaden at center and Art Winter and Rich Olthoff at guards.

Carlson and Winter were all-west choices.

Here are “team of the year” choices, points in parenthesis:

Advertisement
  1. UND hockey (37)
  2. Bismarck high basketball (24)
  3. St. Mary’s high football (16)
  4. Bottineau high basketball (11)
  5. Valley City Teachers basket- ball (10)
  6. Williston high wrestling (5)
  7. Grand Forks Legion baseball (2)
  8. Shanley high football (1)
  9. NDAC football (1).

Rite Spot Liquor Store advertisment as published on Dec. 29, 1959. Grand Forks Herald archive image.

Our newsroom occasionally reports stories under a byline of “staff.” Often, the “staff” byline is used when rewriting basic news briefs that originate from official sources, such as a city press release about a road closure, and which require little or no reporting. At times, this byline is used when a news story includes numerous authors or when the story is formed by aggregating previously reported news from various sources. If outside sources are used, it is noted within the story.

Advertisement





Source link

Continue Reading

North Dakota

40 million from Midwest to New England brace for severe winter storm

Published

on

40 million from Midwest to New England brace for severe winter storm


A storm bearing down on the Great Lakes and New England is expected to bring rain, snow, and high winds over the next few days.

A narrow band from Fargo, North Dakota south to approximately Mason City, Iowa is under a blizzard warning ahead of the storm. That includes parts of of both states as well as parts of Minnesota. Winds in the affected areas are forecast to reach 45 miles per hour and, paired with an expected 3 to 8 inches of snow, are expected to create whiteout conditions through the start of the week.

Michigan’s upper peninsula is under a blizzard warning as well. There, snowfall is expected to be between 9 inches and 2 feet, and winds are expected to reach as high as 60 miles per hour, ABC News reports.

The National Weather Service has issued winter weather advisories for parts of the northeast, from the Scranton, Pennsylvania up through Burlington, Vermont and Portland, Maine. Freezing rain is expected in that area on Sunday and Monday.

Advertisement

Buffalo and Jamestown, New York, are also both under flood watches from Sunday afternoon until Monday afternoon.

A closed-for-the-season seafood restaurant at Pine Point in Scarborough, Maine. A winter storm bringing blizzard conditions, high winds, and ice accumulation began moving east across the midwest on Sunday morning, and will disrupt the Great Lakes and northeast until early Monday

A closed-for-the-season seafood restaurant at Pine Point in Scarborough, Maine. A winter storm bringing blizzard conditions, high winds, and ice accumulation began moving east across the midwest on Sunday morning, and will disrupt the Great Lakes and northeast until early Monday (Reuters)

Back in the Great Lakes region, both Cleveland and Detroit are bracing for high winds. Forecasters expect the cities will see gusts of up to 60 miles per hour on Sunday night through early Tuesday morning.

In the upper midwest, both Minneapolis and Green Bay are forecast to see between 5 to 9 inches of snow. A level 1 of 5 severe storm threat exists in a stretch from northern Indiana south into Missouri. That band includes Indianapolis, St Louis, Louisville, and Nashville. The affected region will be subject to high speed, damaging wind gusts, according to Fox Weather.

The storm began dropping snow on Sioux Falls and Fargo early on Sunday morning, and will continue to sweep east across the northern sections of the U.S. The midwest will begin to see storm conditions on Sunday afternoon, and the northeast will be affected shortly thereafter.

Advertisement
People play in the snow in Central Park in Manhattan, New York

People play in the snow in Central Park in Manhattan, New York (REUTERS)
Army Black Knights fans throw snow after a touchdown during the second half of their win over the UConn Huskies in the Wasabi Fenway Bowl at Fenway Park in Boston, Massachusetts

Army Black Knights fans throw snow after a touchdown during the second half of their win over the UConn Huskies in the Wasabi Fenway Bowl at Fenway Park in Boston, Massachusetts (Getty Images)
A man shovels snow in Brooklyn, New York City

A man shovels snow in Brooklyn, New York City (Getty Images)

Road travelers in the affected regions should be wary. Parts of the I-95 corridor between Philadelphia and Boston may be made treacherous by freezing rain around 5 pm on Sunday night.

Forecasters believe that the storm system will clear by Monday night, though lake-effect snow is likely to follow in its wake for Great Lakes communities. That snow will likely continue into Tuesday and potentially Wednesday.

Advertisement

In northern New England, wintry precipitation may produce up to a quarter of an inch of ice in the area. While the interior northeast is expected to receive some lake-effect snow as well, forecasters believe snowfall in the region will be lighter.

The storm comes on the heels of another winter weather system that swept across the northeast earlier this week, dropping snow on New York and New Jersey and forcing thousands of flights to be either cancelled or delayed.



Source link

Continue Reading

Trending