Detroit, MI
Detroit judge’s decisions probed by prosecutor, worrying he ‘made up some law’
Detroit — Wayne County Prosecutor Kym Worthy launched an investigation into the docket of 36th District Judge Ronald Giles in October, directing her staff to review cases the judge had dismissed, along with instances in which he acted outside the law or “made up some law,” according to two emails obtained by The Detroit News.
“I want to see every, single Judge Giles dismissal going back (to) January of this year sent to me as soon as possible,” Worthy wrote in an Oct. 6 officewide message.
Worthy sent a follow-up directive on Oct. 8: “Thank you for the huge response concerning Judge Giles’ cases. Please send cases also where he did not follow the law or made up some ‘law.’”
“Please continue to document and send,” the second memo instructed. “If any dismissal memos need to be updated, please do so now. Any case — ‘big’ or ‘small’ — because, obviously, all of our cases are extremely important to our victims and survivors.”
It’s unclear how long the review into Giles’ cases lasted, or whether it’s still ongoing. When asked about the memo, Worthy replied in a statement: “It is an internal email that was not meant for public consumption to address a serious issue. I will have no public comment.”
Giles didn’t respond to a phone call request for comment, and Chief 36th District Judge William McConnico did not return a text message and phone call seeking comment.
The state court administrator said it’s within Worthy’s authority to review a judge’s record.
“The Prosecutor, like all court users, can request file information as a part of their preparation and/or review process,” State Court Administrator Tom Boyd said in an email. “We have no information that suggests this activity is inconsistent with such objectives.”
Andre Ash, the victim in a case handled by Giles, said he wasn’t surprised to learn of the Worthy investigation.
Ash said a Wayne County assistant prosecutor warned him that Giles had a propensity for “excusing a lot of cases” when the 61-year-old Detroit resident prepared to face his alleged attacker during court proceedings in October and November.
Latest court case controversy
Ash said he had just finished his security rounds at the Regency Tower apartments on Chene on Detroit’s east side on Oct. 23 when a man attempted to enter the building without authorization.
The man, 44-year-old Marcus Shamily, became irate when questioned and produced a knife, Ash said.
“I told him, ‘This isn’t going to go how you think it’s going to go with that knife,” said Ash, a lifelong Detroiter who said he has had martial arts training and has fended off knife attacks before.
The two men clashed, and Ash said Shamily got on top of him. During the struggle, Ash was stabbed several times in the hand, although he said he wrestled away the knife and cut his alleged attacker multiple times.
“When the police showed up, they saw all that blood — it was his blood,” said Ash of the alleged attack that was captured on surveillance video.
Shamily was charged with assault with intent to murder, which carries up to life in prison; assault with intent to do great bodily harm less than murder, punishable by up to 10 years in prison; and felonious assault, which carries up to four years in prison.
During Shamily’s Nov. 14 preliminary examination in 36th District Court, Giles dismissed the most serious charge and bound the defendant over for trial on the other two allegations.
Shamily’s attorney, Rene Cooper, didn’t respond to a request for comment.
Ash said he was surprised by the judge’s treatment of him during his testimony.
“I wasn’t prepared for what he said to me when we first went to court,” Ash said of Giles. “He acted like I was lying; I felt like he was blaming me.”
Ash said he was “shocked” to learn that Giles dismissed the assault with intent to murder charge against Shamily.
“If you look at the video, I don’t see how you can see it any other way — (Shamily) tried to kill me,” Ash said.
In 2017, Shamily pleaded guilty to domestic violence, third offense, and was sentenced to probation. He violated the terms of his probation in 2018, court records show, but his probation was continued, ending in September 2020.
In Shamily’s latest court case, a Feb. 6 final conference hearing is scheduled before Wayne County Circuit Judge Shannon Walker.
Ash said he’s still hoping for justice, but he remains unhappy about how Giles handled his case.
“To me, it’s shocking that this judge still has a job,” Ash said.
The prosecutor’s office is appealing the ruling to dismiss the assault with intent to murder charge, arguing the judge abused his discretion, Assistant Prosecutor Maria Miller said. The motion will be argued before Judge Walker on Friday, Miller said.
Dismissals panned
Worthy has criticized other judges for dismissing cases.
In December, after Wayne Circuit Judge Cylenthia LaToye Miller dismissed felony murder and first-degree murder charges against defendant Charles Evans, Worthy said the judge should’ve recused herself. The defendant’s attorney worked for the Perkins Law Group, which represented Miller when she was charged with bringing a loaded, unregistered pistol through a security checkpoint at Detroit Metropolitan Wayne County Airport.
“Based on this obvious conflict of interest (unknown to the assistant prosecutor at the outset of the trial), Judge Miller should have recused herself from the case,” prosecutors said in a December statement. “Judge Miller dismissed the case, erroneously, citing a discovery violation … (the prosecutor’s office contends that there was no violation, and that the judge failed to follow the law.”
In 2022, Worthy told The News she was “disturbed” by unnamed judges’ bond decisions. When former Michigan State University basketball star Mateen Cleaves was charged in 2016 with sexual assault, charges for which he was acquitted, Worthy was critical of how a Genesee County district court handled the case.
Other cases dismissed by Giles in recent years include:
- In May, Giles dismissed all charges, including attempted murder, against Robert Pugh, who was accused of shooting an autistic teenager outside his house in April. The judge dismissed the charges after the defendant’s attorney said the alleged video of the shooting did not show her client. Prosecutors replied that the issue should have been discussed at trial.
- Giles in 2024 dismissed charges against graffiti artist Bryan Herrin, who was accused of spray painting the silhouette of Beavis from the TV show “Beavis and Butt-Head” throughout Detroit. The judge ruled there was not enough evidence to proceed with the case and dismissed six counts of felony malicious destruction of property, which carries a penalty of four years in prison, against the artist, who is known by the moniker BVIS.
- In 2017, following nearly three years of legal proceedings, Giles dropped charges against the “Homrich 9,” a group of activists who blocked trucks from conducting water shutoffs in Detroit. Giles said he dismissed the charges due to the lack of a speedy trial, court records show.
- Giles dropped murder charges against Deangelo Dukes, who was accused in the 2019 shooting death of a 62-year-old Arthur Boyle on Detroit’s east side due to “insufficient evidence,” court records show. After dismissing the charges of felony murder, three counts of felony firearm, one count of being a felon in possession of a weapon and one count of first-degree home invasion, Giles bound Dukes over on charges of unlawful driving away of an automobile and intent to pass false title. Dukes was given probation, which he violated in June 2019 — three months after Giles dismissed the most serious charges against him.
History of issues
Worthy’s call for an investigation isn’t the first time the prosecutor has had an issue with Giles, a 36th District Court judge since 2006. After former Detroit Mayor Kwame Kilpatrick was charged in 2008 with perjury, conspiracy, misconduct in office and obstruction of justice, Worthy unsuccessfully sought to have Giles and other 36th District Court judges recuse themselves, arguing the case up to the Michigan Supreme Court.
Worthy argued that Giles and the other judges on the court should be barred from hearing Kilpatrick’s trial because they were too politically connected to Kilpatrick. Giles contributed to Kilpatrick’s election campaign and hosted the mayor as a houseguest at his daughter’s high school graduation party.
But in August 2008, Giles ordered Kilpatrick to spend a night in the Wayne County Jail for violating the travel restriction of his bond by crossing the Detroit River to Windsor without notifying the judge.
“If it was not Kwame Kilpatricksitting in that seat, if it was John Six-Packsitting in the seat, what would I do?” Giles asked the mayor before revoking his bond and sending him to jail — the first time a sitting Detroit mayor had been locked behind bars in his own city.
Kilpatrick pleaded guilty to obstruction of justice in September 2008, and Wayne County Circuit Judge David Groner sentenced the ex-mayor to four months in jail. Kilpatrick, in 2013, was sentenced to 28 years in prison after he was convicted in federal court of multiple offenses, including conspiracy, extortion and mail fraud. President Donald Trump commuted the sentence in 2021.
ghunter@detroitnews.com
(313) 222-2134
@GeorgeHunter_DN
Staff Writer Craig Mauger contributed.
Detroit, MI
Preview: February 28 vs. Detroit | Carolina Hurricanes
RALEIGH, N.C. – The Carolina Hurricanes will try to extend their point streak to a dozen games on Saturday, when they go head-to-head with the Detroit Red Wings.
—
When: Saturday, February 28
Puck Drop: 7:00 p.m. ET
Watch: FanDuel Sports Network South, FanDuel Sports Network App | Learn More
Listen: 99.9 The Fan, Hurricanes App
—
Canes Record: 37-15-6 (80 Points, 1st – Metropolitan Division)
Canes Last Game: 5-4 Win over the Tampa Bay Lightning on Thursday, Feb. 26
—
Red Wings Record: 34-19-6 (74 Points, T-2nd – Atlantic Division)
Red Wings Last Game: 2-1 Win (OT) over the Ottawa Senators on Thursday, Feb. 26
Detroit, MI
Terrion Arnold ‘maintains complete innocence’ in kidnapping, theft case
I represent Mr. Terrion Arnold in connection with an incident that allegedly occurred on February 4, 2026, in Tampa, Florida, which resulted in the arrest of five individuals on serious felony charges.
To be clear, Mr. Arnold had no involvement whatsoever in the activities that led to those arrests. He did not participate in, nor was he present for, any conduct related to the alleged offenses. There is no evidence in police reports, text messages, or witness statements that implicates Mr. Arnold in any way.
In fact, after direct communication with the lead prosecutor, it has been confirmed that no charges have been filed against Mr. Arnold in connection with this matter.
Recent media coverage has referenced an Order issued by Circuit Judge J. Logan Murphy, which improperly suggests Mr. Arnold’s involvement in the incident. That same Order also incorrectly identifies Ms. Devalle as Mr. Arnold’s girlfriend. Both assertions are false, misleading, and entirely unsupported by the record.
Mr. Arnold categorically denies these unfounded claims and maintains his complete innocence. He was not involved in the crimes allegedly committed on February 4, 2026, in Tampa, Florida.
We strongly urge members of the media to refrain from perpetuating inaccurate or speculative narratives. The facts are clear, and they do not support any claim of wrongdoing by Mr. Arnold.
Detroit, MI
Robert ‘Fish’ Jenkins helped Detroit students soar in sports and life
There was a time when many Historical Black Colleges had swimming teams. The late Robert ‘Fish’ Jenkins benefited from that era and then he spent much of his adult life lifting up youths in Detroit.
Black heritage tours teach travelers what they missed in history class
So much of America’s Black history isn’t taught in schools, but travelers can learn about some of those experiences on the road.
Cody Godwin, USA TODAY
The celebration of Black History Month throughout February provides an opportunity to share stories about Detroiters that have positively impacted the lives of others in a variety of ways.
And included among those stories that have been shared this month is a “Fish” story that is unique, without exaggeration.
That is because this story is about the late Robert “Fish” Jenkins Sr., a longtime Detroit educator and a groundbreaking coach, whose superpower was his ability to create life-changing opportunities for young people in unconventional spaces.
In 1969, Jenkins arrived at Detroit’s Northern High School as a physical education teacher and coach. During Northern’s heyday, the high school, formerly located on Woodward Avenue at Owen in the city’s North End, produced a host of high-profile sports stars, including basketball greats Bill Buntin — a two-time All-American center at the University of Michigan during the 1960s — and Derrick Coleman — the first overall pick in the 1990 NBA draft. And record-breaking sprinter Marshall Dill, Track & Field News’ High School Athlete of the Year in 1971, who set world records in the 300-yard dash while running for Michigan State University.
However, Jenkins specialized in coaching sports that were a little less popular among young people in Detroit, particularly Black students. Jenkins coached teams at Northern — and for one year at East English Village Preparatory Academy after he retired from teaching in 2001 — to 24 Detroit Public School League championships in swimming, golf and soccer.
“No matter what the sport was, he had the formula to make a team a champion,” Robert Jenkins Jr. said about his father, who died on Jan. 14 at the age 86.
“But more than that, my father had a profound impact on the minds of every student he touched. He brought golf, and all the lessons golf teaches, to the North End. And, in the summer, he had members of the swim team teach the younger kids in the neighborhood how to swim, which taught his swim team members how to give back to the community.”
During the evening of Feb. 22, Robert Jenkins Jr. took pride in sharing stories about young people who were coached and mentored by his father across multiple decades that went on to become “doctors, educators, business leaders, and parents” that have made positive contributions to the city of Detroit.
Robert Jenkins Jr. also described some of the friendly interactions that his dad had with notable people like U.S. Olympic sprint champion Wilma Rudolph and Naismith Memorial Basketball Hall of Famer Dick Barnett at Tennessee State University, where the elder Jenkins received the education and training that he needed to teach and coach student-athletes in Detroit.
But earlier that day, an equally compelling “Fish” story was told by another community member.
“Mr. Jenkins was a very important person in my life and he is one of the reasons why I have always tried to do my part when it comes to providing opportunities for young people in our city,” said Gary Peterson, who has coached young swimmers in Detroit for 47 years, including at Detroit’s King High School, where he coaches boys and girls swimmers today.
Long before Peterson coached high school swimmers — and youth swimmers of virtually all ages when he was a full-time swimming instructor for the city of Detroit’s Recreation Department — Peterson was on the swim team at King High School (Class of 1974), when Robert Jenkins Sr. came into his life.
“There were coaches at other schools that helped young swimmers that wanted to improve and go to another level, and Mr. Jenkins was one of those coaches,” said Peterson, who was coached at King High School by Clyde James, a lifelong friend and teammate of Jenkins on the Tennessee State University swimming team during the late 1950s and early 1960s, when they brought national attention to the school’s swimming program.
“Mr. Jenkins would make his pool at Northern available to students from other schools that wanted to get in extra practice. Then, as I got closer to going to college, Mr. Jenkins was the person who introduced me to the colleges that were recruiting Black high school swimmers.
“At that time, there were more than 20 HBCUs (Historically Black Colleges and Universities) that had competitive swimming programs. Today, there is only one (Howard University in Washington, DC). But back then, Mr. Jenkins wanted to make sure we had the opportunities and exposure, which included sending a small group of us to South Carolina State for a recruiting trip.
“Afterwards, Mr. Jenkins even came over to King from Northern to present me with my scholarship to South Carolina State, while I was sitting in a King classroom. I couldn’t believe it and I was ecstatic, but everything that he did for me and other young swimmers in the city he did so willingly. And that’s what I always thought I was supposed to do as a coach.”
Peterson said he would do even more with Jenkins when Peterson returned to Detroit from Orangeburg, South Carolina, after graduating from college.
“In the late 1980s, a team I was coaching at Johnson Recreation Center and Mr. Jenkins’ team at Northern, traveled to Washington DC as one team in February to compete in the Black History Invitational Swim Meet. And that tradition of Detroit competing as one team at that meet continued every year until COVID,” said Peterson, who also recalled that Jenkins coached softball and even junior varsity football for a time, in addition to swimming, golf and soccer.
“Just as Mr. Jenkins thought it was critical for us to come together and take our kids to DC for that swim meet because it was the biggest showcase for Black swimmers, he wanted all the young people he coached to have good training and exposure. And in my case, as the son of sharecroppers, I can say that Mr. Jenkins inspired me as well, as a swimmer and a coach.”
Every time Peterson walks into King High to coach the current group of swimmers at the school, he said he is reminded of Jenkins and other important people that paved the way for Black swimmers in Detroit.
For example, in 2023, the natatorium at King was rededicated as the Clyde James Natatorium by the Detroit Public Schools Community District. Peterson says the renaming was not only a salute to James, who was a finalist in the National Association of Intercollegiate Athletics Championships in the 100-yard butterfly during the 1960-61 season while swimming for Tennessee State, but also a tribute to the fabled swimming program that was once housed at the Brewster Recreation Center, which helped to develop James, Jenkins and many other Detroit swimmers that competed nationally. Brewster’s early swimming program was led by the legendary Clarence Gatliff, an all-city swimmer at Cass Tech during the 1920s.
Another pleasant reminder of the history and evolution of Black swimmers in Detroit that Peterson sees when inside King High is 54-year-old Robert Jenkins Jr., an educator like his father, who is teaching personal finance this school year at King and hopes to honor his father’s legacy this summer by offering a swimming and golf program to students.
“I want to make sure that Detroiters understand my father’s legacy,” said Jenkins, a 1989 graduate of Northern High School, who explained that his father and mother (Norma Jean Jenkins) taught him and his sister (Dr. Marlo Rencher) that “we don’t half do anything.”
And that includes community service.
“My father was a servant leader and he would offer encouragement to any young person he was around, not just the students he coached. And paying it (that support) forward was a lesson he always taught in the process.”
Scott Talley is a native Detroiter, a proud product of Detroit Public Schools and a lifelong lover of Detroit culture in its diverse forms. In his second tour with the Free Press, which he grew up reading as a child, he is excited and humbled to cover the city’s neighborhoods and the many interesting people who define its various communities. Contact him at stalley@freepress.com or follow him on Twitter @STalleyfreep. Read more of Scott’s stories at www.freep.com/mosaic/detroit-is/. Please help us grow great community-focused journalism by becoming a subscriber.
-
World3 days agoExclusive: DeepSeek withholds latest AI model from US chipmakers including Nvidia, sources say
-
Massachusetts3 days agoMother and daughter injured in Taunton house explosion
-
Montana1 week ago2026 MHSA Montana Wrestling State Championship Brackets And Results – FloWrestling
-
Louisiana5 days agoWildfire near Gum Swamp Road in Livingston Parish now under control; more than 200 acres burned
-
Denver, CO3 days ago10 acres charred, 5 injured in Thornton grass fire, evacuation orders lifted
-
Technology1 week agoYouTube TV billing scam emails are hitting inboxes
-
Technology1 week agoStellantis is in a crisis of its own making
-
Politics1 week agoOpenAI didn’t contact police despite employees flagging mass shooter’s concerning chatbot interactions: REPORT