Arkansas mom says school mask mandates led to ‘cruelty and discrimination’ against her daughter

To forestall the unfold of COVID-19, the Facilities for Illness Management and Prevention (CDC) first advisable the sporting of face masks in all public settings in April 2020. Finally, this led to long-term masks mandates throughout the nation — together with in most faculties.

It additionally sparked an typically contentious divide between mother and father who supported the mandates and those that opposed it.

Ginny Lauren Dowden, 40, of Arkansas fought for her daughter to have the ability to stay mask-free — a hard-won battle that took an emotional toll.

PARENTS NOW QUESTION WHETHER COVID MASK MANDATES DID MORE HARM THAN GOOD

It was just some months earlier than the pandemic when Dowden and her household moved from Dallas, Texas, to Fayetteville, Arkansas. 

She enrolled her older daughter, Rosalyn, 8, in second grade on the native public faculty. (Her youthful daughter was simply an toddler on the time.) Then when COVID hit, the faculties in Northwest Arkansas abruptly closed.

After a number of months of on-line studying, younger Rosalyn was excited to return to in-person faculty in third grade — till the masks mandate was introduced.

Straight away, Dowden began the method of looking for a masks exemption. 

“Rosalyn has bronchial asthma, takes day by day treatment and makes use of an inhaler,” Dowden informed Fox Information Digital in a telephone interview. 

“Frequent sense tells you {that a} youngster with bronchial asthma shouldn’t be in a masks for eight hours a day.”

FACE MASKS MADE ‘LITTLE TO NO DIFFERENCE’ IN PREVENTING SPREAD OF COVID, SCIENTIFIC REVIEW FINDS

A number of research have proven that face masks are protected for kids with bronchial asthma to put on and don’t trigger respiratory points or worsen underlying lung circumstances. 

The American Academy of Allergy, Bronchial asthma & Immunology, headquartered in Milwaukee, has mentioned that sporting a masks doesn’t have an effect on oxygen saturation, whereas the American Lung Affiliation of Chicago states on its web site that “kids with bronchial asthma ought to be capable to put on a non-N95 facial protecting with out affecting their oxygen ranges.”

“Frequent sense tells you {that a} youngster with bronchial asthma shouldn’t be in a masks for eight hours a day.”

Advertisement

Even so, Dowden was not comfy together with her daughter sporting a masks for lengthy intervals of time.

She began by asking her daughter’s pediatrician’s workplace to approve the exemption, however the workplace refused.

“The medical industrial advanced right here on the town works collectively with the college district, so I believe they had been underneath stress to disclaim all exemption requests,” mentioned Dowden.

Ginny Lauren Dowden, proven with daughter Rosalyn, has spoken up in school board conferences and at state Senate committee conferences in protection of parental alternative and freedoms. (Ginny Lauren Dowden)

Subsequent, Dowden went again to her hometown in South Arkansas, the place she was lastly in a position to get an exemption observe from the physician there. 

“The docs that I actually trusted — and who weren’t simply spewing out the identical CDC speaking factors — by no means inspired me to masks my daughter due to her bronchial asthma,” she mentioned.

SHOULD YOU STILL WEAR A MASK TODAY? WHAT ALL OF US SHOULD KNOW NOW

Nonetheless, even after the physician signed off, the elementary faculty nonetheless pushed again. 

Though the college’s coverage said that solely a physician’s observe was required, the administration informed Dowden she would even have to offer an “bronchial asthma motion plan” outlining how Rosalyn’s bronchial asthma was managed. 

Dowden returned to the physician for the additional documentation. After a number of extra emails and telephone calls, Rosalyn’s exemption was lastly granted.

Pals flip chilly

However the wrestle was removed from over.

The subsequent day, for the primary time for the reason that begin of COVID, Dowden’s daughter Rosalyn was excited to return to high school and not using a masks — however it wasn’t the constructive expertise they’d anticipated.

“Each day, she would lose extra buddies. Lots of the different youngsters simply wouldn’t come close to her anymore.”

Since transferring to Fayetteville, each Dowden and her daughter had made many new buddies, primarily different moms and daughters from faculty. 

WOMEN MORE LIKELY TO SUFFER FROM ‘LONG COVID,’ BUT HEALTHY HABITS CAN LOWER THE RISK

However when Rosalyn confirmed as much as class and not using a masks, that every one modified.

“Each day, she would lose extra buddies,” mentioned Dowden, turning into emotional within the interview.

“Lots of the different youngsters simply wouldn’t come close to her anymore,” mentioned Dowden about how her daughter was handled in school as soon as she confirmed up and not using a masks. She mentioned her daughter skilled stress, anxiousness and discrimination. (David Crane/MediaNews Group/Los Angeles Every day Information through Getty Photos)

“Lots of the different youngsters simply wouldn’t come close to her anymore.”

Dowden additionally skilled social fallout of her personal, she mentioned, as she was ridiculed by different moms who had as soon as been her buddies.

“It’s one factor for me to lose buddies — I will be high-quality — however it’s a lot more durable for an 8-year-old woman,” Dowden mentioned. 

“They handled her terribly. Their mother and father had been telling them to not go close to Rosalyn as a result of she would make them sick.”

“I requested if she’d really feel extra comfy simply going together with it. Rosalyn’s reply was at all times an emphatic ‘no.’”

Regardless of the poor remedy she skilled, younger Rosalyn by no means wavered in her resolution to not put on a masks. 

“There have been days when she was nervous about not sporting one. I made certain to repeatedly verify in together with her and her coronary heart,” Dowden mentioned. 

NJ 3-YEAR-OLD KICKED OUT OF SPEECH THERAPY DUE TO MASK MANDATES: ‘CATASTROPHIC MORAL CRIME’

“I might ask about how she was feeling and the way troublesome issues had been for her. I requested if she’d really feel extra comfy simply going together with it and sporting one.”

Rosalyn’s reply was at all times an emphatic “no,” mentioned Dowden.

‘You possibly can kill me’

A latest scientific overview indicated that masks mandates could have achieved little to nothing to curb the unfold of COVID. Based mostly on the outbreaks at her daughter’s faculty, Dowden believes that’s true.

“They took all the precautions — checking youngsters’ temperatures, having them use hand sanitizer and ensuring their masks had been pulled up over their noses — however then there could be a constructive case and the entire class must keep dwelling and quarantine,” she mentioned. “It utterly disrupted the complete 12 months.”

“The masks did nothing,” she added. “Everybody knew it, however they nonetheless went together with the narrative.”

Along with masks sporting, Ginny Dowden mentioned her daughter’s faculty additionally required day by day temperature checks and the common use of hand sanitizer. (iStock)

Dowden doesn’t consider that everybody was being intentionally merciless. She mentioned some had been appearing out of real worry, in her view.

“Concern may be paralyzing,” she mentioned. “I can completely perceive and empathize with those that had been actually scared concerning the well-being and well being of their youngsters.”

“However there was no area — and no grace — prolonged to these of us who genuinely questioned issues,” Dowden continued. “Like them, we actually felt we had been doing what was greatest for our youngsters. However we had been categorized as egocentric, unkind, negligent and presumably [even] able to killing others.”

“We had been categorized as egocentric, unkind, negligent and presumably able to killing others.”

Rosalyn Dowden frequently got here dwelling from faculty with new tales of repercussions for not protecting her face. 

KIDS’ MASK USE ‘SHOULD NOT BE FORCED,’ STUDY AUTHORS ARGUE

No less than as soon as a day, a instructor would method her within the corridor and inform her to placed on a masks. The woman must clarify, time and again, why she didn’t need to put on one.

“There was no motive the lecturers needed to preserve asking her about it day by day — they need to have recognized about her exemption,” Dowden mentioned. “Each day, this 8-year-old was pressured to defend herself to adults and different college students. There was no help system for her.”

In a single instance, one other pupil informed Rosalyn, “I’ve to put on two masks day by day since you received’t put on one. You possibly can kill me.”

No less than as soon as a day, a instructor would method Dowden’s daughter within the corridor and inform her to placed on a masks. The woman must clarify, time and again, why she didn’t need to put on one. (REUTERS/Brendan McDermid/File Picture)

In her personal classroom, Rosalyn’s third-grade instructor didn’t supply a lot help. She even appeared to keep away from her as a lot as attainable, Dowden mentioned. 

“It was nearly like Rosalyn was invisible,” Dowden mentioned by way of tears. “The instructor made her sit at the back of the category away from all the opposite youngsters. It’s simply merciless to single kids out deliberately and make them really feel ‘lower than.’”

Added Dowden, “Actually, every little thing she went by way of — it was like youngster abuse.”

“It’s simply merciless to single kids out deliberately and make them really feel ‘lower than.’”

Nonetheless, Dowden identified that there have been additionally some nice lecturers on the faculty who had been put in a tricky place. 

“They had been merely imposing what that they had been required to do by the district,” she mentioned.

Talking up in school board conferences

As the opposite mother and father and college students continued to distance themselves, Dowden figured she had nothing to lose. 

She began the state’s first chapter of Mothers for Liberty. It is a nonprofit nationwide group devoted to “preventing for the survival of America by unifying, educating and empowering mother and father to defend their parental rights in any respect ranges of presidency,” in accordance with its web site.

Dowden additionally began talking in school board conferences about not solely the masks mandates, however about adjustments to the curriculum that made her uncomfortable. 

In July 2021, over 250 mother and father from the neighborhood confirmed as much as a gathering.

“They had been introducing the youngsters to matters that don’t have any place in colleges,” she mentioned. “I acquired the sensation that these adjustments would affect the youngsters greater than a masks ever might.”

YEARLY COVID VACCINE AS PROPOSED BY FDA? ‘CART BEFORE THE HORSE,’ SAYS DOCTOR

As well as, Dowden began a grassroots group with another mother and father who had been additionally in opposition to the masks mandates and different adjustments taking place within the colleges. 

In July 2021, over 250 mother and father from the neighborhood confirmed as much as a gathering, mentioned Dowden.

She has spoken in entrance of the Senate Schooling Committee on the Arkansas State Capitol. And thru Conduit Information, the nonprofit information community the place she works because the communications director, she collaborates with legislators and different counties to activate change. 

Making a constructive change

Within the spring of her daughter’s third-grade 12 months, issues began to enhance. The opposite youngsters began to inform Rosalyn that she was fortunate that she didn’t need to put on a masks — which made her really feel a bit of higher. 

However then, that summer time, Dowden realized the college wouldn’t be lifting the masks mandate going into Rosalyn’s fourth-grade 12 months.

“And so I began the identical outdated music and dance once more with the docs and the exemption documentation,” Dowden mentioned.

“Between the masks and what I used to be studying about what they had been educating within the school rooms, I simply felt so heavy-hearted,” mentioned Ginny Dowden concerning the public faculty system and what her daughter (not pictured) was going by way of.  (iStock)

“However between the masks and what I used to be studying about what they had been educating within the school rooms, I simply felt so heavy-hearted about sending my daughter again there.”

Round that point, Dowden heard a few new classical Christian faculty that had simply opened up within the space. It was small, with just some dozen college students. 

Ginny Dowden utilized to it for her daughter, who was granted a scholarship — and the mother then pulled Rosalyn out of the general public faculty in the course of the autumn semester.

CONNECTICUT FAMILY SHARES HEARTBREAKING IMPACT OF SCHOOL MASK MANDATES

“She was in a position to go to the brand new faculty unmasked, with out being handled any in another way,” Dowden mentioned. “All the opposite youngsters and lecturers welcomed her with open arms. It was an actual godsend.”

Right this moment, Rosalyn Dowden is flourishing in her fifth-grade class, her mother mentioned. 

“She’s far more lighthearted,” Dowden mentioned. “Kids aren’t imagined to have to hold most of these burdens and see such public discourse from mother and father. They are not outfitted to deal with that. Now, she is in an atmosphere that encourages her to thrive, one which talks about magnificence and goodness and fact.”

‘By no means had a sufferer’s mentality’

Dowden firmly believes the masks prompted immeasurable psychological and emotional turmoil for teenagers, to not point out a lack of studying. 

Even so, regardless of all of the stress and anxiousness her daughter skilled, she mentioned her daughter by no means felt like a sufferer.

“Regardless that she was discriminated in opposition to, handled poorly, made enjoyable of — even accused of having the ability to kill different youngsters as a result of she didn’t put on a masks — she by no means had a sufferer’s mentality,” mentioned Dowden. 

“She was so mentally sturdy. It was arduous and scary, however she stood her floor, though many individuals would have caved to the peer stress.”

Ginny Dowden mentioned her daughter has bronchial asthma, takes day by day treatment and makes use of an inhaler, making her fear concerning the potential affect of sporting a masks all day lengthy. (iStock)

“She understood that typically it’s important to swim in opposition to the present — that doing the fitting factor, as a rule, is tough and unpopular,” Dowden mentioned.

“She confirmed extra fortitude, braveness and spine than the vast majority of adults.”

Preventing mandates held ‘vital lesson’

In some methods, Dowden feels that the college’s dealing with of COVID and masks mandates served as an vital lesson for folks. 

CLICK HERE TO SIGN UP FOR OUR HEALTH NEWSLETTER

“It gave us a extremely clear image of how political pursuits had been put forward of what was greatest for our children,” she mentioned. 

“They had been educating our children what to suppose, not methods to suppose. I believe by the tip, it actually opened so many mother and father’ eyes.”

Via her advocacy efforts, Dowden has made a brand new circle of buddies. 

“I discovered that [as] I stood up and spoke out, folks I’d by no means met began reaching out to me,” she mentioned.

“There’s nonetheless an ongoing battle in our colleges … You possibly can’t be complacent.”

Now, going into the second 12 months of her Mothers for Liberty group, Dowden is seeing a shift as native mother and father turn out to be extra concerned — however it’s nonetheless a sluggish course of.

If she might ship a message to different mother and father, it could be, “Don’t neglect what they did.”

“They had been principally tyrants who put unconstitutional mandates in place, and everybody simply took it,” mentioned Dowden. 

“It’s vital to proceed to struggle. There’s nonetheless an ongoing battle in our colleges proper now, and you may’t be complacent, not even now that the masks are gone.”