Connect with us

Entertainment

The Yolanda Saldívar docuseries is the latest exploitation of Selena’s memory

Published

on

The Yolanda Saldívar docuseries is the latest exploitation of Selena’s memory

Earlier this month, the Oxygen network announced “Selena & Yolanda: The Secrets Between Them,” a two-part docuseries airing Saturday that promises to shed new light on the murder of Tejano icon Selena Quintanilla directly from her killer, Yolanda Saldívar.

“After so many years, I think it’s time to set the record straight,” says Saldívar in a trailer, speaking from inside Mountain View Prison in Gatesville, Texas, where she’s been since 1995. She is up for parole in 2025, almost 30 years to the day of Selena’s murder.

The clip points to “secrets” Quintanilla held, and based on the tone, it’s heavily implied that those secrets are dark in nature. “This is not a simple case of murder,” a family member of Saldívar says. Another talking head comments, “She’s just a person you can’t believe,” leaving plenty of room for the viewer to believe it’s Selena he is referring to.

This all feels like yet another exercise in salacious, tabloid rabidness that has long plagued victimized women. The series, created without the consent of the Quintanilla family, thus far has come off as a cash grab from a network that devolved from a space for women-led stories to focusing on true crime shows that regularly swerve into the morally questionable.

Advertisement

“In documentary filmmaking, the director, the producer, and the writers hold the power of framing: What are they highlighting? What are they giving weight to? What are they centering?” said Maria Elena Garcia, creator and host of the podcast “Anything for Selena” and executive editor at Futuro Studios.

“Based on the promotions that have aired, it’s very clear to me that they’re giving a lot of weight to Yolanda’s allegations. Empty allegations that she has been making for literally decades. To me, that’s incredibly irresponsible, unethical and, frankly, just distasteful.”

To capitalize on Selena, exploit her in death and attempt to renegotiate her victimhood by platforming her killer and positioning the existence of “secrets” as a means of rationalizing her murder is a new low, even in the true crime-obsessed world we live in now.

“What bothers me the most is that framing implies that whatever Selena’s secret was, somehow contributed to her death,” Garcia said. “That somehow, whatever she was allegedly hiding, informed Yolanda’s decision to kill her and when you do that, you’re putting Selena on trial.”

Any allegations, added Garcia, are “a really unfortunate attempt to skew her story into some sort of true crime cliché,” which is a shame when “there’s so much richness to her legacy that people could dig into instead of going for the cheap tricks of true crime.”

Advertisement

What those allegations are doesn’t matter. No secret held, nothing Quintanilla may have done or said, excuses Saldívar murdering her, and positioning a docuseries in a manner that encourages that narrative is nasty business.

And business it is. Selena is big money; a brand that routinely pulls in profit and is a rare sure bet because of her devoted fanbase. The Quintanilla family has collaborated with partners for a number of successful Selena-centric projects including, but not limited to: the 1997 film “Selena” (starring Jennifer Lopez); 2020’s “Selena: The Series,” which streams on Netflix; collections with Funko Pop!, Forever 21, MAC, and others; and a 2015 crowdfunding attempt to create a Selena hologram for concert use, which drew some criticism.

Quintanilla is a venerated figure whose violent killing has fueled her exploitation. She was taken at her prime, which leaves space for others to continue to exalt her cultural impact and memorialize her through art and merchandise, usually with reverence and loving intentions. But sometimes not.

Ultimately it’s the decision of her family to allow Selena products to be created, and the consumer’s choice to buy them. What keeps consumers engaging in all things Selena is when it’s apparent that what’s being offered comes from a place of love and celebration. And so much of it is. From podcasts, to T-shirts, to piñatas.

This docuseries, however, is rooted in something much darker. The Quintanillas, for better or worse, have been litigiously protective of her image, and this docuseries perhaps explains why to some extent.

Advertisement

“I understand why this show is being made, but it’s not a great reason,” said Jorge Rivera, a television writer and co-chair of the Writers Guild of America Latinx Writers Committee, who has worked on a number of true crime docs over the years. “No one’s going get answers from this that they think they’re gonna get. No one’s going get closure from this that they think that they’re gonna get … I don’t think anyone’s going to benefit except for the people making the series. So what is the point of this except for a money grab?”

That it exists is not a shock, as the Selena Industrial Complex will always churn so long as there’s money to be made, which points to Hollywood’s lack of imagination and investment when it comes to Latinx stories.

“The industry seems to really gravitate towards our trauma,” Rivera said. “It’s really, really frustrating because we are way much more than that. We are fully realized human beings with a tremendous scope of experiences and stories to tell.”

After last year’s SAG and WGA strike ended in November, many writers are still out of work, shows are being canceled (Hulu’s “This Fool” being the latest on the chopping block) and Hollywood is struggling to get it together, leaving creatives all around frustrated and in financial straits.

“It’s really a struggle to get our shows greenlit and even when they get greenlit they don’t get the proper marketing support and they often get canceled first before really finding an audience,” Rivera added. “But these are the kinds of things that we’re seeing greenlit in this market. It’s a huge bummer.”

Advertisement

Movie Reviews

Review | Hoppers: Pixar’s new animation is a hilarious, heartfelt animal Avatar

Published

on

Review | Hoppers: Pixar’s new animation is a hilarious, heartfelt animal Avatar

4/5 stars

Bounding into cinemas just in time for spring, the latest Pixar animation is a pleasingly charming tale of man vs nature, with a bit of crazy robot tech thrown in.

The star of Hoppers is Mabel Tanaka (voiced by Piper Curda), a young animal-lover leading a one-girl protest over a freeway being built through the tranquil countryside near her hometown of Beaverton.

Because the freeway is the pet project of the town’s popular mayor, Jerry (Jon Hamm), who is vying for re-election, Mabel’s protests fall on deaf ears.

Everything changes when she stumbles upon top-secret research by her biology professor, Dr Sam Fairfax (Kathy Najimy), that allows for the human consciousness to be linked to robotic animals. This lets users get up close and personal with other species.

Advertisement
“This is like Avatar,” Mabel coos, and, in truth, it is. Plugged into a headset, Mabel is reborn inside a robotic beaver. She plans to recruit a real beaver to help populate the glade, which is set to be destroyed by Jerry’s proposed road.
Continue Reading

Entertainment

Kurt Cobain’s Fender, Beatles drum head among $1-billion collection going to auction

Published

on

Kurt Cobain’s Fender, Beatles drum head among -billion collection going to auction

In the summer of 1991, Nirvana filmed the music video for “Smells Like Teen Spirit” on a Culver City sound stage. Kurt Cobain strummed the grunge anthem’s iconic four-chord opening riff on a 1969 Fender Mustang, Lake Placid Blue with a signature racing stripe.

Nearly 35 years later, the six-string relic hung on a gallery wall at Christie’s in Beverly Hills as part of a display of late billionaire businessman Jim Irsay’s world-renowned guitar collection, which heads to auction at Christie’s, New York, beginning Tuesday. Each piece in the Beverly Hills gallery, illuminated by an arched spotlight and flanked by a label chronicling its history, carried the aura of a Renaissance painting.

  • Share via

    Advertisement

Advertisement

Irsay’s billion-dollar guitar arsenal, crowned “The Greatest Guitar Collection on Earth” by Guitar World magazine, is the focal point of the Christie’s auction, which has split approximately 400 objects — about half of which are guitars — into four segments: the “Hall of Fame” group of anchor items, the “Icons of Pop Culture” class of miscellaneous memorabilia, the “Icons of Music” mixed batch of electric and acoustic guitars and an online segment that compiles the remainder of Irsay’s collection. The online sale, featuring various autographed items, smaller instruments and historical documents, features the items at the lowest price points.

A portion of auction proceeds will be donated to charities that Irsay supported during his lifetime.

The instruments of famous musicians have long been coveted collector’s items. But in the case of the Jim Irsay Collection, the handcrafted six-strings have acquired a more ephemeral quality in the eyes of their admirers.

Amelia Walker, the specialist head of private and iconic collections at Christie’s, said at the recent highlight exhibition in L.A. that the auction represents “a real moment where these [objects] are being elevated beyond what we traditionally call memorabilia” into artistic masterpieces.

“They deserve the kind of the pedestal that we give to art as well,” Walker said. “Because they are not only works of art in terms of their creation, but what they have created, what their owners have created with them — it’s the purest form of art.”

Advertisement

Cobain’s Fender was only one of the music history treasures nestled in Christie’s gallery. A few paces away, Jerry Garcia’s “Budman” amplifier, once part of the Grateful Dead’s three-story high “Wall of Sound,” perched atop a podium. Just past it lay the Beatles logo drum head (estimated between $1 million and $2 million) used for the band’s debut appearance on “The Ed Sullivan Show,” which garnered a historic 73 million viewers and catalyzed the British Invasion. Pencil lines were still visible beneath the logo’s signature “drop T.”

A drum head.

Pencil lines are still visible on the drum head Ringo Starr played during the Beatles’ debut appearance on “The Ed Sullivan Show.”

(Christie’s Images LTD, 2026)

It is exceptionally rare for even one such artifact to go to market, let alone a billion-dollar group of them at once, Walker said. But a public sale enabling many to participate and demonstrate the “true market value” of these objects is what Irsay would have wanted, she added.

Dropping tens of millions of dollars on pop culture memorabilia may seem an odd hobby for an NFL general manager, yet Irsay viewed collecting much like he viewed leading the Indianapolis Colts.

Advertisement

Irsay, the youngest NFL general manager in history, said in a 2014 Colts Media interview that watching and emulating the legendary NFL owners who came before him “really taught me to be a steward.”

“Ownership is a great responsibility. You can’t buy respect,” he said. “Respect only comes from you being a steward.”

The first major acquisition in Irsay’s collection came in 2001, with his $2.4-million purchase of the original 120-foot scroll for Jack Kerouac’s 1957 novel, “On the Road.” He loved the book and wanted to preserve it, Walker said. But he also frequently lent it out, just like he regularly toured his guitar collection beginning 20 years later.

A scroll of writing.

Jim Irsay purchased the original 120-foot scroll manuscript of Jack Kerouac’s “On the Road” for $2.4 million in 2001.

(Christie’s Images)

Advertisement

“He said publicly, ‘I’m not the owner of these things. I’m just that current custodian looking after them for future generations,’ ” Walker said. “And I think that’s what true collectors always say.”

At its L.A. highlight exhibition, Irsay’s collection held an air of synchronicity. Paul McCartney’s handwritten lyrics for “Hey Jude” hung just a few steps from a promotional poster — the only one in existence — for the 1959 concert Buddy Holly, Ritchie Valens and J.P. “The Big Bopper” Richardson were en route to perform when their plane crashed. The tragedy spurred Don McLean to write “American Pie,” about “the day the music died.”

Holly was McCartney’s “great inspiration,” Christie’s specialist Zita Gibson said. “So everything connects.”

Later, the Beatles’ 1966 song “Paperback Writer” played over the speakers near-parallel to the guitars the song was written on.

Irsay’s collection also contains a bit of whimsy, with gems like a prop golden ticket from 1971’s “Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory” — estimated between $60,000 and $120,000 — and reading, “In your wildest dreams you could not imagine the marvelous surprises that await you!”

Advertisement

Another fan-favorite is the “Wilson” volleyball from 2000’s “Cast Away,” starring Tom Hanks, estimated between $60,000 and $80,000, Gibson said.

Historically, such objects were often preserved by accident. But as the memorabilia market has ballooned over the last decade or so, Gibson said, “a lot of artists are much more careful about making sure that things don’t get into the wrong hands. After rehearsals, they tidy up after themselves.”

If anything proves the market value of seemingly worthless ephemera, Walker added, it’s fans clawing for printed set lists at the end of a concert.

“They’re desperate for that connection. This is what it’s all about,” the specialist said. It’s what drove Irsay as well, she said: “He wanted to have a connection with these great artists of his generation and also the generation above him. And he wanted to share them with people.”

In Irsay’s home, his favorite guitars weren’t hung like classic paintings. Instead, they were strewn about the rooms he frequented, available for him to play whenever the urge struck him.

Advertisement

Thanks to tune-up efforts from Walker, many of the guitars headed to auction are fully operational in the hopes that their buyers can do the same.

“They’re working instruments. They need to be looked after, to be played,” Walker said. And even though they make for great gallery art, “they’re not just for hanging on the wall.”

Continue Reading

Movie Reviews

Film reviews: ‘How to Make a Killing,’ ‘Pillion,’ and ‘Midwinter Break’

Published

on

Film reviews: ‘How to Make a Killing,’ ‘Pillion,’ and ‘Midwinter Break’

‘How to Make a Killing’

Directed by John Patton Ford (R)

★★

Continue Reading

Trending