San Francisco, CA
Time for reform? San Francisco has been working under same legislative rules for nearly 30 years
SAN FRANCISCO (KGO) — San Francisco has been working under the same legislative set of rules for the past nearly 30 years.
We’re talking about the city’s charter that dictates how things operate. In order to build a better Bay Area, most anyone in city government will tell you it’s time to reform the city charter.
“What we have at this point, I think, is kind of a mess,” according to Supervisor Rafael Mandelman because of how the city’s governance is structured, based, in part, on that charter.
Here’s how the San Francisco Bay Area Planning and Urban Research Association, SPUR, explains it.
“Who’s in charge and who gets to make which decisions and who ultimately has responsibility and authority and accountability is very confusing,” said SPUR President and CEO Alicia John-Baptiste.
MORE: Here’s why a San Francisco landlord is purposely keeping commercial rents low for businesses
The charter was adopted in 1996 started out with 173 pages. Through the years, city leaders have added another 365 pages.
It includes proposals and ballots measures that voters have also approved. As a result, a lot of that extra stuff has, little-by-little, weakened the power of mayors that came after Willie Brown.
“I was certainly the last mayor that had the authority to be the mayor,” Brown said.
What most San Franciscans don’t know is that any mayoral candidate who wins in November will have limited authority over who leads San Francisco’s city departments.
Let’s say the mayor wanted to pick the next police chief. The mayor can only select someone from a short list given by the police commission.
MORE: Here’s why San Francisco’s art market continues to struggle against other big US cities
When it comes to hiring or firing the head of the Municipal Transportation Agency, the mayor can’t even do that and has absolutely no say in the matter, because that person is appointed or terminated by the SFMTA Board.
“All of that has made it really difficult, if not impossible, for a person to really be the CEO of a city like San Francisco,” Brown said.
Therefore, one can argue that there are too many cooks in the kitchen slowing things down. Have you tried to open a restaurant in San Francisco? Sure, the health department has to be involved, but why does it take 11 city agencies to get the required permits and licenses?
According to SPUR a new restaurant must go through 61 steps just to open.
“Well, there are too many cooks in the kitchen but there is also too many kitchens. We actually should be consolidating a lot of this. We should be bringing these agencies with responsibility for permitting together and making them function together, a unified authority,” Mandelman said.
MORE: SF launches new downtown revitalization push at Embarcadero to bring people back to city
San Francisco also has 126 boards and commissions, some with decision-making power that shape how a department operates.
According to SPUR, with so many commissions and departments sometimes conflicting with one another, it’s like a maze, making advancing a citywide agenda difficult not to mention time consuming.
SPUR says some commissions are very useful to maintain checks and balances. Still, they are recommending a review of all commissions.
“To decide which ones should stay, which one should have their roles changes and which ones have already lived out their useful purpose and can be let go,” Jean-Baptiste said.
For example, voters approved the creation of the Department of Sanitation and Streets, only to have it abolished two years later.
MORE: SFMTA delays vote on banning right turns at red lights anywhere in SF
Even though that department no longer exists today, its own oversight commission is still there.
As a result, people are not very satisfied with how things run in the city. A survey conducted last year by the city found residents gave certain departments mainly Bs and Cs.
There are many now calling the city charter to be reformed.
How do they get there? Let’s just say in the coming months, lots of people are expected to weigh in to develop a charter reform measure so that the board of supervisors can place it on the November 2026 ballot.
“If we want to do better than what we’ve been doing, if we want to improve the functioning of city governance, I do think there are structural changes that we need to make to make our city government is more successful going forward, and I think San Francisco deserves it. I think we should do it,” Mandelman said.
Copyright © 2024 KGO-TV. All Rights Reserved.
San Francisco, CA
Bay Area Teen Waymo Riders Nabbed For Allegedly Shooting Projectiles From Robotaxi
San Mateo Police said they were contacted by Waymo about the two 15-year-old riders after they were seen drinking and shooting from the vehicle. The vehicle was stopped as police responded and officers were able to safely remove the teens.
An investigation determined the teens were shooting Orbeez water beads and drinking while being chauffeured around the city.
San Francisco, CA
Bay Area restaurant has strict policy on acceptable children behavior
Watch CBS News
San Francisco, CA
49ers Sign DL Gracen Halton to a Four-Year Deal
The San Francisco 49ers today announced they have signed DL Gracen Halton to a four-year deal. With the signing, the 49ers now have all eight of the team’s 2026 draft picks under contract.
Halton (6-3, 293) was the first of two fourth-round draft picks (107th overall) selected by the 49ers in this year’s draft out of Oklahoma. He appeared in 47 games (10 starts) over four seasons at Oklahoma (2022-25) and finished with 84 tackles, 17.5 tackles for loss, 8.5 sacks, three forced fumbles and two passes defensed. In 2025, he appeared in 13 games (seven starts) and tallied 33 tackles, 7.0 tackles for loss, 3.5 sacks, two passes defensed and one forced fumble (returned for a TD), earning Second-Team All-SEC honors. In 2024, he appeared in 13 games (three starts) and recorded 30 tackles, 6.0 tackles for loss, 5.0 sacks and two forced fumbles. In 2023, he appeared in 11 games and tallied 11 tackles and 3.5 tackles for loss. As a true freshman in 2022, Halton appeared in 10 games and recorded 10 tackles and 1.0 tackle for loss.
A 22-year-old native of San Diego, CA, Halton attended St. Augustine (San Diego, CA) High School.
-
Los Angeles, Ca3 minutes agoWaymo video could determine charges after teens’ bizarre California ride
-
Detroit, MI21 minutes ago
DPD investigating after human remains found in home on Detroit’s west side
-
San Francisco, CA36 minutes agoBay Area Teen Waymo Riders Nabbed For Allegedly Shooting Projectiles From Robotaxi
-
Dallas, TX41 minutes ago
Role Call: Tyrus Wheat looking to make most of second stint with Cowboys
-
Miami, FL48 minutes ago2026 Miami Football Early Opponent Preview, Game 8: North Carolina
-
Boston, MA51 minutes agoBoston sues social media companies over ‘addictive’ features, joining nationwide litigation
-
Denver, CO56 minutes agoPeyton Watson landing spots: Could Nuggets star actually leave Denver?
-
Seattle, WA1 hour ago14-year-old dies in Seattle e-bike crash at Colonnade Park after losing control on steep stairs – MyNorthwest.com