San Diego woman sentenced to eight years for fatal vehicle altercation

SAN DIEGO (CNS) — A San Diego woman who drove a car toward her neighbor was sentenced today to just over eight years in state prison. The neighbor wound up clinging to the moving vehicle before she was thrown to the ground, causing fatal injuries.

Read San Diego Police: Woman killed following argument with neighbor

Samantha Muniz, 45, was found guilty by a San Diego jury for the deadly altercation that led to the death of 29-year-old Jennelle Self June 27 last year.

Muniz was initially arrested on suspicion of murder but was ultimately charged with assault with a deadly weapon. Prosecutors declined to comment on the charging decision.

Prosecutors said Self was standing in front of Muniz’s car when the

defendant accelerated toward her. While Self clung to the car, Muniz continued driving until Self fell to the street.

Deputy District Attorney Kelsey Hollander said she sustained blunt-force trauma to her head and went into cardiac arrest. She was taken to a hospital, where she died.

At trial, Hollander detailed a longstanding feud between the women, who were neighbors at a Veterans Village of San Diego transitional housing property on Imperial Avenue.

Hollander alleged that just before Self was fatally injured, Muniz waved a knife in Self’s face during a heated argument. In February of 2022, Muniz threw a chair from her second-story balcony, striking Self, who was below.

Along with the assault with a deadly weapon count, Muniz was convicted of brandishing a knife and assault for the other two incidents.

The February assault led Self to seek a temporary restraining order against Muniz, which a judge granted. In her restraining order request, Self alleged Muniz had struck her with a vehicle on another occasion and had threatened to stab her.

Defense attorney Bridget Rubin told jurors Muniz acted in self-defense and said Self was the aggressor. Rubin alleged Muniz was trying to leave her home, but Self placed herself in front of her car and slammed her fists on the car’s hood in an attempt to provoke a fight.

The attorney said Muniz thought she had enough space to turn and drive away from Self, but Self jumped onto the vehicle.

Hollander told jurors Self did not pose a threat to Muniz, as she was behind the wheel of her car and armed with knives.

The prosecutor showed jurors a series of text messages in which Muniz referred to Self in derogatory terms, which Hollander said showed Muniz acted “out of anger and hatred”‘ toward Self and not self-defense.

Copyright 2023, City News Service, Inc.