Federal judge says Phoenix can’t ban homeless encampment but sweeps are OK

PHOENIX (3TV/CBS 5) — It was a combined bag of wins and losses for the ACLU over its lawsuit towards the town of Phoenix and the raids of the homeless encampment downtown. A federal choose on Thursday issued an abbreviated order about what the town can and might’t do. It says the town can’t implement tenting and sleeping bans for homeless individuals or seize any gadgets in the course of the metropolis’s sweeps of the homeless encampment until the gadgets are an “rapid risk to public well being or security” or might have been utilized in against the law. If the police take one thing, they’ve to attend at the very least a month earlier than destroying it.

If officers or metropolis workers take one thing from the encampment that they assume was deserted, they’ve to go away some type of discover on the spot the place the property was taken so the proprietor can retrieve it. The choose’s order additionally mentioned the town can nonetheless do the sweeps at Phoenix’s largest homeless encampment, generally known as The Zone. The town is about to renew these on Friday morning. The sweeps, which normally concerned metropolis employees and law enforcement officials, had been paused at the start of 2022. Some have known as them “raids,” however the metropolis mentioned the sweeps had been accomplished to guard the well being and security of individuals within the camp. The ACLU claimed homeless individuals within the encampment misplaced important paperwork, medication and different belongings throughout these sweeps and by no means received them again. “Due to this injunction, unsheltered individuals received’t be liable to dropping important belongings, receiving unconstitutional citations, and experiencing additional trauma by the hands of the town and Phoenix PD,” Benjamin Rundall, senior workers lawyer on the ACLU of Arizona, mentioned in an announcement.

Additionally on Wednesday, a Maricopa County Superior Courtroom choose heard arguments a couple of totally different lawsuit concerning the homeless in Phoenix. Enterprise homeowners close to The Zone sued the town, claiming the encampment is a public nuisance. The town’s attorneys argued in courtroom it doesn’t have the constitutional obligation to guard the property values of the tenants and homeowners who filed the lawsuit. Those that filed the lawsuit say they’re involved for his or her security. In 5 weeks, there have been a few incidents within the encampment. A lifeless new child was discovered mendacity on the street on Nov. 12. Two days later, just a few tents caught fireplace, leaving one man badly injured. The choose, Scott A. Blaney, mentioned he’d get a ruling as rapidly as doable, however as a result of it’s an advanced case, it most likely received’t come down till subsequent week or later.

Copyright 2022 KTVK/KPHO. All rights reserved.