Pogie bill would put the first-ever limits on Louisiana’s biggest catch

A invoice that may put the primary substantial limits on Louisiana’s largest however least-known industrial fishery might enhance the well being of the Gulf of Mexico however cripple the economies of some coastal communities.

Home Invoice 1033 would cap the menhaden catch in Louisiana waters at 573 million kilos per 12 months – an quantity that far exceeds the state’s mixed annual catch of shrimp, oyster, crab and crawfish however falls far beneath the unrestricted hauls the menhaden trade has loved for many years.

The invoice would additionally require menhaden fishing vessels to file each day experiences on catch quantities and areas, making a degree of accountability that the invoice’s proponents say has been sorely missing.

“We owe it to our coast, our state and ourselves to grasp and handle this fishery correctly,” David Cresson, CEO of the Coastal Conservation Affiliation of Louisiana. “Proper now we don’t and it’s not.”

Nonetheless, trade officers say the invoice might power the closure of the state’s two menhaden processing crops, placing a whole bunch of individuals out of labor in areas with few different job prospects.  

Advertisement

“This invoice goes to shut us down in a pair years, and it’s going to have a direct impression on Plaquemines Parish,” stated Shane Treadaway, a fleet supervisor for Daybrook Fisheries in Empire. 

The invoice handed out of the Home Pure Assets and Surroundings Committee by a 9 to three vote final week and will likely be debated on the Home flooring Tuesday.

Taking meals from ‘Sportsman Paradise’ fish

Menhaden, additionally referred to as pogies and bunker, are a tiny, oily fish used primarily in fertilizers and meals for cats, hogs and chickens. Their oil can be added to cosmetics, cleaning soap, omega-3 fatty acid capsules and different well being dietary supplements.

Two foreign-owned firms – Omega Protein of Canada and Daybrook of South Africa – dominate the Louisiana menhaden fishery, which has produced an annual catch price a median of $80 million since 2010. Throughout that point, the yearly catch has ranged between 612 million and 1.1 billion kilos. 

With no catch limits, Louisiana has the Gulf’s most lax menhaden laws. Texas units a catch restrict and prohibits menhaden fishing inside a half-mile of its coast, and Mississippi just lately joined Alabama in enacting statewide 1-mile buffer zones. In the meantime, Florida has a blanket ban on large-scale web fishing in its waters.

Supporters say the invoice is a long-overdue examine on industrial-scale harvests of a fish that helps a lot of the Atlantic meals chain. Whales, seabirds and dolphins eat menhaden, as do fish in style with anglers, like redfish, trout and bass. 

Whereas Gulf menhaden populations seem steady, anglers blame the menhaden trade for the decline of prized catches in areas commonly swept over by 1,500-foot-long menhaden nets.

“Should you do wholesale elimination of menhaden, it takes away meals from Sportsman Paradise species,” stated the invoice’s sponsor, Rep. Joseph Orgeron, R-Larose.

What’s extra, menhaden nets snag greater than menhaden. The state Division of Wildlife and Fisheries has acquired an growing variety of complaints about menhaden bycatch and the paths of useless redfish and trout left within the wakes of menhaden ships, which typically come inside a number of hundred yards of the shore.

“With this indiscriminate sort of take, every thing is affected,” Orgeron stated.

‘What jobs I’ve, I want’

Nevertheless, the menhaden trade has warned that the Louisiana invoice’s restrictions might power the closure of the 2 massive menhaden processing crops in Louisiana. Omega owns a plant in Abbeville, and Daybrook operates a plant within the small south Plaquemines Parish group of Empire. In keeping with Daybrook, the Empire plant processes about 40% of the Gulf’s menhaden catch.

Rep. Mack Cormier, D-Belle Chasse, stated Plaquemines “can’t endure that loss.”

The parish has misplaced three massive oil trade employers lately – most just lately the Phillips 66 Alliance Refinery, which had 470 staff and nearly as many contractors. With about 300 employees, the Daybrook plant might now be the parish’s largest personal employer, Cormier stated.

“What jobs I’ve, I want,” he stated.

However these jobs have come at a value. The plant has air pollution issues that parish well being officers and environmental teams have been elevating alarms about for many years. In a lawsuit final month, Daybrook’s personal security and environmental supervisor charged that the plant willfully spews massive quantities of fish waste into close by waterways and has resisted taking primary precautions to keep away from leaks and spills.

Omega’s Abbeville plant has been the supply of odor complaints from as distant as New Iberia, about 20 miles east. Amongst its environmental violations was a $1 million high quality in 2017 for twice dumping massive volumes of polluted water into the Vermilion River.

Different latest efforts to limit the menhaden trade have been unsuccessful. In 2020, the state Wildlife and Fisheries Fee rejected a proposed menhaden fishing “exclusion zone” extending one mile from Louisiana shoreline.

Final 12 months, Orgeron crafted a invoice that may have established half-mile exclusion zones, with wider buffers round some barrier islands. The zones had been whittled all the way down to 1 / 4 mile by Senate leaders however the measure died amid negotiations in a Home-Senate convention committee.