Louisiana has 8 of the worst water-polluting refineries in the country, study says

With roaring flares and stacks that billow clouds of smoke and vapor, it’s no secret that oil refineries hurt the air. However the poisonous chemical substances spilling out of refineries as wastewater additionally pose environmental dangers, particularly in Louisiana, the place eight services ranked among the many high oil operations that pollute public waterways, in keeping with a nationwide examine.

In an evaluation of wastewater discharge data from 81 refineries, the Environmental Integrity Challenge discovered south Louisiana refineries discharging among the highest quantities of heavy metals, nitrogen and different pollution into rivers, estuaries and different waterways.

The EIP examine says the U.S. Environmental Safety Company and state regulators are doing little to curb the half billion gallons of wastewater that pours from U.S. refineries every day. Federal requirements enacted many years in the past are not often enforced and have did not maintain tempo with advances in water remedy strategies, the examine stated.

“The EPA’s failure to behave has uncovered public waterways to a witches’ brew of refinery contaminants,” the examine stated.

The Marathon refinery alongside the Mississippi River in Garyville ranked fourth and the Phillips 66 refinery in Lake Charles ranked seventh for releases of nickel. Marathon’s refinery ranked eighth for selenium discharges, and the Exxon Mobil refinery in Baton Rouge ranked tenth, the EIP examine stated.

Nickel and selenium are poisonous metals that may mutate fish, mangle reproductive methods and journey up the meals chain to different sea life, birds and other people. Additionally they persist within the surroundings for lengthy intervals, probably poisoning an ecosystem for many years, EIP Government Director Eric Schaeffer stated.

“These heavy metals are extremely poisonous to fish and different critters even in minute portions,” stated Schaeffer, who managed the EPA’s civil enforcement division through the late Nineteen Nineties. “Within the surroundings, they’re actually not possible to take away.”

The Citgo refinery in Lake Charles, Phillips 66 Alliance Refinery close to Belle Chasse, and Chalmette Refinery close to New Orleans ranked eighth, ninth and tenth for releases of nitrogen, a nutrient that feeds algal blooms and is the primary contributor to the Gulf of Mexico’s low-oxygen ‘lifeless zone.’ The three refineries launched a mixed 1.4 million gallons of nitrogen in 2021, in keeping with the examine.

The Alliance Refinery closed in late 2021 and now serves as a storage terminal.

The Exxon Cell refinery in Baton Rouge and the Shell refinery in Norco ranked sixth and ninth for the discharge of ‘whole dissolved solids,’ a cocktail of byproducts from the refining course of that may increase water salinity, harming fish and tainting public water methods.

Louisiana made up half of the highest 10 ammonia polluters. The Alliance Refinery ranked first, with greater than 255,000 lbs. launched in 2021. The Valero refinery in Norco, Phillips 66 and Citgo refineries in Lake Charles, and the Chalmette Refinery had been additionally high dischargers of ammonia, which might hurt the interior organs of fish and different animals. In accordance with the EIP, the Valero refinery in Norco has outdated federal permits that enable it to dump practically 2,000 lbs. of ammonia per day into the Mississippi.

Most Louisiana refineries named within the examine didn’t reply to requests for remark or deferred questions to grease business commerce teams. The Louisiana Mid-Continent Oil and Gasoline Affiliation, which represents lots of the refineries, didn’t reply to a request for remark.

In a press release, Exxon Mobil stated its refineries function “in compliance with stringent native, state and federal rules, and are all the time working to enhance environmental efficiency.”

No matter refineries are doing to enhance, it’s clearly not sufficient, stated John Beard, founding father of the Port Arthur Neighborhood Motion Community, a bunch working to scrub Sabine Lake and different waterways alongside the Texas-Louisiana border.

“Individuals say we’d like the roles and the merchandise (refineries) make,” he stated. “That’s true. However we don’t want the air pollution. They will do higher.”

The EIP locations a lot of the blame on the EPA, which it says has the ability to toughen refinery rules and enforcement however chooses to not act.

The U.S. Clear Water Act requires the EPA to set limits on refinery pollution and replace them each 5 years as remedy expertise improves. However the EPA has by no means set limits for a number of widespread refinery pollution, together with selenium, benzene, mercury and cyanide, in keeping with the report. And whereas the instruments for treating these pollution have turn out to be higher and cheaper over time, the EPA nonetheless holds refineries to requirements set practically 40 years in the past.

“No person thinks a rotary telephone is one of the best ways to make a telephone name in 2023,” Schaeffer stated. The identical considering, he stated, must be utilized to the EPA’s Eighties-era water remedy requirements.

Few refineries have adopted new expertise partly as a result of most are very previous, averaging 74 years within the U.S. The Exxon Mobil refinery in Baton Rouge began operations in 1909. The Marathon refinery, at nearly 50 years previous, is one among Louisiana’s youngest.

The report says the EPA has a double normal on the subject of coal-fired energy crops, that are additionally sometimes fairly previous. In 2015, the EPA mandated more durable coal plant discharge limits for selenium, although the common refinery discharges way more selenium than the common coal plant, in keeping with the EIP.

EPA officers stated they had been conscious of the report however declined to touch upon it.

When refineries exceed their beneficiant discharge limits, the EPA usually fails to behave, in keeping with the examine. Greater than 80% of the the 81 refineries assessed by the EIP exceeded their air pollution limits a minimum of as soon as between 2019 and 2021, however solely 1 / 4 had been penalized, it stated.

When the EPA does challenge fines, they usually quantity to “chump change” for the billion-dollar industries, Schaeffer stated.

In some circumstances, states have enacted more durable guidelines than the EPA. California, for instance, has restricted ammonia discharges from a Valero refinery in that state to about 1% of the ammonia spilling from the Valero refinery in Norco, in keeping with the examine.

Louisiana not often enacts stricter guidelines than the EPA. The state Division of Environmental High quality sometimes follows the EPAs lead and has in circumstances fallen wanting it. It has recently taken warmth from the federal company over permitting Black folks to endure disproportionate impacts from air air pollution.

However the examine says the EPA is doing the identical to minority and poor communities. Citing the EPA’s personal information, the examine notes that over half the nation’s refineries are concentrated in areas with excessive percentages of Black or Hispanic residents. Two-thirds of refineries are in areas the place the variety of low-income residents exceeds the nationwide common.

As soon as refinery pollution are in public waterways, they unfold a lot farther than the neighboring communities, probably contaminating the seashores the place many individuals swim and the fish many individuals eat. The report estimates that just about 70% of the refineries examined in 2021 discharged right into a waterway that was listed as “impaired” beneath the Clear Water Act. Which means the water was thought-about unsafe for for fishing, swimming and different leisure actions.

“We’re within the stomach of the beast,” Beard stated of the heavy business alongside the Gulf Coast. “All the things that occurs with petrochemicals is occurring right here.”

“Take into consideration that,” he added, “subsequent time you go fishing or swim within the Gulf of Mexico.”