News
Doomed plan to send Polish jets to Ukraine exposes rift in western alliance
Victoria Nuland, the senior US state division official, was on her method to testify earlier than Congress on Tuesday when she heard that Poland had provided to provide its Russian-made MiG fighter jets to the US to move to Ukraine.
“I noticed that announcement . . . as I used to be actually driving right here,” Nuland instructed the Senate international relations committee, including that it was a complete “shock”.
The White Home was additionally caught off guard when Poland revealed the provide on a authorities web site. One particular person accustomed to the state of affairs stated the US ambassador to Warsaw had not even been knowledgeable by the Poles.
The discharge of the provide with out consultations with Washington uncovered the primary actual fissure within the united method that the US and its Nato allies had proven over the struggle in Ukraine.
Hours later, John Kirby, Pentagon spokesperson, stated the plan was not “tenable”. He stated the concept of Poland sending MiGs to Ramstein, a US-Nato air base in Germany, from the place they might “fly into airspace that’s contested with Russia over Ukraine raises critical issues for the complete Nato alliance”.
The Polish provide was the most recent twist in a saga that performed out in private and non-private because the US, Poland and Nato debated the switch of the MiG plane to Ukraine. It was a brand new variation of a convoluted swap thought that may have concerned the US sending F-16 fighter jets to Poland to replenish its air drive.
9 days earlier than, Josep Borrell, EU international coverage chief, had thrust the broader subject into the general public eye by saying some EU members deliberate to provide fighter jets to Ukraine following a request from Kyiv. His remark put strain on different western leaders to reply to an concept that the US and its allies weren’t planning to make public at the moment.
A number of days after Borrell had spoken, Polish president Andrzej Duda stated Warsaw wouldn’t ship MiGs to Ukraine as a result of it might be “army interference within the battle”.
However a number of US and Polish sources accustomed to the state of affairs stated his remark got here after Washington rejected a Polish proposal that may have concerned Poland straight sending MiGs to Ukraine and receiving F-16s in return. One senior Polish official stated Warsaw obtained a “sceptical” response to its authentic proposal.
The US didn’t oppose Poland transferring its MiGs to Ukraine. However the Pentagon concluded that supplying F-16s can be each troublesome logistically and, extra importantly, risked dragging America right into a struggle with Russia.
One particular person accustomed to the controversy stated the Pentagon had opposed the F-16 thought from the start. Some US officers have been involved that Poland was primarily suggesting the swap as a method to improve its air drive.
A number of different folks stated the state division supported the primary thought whereas the White Home Nationwide Safety Council was divided.
The concept appeared to have evaporated till it re-emerged on March 5 when Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky spoke to virtually 300 US lawmakers on a Zoom name, and made a passionate plea for fighter jets. He stated Poland was ready to ship MiGs to Ukraine in change for F-16s.
Hours later, the White Home instructed the Monetary Occasions it was in talks with Poland over the problem. The next day, Antony Blinken, secretary of state, stated throughout a go to to Ukraine that the proposal had the “inexperienced gentle”. Warsaw reacted angrily as a result of they’d not been instructed in regards to the US shift.
“The issue was that we had been instructed ‘No’. After which all of the sudden they go to the media and say there’s a inexperienced gentle and on the similar time there was no communication with us,” stated the senior Polish official.
One particular person accustomed to the diplomatic forwards and backwards stated the US didn’t imply to blindside Poland. He stated it was unclear if Poland was nonetheless — as Zelensky had urged — and wished to provide Warsaw house to manoeuvre. However he stated he understood why Poland was upset on the approach the US had dealt with the state of affairs.
A number of folks accustomed to the diplomatic kerfuffle stated Warsaw had made the shock provide handy its MiGs to the US as a result of it wished to scotch ideas that it was merely in search of to improve its air drive. It was additionally pissed off at what it perceived as an try to strong-arm it into taking dangers that would immediate retaliation from Russia with out the complete assist of the Nato alliance.
“It was public statements with out session . . . and portraying us to Ukraine as reluctant, whereas really they have been discouraging us,” the Polish official stated. “The federal government acquired infuriated and replied in type. The US shouldn’t be attempting to shift the blame on to us. We’re doing quite a bit for Ukraine, so we shouldn’t be uncovered like this.”
Dan Fried, a former US ambassador to Poland, stated the Poles interpreted Blinken’s remark in regards to the “inexperienced gentle” within the wake of the Zelensky name with Congress because the US shifting the onus on to them.
“They acquired pissed,” Fried defined. “They determined to place the onus again on the US (with the Ramstein proposal).”
“Borrell tousled, the US tousled, the Poles tousled, however no one was performing in unhealthy religion,” stated Fried, who’s now on the Atlantic Council. “It was an operational clusterfuck, however not strategic abandonment of Ukraine.”
Michal Baranowski, a US-Poland skilled on the German Marshall Fund think-tank, stated the spat was unlikely to derail Polish-US relations in the long run.
“If the Individuals got here throughout as pushy and twisting Poland’s arm, then the Poles got here throughout as unpredictable to the Individuals,” he stated. “It is a scratch on this very shiny new Polish-US relationship, however I don’t essentially suppose that it’ll be a really lengthy or persistent scratch.”
US officers have since confused that they worth Poland’s contribution within the effort to assist Ukraine. Kamala Harris, vice-president, additionally visited Poland final week in an effort to indicate assist for nations on Nato’s jap flank.
“In shut relationships you typically want a quarrel. We’re often very well mannered to our American allies, however typically in addition they want to grasp that we have to be handled as companions,” stated the senior Polish official, including that latest high-level conversations urged that each side had moved on. “There are extra necessary points.”
Observe Demetri Sevastopulo and James Shotter on Twitter