News
A full guide to the sexual misconduct allegations against YouTuber Andrew Callaghan
Screenshot by NPR/Instagram
Andrew Callaghan, a documentarian behind YouTube’s Channel 5 and HBO’s This Place Guidelines, is thought for chronicling spectacles from Phish exhibits to white nationalist rallies.
However this month, the 25-year-old was himself the story after 1000’s of social media customers noticed a sample of misconduct in first- and second-hand accounts of girls’s experiences that had been shared throughout platforms in public feedback and movies.
Callaghan addressed the allegations in an Instagram put up on Sunday, apologizing to the ladies and pledging to look at his conduct in remedy.
However for a lot of who observe Callaghan’s work, the incident raises questions on Gen Z’s tolerance for sexually questionable conduct.
This is an account of what has occurred as of Friday.
Who’s Andrew Callaghan?
Screenshot by NPR/YouTube
Callaghan is a self-styled journalist for the digital age whose irreverent YouTube movies have earned him fame throughout a number of platforms. His model, Channel 5 information, has 600,000 followers on Instagram and one other 2.25 million on YouTube.
Callaghan received his begin whereas a pupil at Loyola College in New Orleans, the place he launched a YouTube collection referred to as Quarter Confessions. Carrying pale fits and carrying a corded microphone, Callaghan interviewed intoxicated Bourbon Road party-goers, modifying collectively their wildest statements with fast cuts and deliberately outdated results.
In 2019, he took that type of filmmaking throughout the nation in a beat-up RV, stopping for interviews at websites like a flat-earthers’ convention and the Talladega Speedway. The present, All Gasoline No Brakes, fell aside in 2021 after a contract dispute with its manufacturing firm, Doing Issues Media.
Callaghan then began the Patreon-funded Channel 5. The collection has amassed over 106 million YouTube views since April 2021.
His following has solely broadened because the Dec. 30 launch of his first HBO documentary, This Place Guidelines, which examines the cultural divisions underlying the Jan. 6 assault on the U.S. Capitol.
In interviews with legacy journalists about his unfiltered reporting, Callaghan has defended his recognition amongst youthful millennials and elder Gen Z’ers as a little bit of media mockery within the service of media literacy.
He says giving airtime to fringe voices is an precise type of reporting in an age of overwhelming journalistic punditry.
“When there’s a large divide in America, you are going to discover interviews on the perimeter,” he stated in a latest interview with NPR. “What we attempt to do is bodily converse to folks, really present up and be there and ask folks easy questions like, What’s in your thoughts? How are you feeling?”
He added that he lets the topics “information the dialog” in distinction to cable information reporters who use talking-head panels to “get the viewer as pissed off as attainable.”
This is when the allegations started to unfold
The claims towards Callaghan started to go viral on Jan. 5, when a TikTok person who goes by the identify Caroline Elise (@cornbreadasserole) posted a 2-minute video saying Callaghan pressured her into having intercourse with him.
She stated Callaghan, whom she’d been messaging on Instagram, requested to remain over at her home as a result of he’d had a falling out with a crew member.
“I used to be very clear about the truth that we aren’t hooking up,” she stated. “He will get in my mattress and wears me right down to the purpose the place I ultimately do conform to do issues I wasn’t pleased with.”
On Jan. 7, she posted once more, sharing screenshots of messages she exchanged with Callaghan in 2021 and a photograph of them collectively. She additionally shared screenshots of at the very least 10 messages from folks saying they’d had an analogous expertise with Callaghan or knew of somebody who had.
Caroline Elise has since deleted the movies from her TikTok feed, saying the response had diminished her psychological well being. However different customers have saved and proceed to share the movies throughout different platforms.
One version of it posted to Twitter has been seen over 756,000 occasions. A model shared on a Twitch livestream has over 833,000 views.
Caroline Elise stated she did not need to discuss on to NPR additionally for psychological well being causes. She as an alternative put us in contact with a long-time good friend, whose identify we have agreed to withhold over her fears of on-line harassment.
The good friend stated that Callaghan knew how Caroline Elise felt in regards to the incident months earlier than she’d ever posted it to TikTok. The good friend shared screenshots of Instagram posts from August 2021, by which the good friend warned different ladies in her metropolis that Callaghan had “knowingly assaulted my good friend and received away with it.”
The good friend additionally shared screenshots of a textual content message dialog that came about between Callaghan and Caroline Elise in December 2021, after Caroline Elise had confronted Callaghan about his conduct.
In a single lengthy message, Callaghan stated he acknowledged that the social energy dynamics at play “can dramatically warp consent” and had tried to unpack his conduct in remedy.
He additionally stated that “prior companions” from New Orleans and Nashville had reached out to him in response to the Instagram posts and had “began dialogues with him which have benefitted all our lives for the higher.”
“I need to do no matter I probably can to be accountable and assist you in no matter approach you want,” the message continues. “It will imply the world to me to have the ability to have an open dialog with you.”
A second accuser claims Callaghan sexually assaulted her in 2019
Caroline Elise’s video prompted one other lady, a TikTok person who goes by the identify Dana (@moldyfreckle), to come back ahead.
In a collection of movies, Dana stated Callaghan assaulted her on a drive house from dinner, first kissing her neck, then placing his hand down her pants and placing her arms on his crotch as she was telling him to cease. Callaghan left the automotive after she’d requested a number of occasions, Dana stated.
Dana later posted a video exhibiting screenshots of her messages with Callahan in January 2019. She hasn’t responded to a number of requests from NPR.
In addressing the responses to her movies, Dana dismissed concepts that she was searching for clout, cash or attempting to sabotage Callaghan’s success.
“I am not going to let another person undergo this alone,” she stated in her TikTok put up, referencing Caroline’s video. “I am simply saying the reality proper now and I do not care what you consider, however I would like different ladies who he is affected to really feel snug speaking about it.”
Whereas the tales from Dana and Caroline Elise have remained probably the most broadly shared and commented upon, a number of different folks have since posted in feedback or movies claiming equally pushy sexual conduct. They are saying their experiences with Callaghan shaped a sample.
How did Callaghan reply?
In a video posted to Instagram on Sunday, Callaghan thanked the individuals who’d spoken out about “other ways by which my conduct has made them really feel uncomfortable or pressured throughout a sexual state of affairs” and apologized to them, in addition to his collaborators. He didn’t single out any explicit accusations, or verify or deny any deny particular accusations circulating.
He did, nonetheless, say that he thought most of the accusations had been lacking necessary contextual info.
“I need to make a couple of issues clear: I’ve at all times taken no for a solution,” he stated. “So far as consent, I’ve by no means overstepped that line.”
“Up till this level, I did not actually understand that I had this sample that affected a number of folks,” he stated, later including that he thought going house from a bar alone “made you a loser” and that “persistence was a type of flattery.”
Callaghan had largely laid low on-line and in public since a tumultuous dwell interview with NPR member station WBUR on Jan. 4. He defined within the video that he’d waited practically two weeks to reply as a result of he was in a state of shock and “spiraled right into a psychological well being disaster.”
Callaghan additionally stated he believes alcohol might have contributed to his decision-making and stated that he is planning to hitch a 12-step program.
Dana posted YouTube and TikTok movies on Wednesday night saying that she did not consider the apology was real and she or he did not forgive him, but additionally that she was completed speaking about it.
“I am fed up, and I do know different persons are getting fed up,” she stated. “It is referred to as karma. It is not blackmail. It is not revenge, it is simply the way it goes.”
Caroline Elise had not publicly addressed Callaghan’s statements on the time of publication.
What in regards to the blackmail claims?
Three days earlier than Callaghan’s Instagram video, information retailers like TMZ and Selection printed parts of an announcement, shared by a “authorized consultant” for Callaghan, which acknowledged Callaghan’s have to re-evaluate his conduct but additionally pointed to “a number of sides to a narrative.”
“Whereas each dynamic is open to interpretation and correct communication is essential from all these concerned, repeated requests for cash shouldn’t be a part of these conversations,” reads the assertion, in line with each retailers.
Neither Callaghan’s agent or publicist responded to NPR’s request for affirmation of the assertion. Callaghan hasn’t responded to a number of NPR makes an attempt to achieve him by his social media.
Caroline Elise’s good friend shared a screenshot of 1 message Caroline Elise despatched to Callaghan six days earlier than posting the allegations on TikTok.
The message consists of the deal with of Caroline Elise’s Venmo account. She wrote Callaghan might use it if “HBO cuts you a fats verify, and also you in any approach really feel like serving to contribute to the huge quantities of remedy payments I’ve accrued.”
Caroline Elise’s good friend advised NPR that is the one time Caroline Elise had introduced up the prospect of him reimbursing her of their conversations collectively. Callaghan by no means responded to the textual content, Caroline Elise’s good friend stated.
Caroline Elise confirmed by her good friend that she shared the allegation to boost consciousness of Callaghan’s conduct. She has no plans to file a police report or a lawsuit, her good friend advised NPR.
Screenshot offered to NPR
How did Callaghan’s followers react to the allegations?
The claims, statements and response rapidly unfold on a number of social media platforms, the place customers, lots of them nameless, dissected Callaghan’s conduct in methods harking back to 2016’s #MeToo eruption, however with new cancel tradition concerns.
The Reddit discussion board r/Channel5ive, which is within the high 5% of Reddit communities by measurement, was as soon as devoted to Callaghan fan adoration. Now it incorporates over 100 posts devoted to investigating the allegations and debating which of the alleged behaviors crossed the road.
“Ingesting with somebody, inviting somebody into your own home, even inviting somebody into your mattress doesn’t equal consent,” wrote one person in a put up that obtained 1,100 up votes and 382 feedback.
“I am not saying let’s simply ‘cancel’ the entire thing, however I actually do not like folks saying we are able to simply separate his journalism from his misconduct,” posted one other.
Responding to requests by customers, moderators finally eliminated a Patreon hyperlink supporting Callaghan’s work and changed it with a hyperlink to the Nationwide Ladies’s Regulation Heart, which helps victims of sexual assault.
The Andrew Callaghan allegations suck as a result of it’s one thing that’s occurred to myself and many ladies I do know; a man wears you down till you say “sure” since you don’t need to cope with what occurs after you repeatedly stated no…
— ✨ tony soprano’s hoochie daddy shorts. ✨ (@_letterbxmb) January 10, 2023
YouTube and Twitch streamers whose audiences overlap with Callaghan’s additionally parsed by the allegations and apology, attempting to glean common classes.
Twitch streamer Hasan Piker (@Hasanabi), who boasts 2.3 million subscribers, stated in his third video mentioning the allegations that Callaghan’s apology is promising however that it is solely pure that his followers wait earlier than passing judgment.
“Individuals are not going to learn this with any form of charitability,” as a result of Callaghan hasn’t finished something but to exhibit how he is modified, Piker predicted.
What does this imply for Channel 5 and Callaghan’s work?
In his video apology, Callaghan stated he wasn’t positive what comes subsequent, however he wished to take a step again from public life whereas he processed his conduct.
“I am solely 25 years previous and I’ve my complete life forward of me,” he stated, including that reporting was nonetheless his past love.
Tim Heidecker, a comic who helped produce This Place Guidelines, addressed the allegations on his Workplace Hours podcast final Thursday by saying he had no plans to collaborate with Callaghan once more sooner or later.
“We’ve no skilled relationship with Andrew right now and haven’t any plans to have any relationship with him,” Heidecker stated, talking on behalf of his comedy and manufacturing companion, Eric Wareheim.
A publicist for Heidecker and Wareheim advised NPR the pair had no up to date feedback on Callaghan’s apology. The press places of work for A24 and HBO didn’t reply to NPR’s requests for remark.
The YouTube web page for Channel 5, which had been sharing clips from This Place Guidelines for the final three weeks, hasn’t posted a brand new video because the week the allegations surfaced.